High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/723/1991dismissed

(O&M) Balkar Singh And Others v. Joginder Singh And Others

2015-03-23Mr. Justice J.C. Verma12 pages

!"#"$%& '!( ' ) * + ,- '"$.( ('# /

'.0 12% ('" '3 $"$.()$"' /!

('" 4'") /!

# ('" , /5 4') /!

''#4$ $

("#'.0, '#!$ ,"# "'!

60 .7$ !'

8 ( ,3' !0'

1,3 3('12 #0"

'#4!"

#,,

) (, "$.

89:!0 12 "$

"$ '.

$ 1"$.

(0 ('"

$ 3"

$"$ "$ !

0#,##

)3 !' ,4'

'' 12 (/$ !' (,3'!0'

)3 ,# "#7"## $

$"$.() $ '#4$ $ ('"$) 1"$.3$' $ "$#0"

.' #,, 7 4,

."$ ' "$.( ;#"$! !

# $ 1"$. '4'#$ 12 ("# <#=) '#4$ $ > # )***? 4' -",, /" #,,

)3($ '$# 7$2 #+)***?( ,#1$4 " , 1:!0 $'1 '8

$ ('#07 #+)***?3

'!"/ 12 ( 3$' '7 ( 4,

$ 9

8@ /"

3'"

"$.7 $ (1 !- ('"."$ , A($ 3$'

$"$.( " $ !7 '3 ' :!0 , 3($3('

!$ "$0 1'

$ 3",,"$. 4'

!$ )$ 44"$

(3$ (

"! (01."# ') &0- ''

23"

(1 $!# ,!$#" '

"$ ,#7$2 :4$## '#

74 $ !( '.# ,#7"#!,, $0#:4$##10

" $ 0'$04 ':!0 , $#B0$ ,2 "$. (3(, 2)

7 44,"!

"$;: =3('"$ "1(#", '&0- '7 -"$.$ '#7$ : ?)$ "! ("#4'#$!

, "7"$. ("7#, 1 '

2 $ 3",,"$. 4'

)$ "!;:=3 ##$ $ *

8@ 3$'

$"$.( ('0.(("#!0$#,!

,,"$.04$ (/$ ' :!0 , 3"

("$ 3-10 /$ ($ " $

$2# 4#"$

"'!

"$ $ !$ "$0 $! 4'

!$ @ A($

!$ "$00#,21$3 "$.1"$.'

(1 $!# ,!$#" '

"$ $ 7$2 2"$.!( '.# '

74 $ '."#

"$ ,#7"#!,, $0#:4$##) #,

# ;$3 #=/" # , : $

89) (0# 4'60 "!"$. ( '".( # ( 4,

,3"$. '7

;:+= B0,,2)

", #-"$.#4!"

$ !, "7"$. , "$

1$0,, $ /" (0#1"$. $!$#B0$! + $ #4"

#'/"!'#0, "$ :4 4'! "$.# ("7$

89 9 $ ("'6"$ 3'"

7$ 0'$"#( 12/$ ) (2( /!, "7 #,,"$

1"$!74, $ 0$!'

"$0"

,#!$ $

#4'

,, #@@- ,3('

1$ ", '#4!"

, $ $,2 +- ,#

7 ', #

, "7"$. (7#,/# 1 1$ " 40'!( #'# ' / ,0 !$#" '

"$) (2( $" -$3, . $2 "$

# (!

# (4,

,# $" )4'

2"$. '

"#7"## , $'4,"!

"$4'

'' 12

)!$ '/'

"$. ,,

/'7$ # "$. #)!

## 0412

"$ )3 #'"

8 $ "$.# (4 "#) ,,3"$."##0#3'#

60 "!

"$12 (,3'!0'

A( (' $"$.( :!0

98 '# , , $ "$ "#40

# 3(

C A( (' ( 4,

( # 1$ '

2 $ 3",,"$. 4'

A( (' # '1$ " 40'!( #'#

'/ ,0 , $ C # 3(

C @ A( (' "$ "#40 "# 0$!'

"$ "$!74, C # 3(

C + A( (' "#3"

("$,"7"

"$C 9 A( ('#0"

"#4'4',2/ ,0 '40'4## !0'

$ 60'"# "!

"$C ,"

''!"/"$.'

, #3,, # !07$

'2/" $! '71

(4 "# $ 4'/" "$. ( '"$. ("'!0$#,) ,, ("##0# 3'

!" "$

/0' ( 4,

# !$#B0$ ,2)

# !' 12 (,3'!0'

8 44 ,4'

'' 12 (/$ 60 .7$ $ !' (,3'!0'

)3 ,# "#7"## $

* $ (4'#$ '.0, '#!$ , /' "!

@ !0'

# 1,3) "

( # 1$ # 04 12 #

# ( 40'!( # ( #0"

, $ 3($ (2 ( $ -$3, .'"$

"$ 10 #,, $ :"# "$."$

## ","$. ("# )"

"#!, "7

/ .0 $ 0$!'

"$ ,#1$ ", '4

(0#3 #,"

1, 1 "#7"## 10 (!0'

#1,3 " $

- (#

#4!

#"$ !$#" '

"$ "#!, "7

1$ $ 3",,"$. 4'

$'( !7 '3

:4 "

"0#,2 ", "#!, "7

/$$ "! (/$ '

#"##0 /'2,

$ /$ ('

'(( 1$3(","$.

"7 "# ,#!

$/ ##

('3 #'

2$'

#3",,"$. $ ( ,#$ 0$ # 4 (1 $!# ,!$#" '

"$ '

40'!( #"$. $

"# /''

(!$!,0#"$ (!0'

#1,3

#,,3 #"$ (-$3, . (/$ # #"#3'$.) 3('

(4 "# ' '7 "

'$ /",, .# $ "#,!

"$2

$ ('/",, .'

2"$. !!4

,)'/'# , !'

1 (!0'

#1,3( #1$#0.(

#4'#

#) ,,3"$.#01#

,B0# "$# , 3 '"# '7"$

"$12 ("#0'

A( ('

"#'B0"' 4, $ 4'/ "$## $ 3",,"$.$## 4'

'7("#!$ (, "$

9*9D '< ,A (3 E$' /# '"

(( - '3 "DC A( ('

#'B0"' #(312/" $!

("#!

!$ $ ((

0$ # 4 21 $!# ,!$#" '

"$C

A( (' #/ .0 $ "$ "$"

$ ("

12!

"$ ($ "

$$ !

8 C @ A( ('

7$ ,$"##0

"!"$

4'/$.

"/ ($0# ('

'#("

4'/ ( #01#B0$ $# ' ( # $

+ -$3, . 10 + A( (' "$ "$.# (!0'

#1,3

'$ 1$

" 40'!( #' / ,03"

(0 $ "! '1 # $,.

,/" $!$ '!' C 9 A( (' ( #4!"

"! 4'

$! !0, 1 ' '

3($ ",

37$ (#,## $ ('

'#3($ , 3 1:!0 "#(,

"$' "$

, 230, 1 (',"

#4!"

& "$ !, "7 # "#

(2 ' 1$ 40'!( #'# '/ ,0 $ !$#" '

#,, "$

#$ $,2/ .0 $ "$ "$"

10 (( ,# 1$3(","$. "7 $ "$

$ 1$'

$ 3",,"$. 4'

$ '

('/$ " $ / (!

$ 7$2 # "#!, "7

(2 " $ /-$3, . $2

#,,:!0 12 (/$ ' "#!, "7

"# #

1,"#( 7 $.

1$ " 40'!( #'# 0412 # "# ,#0'.

","$. ,# "#$ ,#

(',"

#4!"

@ 0$#, ' ( '#4$ $ 4,

$ ( (' ( $ ( 0'.

,, (4"$

-$12 #( / 0,21$ !$#" ' 121 (!0'

#1,3 $ ( /1$ !"

# "#!$ $

#$!7'( '

"# 74, #3("!(( /$7'"

4 "!0, ',23($3($ (2( 40'!(

, $ -$3"$."

0,,2

#,, 7, #01#"# "$."$

"#7"## , ,( #1$ #0.(

+ ''"/ ,!, "7# (4 "#"$ ("# ,"$ ("$

#01#

,B0# "$# , 33("!($ '7"$

"$12 (!0'

60 "!

30, 14'4'

-# !-

10 3("!( ('

"#$ "#40

9 .'7$ #,,"#

;:+=#4'/'#"$

('#4$ $ 4,

'$# 7$2 #+)***?3 #4 " $ 2

:!0 #,, $ 2 $ ('#07 #+)***?3 " $ 9

/" 3'"

"$.:9'!' $1 !- .'7$ ;:+="# 4'/ 12

"$. 3"

$## !(( '"$.(A F 3'"

"$.;:9= 9

$ (1 !- ;:+="#4'/ 12 "$.(A ,

."$ '"$.(("7#, $ '"$. (3"

$## 1: #A )( # 4# "$!$ '7"

23"

(("#4, "$.#)#4!"

,,2

"$. 4 27$ #+)***? # '$# 7$2 12 ("7

$"$.($

3($ #,,3 #:!0 12 ("7"$("#

/0' $ #

2 $ ('#07 #+)***?3 " $ 9

(, .' 1#, ># )***?4'-",,

G$ ' $"$.( '"$. #A+( #"$$0$!'

'7# 7"

:!0 ;:+="$

!!4 $ "'/'#"$

(0#)$"

(' #,, :+=$'3'"

"$.;:9="# "#40

8 ! 3"

( ("# #"

"$) $ $,2 $! /$ '

$ "$.( # 3"

$## ( 4,

3 # B0# "$ 10 /$ "$#"$0

"$#3'7 ("7

(3 # 7 $ "$.# )***? '7

(710 3($ (2 " $ ."/("7 ("# 70$ )( ' 3"

$##

"#3'

($ "!

3($ $"$.( ' (3"

$##1: #A+)(( !!4 !( $ /'2 #4!

$ ( #, 1'

1 ':!0 "$.# , ;: ="$

# )$3 #)(( !, ',2 "#!,# 10 #01#"# #,, 7, $ "$

/0'

#4"

", !'##:

7"$

$("7)$ ("$.

"740.$"$.("#("#!' $!#0'

! $'!' A($7'#!'0 "$"H"$.

$ .'",,"$.1!

7 (!'##:

7"$

"$)7' $#4 '$ ,27'. #

) 7,"#("$. (!

# # ,#!

.'"!

,,2 4#

,3 2#!$ "$0

$ 3",,"$. 4'

10 (("7#,

#$ '

:!0 , "$

(0#("7#,

1 2 ("# '

"$## $ 3",,"$.$## 4'

'7 ("# 4 !$ )"$

"# 3'

( $ "!

( /$ # ( 1$ !$!$

"$.$4'/"$.# , +

89;: ="$ ("'

/0'

'7 #):!0 3("!("$

"#$ $" "

('12 /$ ' $"$.('12 ('#4$ $ 4,

* (7 4"$ '!$#" '

"$'

('"# 3( (' /$ #) $3 #) ( $2-$3, .' "$

10 #,,;:+="$

'$ 1 '

"$. , ;: =:!0 "$ ("'

/0'C

B0,,2) ('"

2 , # ( .3 $ "$.( / &(

"-( ',"5( $ ('#)

;

=,,$ "

< $ < 3# 4'

+)!"

12 (/$ #!, "7"$.

"# / .0 $ "$ "$"

) #$ (,4 (7 $ " ('"

2$"

10$ '"#$':

$ ( 1$."/$:

,#$ "#!'$"1, #(,

#0!( $ "#$

1, #4!"

$! $ (4'#$ !

#)# , ;: ="$

( #:

,2 7 #!'"4 #"# / ", 1,"$

#,, ;:+= A($ !( $ /'2 -( #'

$071' "# #4!"

,,27$ "$ "$1 ( !07$ #) #( / $.'0$ '

"# 4"$ "$.'

(/ ," "

$ ,.

;:+= "7", ',2 #0

' '4 "$) 4, 1#$!

:!,0#"/ 3$'#("4 3"

( /$ ' $ "$.( # $ !0 $2 "!

0#( ,$( :!0 # , 7, $ "$ ("'

/0' 2 44,2"$. 7 )/ ," "

2 "$

$$ 1B0# "$ 12 #

' ("# #4!

-$ 0'

(' "#!0##"$)"

7 21 4"$ ,2$ "!

#,,"#/ .0)

8 "$"

$ 0$!'

"$)( #$7'"

&',21!

0#"

7$ "$ 1@@- ,)."/"$.

", 4 "!0, '# (' )10 "$

'7 '/$0'!' "

#!,

#$,2 +-

7 ', #) #$ 7 - 1/ .0("#4,

-$12 /$ ('3"#"#$ 1,1!

0#/$ , "$ ("'

/0'"# $,2 +- ,

7 ', # ("## , ;: ="$

#4'/#

$ 3"

$ "$.'!"

$ 1"$.@@- ,#)"$

,, $ (, "$.$,2 + - ,#

7 ', #4'

",# $ "$ #,, ,#"$

'7# 6 $ " (2

8 ;: ="7", ',2)/'#"$

$"$.(3 #$ 1#,0 3$' "$#0"

(0#!0, $ /$ ' "$ 3"

$ # 7,"#( 1!

0#/$ , "$

#"# :!0 $,212 $"$.( $ # ,!$#" '

#( ' ('!3$'#3"

(("73 # 0,2 4#"

"$ ("''#4!

"/ $- !!0$ # @ A($ ('"##4!"

"!#

7$ /$ ' $"$.(

' :!0 "$ ( # , ) ( ( "#!,# 10 #01#"# "$.

.'7$ "$

,- '"$.( $ ("#

&("$ '"$.()3( ,#( /$ ' (3"

$##1: #A $ A9)

#( /$!(-# $2-$3, . #,,;:+= ,

."$ '"$.(1,$.# /",, .( -, 7!( $) #"#!, '7

, ( 4, "

#, 7 "$.() '4 $!( /",, .

# /"H 0'40' 5"'4 , 5) !7"$. "$ #044'

( /$

#"#$

-"$.$"

#3$7'"

#) "7$2 7"$.( A+

$/' , ("7' $2 $!( ("#/",, . 10

:!0 #,,"$("#

/0'12/$ ' $"$.()"# $#".$"

$!"$!

!$! ,21,$.# $ ('/",,

('3 #$ "#40 4$ "$. 60 "!

"$) (7

'3 #$ 1 1'0.( ($ "! '4 $!( (/",, .$ 1#$! $2 "#40 )

#$ :4!

. '0$ (/",, . ,,"$. '4 $!('

$!(#

(( #,, , 3$' $"$.("$("#

/0' 0$#, # ( # $ ("$. 3'".., 0

7$ $"$.(;A+=3(( ##

((

"#!,# 10 #01#"# "$. 7, $ "$

."$ '"$.( $ ,- '"$.( $ ("#

('&("$ '"$.( "# (0# !,

(7#,/#(

-$ ('"#- 40'!( #"$. $ 3("!(( ,3 2#1$ .' 1#,

12/$ '

$"$.( ## ",,#01#"# "$. + $"$.(;A+=3 #$/'!'##:

7"$ $ #4!

(( $/' , ,- '"$.('("#

('&("$ '"$.(

10 ("# ( /"$. :!0 ;:+= 10 $ '#7$

;:9="$

7 $"$. ('12

7$ $ ("#

#4!

.#0$'10

$ 0$!( ,,$. "$ 1#$! !'##:

7"$

"$ $ ("#/"

, #4!

(')"

"# !, 7"##"$ ("# "7$2$ ("# !0$ 12 # )$3 #$ ("##"

"$)!, "7

(2 '1$ " 40'!( #'#

$ ##(

' $ "#

$/ ,0"$ (2# , 3 9 "$ "$. ("'#("4!

0.( "$ '7# ("'3$ 7"##"$ 12 #) ('4'"4('

,"##0#( /1$'

- 0412

# "

"$. ' < , A (3 $ (' / '"4

( -'

9*9)"

"#!, "7

3($

-4"$.!$ ,"/124'

'7"$.("#4 $ " $

#(3("#'

"$## $ 3",,"$.$##"$' ' !, "7#4!"

$!) ("#!, "7$,2 .##0'/"/# $,2 (' ' #4!"

"! 4, "$.# 3"

( '.

' ("# "$## $ 3",,"$.$## 4'

12'#4$ $

."$ '"$.(10 /$ ('3"#) ('"#/'3(,7"$./" $!

#044'

$ #0#

"$#0!(4, "$.# , "7

$7$2 4 (1 $!# ,!$#" '

"$ ,#

74 $ '."#

"$!( '.# ('7"#!,, $0#:4$##)"#

,# $#".$"

$!1!

0#'

23"

(1 $!# ,!$#" '

,#7$2 4 2#

74'."#

"$ ('7"#!,, $0#:4$##$

44"$ 2)

!( (

"! (01."# ') &0- ',

."$ '"$.( '"$. #A "#/"/" $ , 1'

$ ("#!0$ "$7 -"$. 4#"

"$"$!$#$ $!3"

(("#4, "$.#

1$'

$ 3",,"$. 4'

(

,# 4'/ 44,"!

;: = 7 12 ("7 01 ."# ')&0- '.

"$.("#4'#$!7 '- "$

"! /$

')3($ #4, 2"$. '0 #$ !7"$.

'3 ' :!0 , )(( "##0 $ "!:$ *

('0.(("#!0$#,('"55( '7 )3(#,'-7 '< ,A@$ '"$.

(3"

$##1:( #4'/ $ "!:('"#0$ ## ", "7$2

."$ '"$.(A

/$ ('

",,

)(!$ "$0# 1 $ 3",,"$. 4'

8 /$ $ "$.( '"$. # A+) #0#

"$"$. #044'

"$.!

)( #!$!

3('

$ 3",,"$. 4'

10 (( $ 1$ 3",,"$. :!0 , (0#( #!, ',2 7"

0, #3"

(/$ ' $"$.()3('

('0.(0 1$'

$ 3",,"$. 4'

&',21!

0# 1$ ",

'7' $ 3 '# :!0 10 3"

("$,"7"

"$)"4#

"#$ .'0$ $$#0"

044'

#0.( '7&'# $ (2 $"

'- ' / 7 0 ( $" 1" $ ('#

8 + 12

# #$ #044'

(!, "7 #)1!

0#"$

('"

('3 #"$' "$

, 2$ (4

(' 4 ( !$ $ "$

/$ ,"

2 !' ' #4!"

$!3 #'

0# $ (4'#$ !

#$ $,2

#01#

$ #0#

"$ ("#4, "$.)(1"$.'

$ 3",,"$. 4'

'7 ('0.(0 )/$/$ ' $"$.(( #044'

("#!, "73(",!$! "$.

0, $$4'

#3"

(("7 $ $ 3"

A($

:!0 , : "$

" $

- 70!( "7 "$ 44' !("$. #-"$. #4!"

;:+=) ,# /"

* "#',/ 7$ "$('

'10 (!, "7 /$ ' $"$.(

(("7#, #$ '

$ 3",,"$.

:!0 , "$

)/" $!3 ##0.( 1 4' 0! 12 #3($ (2( #077$ 3'"

G"6 2507 '$ 9+

8 ,$.3"

(."# '$8

8 #(3

$ 44"$ 2) # 4'#$ "$ (

"! 01 ."# #'

:!0 , "$

"#$ :4, "$ 12 3(2 " #077$ 3"

$## G"6 2507 '3 #$ :

7"$ 12 (7"$ "$ ,/" $! (0.( 4'7"##"$ 7( 1$.'

12 (!0'

!!' "$.,2 3"

$##( ,#1$#077$ $:

7"$

G"6 2507 ') 3'"

') (0#.# (!

0# #

0$#, ' # ( # !"

& ", , "$ / 7 #"/" ('#) *** @*8;

=)0'."$.

"/ ',"

.#( /"$.1$4, )#4!"

$!#(0, ( / 1$'

0# )4 "!0, ',2"$/"3 ( , 2 ","$.

$! ,2 "#3"

("$,"7"

"$ G$ '

("7#, $ '"$. (3"

$##1: #A+( #!, "7

#("#

0, ) 3('

('0.(0 1$'

$ 3",,"$. 4'

'7("# /$"$ (!"

('"

44"$ $ "!( 1$"##0 (/$ '

@7$ (# ('

", # ",, 7$ (#

$ "!)"

#(,

(#!"'!07#

$!#3'#0

"!"$ $0.( (, 11,

$2 (',"

#4!"

$!$ (4'#$ !

#) 1:!0 $8

$ !7 '3

:!0 , )

. ("#4'#$!7 '- /"

44,"!

"$: "!3 #"##0 $ *

8@( /$

($ " $ 0'$04'

('1 2

$ #, ,

$ 60#

#('

3(",) ", )3("!( $$ 1# " ( /1$ ", 1,

,2# '

0# (',"

#4!"

$/"3

", "#!0##"$) ,,#01#

,B0# "$#

3 ' $#3' #

@ "$ "$.$7'"

("#'.0, '#!$ ,"# "#7"## 3"

!# # !'#( 1 '