High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/16946/2015allowed

Mintu Mathwan And ORS v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ANR

2016-02-17Mr. Justice S.C. Malte5 pages

!"#"$% &'( ')*+ "$( (

,- $ '# /

'# '#(#

, ',34 /

'

% '6 #,"$.

'1"$2,1".,(+.7!

+

'#6 '68

51"$2,"99+.."

966+ 66+, ',+ ''

66 /66

'

) '"$ ,"#5

"$ "9 .($.

'1 "$: '666+ "# ';( #,"$2 6 +.

3$$ <('

4+ #5($"#, &9 ($.

'1 "$#*+:+= $.

. -"

, 1 "$ + + '

9"!

1

"$+ +, ',+

."$2#

'"#"$2 '8 $ & #"# !85'8"# ?

".

7"

3$$ <('

46

0".

'.

'.

.6 +5 ## ,"#('

+

.5 #- ."'

'& 9

.'

(."!"

9

' 2

"$2 "' '

#5 #

!'.

. -"

, '

'. !85'8"# 6 , # ". ('

- ."'

# $. .

"9 . '

"$

'

'. 9$2 -"

!5"

#

# ,"#('

$!859"

&7 +

'#3 ,"'

$"$ $(8& '4 #- #5.

#,@(8 '+'

6 ?"$>('

.+.".

'& ".('

$.2 !'.

"'#

#6 5.

#,@(8 '#( 99-"$2#

% ! "# $ % &'&(&)*+,)(-).-)%- )-)/#01

0,23 1 43 34,5- )4 7 5 /4 '4 8 (4

.4$ %4,&437 4 3

4 5 4

.9

+

(%+%- 8 -, 2'-1 $ %9 &

&''3 : - 1 $ 9

.'- :1 -1

7

7 -

#

"#

-

# 7

"#

;

< 1"8"9 '#

#- #(

'#+

.8"

"$2 (8 !85'8"# , 5

. '89

.

('

& 9-"# #($.

'% #

= >= 1 3232'%)'

&/-

&&/

&(&/

7 -

1

?

-

@

<

.!($# 9 ' 1

$"$# '(!

"$# '81(&

$#5 ' $.,"' 1"$2, 9"!

1

"$+ + , ',+ 9# .8"

# (8 !85'8"# $., #$ &> "$+ " "85(2$ . 6 + .

+

9"!

1

"$+ +, ',+

!$#

."$2# '"#"$2 '8 ;( #, .$

& #"# !85'8"#

.!($# 9 '

'#!$

$.#

$

!!($

)"##( + ;( ''

9, .'"2"$

.+"$-,"!, 5.

#,@(8 '+'

6 +, .9)'

#"859 "$>('"

#+-,"!,, ,

$., 3'

6 4"#

."$2 $'8 99"

6 ('

'!$

$.#

'# - # "$ '8 ?!859 "$ ?"$>('

9"7"$2"$7"!"$"

)+

!85'8"#

.&

-

$ #-(9.9

.

8 9"7

(99)6 ('

'#(&8"

#

"$7"

-

!85'8"# #

.&

-

$ #+5 $!)

"85(2$ .

."$2#

"$2

'8-(9.& #,

&(# 5'!

## 9 -6

',

'"$29

.!($# 9 ' #+2"$2

,'(2,

##(

.5 # $.'

. '8 9

. ('

& 9-+ ,"# ('

"#

!$#".

.5"$"$

$!) "85(2$ .

."$2# '"#"$2 '8 #,

&(#

5'!

## 9 -6 # 9

+ 6 +.

3$$ <('

4+ ' #5($"#, &9 ($.

'1 "$#*+ :+= $.

.-"

,1 "$+ +'

9"!

"$+ + , ',+ $. 99 !$# 5'!

."$2# '"#"$2 '8 , &);( #, .6

!

"# $%"&

5('7