High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/16732/2015allowed

Sandeep v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2015-09-21Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh7 pages

! "#$%%& '%(( #% )%* ("(% +","#""#$"# (-% .%& #$%#(

"!#$!%&$'

(" & )&*+ &$$!( , ! "

-.,/) '

1 !+

, ! !

"!'!

-.,/) '

!.$,+ !

,3'

3/ "

'%%#(

/(- *$-",0$1 "(% (-%&%(( #% )2""2030+","#" ."4&"#5-0$1 "(% %&

4 $3"%!15167!#187 7%$"&",%$ $3"%!9:21!#187 -%&%%#(&%(( #-"8%%#%$*#$%% ( #9! ' "# %"( # %5*" 8" 5"#(%$ ( %&

8, $$( #"% #:*$5%0 "$"8"$1$% $%$"(%$99 # "%

$"(%$ %5(%%$*#$%% ( #90909;0

< '"('

%("( #(,<""85"-0( ( "$"8"$ =%"#%$ (-%&%(( #% #(%#$(-"(#(",(-%

8""&& "( # / 1%$8, %&

8% %(-% (" *( 7" $/%$ #! -%%"(%"5"#"#"&& "( #7"/ 1%$8, %&

%5*"8"8% %(-%(" *(07- -7" " 7%$1$% $%$"(%$99 %7(-#"&% $ %(-"# #% / #(- =%"#%$ *#%*(-% #(%#$(-"((-%"%5"( #"5"#( %&

"% % * # #"(*% 8*( *8%>*%#(, 7(- *( "#, $%1% &/%#("(%! 08"-"8%%#5"#(%$( %&

&% %" #7-"( %1%-"8%%#/%#( #%$# $%$"(%$99 7-%5"#(#58"( %&

-%"%5"( # 5#5 ?"% " (-%%"5"#(%&

%(-%(-%#"(*% %# %# (-% " (*/ %"%$/" (-%8""&& "( #-"8%%# #$%%$7-% 5"#(#58"( %&

=%"#%$ *#%" #(%#$(-"((-% 8"5"#(%$8,(-%(" *("8%( 8% "# %%$ =%"#%$ %&

*8/((-"( $% 5"#(#58"( %&

8"%$ #%" ##5"#$ #(%#( # %&

=%"#%$ (-%%& #$%#( ("(%*8/((-"(8" 7"5"#(%$( %&

"(% #$%#5(-% =%& ( +%"$(-%"5*/%#("$1"# %$8,%"#%$ (-% &"(%"#$-"1%" 5 #%(- *5-(-% $%&"%$#(-%%"%8" "&& "( #"7%"*8%>*%#( $%$"(%$99 01$%7- -0%5*" 8"-"8%%#5"#(%$( %&

$/((%$,0

$"(%$ 7"%5(%%$*#$% % ( #90909;0 < '"('

%("( #(,<""85"-0( (

"$"8"$"5"#(%&

"#$ /% (-%&% #.%& #$%#(

7""%(%$ # "#$(-%%"(%-%/ 1%$"#"&& "( 8% %(-%(" *( %5*"8"07- -7"$/%$ ! -%%%1"#(& ( $%$"(%$! %& $* %$"

*#$%

@%5"( # "5"#( (-% "&& "#( "% % * # #"(*% -*/8 /&% # (-% $% %"%$ 7%% 8("#%$ / &%# #% $ #1%(5"( #"(#("("5%"#$%/"##5 " *%$-"1%# (8%%#"%(%$",%( # "%0(-%"&& "#( %%"%$ #8"0-%/",(,( 7# 1%(-%7(#%%"#$ -"/&%(-%("* -0(-%" *%$$ %# ($%%1%(-%

# % 8" .%*("#(,"#$#1%7 " %"$$ * #0(-%8" "&& "( # $/%$ % 8% #5#%$ ( (-% % $

/ ## *# %$# &%# *( $A

! B."(- $$( #"% #:*$5%0

"$"8"$C -%%"(% "# (-% "&& "( # 5"#( %5*" 8" (

7" / 1%$0 7- - 7" " 7%$ # 99 -% %%1"#(& ( (-% $%%& $* %$"*#$%

@?(- *( //%#(#5 #(-%/%( (-% "%8*(#1%7 (-% #(%#( #"%$8,%"#%$ (-%"&& "#(" ( %$"8 1%0(-%8""&& "( #" %&(%$"#$"&& "#(

$%%$( 8%%%"%$ #8" #*#-#58"8 #$#(-% */ . 00A 7(- #%*%(,#(-%2%"/ *#(( (-% "(" ( %"A*(,"5("(%*84% (( /&"# % 7#5 #$( #

(-"((-%"&& "#(-"# ( //("# %# %/"( (-%

%# % 7- - -% " *%$0 *&% (%$0 (-%

// 7- --%*&% (%$0"#$ (-"((-%"&& "#(-"# ($% (, #$% (,/"2%"#,

9 #$* %/%#(0(-%"( & /%( "#,&% #" >*"#(%$ 7(- (-% " ( (-% "% " ( $*"$% -/ / $ #5* -" (( (-% *( ( "#,& % % ("/&%7(-(-%%1$%# %D (-"((-%"&& "#(-"# (%"1% #$"7(- *((-%&%1 * &%/ (-% *(C

( " %%1"#( ( /%#( # -%% (-"( 7-%# (-% %"% "&& "( %&

8"7"$/%$(-%#-%$$# (% "#,&%(( #8% %(- *( 8"07-%%"0(-%%/%$,7" "1""8%( -/8% %(- *( #,5"#0"(%"&% $ $",

#,0% #$"&& "( # %5*"8"7"/ 1%$8% %(-%(" *( "#$ (-% "/% 7" " 7%$ 1$% $% $"(%$ 99 7(- *( /%#( ##5"#,&% %" # 1%## %" ##57-"( %1%-"8%%# 51%##(-% $%5"#(#58"( %&

"( 7-"(7"(-% *8%>*%#($%1% &/%#("(%$/" %"%8""&& "( # #(-%

$% $% ##58"0(7"/%#( #%$(-"(8"$% #%$2%%&#5# 1%7(-%% *#% (-% %# %"7%"(-%" ((-"(# "%(-% "&& "#(%%"%$ #8"-%/",(,( 7# 1%(-%7(#%%"#$ -"/&%(-%(" ?-%5"#(#58"#%(-%(-%("5% (-%("# "#,(-#5-"8%%#/%#( #%$"( - 7(-%" *%$7# (#*%# %(-% 7(#%%

( #,% *"#$&% "%5"( # 5%,8*( & *%/%#( "2%?"%(-%%"5"#(%&

=%"#%$

-"" # (8%%#"8%( - 7"( 7-"( 7%% (-% -"#5%$ */("# % $*% ( 7- - %&

7" 5"#(%$8"7-%#%"%"&& "( # 8"7"$/%$

(-"8%%#-%$#1" *4*$5/%#( (- *("7%"

+ #E8%(-%&%F *((-"(8" "#8% "# %%$7-%% $% 8" &%1%%"#$-"8%%#&"%$8,5# #5(-%%1$%# % #% $"#$8,

("2#5#( #$%"( #(-%%%1"#(/"(%"&" %$ #% $ ?-% 5"#(#5 8"0 (-% *( -" ( 2%%& # /#$ # ( #, (-% #"(*% "%5"( # 8*( " (-% &*#-/%#( 7- - "# 8% "7"$%$ "#$ (-% %" #"8% "&&%-%# # (-% 7(#%% 8%#5 ("/&%%$ 7(- "&&%-%# (-%%8%#5"(-%"(( (-% /&"#"#(+ #E8%(-%&%F *(#(-% "% &)&'&$;" &

!# &',&'!

9 ../#"!;97-%$%"#57(-"#"&& "( # 8"-"("(%$ (-"( %("#" ( "%( 8% #$%%$ 8"0(-%,"%D(-% #"(*% " *"( #"#$(-%%1%(, &*#-/%#(# "% #1 ( "#$(-%#"(*% *&& (#5%1$%# %D%" #"8%"&&%-%# ("/&%#57(-(-%7(#% "&&%-%# (-%"(( (-% /&"#"#(D "#$&/"" %"(" ( (-% *(#*&& ( (-% -"5% /", + #E8% (-% &%F *( # (-% "% &<&"

=&,&)&',!

";" &) &"&,;3"

(&'&

&&',&'!

../#" 07-%/"2#5$(# ( #8%(7%%# "# %"( 8""#$ #$%"( 5"#( 8"-"-%$"*#$%

@ ; #$%#57-%(-%( "# %(-%8"(-% *(-" " ( #$%(-%5"1(,"#$#"(*% (-% %# %0&/"

" % "%"5"#((-%" *%$0(-%& ( #"#$("#$#5 (-%" *%$0%( (-%%"%1%,% *"%5"( #"5"#( (-%" *%$-8"/",8% "# %%$%1%#-%-"# ( /*%$(-%8"5"#(%$( -/ % 1%0(-%"8 1%&# &% "&&%7-%#(-%"/% *(7- -5"#(%$8""&& " -%$ "# %#5(-%8" (7# ("&&,7-%#(-% $%5"#(#5 8""&&%"%$"5"#(8% %"#"&&%"(%A.%1 #" *(

! * &# #0(-%%# "8 *(%*%(-"( # %8" 5"#(%$( (-%" *%$(-%#( "# #,8% "# %%$(-%% 2%-

$ /*% (-%8"-"(" ( 0(- *5-# $ *8(

/& ("#(0 # ( (-% #, " ( -%% "%%1%" (-% " ( 7- -/",8%%%#7-%$% $#5( "# %(-%8"C

*(-% + #E8% (-% &%F *( # (-% "% &, &'&'

&);".'&% &$&)&',&'!

. !;;-" -%$(-"( /%"#" ($%%/%$8,"7( 8%-"/*( (-% %(,# 5%#%"0%1%#(- *5-(//%$"(%1 (/"##$1$*" /",+ #E8%(-%&%F *(#(-% "% "&

=&.&>3', 3'/ ,3;" &

!#& &&"

&&',&'!

!!!!"(7

:*$5%<%# -0-" 8%1%$"*#$%

@/%"%1 ("5"#((-%7- % %(,"#$"#"((" 2 (-% 1G"( (-%$", $%(-%8" #%%$ "#,

5"#G%$ 1G%$ %(, "#$ "#, "((%/&( ( $(*8 (-"(

$%"% ((-% %(,"#$(-% //*#(,C H%%&#5#1%7(-%" %"$" (07- -"%( 8%8 #%# /#$07-%$%"#57(-(-%"&& "( #/ 1%$*#$%% ( #9!'0 # %&% ( % * %# %0 (-% $(# ( # 8%(7%%# " E&%1%%E E%5"E $%"#$ "# %"( 8" 8"0(-%$%#( /% "#$(-%4*$5/%#( (-% *(0(( 8%%%#"( - 7#(-% "%# -"#$(-%8""&& "( #-"8%%#$%"(7(-8,(-% 7% *(-% $%

5"#( 8""$/((%$, ,&( "#$*#%" #"8%"#%(-%(-%#"(*%

%# %/%#( #%$# (-%("5% (-%(" 1%#%"%"&& "(

%5*"8"7"$% #%$8,(-%"/% :*$ " % 8, &"#5 " &%"2#5 $% "#$ #$%#5 %("# " ( //%$"(%,"(% $",0(-% 8"-"8%%#5"#(%$7(- *( /%#( ##5"#,%" # 1%#(-"# (8%%#/%#( #%$"( 7-"(7%% (-%" ( $*%( 7- -(-%8"7"$% #%$ %(-%#(-%"&& "( 8"# #(-% $%0(-"8%%#/%#( #%$"( - 7%&

7"%#((%$ 8""#$7-"(7%%(-% -"#5%$ */("# %$*%(

7- -8"7"5"#(%$-%(" *(7"#(-%"/%("5% #(-%$"(%

&"#58 (-(-% $% $#5,0(-%%/%(#(-% #(%#( #"%$8,%"#%$

(-%&%(( #%-%&%%#(&%(( #" 7%$"#$ $%$"(%$ 99 5"#(#5 8" ( %&

%( "$% -% & % "*(- (%"%$% (%$( ("2%%&

# *( $, (-7(- %&(%/8% 0 ? @ &