High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/16907/2015allowed

Rajesh Joshi v. State Th Electoral Registration Officer And ORS

2016-04-01Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan13 pages

!#$ !$'()(% *

+,+

-$).

++++++

$#(#(%$/ 0$/)1) 2##$ #./%13.

4$'#%/4 $3()#/#(% &&('$/

++++++ $)5%$#

0(-6

%#.$/) ++++++

$#(#(%$/) 0$/)1) 2##$ #./%13.

4$'#%/4 $3()#/#(% &&('$/

++++++ $)5%$# * 7 8 +

2 98!

/$)$#* /+ 2#6

2$(%/ ;%'#$:

<(#.:

/+ !.$$/-

;%'#$:

5$#(#(%$/) =%#.

')$)+ /+

+2+

14:

!$51#6 ++

1-=:

))()#$ /+

/$$5 91>/:

++2+ /+ 2$$5 ?.<:

;%'#$:

(#$/;$%/+ + ?.$#.$/ $5%/#$/) 4%'4 $<)55$/ >6 44%<$

)$$ -13>$# @

% /$&$//$ $5%/#$/ %#+

+ ?.$#.$/ -13>$# ).%14 /$5%/#$ (3$)# @

+ + 98!

#.() %/$/:

<(44 ()5%)$ '%$'#$ 5$#(#(%) (+$+

#(#4$

&(4$ ,A

/+ ++:

B1).(3 '/(>(4

)$ A, #$

$C1/$ :

5$(3 3()# 5/$)$# 5$#(#(%$/) =$&%/$ %1/# 4$/$ .($&

1('(4 3()#/#$:

>/(#)/+

/6$/ 4)% B1).(3 )1>>%(3 %/$/ #$

$C1/$ :

4%3<(#.

44 '%)$B1$#(4 5/%'$$(3) /()(3 #.$/$&/%>+ /($& &'#) ')$ 2##$ #./%13.

4$'#%/4

$3()#/#(% &&('$/:

%)#(#1$'6'1>(#(%4 !$51#6 %>>())(%$/

!$;$4%5>$#:

>/(#)/:

/$$5 91>/ 2=./<4:

. &(4$ '/(>(4 3()# 5/$)$# 5$#(#(%$/) /$ $5/$)$##(%

$%54$ '#:

).%/# 7#.$ '#7:

)##(3 5$#(#(%$/) .;$ 3%# #.$>)$4;$) $/%44$ 54'$) ;%#$/ . </%3 $'4/#(%):

51().=4$ '#+

'%#$#) <(44 $C>($ 4#$/ 5/# -13>$#+ %#('$ ())1$ /$)5%$#+ .;$ .$/ 4$/$ '%1)$4 5/#($) .;$ 4)% '/$&1446 3%$ #./%13.

&(4$+ $'$))/6 /$5/%1'$ 5/%;()(%) 2$'#(%) '#:

/$ *

D2+ + % 5$/)% /$3()#$/$ >%/$ #. '%)#(#1$'6+ % 5$/)% ).44 $#(#4$ /$3()#$/$ $4$'#%/4 /%44 >%/$ #. '%)#(#1$'6+E D2++ F(3 &4)$ $'4/#(%)+G& 5$/)% >F$) '%$'#(%

5/$5/#(%:

/$;()(% '%//$'#(% $4$'#%/4 /%44:

= ('41)(% $C'41)(% $#/6 $4$'#%/4 /%44:

)##$>$# $'4/#(% </(#(3 &4)$ .$ $(#.$/ F%<) =$4($;$) &4)$ %$) =$4($;$ #/1$:

.$ ).44 51().=4$ (>5/()%>$# #$/> >6 $C#$ 6$/:

&($:

=%#.+H 5$/1)4 '# ).%<) 5$/)% ).44 $#(#4$ /$3()#$/$ $4$'#%/4 /%44 >%/$ #. '%)#(#1$'6+

%<$;$/:

;(%4#(% )$'#(% (#)$4& 51().=4$:

>$(3 #.$/$=6 /$3()#/#(% ;%#$/ 54'$) (#)$4& '/(>(4 %&&$'$+

5/%;($) 51().>$# ')$ >F(3 &4)$ $'4/#(%:

$(#.$/ F%< =$4($;$ &4)$ =$4($;$ #/1$ /$3/(3 5/$5/#(%:

/$;()(% '%//$'#(% $4$'#%/4 /%44 ('41)(% $C'41)(% $#/6 $4$'#%/4 /%44+

'//($) >C(>1> 51().>$# &($ =%#.+ ,A /+ ++ 5/%;($) =/ #F(3 '%3(I'$ &#$/ 45)$ 5$/(% 4(>(##(%+

)$'#(% /$) *

D2+,A+ / #F(3 '%3(I'$ &#$/ 45)$ 5$/(% 4(>(##(%+

C'$5# %#.$/<()$ 5/%;($ $4)$<.$/$ #.() %$:

%1/# ).44 #F$ '%3(I'$ '#$3%/6 )5$'(&($

)1= )$'#(%

&#$/ $C5(/6 5$/(% 4(>(##(%+

5$/(% 4(>(##(% ).44 =$

)(C >%#.):

(& 51().=4$ &($ %46 J

= 6$/:

(& 51().=4$ (>5/()%>$#

#$/>

$C'$$(3 6$/J

' #./$$ 6$/):

(& 51().=4$ (>5/()%>$#

#$/> $C'$$(3 =1# $C'$$(3 #./$$ 6$/)+

51/5%)$) #.() )$'#(%:

5$/(% 4(>(##(% /$4#(% %&&$'$) >6 #/($ #%3$#.$/:

).44 $#$/>($ /$&$/$'$ 51().=4$ >%/$ )$;$/$ 51().>$# %/:

')$ >6 =$:

>%)# )$;$/$ 51().>$#+HE 3%$) ).%< 41)$

= )$'#(%:

4(>(##(% #F(3 '%3(I'$ 5/$)$# ')$ 6$/+

, /+ ++ 5/%;($) '%>>$'$>$# 5$/(% 4(>(##(% (+$+ #$ <.$ '%>>(##$ <.$ '%>>())(% F%< 5$/)% 33/($;$ %&&$'$:

#.$ #$ )1'.

F%<4$3$+ %<:

'%>(3 '%#$#) 5/$)$# '%>54(#:

44$3$ *

++ :

2>#+

%%>

5$#(#(%$/ 554($ $/%44>$# ;%#$/ .$/)$4&

.$/ &>(46 >$>=$/) (+$+ &#$/ &(4(3 4$'#%/4 / A:

2$/(4

/ /

$$/4

/$$4(>(##(%:

).%<(3 #.$> /$)($#) 4( .55/ ?4(

/ /+

''1)$

%%>

)(3$ $4$'#%/4 '/ =$(3 .$)$(%/ 14# >$>=$/ &>(46+

''1)$ <$/$ ''%/(346 $/%44$ ;%#$/)+

;%#$/ 4()#:

5/$5/$

$$/4

/$ $4(>(##(%:

>$) 2./(

2>#+ %(F

2>#+

1).5 ( <$/$ $#$/$ 2$/(4 , ,A:

).%<(3 #.$> /$)($#) %1)$ :

'F)($ ( I/:

$$/:

$< %4$ ;$1$:

>/(#)/+

;%#$) <$/$ 4)% 554($ $1>$/#(% 5 )>$ /$'%/ #/'$=4$+ + 3%# 5/$5/$ ;%#$) >$) >/(#)/ ?$)#

$$/4

/$$4(>(##(%+

.$)$ ;%#$) <$/$ 5/$5/$ >$) =)() .</(##$ >1)'/(5#+ >$) <$/$ >$#(%$ $4$'#%/4 '/+

!(;()(%4 %>>())(%$/:

4./ !(;()(%:

4./:

'%1'#$ (B1(/6 ;($ /$5%/# #$

+ &%1 #>5$/(3 >1)'/(5# $4$'#%/4 /%44)'/+ ,+

2./(

2>#+ %(F

2>#+

1).5 ( 3%# $4$#$ #.$(/ ;%#$) / /

/$$4(>(##(%:

=1# ;%#$

1).5 ( $C()#$

A / /

/$$4(>(##(%+

%<$;$/:

%(F

1).5 ( 3%# $4$#$ #.$(/ ;%#$) >/(#)/

$$/4

/$$4(>(##(% &1/#.$/ 3%# 5/$5/$ )>$

$$/4

/$ $4(>(##(%:

$#$/$

/# ,:

2$/(4 , ,A+ &#$/ $4(>(##(%:

;%#$) <$/$ #/)&$//$ $< A )#

$$/4 %)#(#1$'6:

<$/$ 3%# $4$#$ )1554$>$#/6 4()#

A+

;%#$) 5$/)%) >/(#)/ ?$)#

$$/4

/$$4(>(##(% <$/$ 4)% #/)&$//$ &#$/ $4(>(##(% $< >/(#)/

$$/4 %)#(#1$'6+

/$>((3 )$;$ ;%#$) 2$/(4

/ /

/$$4(>(##(% <$/$ 4)% ).(&#$ &#$/ $4(>(##(% $< / / $$/4 %)#(#1$'6+

.$)$ ;%#$) <$/$ 3%# $4$#$

+ ;%#$) )$;$ <$/$ 3%# $4$#$ >/(#)/

;%#$) <$/$ 3%# 5/$5/$ / / %)#(#1$'6:

$C'$5#

6%#(

44$3$ 3()# * D+ .# 5$/)%) $#(#4$ /$3()#$/$ $4$'#%/4 /%44) '%)#(#1$'6 >%/$ #. %'$ 4)% $#(#4$ /$3()#$/$ $4$'#%/4 /%44 >%/$ #. '%)#(#1$'6+

.$6 .;$ >$:

'%$'#(% ('41)(% $C'41)(% $#/6 $4$'#%/4 /%44:

$'4/#(%) </(#(3 &4)$ #.$6 F%< =$4($;$ &4)$+

5$/)%) <.% <$/$ %46 #.$)$ 54'$) ;(/#1$ $/%44>$#)+

).%<) #.$6 <$/$ </$ =%1# #.$(/ $/%44>$# (&&$/$# 54'$) )1'.

.;$ ;(%4#$ 5/%;()(%) $5/$)$##(%

$%54$ '#:

.;$ '%>>(##$ 51().=4$ 1) $5/$)$##(%

$%54$ '#:

+ &1/#.$/ )##$ /$'$(5# '%>54(#:

!(;()(%4 %>>())(%$/:

4./ !(;()(%:

4./:

)1=>(##$ .() (B1(/6 /$5%/#

+ .($& 4$'#%/4 &&('$/:

1-=:

.(3/.:

<.% &1/#.$/ )1=>(##$ /$5%/# 4$'#(% %>>())(% (:

(/$'#$ &(4(3 '/(>(4 '%>54(#+ # &1/#.$/ )##$ (& %1/# '%>$) '%'41)(% '%14 &(4$ <(#.( 5$/(% 4(>(##(%:

$46 1$ /$)% '%//$)5%$'$ =$#<$$ 51=4('

%&&('(4) #(>$ #(>$ 1$ 5$$'6 (B1(/($)+

) )1'.

)$5/#$ 554('#(% , /+ ++ $C#$(3 4(>(##(% 5$/(% =$(3 &(4$ 4%3<(#.

'%>54(#+

&1/#.$/ '%>$) %1# 554('#(% , /+ ++:

)>$ ;$/>$#) <$/$ '%%(3 $46+ 4$/$ .($&

1('(4 3()#/#$:

>/(#)/:

5))$ &%44%<(3 )1>>%(3 %/$/ * %>54(# &(4$ #%6+

/$3()#$/$+

4%3<(#.

554('#(% , %$ /(>(4

/%'$1/$ '%%#(% $46 &(4(3 5/$)$# 4)% &(4$ 3/%1 >##$/ $B1(/$ !(;()(%4 %>>())(%$/:

4./ <.% )1=>(##$ .() /$5%/#

+ .($& 4$'#%/4 &&('$/:

1-= <.% &1/#.$/ )1=>(##$ .() /$5%/# 4$'#(% %>>())(% ( ;($ .() 4$##$/ #$ ++ , (/$'#(% 4$'#(% %>>())(% ( 5/$)$# =$(3 &(4$ 3()# 5$/)%)+ .;$ 3%$ #.%13.

/$'%/ ')$ /$4$;# /$&$//$ /$5%/#) /$'%/+

2% ;($< #.$/$%&:

%1/# )#()&($ $46 5/%5$/46 $C54($+ $/+

/$)$# >%;$

1=4('

&&('$/ ()'./3$ .() %&&('(4 1#($)+

2% /$'%/(3 5/$4(>(/6 $;($'$ .$/$=6 ()5$)$ <(#.+

.;$ 3%$ #./%13.

/$'%/ ')$ %'1>$# /$'%/+

/(> &'($ ;(%4#(% $5/$)$##(%

$%54$ '#:

%1# 3()# 44 ''1)$+

8$# %#('$ 44 ())1$ +,+ ,+E

# ;$/6 %1#)$#:

)$$ #.%13.

4$/$ .($&

1('(4 3()#/#$:

>/(#)/:

;($< %1/# )#()&($ $46 5/%5$/46 $C54($:

=1# %/$/ 5))$:

'%%(3 $46 3(;(3 /$)%) <.$ '%>>(##$ .%< $46 %''1//$ .%< %1/# )#()&($ =%1# $C54#(%+ 8$/$ )$(%/ '%1)$4 5$#(#(%$/) ;$.$>$#46 /31$ '%#$#) ).%< 4'F) $'$))/6 (3/$($#) '#+ &1/#.$/ /31$ /$3()#/#(% ;%#$) 54'$) (#)$4& %&&$'$+

>F(3 </%3 $'4/#(%)+

&1/#.$/ /31$ )1'.

44$3$ &4)$ $'4/#(%) .;$ ##'.$ '%>54(#+ 4)% %$) >$#(% =%1# 5/#('14/) 44$3$ &4)$ )##$>$#) $'4/#(%)+

% #$:

#(>$ '%#$#) &4)$ )##$>$#) >$#(%$+

4)% )5$'(&($ <.$#.$/ &4)$ $'4/#(% %46 =$.4& %#.$/) 44 )$5/#$46+

&1/#.$/ /31$ =//$ 4(>(##(% ,A /+ ++

$C54#(% 3(;$ )155%/# 554('#(% &(4$ , /+ ++ #%#446 ;31$ ()1&&('($#+ =$.4& 2##$:

4$/$ 2##$ '%1)$4 5%(#$46 B1$)#(%$ <.$#.$/ '%>54(# 3%# .() 5%))$))(% &4)$ $'4/#(% 44 ''1)$:

/$54($ $'4/#(%) #(>$ 5/$5/#(% ;%#$) '%>54(# >$#(%$ (#)$4& /$'%/ $1>$/#(% 5 #/'$=4$+

&(/)# '#:

5$/ 44$3#(%) 4$;$44$ %46 2>#+

%%>

554($ /$3()#/#(% ;%#$/) =$.4& 44 ++

&(/)# $/%44>$# ;%#$/ %&&$'$+

.$:

5/, '%>54(#:

44$3$

>$) 2./(

2>#+ %(F

1).5 ( <$/$ $#$/$

$$/4

/$$4(>(##(%:

=1# /$'%/ $1>$/#(% 5 #/'$=4$+

.$/$&%/$:

'%# <.% 3%# >$) 44 ;%#$/):

>$46:

%(F

1).5 ( $#$/$ '%)#(#1$'6+ 2('$ 44$3$ $/%44>$# / /

$$/4

2>#+

%%>

=$.4& 44 ''1)$:

#.$/$&%/$:

$;$ (& )%>$ /$'%/ . ;(4=4$ ).%< $(#.$/ 44 5$/)%):

>$46:

%(F

1).5 ( $'4/#(%:

$;$ #.$ '# '#:

)('$ &(/)# $'4/#(% %46 2>#+

%%>

$#'+ /$3()#/#(% ;%#$/) >/(#)/

$$/4 %)#(#1$'6+ .$:

#.$/$ 44$3#(%) /$3()#/#(% ;%#$) %+ >/(#)/ ?$)#

$$/4 %)#(#1$'6+

%<$;$/:

44$3$ <.% . 3%# #.$(/ >$) $#$/$ ;%#$/) <.$#.$/ 44 )(3$ )$5/#$ $'4/#(%)+ .$:

#.$/$ 44$3#(%) $4$#(% ;%#$) $#$/(3 %#.$/ '%)#(#1$'6:

/$3/(3 $'4/#(% ##'.$ ).%< <.% 3%# $4$#(% $#/6 $4$'#%/4 /%44)+ 8$/$ )$(%/ '%1)$4 5$#(#(%$/) 54'$ &(4$ )5$'(>$ 554('#(% &%/> ('41)(% >$ $4$'#%/4 /%44:

%/> 14$)

/$B1(/$) &%44%<(3 $'4/#(% *

554('#(% ('41)(% >$ $4$'#%/4 /%44 + + CCCCCCC CCCCCCC CCCCCCC 0+ !$'4/#(%

.$/$=6 $'4/$ =$)# >6 F%<4$3$ =$4($& *

( > '(#(I$ (J

(( > %/(/(46 /$)($# /$)) 3(;$ 5/ =%;$ )('$ +++++++

#$:

>%#.:

6$/

((( .;$ 554($ ('41)(% >6 >$ $4$'#%/4 /%44 %#.$/ '%)#(#1$'6J

(; K6 >$ 4/$6 ('41$ $4$'#%/4 /%44 #.() %#.$/ ))$>=46 '%)#(#1$'6J / K6 >$ >6 .;$ ('41$ $4$'#%/4 /%44 LLLLL LLLLLLLLL 2##$ %/(/(46 /$)($# $/4($/ /$)) >$#(%$ =$4%< (& )%:

/$B1$)# )>$ >6 $4$#$ $4$'#%/4 /%44+ LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

/$))

/4($/

4'$ %/(/6 /$)($'$ 4$'#%/)

.%#% $#(#6

LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL / 1>=$/

(& 4/$6

LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL ())1$ LLLLLLLLLLLL LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL !#$ ())1$ LLLLLLLL

4'$ * !#$ * 2(3#1/$ #.1>= (>5/$))(% 554('#

&%/> $($ 2##$+

>(##$46:

)1'.

&%/> ##'.$ '%>54(#+

;$ (&:

$/4($/ $/%44>$# ;%#$/ '%)($/$:

$(#.$/ )(3$ .$ &>(46 >$>=$/) &>(46+

;%#$) <$/$ $/4($/ $1>$/#(% 5 %'1>$# ##'.$ $&&$'#

$'4/#(% '# /$B1(/$ 44 (& /$B1(/$:

<.# <$/$ '%#$#) #.$/$%&+

2('$ $'4/#(%) ;(4=4$ &(/)# $/%44>$# ;%#$/)

/ /

$$/4 2>#+

%%>

#.$/$&%/$:

)1=)$B1$# $/%44>$#

$$/4 $;$ (& 5/%;$ 2./(

2>#+ %(F

2>#+

1).5 ( %$) ##/'# 5/%;()(%) '#+

)1=)$B1$# $#/($):

/$'%/ ##'.$ ).%< <.% 3%# $/%44>$# <.% $'4/#(% '#+

.$/$&%/$:

5$/1)4 %'1>$#) ##'.$ )>$:

/$ '# %1# 3()# ''1)$+

1/#.$/:

'%>$) %1# '%#$#) '%>>(##$ =$#<$$

A+ &(4$

, (+$+ >1'.

=$6% 5$/(% 4(>(##(% 6$/+

3/%1 >$#(%$ $C#$(3 5$/(% 4(>(##(% (B1(/($) <$/$ 5$(3 =$&%/$ (&&$/$# 1#.%/(#($) 1$ '%//$)5%$'$ =$#<$$ (&&$/$# %&&('$)

1-= %;$/>$# <$44 4$'#(% %>>())(% (+ %<$;$/:

5$/ (#)$4&:

)>$ &(/)# #(>$ /$'$(;$ !$'$>=$/:

=)() (B1(/6

((#(#$+

/$'$(;$ '%>54(# (#)$4& =$6% 5$/(% 4(>(##(%+

% /$)% >$#(%$ <.# <$/$ /$)%):

44$3$

$#$'#$ #(44 !$'$>=$/:

1/#.$/:

%/$/ 5))$ 4$/$ .($&

1('(4 3()#/#$:

>/(#)/:

/$5/%1'$ =%;$:

).%<) #.%13.

>$#(%$ %1/# $46 5/%5$/46 $C54($:

=1# 4$/$ .($&

1('(4 3()#/#$:

>/(#)/:

( 5)) $C5/$))$ %/$/:

'%%(3 $46 , /+ ++

$$4$)) )6 =$&%/$ 5))(3 $;$ %/$/ /$3/(3 .() )#()&'#(% B1 $46:

.$/(3 %55%/#1(#6 3(;$ 4$/$ .($&

1('(4 3()#/#$:

>/(#)/+

/%> &%/$3%(3 ()'1))(%:

'%>$ '%'41)(% 4%3<(#.

%'1>$#) ##'.$ )>$ %$) ()'4%)$ 2$'#(%) '# %#.(3:

=1# >()1)$ 5/%'$)) %1/#+

$ .$/$ 554('#(% &(4$ 5$/)%):

>$46:

2$$5 %/)(:

;%'#$:

0$$# .-:

;%'#$:

>/(#)/:

(>54$(3 #.$> $'$))/6 5/#6:

()>())$ #.() %1/#:

;($ %/$/ #$

A++ :

5))$

;$ %/$/ 5))$ !(;()(% $'.

#.() %1/#

/()(3 %1# ?

$'($ ,+ ).%<) 554('#) <#$ 2./(

<.% $4$'#$ $>=$/ 8$3()4#(;$

8 1)$#$ =)() )(>(4/ 44$3#(%) >F(3 </%3

$'4/#(% 44$3(3 #.#:

.() >$ $#$/$ 54'$)+ 5$#(#(% ()>())$ !(;()(% $'.

#.() %1/#

')$

)15/ ,+ :

(>5%)(3 '%)#) )+

3%$) ).%< 554('#) .;$ #.$(/ %< C$ 3/( <# )$##4$ )%>$ )'%/$ /$)5%$#):

>$46:

<.% $4$'#$ $>=$/ 8$3()4#(;$ %)#(#1$'6+ ) /$)14# &%/$3%(3 ()'1))(%:

=%#.

5$#(#(%) 44%<$+

'/(>(4

)$ A, #$

$C1/$ :

5$(3 =$&%/$ 4$/$ .($&

1('(4 3()#/#$:

>/(#)/:

4%3<(#.

)1>>%(3 %/$/ $;$ #$ 44 '%)$B1$#(4 5/%'$$(3) /()(3 #.$/$&/%> )# B1).$+

98!

! +,+ )-F)