High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6748/2021disposed of

Jagat Pal v. Haryana Staff Selection Commission And ANR

2025-04-21Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal13 pages

#$ % # &'( '

) '$*'

' '

) "'$

) + ),,- &'"'

'$*'

/'%% /!.!

) '

'/!

#(!$

!""# #$%

#% "

!" "# # $ %

#% " ( () *'#

!" %

"# $$ "+#' '""' , (, - !""# #$%

, %'# !""# #$%

#% "

) ,,)

#% " !" %

"# $$ "+#' '""'

. ) "

!" "# # $ %

#% ).)

'+/-

!""# #$%

$'-

1(.!

$ &#/ !

&'" '

/'. 0 121 3

451 6 7 (). "18 119:3

451 6 7 ,,) :; <=13

4516 18 7<=13

451 6 7 ""83

451 6 7 () 12 7% 13

451 6 7 (,) "<1791>13

4516

71"?913

451 6 7 , /1 1@71 >123

451 6 7 ).) 12<;

9 <3%1 =111 6 %"" :1<93

451>7 81@17 3

451 6 7

?18 9:171 173

451>7 "7; =17 13

451 6

, 1 () AAAA &'" '

/'.2 &

03 @=7 588 371B4 1 7 B= 2;

; 494 1= ;?71997 1 588$ 7 1:65451 >775 6 1 37 615 1 B > 6 8)(. 121 3

45171 ;1

1 15B71966 7 ().1 69 7 > 61 =#7

18 1: 5 ? = 5 1? 7 18 1 1

1 915 #7 7 ;?7 1 ; 59 !) 6 7 ; 6 ' 1 :? ? 1 6

8 ! ,) C; 7 C >1 1 81 : "D;1 1 6E% 6; 7 :? 5

5 78 6 7 6

1+81; "1? = ( #7 ;

;1 1 8 !

,) C; 1

9 6 7 6

1 +81 ; " 1? = #7 1 918 18 59 , 1 B= ;%; #7 8 8 53@= 1 18 8E > 4 614; 6585199=1: "5 #7

"1 <4 8

; 651 , C; >7 B= 16 1 18 8 ; >1 8 98 ' >1 591 9= 8 7 65171 5786 41>99B6654

56199

5 5 ;841515 B6 16 #7 941 C 15 6 651 , 1 ;5 1 B9>0 "

!"#

$%&

' "

( ( )

)

+, .

,. /

%$.%2.2%$3."

The respondent- Haryana Staff Selection Commission issued

8 ! ,) C; 4?

951 6 7 6

1+81 >1 1 81 : 6 " 1? = #7 1

1 7 > 1

5; ., 81 :

; 6 81 :

> 1 81 : 6 5 5855 1>757> B1>1 1786 5 ;=6

5;8 #7

5 199 7 51 >7

1 > 6 5585 5 1 >7 1 6> 51 7 8 61 > 4 6 5 ;=6

5;8 #751 > 4 51? => 381?7 B=3 51 >7 1

9 ; < 19 1? = > 5 6

5 ;= 6 5;8 < 19 1? = >7 1 51 >7

9 ; 4 1? = > 5 ; 4 1? =155;6 1 15581=51 >771

9 ; "1? => 5199 6 5 ;=6 5;8 7;?7 7=71 5; 8 81 :

7151 >71

9 < 19 1? = 155; 6 4? 6 5 ;= 6 5;8 3 7

B? 9?B9 >1 ? 1 81 :

; 5 585 5 1 % 5918 71 6 7 1>1 81 :

; 5 585 5 13 7 19 81 :

>;9 B 8 71 5; 66 ; < 191? =1 >991 "1? = +1 5; 96 7 ;B871

18 8 6 ; 1 8 981

1 81 : E 1 6 " 1? = #7 >1 119 B7 1 81 :? 1 6 " 1? = #7 5; 66 ; < 19 1? =>1 1 "1? =81 :

B= 4?E 1 "1? =491 9=81 1 6 ;6' 1B;19 ;5 67"1<4 8 ) /

391 5; 96 7

;B871 D; >1

; %1 =11 "166 "95 88

*1;1 =F.1 48B F.>7 1 18 8 ; >1 81 *1;1 =F 3 7;

3 7 >1 D; 8 98 41 6 " 1? = #7 >7; 1=

8; 1 5 7 95 5

1 1 7 B91 1? 51 B 8 ;B 1 8 96 ' 1 9

6 91> 71 1 51 1 714? B 591 ; ;55

6;9 5157199? 95 5

1 8#75;6681 :

; < 19 1? = 1

?8 6 ";

8 ;

"# # !!" $ %%& '# % !

"#()*

+ "*,,(7 51

19 8 5 671 816 1 5 1?7

95 5

. '71471 1 ?;8 691 5; 96 7 1

;

7 5 >77 1B91

15 $ 87 ;

196 5 3 4 71 9/;81 ).) 5; ,81 :

7> >7571 8;57 9

715;6681 :

"1 >991 < 191? ="891 51 6"74/11 "121=/;81 5,,)B? 56 >7 1;

6 9 /;81 3 "74 /13 1: 7 /;81 3

"1 1 13 ; 1 "121= /;81 3 91 5; 9 6 7

55 717 81=B5 "1? =B51;

7=714 5; 9

81 :

715;66; < 19 1? = 1 >99 1 " 1>1 /;81 19 1 = 1

95 37;

37 71 6 ;5;;

#7 1 8 >1

; ,) 7;?7 %1 =11"166"9588

54 D; 48B F . ' 7 4? 3 18 8 >1 81 ; 1 "1 <4 8

; 651 , >7 B= 18 8>1 81 1

951B9199 5 ;8 B6 16

8D; >1

; ,)3 7 %1 =11 "166 "95 88

>1 B; 8 98 41 95=0"1? =' ?571 7 71

1 1:? 1 71 D; >1

;

18 8 6 ; 6 ' 1 1 7 7 71 4 16 "1? =@= 4? 1; " 1? =37

55 71 7 7;9 B 41 6 "1? =37>4 3588 8 1:>7

5;8B 6

9= 71 1 9= 19: 1B; 4 6 @< 1? = #7 >1

; ? B6 7 ; >7

5 41; 1 51? = 4 @57 6 7 ; 1= 41 ; @< 1? = #7 1 4 6 @< 1? = > B; B 1

< 19 1? ='1

1 71155;69?1>7

5@< 1? =37

1 81 : 1 1 6. 1 6 " 1? =

>*;

?@576

C; 56,0 /,78 /8,

9:0 71 79 71 51 3 714? 1: 1 7 95

>7; 1= 8; 3 51 57199? 7 18 16 714?B 591 ;55

6;9#751 511

B11 B1 1 7 18 8 51 1 51 199? 71 95

>1 ;61 7 >1 8915;17 5

B51;

95 5

>1 1911B9151 1 ' %"# - # ( .)/*0 // *)1316 6 ?51162;

?8 7 5 96>14 1

93";

8; 157199?71 8 6 7 1 717 18>;9 B8111B916 1 5 1? 7 95 5

#7 941C 15 672;

?8 1 0 425. -

6 ,

' 7

, ,

8 (

, ,

.9 #7 ";

8 ; %"# 2-3- !

" 4" 4"--( 56 7- "#!3 !

" .)/0 /) // 71 1 4 57199? 8 1 5 6 8 1

89 B=151 116 7 95#7 ; 71 718 9= 19>1= 1 81? 37;

51 6 ;B958 9=83 8 5 1 ;B252;

519

5 ;=#7 941C 15 67 1 2;

?8 1 0 452.

, ,

0 .- , , ,

, , . , ,

, .

, )6

. 5:. , ,

, ,.-

, , 0

#>*;

?@576";

8; & '&% !

"# - !

"#(./11/0**871 79 71 51 >7 714 81 ; ;55

6;9 7 95 5

51B

6 857199??7 ;9 >7571 1 B 1 =1 49146 59(6 ;6' 1#7 941C 15 6 72;

?8 1 0

4$%. ;;;;;;;. - ,

76 '

" ',

" $5

.9 (

>*;

? @57 6 ";

8 ; 9 %""!

"##5

&!$& 4!&"!:!

"#(.),0; 71 4 D; 68111B9=6> 16

1 5 1? 7 95 5

#7 ; 71 591 9= 79 71

5 9 6

9 51 4 7 91> # ; 7 >

177 79 >;9 71 9=B 1 1B9 1 5;91 9=>7 7 199? 655= 7 5

5;9 B ?1;? 9= B=

1 5 1? 7 95 5

#7 941 C 15 6 7 2;

?8 1 0 4 6+< $<. "

. - , =. ' >, =. / 8 =

7 7 . -

. ?

" $5 $A

- . $3. " , +

. ,

. 0 ""! # $ .)/10 )/;

B 4$1. + ,

, . -

, .

. - ,

)

.9 2%. ' ,

, ,

1B4D; 2;

?8 3 4 71151 1 51B

6 81

19?591;

61 8>7571 1 B 1 = 1 4914 6 59 ( 6 7 ; 6 ' 1 #7

7 51 1 1

19? 591;

6 7 87? ; 71 5 1 = ;6' 11 >99 1 651

; B= "1 <4 83 81? 7 B=3 D; 6419 =67591;

494

7=1 1

19? 591;

6 71 8 >757 8 B5 1 = ; 6 ' 1 1 >99 1 6513 7 51 B 25 17 79 #781

BC18 8 ' 9 691>71 8 5 6 71 851B5 1 = ;6' 13"1; =

4 ;9 '61=591;

671 8 5 1 = 91>3 91B9B? 1 781 1 5 B 7 91> ( #7

B= 8 1: 7 > 4 6 "1? =>7 1 7 7;9 B. #7 71

5; 8 81 :

7191 95 51 1; < 191? =3 7;

B5 < 191? ="891 51 67 '67 >7714 5; 81 :

8 71 95 51 1 ; < 19 1? =3 1 5 6 7

3>;9 ; B1

8681=19 1 = 95 51 >77142 451 8;

714 9 7 6189=#7 51 5=62B75; ='67 95 51 317 1?3 1 ; B 81= ; 7 94 ' >;9 B 7 6

51 6

67?

) 1 B6 7 ; 1 7 1 51 >7714 5; 81 :

711 7141? 717=51B5 "1? = < 191? = #7 81? 51 B 5 B51;

7= 714

5; 81 :

8 71791 95 51 < 191? = #7

71 8 98 41 6 " 1? = ;

1 1 "1 95= #7 1 8 >1

; 16 8 981 6 41 95= 6 "3 7;

>1 B; C B66 41"51 , #7

3 1 7 1?3 81= 81= B 714? 4151 37;

37 ; 6

1 57

5 1997 >7714 5; ., 8 81 :

7> #7 51 >;9 B5 6 81 :

55855 1'67=1 6; 9?B96 81 :

5 5855 11 7 1981 :

588 7181 :

5; B=91 95 51 1; < 191? = "1? =37= >;9 B 95 "1? ='67 1 14191B97= >;9 B1 2;

1?1 4151 71B 56 37

>;9 5 1 ;

;8 1 = #7 1

;

;?7 51;

51 7 >1 5 19=91

7 1 6

37;

37=51B967?71 = #7 1 7 B=

6 >7 1 5

5 591861997 1B4 8 C5 >7 591871 B 25 7 1B4 ) ' 7 B=81 591 71 162?6 36

95 3>;9 B7 161

86 1991 ;

. #7 81= 8 65 1

1577 ; #7B667 7199B14191B99= >;9 B14191B91=65 7 > 7 >;9 B 69?11 81= 1 1F @C #7

%1 =11 "166 "95 88

C 5 5195;91 5 5 1 C15 81 :

6 199 7 51

6;9 7199B >71 67 87 6 8 1= 0 9 /;81 3 "74 /13 1: 7 /;81 3 "1 1 13 ; 1 "121= /;81 1 7 B= 8

7 B= 8

6 ;5;;

* () >1 5199 6 5 ;= 6

5;8 3 7>4 3 7 >1 1>1 81 :

6 5585 5 1 % 5918? 71 B= 8 1: 7 > 3 7 71 B 1>1 81 :

37;?77 9?B9#7

71 1

? 1 6 ? 1?81 :

1 5 1#7

>79 5 ?591867 381=C1859186* 0 81 :

6 55855 1' 7 B=81 591 717 ; C

D;1* F 9881 :

55855 1 ? 8 5 1

951 3 6 1=3 7199 19 1

&'" '

/'.

&#)"! (, - 77

1:?! 1

& !

77 1B9

& !