High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/989/2019dismissed

Nazam Singh @ Raja v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-04-24Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal,Ms. Justice Kirti Singh15 pages

!" #

$%$&'$ ( )*+*

&( (, -$ ( )**

!!"

#$%

'( ) "

+* "+

) ./ * 0

0 1/ ./0* 02 0 ' + ",

- .

/ *01" / &

!1" !!"

2 (!!/ 34/ '( )

* / *01"

' !5!/ *01"

& +* "

66666

2 03*

!1" 1"

-"" 1"

& 1*" * !9 :

*9+ &!

2 *

(&&1 "

1(+

) 5 & 1*

* !9

2 1 /

!1" !!5 * * !9 :

*9+

1* *

0 *

* *" *

+* "

/ !9/ +

* 1 + */ 5 1;("" *

+ 1"+ < / <=/

<8/ <</ 8 :

8 = >'

! * **"!

& ?(*1!

+"" / +/

+ "

) &! * 1" < :

1!"/ !9/

+ .

+ 1!

! 0 !

& $44-5% <

) & &1"+

1!"

8 :

)("

, /

1!"

5& @(!5* @(

". "

( @(

& !*+

1!"

5& 5 +5 1"" + *+/ '(

"1" 5

88 & !*+ +"" * 1(!"0"

&1)!9

1!"

5& @(!5* @( " * +"

& 1(!"0"

!*/

0 )!5

1!"

+ *

+ !&

BC +"(1.

!""!

/ '(

BC )!5

+"(1.

1!"

& !!

5 ! /

+ '(

!+ 1

B )!5

)1.

1!"

" * ( 59

&" / '(

+"" * *

( @(/ *( /

+(&& *

( +

1./ ! &"

)1. @(!*

+ 4( "

& !*+ 1

5" ++ *

11( 1

++ &! * 59 &

1!"/

5& @(!5* @( "

( @( 5

+"!

1!"

*"" * )("

*( + (+ ( +/

1!"

*"" * 0!

2+"!/ +

&" 1* !9 0* 1 /

+( * 1"+ <=/ <8/ <</ 8 :

8 = >' *

1" <:

> 1 0* 1 /

1!"

D * A

@(!*

+(" *

0 +

1!"

5" ++

* A " " *

0 +

1!"

A< @! "/ *1!

&&1 / 0!

2+"!

*1! !!9 D * ( @( &(*

( + * "! *

*1!

$D'

*1!

( @(

$D'E

.* 5 & ( + 1+ (9

)!("

+ " /

*1 ! !!9 D *

* "! * "

$D'3 (!

*1!

$D'$

&" D

1* - F9 "/ (9

* 1! * 0(+ "( (9 +(&& *

* * 5

3 0 ?*!/ *1!

&&1 / 0!

2+"!

+ " * *

*(!9 +5 &&*0"

$DA:G/ 19 F9

$D'A:GE 19 F9 "

( @( $DA:G

+ 1"+ <=/ <:

<< >' *

1" <:

>' & * +"

1 *+ +"

5 )" * *(

* "

&" & / 1++ D * !!

5" ++ + D1 "

3 0 ?*!

&" /

1!"

1!+ *

0* 1

"" "

1" < < ' 1* *

1" ("

* *

+"" *

1 "

* ) &!+ !9 !1" * >

!* +(

.!+ &

1(!"0" & @(

8 :/ / ( @(/

@(!5* @(/ E!* 0

&!1" * ( +

)0 +* !*

+"" "

'( / H> < *" * 8 :

1"+ <</ <:

<8 >' *

1" <:

>' +" *

'!1 "" ? +"

)0 +* ++/ 5 &1 "!

5" ++

+ ("

++(

+ "

1!"

) &! * &!+ &1"+ 0,67 %% ( %(48$& $ -(, %$84(&59$::$88 5

+()"" *

! * 1(+ !

!!"

( * * !)!

) + "

&*+

! * "!

5 +(+")!

9 + !5

+ )+ * 1 1"( + +(+ +

! * "!

** !9 "+

(*1!

* ** 1"

0 5 ! *(1 * 1*

!!"

&(!!9

1 1" *

+* "11(+ *

1++ && 1 &

* ) + " *

8;% %

&" (

+"" "+ 5" ++ +

*1( "+ !1 * 1*/

1+* * 0 5 1+

1++ 0 + H> < *" * 8 :

1"+ <</ <:

1" <:

>' +" * '!1 ""/ ?

11( 1

+ / )9

11( 1

*"" * )"

" + )("

* " "

+ "

1+ +1 "

++ "9

0 +

1!"/

+ "

1!"

8 :

)("

, /

!5"

5& @(!5* @( "

( @( 5

+5 + *+ & !* '(

1 & ".

!1 '(

0 BC )!5

1!"

* +0

+ !& + *

!""!

& 1(" >

5 ! / +

0 B )!5

)1.

1!"

" * +0

+ !&

59 / '(

* * ( @(/

1!"

$ -8$'

$ -$

* ( * ( @(

A< 3 @! "/ *1!

&&1 D * ( @(

0 * "

$D'

- $D'E 1"!

* $D'

> 1++ D"/

+"" * * "

( @( " *

- '++)!"9 (9 +

( @( ) + !& +(&& * *( &!!

) (! * ("

)

* ( *

A< 3 @! "/ *1!

&&1 0 * -

$D'$ 1"!

* $D'H &("

+"" *

(9 * "! * F9 "

* 1! * 0(+ "(

1(+ *

* * 5

! +(&1 !9 +!!

""1 * *+!

!" !

+(&1 +(1

(9 1 ) 1(+ *

> (9 +(&& *

0 + +*

* " * +"

)!5

& + 5(!*

0 )

(9 !""!

& 1(!* )

1(+ *

0 / (9

& +

* *!9 5

0 ! )!* =

1 +

/ +

+ !& +(&& * (9

3 0 ?*!

0 *

F9 "

$DA:GE &1"(

+ (

@( F9 "

( @(

0 *

$DA:G

$4$ -$'$&% (

* & 1 " * * 19

)* $D 3E

++ ++

D" "

:=G< & 1

* ("" *" * : < 0*

("" +1" * &0( @+ 3 0 5*5 A

/ 2) / @(/ ) @( !* A

+ E1

;(!

+ 0 ( 1*/

"9 5 * A

" * @+ 3 0

!* A >&

!* " * -+ A /

0 0 !* ! + 9 >"

1!"

"1 5 0 ++ ++

!* 5 * A $D3 "

" *

() >+ 1" ?(

" *

8 :

1(!"0"

!* ".

! +

& @(

* 1(+ * ( + $D33

1+ ""! * ""

"1 + 5 & * +"

1!"

+ "

1+ / E)( /

@(!5* @(/ 0 @( 1"+ <:/ <8 / <:

8 8 $D3H 19 !! + " * 1+ H> < *" *

8 < $D34 1+ H> < *" * 8 < +" *

+ "

2C)!

( 1"

(* "+ !

* !

+1 5 +

!!"

* !

!(1*" *,

!!"

1("

&(!!

5 0 5/

1+*

(

* &(* *

* !

'1 *( /

< ("+

!""/ +"1" 1*" D 1+ +(1

!!"

1("

) & 9 1

5 11!(+/ )"

;( +"+ &1"

#(+ D +++/ +(1

+/ B+()+""!

1 !! ++C/ B* +(&&1 "

(*+C/ B0 9

+" 11(+"1 +C/ B*+"" * 11!(++C/ B!

+". +C/ "1 " * * 1("!

D" +0 5 +

!!"

1("

1;(""! (1

+ ! +

"( B&!(+

!( C ++

!(1"1 !!"

1("

" &

1("!

1("

0 5

1 "+ 5 11!(+

0 !!"

1("/

5 0 / (+"

) *

1+ 1;(""!/ *()!

+(" &0(

11(+ * H+"!9/

+(" 1 1

0!)!

&(* "!

(+(* 1 0 9 + !!

) +( * )

1 "

(! ++

0 * (!"9 1 " "

1("

!5 1*!9/

0 + 1( *

1;(""!/

+("

1 1 &("

&1 */ && *

+" "

1("

0 >& "5 +)!

11!(++ ++)!

)++

1*/

!!"

1("

(!*

*+"()

&* 1* *

1("

(* ) 1

2C)!

D %9(< 2,7&0

=99 $8>%055$(4 * *0

$0??

*0 " *

;( +"

(+*1" 2

!+ +"

1;(""!

!*,

*,& % -5 ( (459$ =9(,&5

::$8%=

%5 -@, 558%

&+"

!9 +()++

)+ * 1!

!* *5

1;(""!/

!!"

1("

5!!

" &

(! ++ +()+""!

1 !! ++

1 +()++ !!

1(+ !+ &

!!"+ +/ & /

(+"& * 0 +

1;(""!

+" !5

+ 1"

(+*1"

1+ + !+ +"

1;(""!+

5 !!

+")!+ * &" 0 5

(* "+

+() 1"/ 1!& * 9 &:: '* 055$ (4 2& 5<"#0?

I< #(+ D +++/ +(1

+/ I+()+""!

1 !! ++J/ I* +(&&1 "

(*+J/ I0 9

+" 11(+"1 +J/ I*+"" * 11!(++J/ I!

+". +J/ "1 " * * 1("!

D" +0 5 +

!!"

1("

1;(""! (1

+ ! +

"( I&!(+

!( J ++

!(1"1 !!"

1("

" &

1("!

1("

0 5

1 "+ 5 11!(+J

8 >"

+(&&1 "

!* *5

+""(" E 1

**=&A8'*055$ (49&%95&"B+#0 ?)

I = KE("

"( ! !

5 0

11(+ 1"

1("(+

) * !

!+ +"

1;(""!+/

(*()" *!9 ""! * 1

"+ 5 11!(++ (

**(1 *

+ 1(" + 1"

(!"

1 1

11(+ * +"

) 1!& *

'09 (1!

09$( 0A&,: '* 2

= 7:$&(& ,&(977 '*7:$&(&C ? ?D

K!!9 E7$& 0

=9 '* 055$ (4 , E6 C"?#0)?+0 !D )+ 0 *

" & 1

5(!* )

(+"& * !9 & I0 9

+()+""!

1 !! ++ * +J > + "

* 1++/

) +"" * * 1 )

0 + * !9 & I* +(&&1 "!9 1 "

++J

& I+" ++J > 1"

&& 1"

)+ 0"+/ (+"

) ) * )+ 0"+

5 " * * !9 *5 * &! D)!

(!* 0

* 1+

1;(""!+ 5 " * */ (!* )

0 " * * "*(1 **"!

1*"

1!(+

1" :<

* !!

)+ 0"+ " * * ++

* !

( ) 1("(+ ) 1(+ -* (++ !!

)+ 0 *

1+ 5(/

+(" 1 1 &0(

I+ 1 "!9 5 . *

&1"

) 1;("" *

"!J & /

" +"

+( +" *

D ++ I+()+""!

1 !! ++J

(!* ) 1+"( * &(!

) *!9

! * 0 9 1+

&& 1"

1 "

* 1++ ("/ & +"1 / A5 0

=9 '* 055$(4 E%59 C B0?D &6 %0

=9 '* 055$ (4 , E6 C B 0 +D +/

1 ++9 ) & 0 +

(* "

1;(""!/

(+"

1 ++!9 1" +

&*+

1* * 0 + KJ

= H!!5

+""(" E 1 /

9,&$; /8 '* 055$ (4

"!# 0 ?

&(!" *

&!!5 1! +,

&!!5 1! + & 1+ +

!!"

9 0 5

!+ +"

+ 1"+ < <=

'1 *( * /

< >"+ 5

0 5 5*

!!"

1("

" 1* >"

0 5

1("L+ 11!(+

+ 1"

&1"+ !5

+( * 1 "

("!

(!"9

++ ++ * +("

) &

1("

1("L+ )!+" +

+("

1 "

< 3( 5 1+* " (+"

)

1("L+ * 1+ + 1!!9 "(

5" ++L 1 *)!"9 ++( >"

(

*&& "

0 5

0* 1 (+"

!+ ) +()+""!

1 !! ++ &

1("

> !

)0 /

!!"

1("+ (!* &!!5

5 !!+ ""! * 1! +

19+"!! * ()

(* "+ & 0 (!

5+ *+"()

1("L+ 1;(""!,

!!"

1("

9 !9 0 (!

5+ *+"()

1("L+ &

I0 9 +()+""!

1 !! ++J & * +

() +"1 + +

!!"

1("

5(!*

0 I0 9 +()+""!

1 !! ++J

*+1*

1("L+ * 1+ I# 9 +()+""!

1 !! ++J D+"

1("L+ 11!(+

&1"+

!)!9 5M

1("L+ * 1+ )+ * (+

0 5 !5M

1("L+

(* "

!. !9 +(!"

I0 +1

(+"1 JM

" 1

1("

* !

" "!9 !! !M

1("L+

(* "

& +"!9 ( (+"

( +)! M

1("

+ *

" !

* " !

*1( "+ !.

*9 * 1!"+G "

)!!+"1 D "/ "1

0 !+"

" * * ) !!(+""0 /

(+"0

!!"

(+"

!59+ 0 5

1+* "

&*+

1("

< >& "5 +)!

0 5+ 1 ) 1 *

! *+ 1;(""!/

101""

("+G

!!"

("+ (+"

11(+ *

!!"

+ . + 1!

! 0

(* "

* )9 "!

1("

1;("" *

+* " >"

+ ""! * !5 " + 1!

! 0

*+1 "9 5 25 0 /

+(1

) D 1+ *

(*1(+!9

("+

"" * D 1+

+ + &1 +

)"!9 )" ++

!59+ )

!* "

D 1+ 9 5 J

( -8,% (

*"" * &1"

11( 1

* ". !1

!* A

& /

1!"C+ 0 +

* +5

+ *+ & !* ) ""1. *

+* "

+11(+ * + ) &!+

1*/ 1!

(9 +(&& *

+ !&

+(&& * (9

11( 1 ** ".

1!"

* +"" * )

1+* *

0 5

1!"

&! * *(1 +(1

1(!* ) ! * ( ) 9* *()"

1 1"

+* "+

+() 1"

&& 1 +

* " & 1

!!"

19+"!! */ (! ++/

&* &(* ) 0 +

( (+"& */ " & 1

+ 5(!* ) 5" *

**"!

!9 " 1" " * 1+ +

! *9 9+ 1;(""!

!59+ +("

1 1 1+ 1;(""!/ *()!

+("

)(* ! + (

+ 1(" 0

(!"

) 9* +)!

*()"

++ * 5 !!

+ *

(* "

&* 9 &"9

+* *

& +"

5(!* 1 !

(+ ".

*&& "

0 5

> 0 5

)0 / * &* 9 & +"

!! !"9

0 +"9

(* "

*" *

1;(""

+* "

+ 1"+ < / <=/ <8/ <</ 8 :

8 = >'

*!9 9 +()+"1 !1" (1

! ++/

& /

)9 *+++ *

' * +1 !! (+ !1" +/ & 9/ !+ +"*+

*++ * &

"2 0#"

0 1/# ** *

+ . + *

N +

")!

N +