Daya Kishan Sharma v. State Of Haryana And Another
!
"
#$ %&&'
()
#* #$#+$, - $)
.&&'
/0#("
"
#$
&&'
12 & 3 3
! "
# !#
"" $ %&' ( ) * +++++ 3
& (0
' ,-%)
) ( .
( %/ .
( %, 0% %0%%1 # 2 (
( & 3
45* ) $ 6- %07- &)8
$ )79%07-* :8 $ ,% 0/ 0;
%075 / )
7;--# (
,7/ ,%08) ; )
(# <
( ! 1!# ( 4
; )
7;-- (=
## (# "
# #" ( ## (
# ( >
# % '1 :8$ ,%0/ 0;
%075
/ )
7;--&# ( ,7/ ,%08) ; )
* 1 ( # (# <
( 2
( ( # # (
< #
)
# 2 (
( 7;
0, %079 (
,
(
'
# # ! !# 43 ( 1# #
# '# ! 0% 0- %07;
1 # 2 (
( 1 ( ##! (1 4
4. Arguments advanced by learned PP assisted by learned counsel for complainant have been heard and file has been perused intrinsically and ultimately, this Court finds that prima
facie, there is no sufficient evidence available on the file to summon D.K Sharma, who is named in the application as accused to face trial along with co-accused who is already appearing in the Court because the prosecution has examined the complainant Jitender as PW1 but during the cross examination, he has turned hostile and has stated that he had never visited the premises of the accused i.e. Shivam Consultancy, Sector 15, prior to 04.09.2015 and Mr.Puran Khanna accused was not known to him. This witness has further stated that on he said date, Sh. D.K Sharma, did not meet him in the office and someone in the office had suggested him to visit the office of Shivam Consultancy. Since during cross examination, the complainant has resiled from his earlier statement, hence on the request of Ld. PP, he had been declared hostile and as such, he had been cross examined by Ld. PP as well.
5. After recording the statement of the complainant, Ld. PP has moved an application under sect0ion 319 Cr.P.C for summoning additional accused D.K Sharma FSO Gurugram. However, perusal of the case file reveals that complainant has not uttered even a single word against aforersaid D.K Sharma FSO and present application has been moved by ld. PP on the basis of averments made by the complainant in his statement recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C,. While deciding the application under Section 319 Cr.P.C, the court is required to take into consideration the statement made by complainant in the court wherein no word has been uttered by him against the present accused.
= # '
# !# 4
!#1( # ; )
)
# " (
( 67;)
) 1 ( 1
# ( ! !
## (# "
#! #" ## (
# ( >
# .
( %, 0% %0%% 3
45 ' # %/ 4
!
" ##$ %
&
'
()(*(
+ ,
*-./! ! &'
0
0
1
2 %
%
0
,
!
'
0
1
2 %
' %/ .
( & 3
45* ## ( / '# # ! ## (1'
#)
(
'
# # 67;)
) !
# ! # 1 1'
#)
!
)
#
#
67;)
) ( !# ( 4 ## # ()
#) 7 #9
" 1 ( ! ##! ( #
! > 1 1 ! # # .
(
!" #$ % &'()"
*
% +",, - )". /* ,00
%3 1
" (' /* ,00
23 % 1
$" 4 ( /* 5/* / , , ,0 ' +!
2
6,0'+ +
3
%
+"7 (1##!
( %/.
( %, 0% %0%% & 3
45* #1#1> - '# # 4 # (! # $ % # # #(# #4 ( ( ;
8 # # < (
! #13 ' ()
#?= #
888&) 7 #9*! 4 3!3- 3 38)3 390
!
% %
4
%
5
%
6
7 &
&
7
8
6 9
: ;
%
%
'
0 ;
< $!
$ =
5 (787 *>+")-* "- " *> 8
'
%
0 ; &
'
$!
$!
5 "-#-7 1?+@@@7 ") A " *>B '.
(
1# # 4 ' @1#
)
8
!" #$ %C D7 ")A
$!
,
!
E ;
5 <" >) !(*.
7 8 F /
%
3 ,
!
9 6 ' %6
B
"- &
' < G% ." -/ !!)>>.
78 F /6 2 H
%' ." #/ .
7 8 F /6 % .((-/> !!
>.
78 F /6
; 5F .(""/" !!># .
7 8 F / 1 E !
G 4.("/- !!-"".
78 F / ">
"F
%
9
!
9 %
%
7 '. / 9
"#&
5./
,
% "#" %
,
'
I#JK I#J5' % ." #>/ !!->
78 F 6 <
4." -/ .)/ !!">
8 6 ; ; 1 ." (/ !!-**6
78 F K "#< %
' I JK :
I"(JK I J ' 5 % ; ; ." #/" !!6 78 F K I"(J 1 ./K "#*
% 3
'
?
' B6 3
B
3 %
+
BI""JK I""JH
%'./K "
9 % 9 $!
!
DL " ":
I"JK6 I"J0<
F < " >) !"6
78 F K
" 4
%
' I"*JK6 I"*J0< ./K " *
$!
9
D " *"& $!
!
'
9 %
I")JK I")J F ' E 5 F
'.
<" " *
./K " *&
8
!
3&
$!
'
&
% % 6
9
3
B&
,
&
9 = I"-JK7 I">JK
I"-J; .5!&
0 / ("(> !!"6
78 F K I">JM C 84
./K ( & $ !
, 7
?
7
"!
,
9 $!
9 .-/ (#"("( !:
5 " (
("( ;+ % &!
&
'A
A<
' @1#
)
A &' ()" *
% +",, - )"
7# 4 )F
'
$!
$!
N 9
'
,
" *" - !
"" !
9N :
$!
< 1
)* & $!
9
,
A<5 --#+
8 !
.H970:>+ /
0 !
& $ !
%
?
9
H 9
9
& '
$!
*>././
))A *>././ !
9
"*
("* .
(*(("*/
*>70
$
*>./ !
N
,
'
N &
9
7 )- '
$ !
&
7 5 "
).!
5 +(( / *( *>././ !
& 7 5 "
)
%
%
:
; ! !
G
!
+ ')
. /* ,00
%3 1
"7 # 4 H9
8
%
9
& !
9 !
% =
&!
% !
9 "( %
8 ( ("#
9 7 9
%
')
A(' /* ,00
23 % 1
$"7 # 4 E
% !
->
'
D7 N-> ,
:"" !;4
,
,
$ :7""
%
'
!
,
A
B
&
8
7
9
% %
->
'
&
-> '
% % &
%
!
!;4 1 ?
&
< % ->
' *(*(" 8 77 8
B ')
A4 ( /* 5 /* / , , ,0' +!
2
6,0'+ +
3
%
+"7 #
4 ">
& $!
< .! " $< >/./
?
%
< >
' ,
0 ;
< $ !
$ C ! "-()" *>5
&!
( &
&!
%
" A
'
'2 ;+ %&!
./
.1
5!&
0 / %'! ./ ;
$
./0;5
$
./
%
9 &
"# H
&!
&
7
&
" *! !
% ? 7 *" ! !
5
&!
"
#
' *(( 8 1 .
9 7 /
, , ,
#'()
#?= #
888 &) 7 #9*& *! #! # 1 B 1 " (
#91 ##! .
( > 1 ( ! ! # ! (
( )
1 (# (
@)
# 75 0, 7;69 $
1 ##! '
#)
!# ( 4 ## (
'
##!1'
#)
" ! #!
7% :
#.
(
4 8" &' ()" * 8". /* 8"(' /* 8" 4 ( /* 5/* / , , 8" ! #! " ( (
#
1( (3# ' (1 ! #
( ( ( C ! '
#)
(
'
# # 67;
)
)
# = )
# ( %/.
( %, 0% %0%% & 3
45*! 1 ( 7, 8 ! %/.
( %, 0% %0%%& 3
45* 1 # 2 (
( ##
> # ( ( > >
' 1
' (# &* ## (# 3
#!
-5
.4 '
" D " ( E$ D 1# E$