Pandit Gulshan Kaushik v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
"#$%&'(' )* #+ ,- -#$%''
&.
!
!
/ 0.&.
12
' 33
3 4
12
' 34 2 "
#$%#&'
' &(&&)* # &%&+*#&, &(&&
#$%#&' -.&)* # *&'
#&.*& & -.&& # *-&/&, -.&0
1&''.& 2 # *%+*&& 0* # *-(& &* -.& 0* 1!!3456378772 #&$#&*&9& -.&0 # * *% & -.& 0
7:1!!3456378772
3 4
6' 6
. !;3<6=<37877 & !;36>54537877 & 0/ & .//0.& *0+**) &'&+'+ 3 . *%,*&.// #- .!!345637877& !#3 #36787=3787=&'
+./&% 0/.& % -'& +, /& &* &.0*./ .. - 3&3-
+(* !% *% %,* .(0*) 1 &2 %'3 &'( * & !!345637877& !#3#36787=3787=&&'
'&+' + . &',)**) 1 &2 7 *'
.
&(.%''%* &( )''& * 0&. .& &.*0*) = * &( /& !;3<6=<37877&& % "
!
"
# $
%
&
'( $) * +&
*&
* +
> * &( /& !;36>54537877&& % "
1&2 .&.'&''.-(&.
?.% 0&-% 0* & 0*'& @% 1+2
%.*
& )''& * ' ) . &% @% '' && * ) & ,+0* A+'!% 7 +),* 8)*-$9*#+-8-$9#+ ((:;*7 +)*7 #+*7
<
$*< *-*-#$ )8#$9=-*7#*7 < #$ &2 *%,*& /& 77846BB7 * !%)&
'& /&$& 0 &% @%+,/&&
.0 *&.@% '&
)- * & ) *+0.&(
&/& /%.*& *
/& %/ '& * &
) )& /
6:867866 +( * !% 66847866 & &
0*
% '&
+.&/&
%/
*%,*& &47=066847866 & *)& &(&,& * '&%.*,00%*&.@% . , % * & .@% 3 . 6:B>1*&00 & C*.06:B>D2 +2 ; > 4& <!;3<6=836BB7 3 %
1!2 64B6 0 7867 1.- !3467:378642 )*& * 0 7 % &&
1!2 ==<=078671.- !346>5378642 +0* A+' ?!%*
1 21 &2 * ?!% &
& 0 &% @%- 3&3-
8B857864 *' )& 3 /& * !%*&0 * 0' ./ +&,55<0786:+0* ?!% &'',, * *''*&
,1 20-'&0 0 &% @% & +3 .&/ &
8B867867 *% *,% )*.*+.&/&'
'& *./ +&,!!345637877 *%
%+9% .+0* !% .2 & (0.*'-& 0*+ -&3 . *&@% +?&. *&0 & & *% ?&. *&0 ,-
.
+
%
+
/
& 0+"#+
#!/1 $
(
%
$
+
( %
+
$ %
(
.
% $
%
2 ( 3
$ 4
+
4
* +
/
$
/ 5
% & 0+"#+
#!/+
$
$ $ +
$
4
-
4
%
* $+
%
$
2 ( +
4
/
2 (
$
$% $ /
( $+
(
6
7
*%,** &0 &(&&*&
% +0*
?!% *&*./ &&/%&
&+'- 3&3 - *&.@% '&
)%'
+ & %/0 > 5: 77:3%* *%,* &'
+ - *&(*%,** ?!%
/&$+ -& )**&+./ &.%'
+ & +%
.*'& .% ' ,* &0 &(&&+0*
?!% /& &/&*+0 *&&&/% &2 *+ &(&+'*) +%( -, .+(* ?!%&
, /*,*./ &3 *&*&+-&
%/0./ & 2 #- )& &'
&' * *&.& *
&(-'&0&( &(,*
0* - 3&3- *
% '&
*% 0-&'
+.&/ &
%/ *0 &* &.0 +%0* 3 ' ./ &% *,*&!/ && &
&.( & .@% *&+'& '/. 786=1*&00 & *E.0786=D2 *% '+(
.0*&+-+.&/ - * %'&'( * ?!%.' *.- ()*
.* 3 +./,' ./ &% *.06:B> *'
)& (..'% *&0* /
&'
&+'-'&0* ,& +(* ,*!% *% 0* )$%* / * %+9%3
.+0* ,*!%! @%'( *./ 0'
+0* ?!%)& .' ,2 *%,* * ?!% & 1 &2 &03 .' ,*./ %+9% .+0 - '+(
* .%)**./ )*.*&
&
+ & *+0+ %+9% .+0* !%*3 '
* & - '+(+.&/ % * '&$0*&
./ +,&'
%+9% .+0* !% )3 - * & %+/
&
& +&/ 9. %+/
+3 0* ?!% & &*/0.' %0*&+- ./ . , +(* ?!% ./ 3 )& %+9% .+0* !% &*./ +&, 55<0786: +.&/ % 768=7877 *% %+ @% *.' %0*./ . , +(* ?!% *2 F*&& /&( .*&-/ *./ 3 0' +0* ?!% & )*.*+.&/.'
*%,* 1 &2 & /'&* & &/& *
) +&,!;3<6=<37877& !;36>5453 7877 + /& *./ 0' +0* !% +% %+ @%*.' %0./ +&,55<0 786: +(* ?!% 2 ! @%'( )**./ )*& /'& &-/ *&-/ /& *./ +&, 55<0786:)*.*&*+.&/.' +(* ?
!% + )**'+( - * (&,& *./ *% +./ % &/ 9.+3 ,/& +0* ?!% *&*&
./
)& %+9% . +0* !% )*& * &/)& -3
'( %+9% .+0* !%&*/0.' %0.3 / 1 &2 +(* ?!% &*+.&/0'
%+ @%*.' %0*./ . , +0*
?!%*0 & '(*&+- &/ )&
&/ &/+0* ?!%. @%. *
%+ @%'( % ./ )*&-/ /'& * .& *./ )*.*+.&/.' +( * A+'!% +%+-% '( @%&(0%*&. +, &)* +(* !%
&2 ./&'/ .''&% +&,!#3#3 6787=3787=)& &'
0' +0* !% )- .*
!%0&
, *&+- *& 0 *&*&.@%
'&
)&.@% % '&)0%''('&%.* &.@% . ,
% *.06:B>*0 * &(/& !#3#36787=3 787=0, &0&&,& *&00. ..
& & ,0/&
%/ 0'',&'
& & & , 0/*&0 %&+'&''/ 0 ' +,/& *&''3 .. &'
@%+ /
-0*)&
&( &(&,&
0* 0/*
%
'&
*% %'
*)& & &
+(* !% +(* ?!% &,& *'&%.*,00%*&.@%3
. , / 0*.06:B> *% *.%'
+ &(-&' '(/& .&,& *.@%,%*(.3 . &
%/ & &
*%,* & & 47= 0 66847866 *% -*&.@% '&
/./ & % *.06:B> )- )*- '(*)& &( &,& *0%*'&%.*,0&.@% . , % . >0*.06:B>*0 )** !%*& *&+-.3 .'% *&'(-&' & &
+.&/&
%/ +(*
.@%,%*(.. + *& ..'% *&./ &3 & +.&/ / % *.06:B> +.&/ 3
/ 0 .=60*.06:B> +0*'&
!''... 0*&0* &/+./,&/&+'0 +,'& *'& ' .. *0 *&+-
&)0. &% &..'% *&*+(*/& & . &
!"# $%& '( ) & !!
*+,
" '
- . +(*! %F.*0*
?!% @% +./,&
' - 3&3- * .@%,%*( 4
. +**&
&. &
& /
&.. ,'( )$" 0.&. < /&'(&'
)** & & /'& .&% 1 20&. + .'&/ /'&'0 .&-&
!;3<6=83 6BB7 )* *)& & 0/& *% +(* ?
!% %'&'( )**%,*& /& !;3<6=836BB7 *
!%*& .' '0* 5 . @%. ,-*) <6=836BB7+, +) & /'&* & * &) *0 * &) 1 2&/ 3. % *(&+& +(*
. '0 %+9% .& .&
%'& % .680*!!
- )*0&?&. *&0 , * -( / %' 8(
$
$
$ % $
+
$$
.
$
( - % 9
+$(
$
-
$
( :% %4 9 +
5
( 7 :
. +**&
!;3<6=<37877&
!;36>54537877&&'
/
&.. ,'( B '' , &
'.&1 2 0 &( &
0 &.. ,'( 3
3 4
4 2 '' *78 7 *7 < )>-$9?
) #$ "% ?# 7 *7
<# *):8 % ?#