Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd And Others v. M/S Shree Durga Spinning Mill And Another
CWP-5877-2019
!"!
# $% % UTTAR HARYANA BIJLI VITRAN NIGAM LTD AND OTHERS
M/S SHREE DURGA SPINNING MILL AND ANOTHER & '(&%) *
)%+ ,,,,,
!" #$ !
#
% &&&&& *
)%+-%./01 $ ## "
" '(() *
+!
,-
./ % 0 1 # *!.# #/
- " ./ # !
2$ #
! 3)4" ## " 0 ./ 5 .!
. 5 .
(6(( %
7 0 " 8 !
.#
. # % "
" .
+ ,(4(, 7 0 "
## 8 !
.# . #
" 0 . ./ 1
0 !" " #$ !
#
. # % , $ !
#
5 .!
%
!0 .! #
!
/ !
0 /# 9 5!
## 7 # !#/
!0 # /
% :;
0 #
"
06):1" ,4)34(1"" $5
0)(< 6<
% (9)''(, " " 0
" ('(,= " #/ .##
0 5 0. (," "
#/
!" !
#
! .
#/ 7 .
0 1" !
" !
0./ ! / :('(: !
! " . 8!
.#/ 0 !
'')6)9" !
.#
0 % # .#
#
!0 .
#
1 "## / ##
>! #
0 !
" !
.#
0 % 7 0 !
" !
.##
!0
0
, (4 #!0 / 7 %
!0
# .! #
>! . ! .
0" +# % ! >!
0 0 .
# " ./
!0 = "
# !
$ #
! 3)4 .
0 1#*!.# #/
- 6 7
.
#
! .8
0 .#/ # #/ 0 #!
#
8! " ./ 0 1 # *!.# #/
-
#
!.0
0 1#*!.# #/
-## "
# " '(()./ #/ ! :'*-
# / ((, # "
# +
:(((9 7 %
!0 " # #.# / .
0 !
'')6)9 " / #0 ./ .! #
.## 0
(4 : 7 # $ !
# 0 / $ !
##/
% $
!0 .
!# #/ 01 /0 .## 0 ! 0 !
" " 0 ./ / ?
% ! ! +# . ! 0 "
0 "
.8 !./ ! /7 #0 >!
6 " " .
:' *- # / ! !
>!
" 7 % " !
0 1#*!.# #/
- #
! 3)4
!.0
0 1 # *!.# #/
-
#/ ## " # ### . / 0 ./ .! #
' 7 # $ !
# "
## " + "
./ 0 1#*!.# #/
- @
! "
# $% &'#(' $%! )* # $+, $+, - ./ 0# & ! !
&1 1
*1 &!
"
2
3 ##04 ! 51
2
3 ##04 1 6 ' 521 - !
1 ! - -
1 !
5 5
3 ##04 5 1 1 - 8
, &!
-9 1 !:4
:
8;
! 5 5
!
15
1 - 1
! 1 1 ! - 1
5
< 8
= , - 1
-
5
7 -1 ! 1 2 - 1
1 15 ! 4 ;5
3 ##04
1 5 1 5 >51 5- 4;5
- 1 -
3
1
3 ##04 ! 1 1
6 ' 4 .
#
! "
00
:'*-
# / ((, # 8!0 = A.#! 0 $ !
B "## 8!0 $ !
= # #
8!0 = A.#! 0$ !
3(:(, 0
!3(:(,7 # + 0 !
.# "
' ?2 1 !: 2 &
& ,
1 1@ 5 1 = <
A 12 &! !
2
&, 51 ! < & ! ! 1
!
! 5 - 1 = < A > 1 9 9
!
! ! -=-
1
! 1
A ,
(
(# , B 5 ! !
- ! -5 ! - A 2
5 !
)
& , ! 5
-
- !
! 1B
! A
2= ) -5
-
!
4
! - 1 " ! 1@
&, A 5 2 5 ! # !
&, ! 5 1 5 -
5 1
- -5
5A 2 ! - 51 5 5 5
!
-
&, A 2
" ! 1 - 5 1
1
! 5 1
- 5
! "
A @ "
@ ,
) = < -1
1
!- 5
1 )
.
!.0./
# "
/ :'*- # / ((, . "
# # !#/
/!
# 0 8!0 $ !
(,(,
"# $!% # & '
() * +, -
.- / -
" $ !
) ## " "
#./ 5 .!
"
./ 0 1 # *!.# #/
- 1!
0#
!0
" .## .
# .## . ./#/ "
0!## 7
# + 8!0 !
?
- B - -
8
2= , & "
: 0123 4- 5
% ;
! 5 5
!
15
1 - 1
!1 1 ! - 1
5
C -
-
* 1
5 -
!1 1 !
5
2
- 1 1 D E1 )
*
2.
3 (+
) ) * + ,+ -
) 6 - + - 7 6 - +( 1 5 1$ * ,# 2 3 80
9 2 - "
1 !:
3 ? 2 "
!
-1 8
, !
1 1 5
= , & = , ( - ! 5
= , (
!:F ! . +
* * - * 78% 5 5
5
5
5
5
5-5
- E
! 5 ! @ 5 - 5
1
4
!
15
5 ! 51 5
5 ! " 1
5
5 1 5 8 %
!1 , B 1 1 = 1 1
15- 1
" ! 1 5- : - 1
1
( ! B ! 5
! =
E 5
E 5
5 ! B C 2
5 )
= 5 3
(
1
&
1
&, 1
( , 2
5)
1
-
5
- 1 ! 1. 5
6
! 1
:F ? 1 -
1 15C : / :
; -
- 2
$3 !10 ) ! 5
= , ( :F ?
!
1 5 -
5
5
5 ! 5 5
C 78 & 14 78
5
5 2 5 1@
-114 7 8
, 2
!
! 5 1?
C 14 7 8
2 - 5
4
1 1 ! 1 - 1
1
! 1 !
"
1?
C !
1@
8 ' 8 !-
5
"
5
4
"
- ! 1 1
-
#,5
# &
. ( 1
C 3 = !.0
0 #
8!0 #" . "### "
./ = A.#
! 0$ !
#0 " /
#/
#
# / !#/
/0 / 1
/ .
0 !
( B ! !#/ /!
7 # / ((,
." / . "
#!
!0 0
.#
!0 0 /
!0 9 /!
. #"
B !.0
./ 0 1 # *!.# #/
- 1 .
#" ./ = A.# ! 0 $ !
7 "
./ 0 1 #
#/
0 ###/
/ 0 /
#.# . 7 0 ./ 5 .!
!
! # = !.0
8!0 " !.8 0 ##
#% 33) (,
0 . 0
" "
./
!0
(()(, =
8!0 $ !
"
" 0 . ! #./ 5
"## , 7 #$ !
# . # % # ! 01
"
# !
8!0 " !.0
./
#
/
6 B #
# . # "## # $ !
# !
, !0 # "
# 8!0 = A.#! 0$ !
B : B
0 #
8!0
:'*- # / ((," !# 0 #/ #/
!#/ 0 !
. 0!
0 (/
# "
. "
. . # ./
!0 ! .
#
" !# .# .#C!
= A.#! 0$ !
# .
8!0 " 0 !
!
0
" ( /
. "
!
/ ## .
D #/
0
. !#/
# " !
# / .##
! . !
+ # 7 D
.## . ! ./ %
!0 !
!.
0 1# *!.# #/
- " !
0 0 !
B .
/ #9 ! >! >!
.
0
.
! 0 "
"
# # .#
#/ ' C!
.! #
" .## . !
+ # 0#/ 0 #/ 5 0. (:=
#0 00
"
0 .! #
7 0 >! . .##
6
(4
0" " #0 " /
.!
:'*- # / ((,7 !
/ .
0 !
. #/
1 ./ .! #
. E . #
.# ./ = A.#! 0$ !
B
#/ 8!0 *! -.!# 8!0
*
2.
3 (+
) ) * + ,+ -
6 - + - 76 - +( . $ ## % '4 (( ! *$ #-% :3( (3 )((( #! 8!0 & '
() * +, -
.- / -
4 " .
B "
./ 0 1 # *!.# #/
-
0 0 #" "
0 1#*!.# #/
-7 #!
#"" !# " D . ### D !
.# +
" #
#"
.
7 0 "
#!
"
./#.# . ) 7 "
#/ ## " 7 " '(() *
+!
,-
./ % 0 1 # *!.# #/
- $%< $ # ;< -
. * * ;
& '
( ) * +,
: ## 0
## !
# * - / # .*
)%+1
*& $- + ? 1 9
F 9% ? .# F 9%