High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/2068/2012allowed

A.R. Madhav Rao And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2018-05-22Mr Justice Jaswant Singh20 pages

!" # $$ %&

' ()

!" #

! "#$%&'!(""# & '

! "#

$ %

' (

)

* )&+,- &+'& )..+/0 &+'' *

* ! & )&+,- &+'& ! !

1 2% '+,&.+.&+''

.+,3.4 *

* $

# $

'0.

&,+5&+''6 7

3'30 ! *8* ** 1

. )..+/0 &+''

! !

2% '+,&.+.&+''

.+,3.4 *

* $

# $

'0.

&++/&+''6 7

3'3& ! *8* * !

* 9 * *

4 *

" # %

: ;7

;7 <

7= $

/ >1* "

: ;7 <

7= $

&.+.&+''

) ! ( 1* " 2% '+,&.+.&+'' * $

# $

, =

! 1* "

&+ <

7= **) 7

!; !

! !

*?7 &++0

;

** ; * ;

;

1* "!!

=: "

! @

: *

1* " ($ 6! 8!

! * !

1* " ! !

** 1* " !

*** <

7= *

* * =

! *

** 1* "

* !

1* " * !** ! 7

!**1* " ** * !

** *

* : ! 71* " *

* ! * !

B 3

> 2=

* !

1* "

* *:

1* "! ;

* *:! 1* " ! !

* * *

! 1*

! **

2% '+,&.+.&+'' !!

! C *

! *

##$%& '()* # !

")+ #*# ) %#% , * %+ ,% -. /./# 0

( ( #

//" (#

(

(1 # 0 #

( 0 ..

( 20 0

0 - 3

/( /

00 -" 0/

0# 0

$ '

- 0/. 0 ..

0'/ 4 0 0 005 0/0 0 ..

( #

0.-

#0 0#

- $%"#

.) # #

")+ #*# ) %#% * 2$

+ , ' #

0 0 # 7.

8'2//5

0 0.

#./ 0 .#/ ' / (( ../ .-/0 #

05 0 ./ 0 - #

' 0// 2 0 - 00

. /0 ..

/ /

" ( -/ 9

00#000("

00: . : :"

0 :#:"

/ 2 .00 :5 /0 ..

-0

' - (

0 0

0-.0 .#/-" 0

& '

005

- ( -

# 0 0/

-. 4 3

( -0 0 ..

# 0/

0 0

$ '

0/ #

- (". /

0 0

$ '

8' 0// $ ' - :#

0 / :##//5 / - (-

0' 02

7-5 0//

5 0/ . / 0 "

//(0 #

##// 3 # .

" '# 0

$ '

2.0.

. / 4 3

-7./"0 /. #

/-/

0 7.

-" ##//;00</2

2 #0

//(

. /

.( "

/ 2 5 /-= : ##//;00 0 /0 .

/ / 70/" #/ 7# 0 3 # / : ##// # 0 5 ( # -/# 5 /0 /"

(#> 02 5 0# 0

-//(

/ ' .

/ 0 0.02 # * ?

1)@ %

%AB2 4# 0 ( ( 006 0 % !! * & !

* !

* &

- =

* * ! ! C !

*: 1* " !

1* " ! !

C !

* <

7 = ;

! 1* " * !

! =

! * 1* " 7 !

1 * 2

2= !

( $

'4+-&+'.!*

1* "!

! C

* *!

;

2% '+,&.+.&+'' **

5 *

! '+ (

! 7 &&+.&+'' 7 7

3- &&+.&+'' ) ,'.0 ( .-"# (#0

(" ." .

' -

0 0 ..

// (# C'

( ) 2 D 2$E! >2F:.

02) >(90/*5?/ 2G * //-2%? 2//-2

2//-'( //-

/ 5 #

0 .#" E! >2 0F:.

E. / .5 #

/ //--"

//.

// ("'.( $ G .. /"': .

5'0 /( 5 0# .#5# '5 /'

/5 //0 0.0'

../"# -/( .#"

> " - ( #

' .4 ( ( .#/ 0

.# 0 .."0 //(D ' ( 5// - 0

D 4 ' ( # 5

" .D 4'

( ## ." 3# 5

"5##.5( (-".

5=25 ."- 25 .'

' () D .#/ 0.'/

//-0"

( # 5

"/ (5 .' / = . 5 0.' ('

/ ('- . ( 5 #

( 2E! >?'# /

5 : 5 #

/ (5 * 2 5 ' .

- ." =

* 2 /. .5 . 35

/0 & #(

5 #

* ED# '5 (/"

(5 #

' /. .

D # 5

"5. 5 05( 70-"."- . 5= !2 -2'4"

- " .." .

." / #/" * / - ( .." .

/" /5 .

/"-0 " / . 3 /" ."

:5 0 /

."/0:

( 5 //0(/ 0 .#"* 2//-2E! >2$? 2G 5 // 0# -/

-".3" .#/ 0. 00

."/0:

(2 # - / "

/ / # ' () D -0 ".

/.85"( 2' () ."- "5 :

( 0 .#"

0 ?5 /- .' : 5"'0 / .#/ 0

, #/" (. 0:5 .' 4"

'. (# - / "

."0 /

./ 0/ 5 / . 0 3 - ( (#

- .". / ?/ ."./0/ . 025

//0

(5 ;./ 0/3 .

//0# / 00

( .': //# - / "

." - # # -/ 5 - .

-".8 .".

:2'-(

( .

.//# #/' 0( ..-

." .

/" ." /5 # -/

2 ."./2 0/ " /

# -/

'4 / # # -/

." ' (2D 2E! >2 ?* .F:.

0'. / ( . ( -5 F:.

E. -# - / "

./ 5 25 7#

/ 5 #

//-2 ( ?* 5# ("0 //(D

' (/ .

/.'50 .#//

( #."/

" ( ".

"."-# ."5

." 8 -# ."

H9H( 0.

"."- # ."5

'0 .-0-0

//- "

0 .#" 3 # - ./ //

- ." ( ## //(//" ;$ 6 '' #1* "

!> * ! &++0

*?7>*

! !

;

1* "

=:"

! ! 6

8 * ** ! @ ($ * * * ! * <

7= ** *?7 #! ; *! * ! 1* " ! !**

! !

1 * : B* ! C 7 !

*** <

7= *

* *

1* " ! ** *!

!** ! ! **

7 ! ** !* ! * :

! !

7 * !

* ! * !

! !

! ** !

7! * : !

* > ! * 1* " * <

7=;!

* **

! 7 ! !**1* " *!

! !

3/)'03 )'03#

1 ** *:* <

'& !

.) / "

- $%"#

)0 !

"!* ) , ' .

0# -/

0 ..

-""# 2 # 0 (7 0

/ / : 7-5 5 2-.- (# #// (0 0 3 - 0 (

/ -.

3 0 -.2

00 ( ..

.# "0

-0

0 5 / .

/ ( 0..

0/#-/0

0/ = 5 / // 5//

-. / 0 # .

$ '

( "2 0 "2 0/#- / " 0 .#/ "

0-/ 0

0 0 .

-. 0

$ '

20 .

/ 0 .

& 3# ##

$ '

0 -0 -" (

>- G$ A2/70# . , -. / ./ # 0

( (#

//" ( #

(

( ' 0

# 0" / 5 / / ./ # 0

( 0 # 0"

(

( 0 /5 00- 0 - ( ( (

(

( 4 -

# 0-

- - ( 0 ..

0 0

$ '

1) //I 5/AAG &$2 - /-7./"0 / ( 00 0.0

00 00 /

( 5 0/" . 0 . 0 0 /

( '

# 0 0 . 0 ..

( 5 "# " #/02 0

0 . 0/

4 0 ..

" 5 0 0 .-/ ( 0#/02 0

05 7#0 0 .

//" 0 0.0

/ ( " 0 ..

2 0 0 0

0 / -

- (

(00 0(

- (

/ -

( /"6

(

0/"2 / -" (

/ # 0. //I 5/# -7./"0 / ( 0 0 0.0

00 0 5 0/"-. 0 .. 0# ;/

-"0 ..

( 2 5 0

0 . 0 ..

( ## - "# "

#/02 0

0 . 0/

24 ..

" 5 0 -/ ( 0 0 5 7#0 0 .

//"

0.0 / 0 #2 000(5 -.0 / -/( /" 3- 55 ./ /

1)(/ & &6 '. 112

113% *

6.&? 86&+'+8 ! '0./@'0., CC

) JJ 40# -") / # 3(.

0# -/;$ ' - ( 0

&2'

-. .# (+

(

0 ..

- (( ( 0 # 0" 0 ..

02 0 (0 ..

0 -.0 /". .0 ((

## 0 ..

0 3 5 J (J/ //". ( 2(

52# :2

0 0 ( 0#

( 50 /"(( ./ . 0 -" " .2 /((2 0

025 :

7# /

0 (. ' / 0" (

/- /" 5 ." -0 0JJ '4 !

- $%"#

)0 !

! " ,* JJ-. / ./ # 0

( ( #

//" (#

(

('0

0 # 0"/ 5 / / ./# 0

( 0 # 0"

(

( 0 /5 00-0 -

( ( (

(

( 4 -

# 0- -- (0 ..

0 0

$ '

D '/ *#% ()* $% "#

C C7!* !

L ' (

( 2(

52# :2 0

0 ( L0L3 "4 .

(

( 0" 0/ .-

0 50

(

. 0 /" #0

0//" - ((

0 40 M -/

0 " 0 0 40.-0#-/

- (#/ # 05 00-" 0 .

-"0

0 0000 0.0 05/ 5 #

70# 0 ..

5 0 0 (

." -

( .

(0 40 0//"

// 0 - - (

D ', !

#$%& '()*

# !

" ,* L-. / ./ # 0

( ( #

//" (#

(

(1 # 0 #

( 0 ..

( 20 0

0 - 3

/( /

00 -" #. 0/

0 0# 0

$ '

-0/. 0 ..

0'/

4 0 0 005 0/0 0 ..

( #

0. - #0 0#

0 ..

D '0 !

4*1#)15 )$% "#

6#%#-1 !

" * ) L 32 0 /": 5 -

/ (00( /"

0 0

$ '

20 .0#/ /"7.

00 0.0

0/ 00-

5 0/".. 0 . / 0 .5 / - #

' / -- .

//(-.

.-#

0 0

0 . 0 ..

/" //(

.5 - ("# 0

# . .

000 #

00 5 0 / .#//# 0 ..

20 0

$ '

-/CC '-

& '()* % - $% "#

% !

17 !

JJ 35 J(J. 0 "

# .- " . (2 .:# .

4 0:/" # 0/ 0

2 #0 //"-"# (

0 (0# 3

2 # ( ( L( L L(

5L/5

# :2 0 0 (

(

0-"/'

# -.2 .- 500:#

( ( "

(0-"5 2 / / .

0 05 0."-5 / / /02 / 0 02 # ( 0-" 5 5 / / .

0 0

.:0 .

5 .

4 0:/"

5 0

0 /"2 00

# : ( 0 (0 0 ..

5 /0 ( . - < -/"#0

. 0"0 0 .

(

$ ' - (05 # 5

$ '

.-0

0 ..

02# 5 -0 ..

. #/"0 /-"0

(

(0 0 0 / 0 ..

-.-"# 0(

0.-# -/ -"

# 0

0 / - 0 0 0

$ '

E '5 ; 1 C.C6 *8 ; * 3

> * :

* **

CC &+ .-)1

#'$%"#

4 !

" 1, !

* .+,

* C C &' !

#% ()*

+ $% "# .

2#1

" 1*

JJ3 0 00

/5 #0

-.30 /5 0

". (

5 L (

LL( (L30 # / -

# :2 0 0 (

(

0 -" / 90 # J - / "#

. 90# 5

/ ./ #0 3

2 .# -/ /" 5 "

(>0:

./ / (5 0090 0 -0 -

5 0 0.0CC && !

$%2"( :)

,GG -. /./# 0

( ( #

//" (#

(

(1 # 0 #

( 0 ..

( 20 0

0 - G% 3

F( /

00 -" 0 0/

0# 0

$ '

- 0/. 0 ..

0'/ 4 0 0 005 0/0 0 ..

( #

0.-

#0 0#

;0 ..

CC &. $ ** ! 3*:

* ! !

* ! * ! *

.+, &4 ;

.+, '+0 ; !

! * .+, &/ ;

** * 1 7 ** *:*

7 * * 7

* ! * *

:* ** ! * !

1* "

!** * !

! !

! 7

1 * !

* *

: ! *; *

* @ 1* " *: !

* ! *: **

! ** ! ! 7

!**1* " !

! !

! ! * ! * * ! *

*** .+, > *7

&, ;

* * ** *

*:* !

** 2 ** * **

: *

! !

* .+,3.4 !

* * *

** 3 ! &0

2% '+, &.+.&+''

.+,3.4 *

* $

# $

'0.

* ** 1 !

&- (

! )&+,- &+'& )..+/0 &+''**

)("" * +,

: #-. B 3!: F B !

* F