Ankur Gupta And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR




    
 
  

 
      

 !! $    # % & ! 

$ '!(! #  #
  

)

 
 

 !! $    # % & ! 

$ '!(! # #  #
) * 


 

 !! $    # % & ! 

$ '!(! #  #
 


  
$ #   &!'+&"!

,!-&

+ ! . "

  #"

 !-+ ! !    '!/&0"-+ ! 

 "    #

  & 1 !&0" 11- -$ '!(  '!+ &0"-+ ! 

#  2 ) ,1!! , 3 ,!

 * 

  && ( -+ ! 

 "!1! #)4 5 5 *    6&"#!-+ ! 

 "!1! # 5   * 

  #"#"

+ -+ ! 

 "!1! #)

5   * 

      5  *   7!



#1

 "!1! ## ! # "! "( , 

. " !.( " "#!1!  #

!

01/ )

5  *   7!



#1

 "!1! ###. " !.!1

 "# .

!1!  # 

01/-  ( "  "#  !1!  #  !

  #,##  !# . " !.  

   8"#

#"!11# #

 "!

,   "

   #!# "#!,!

  1!    . "!" 6 .+ -

 +!1!

 /!#.11!# !+     

! #- " !1

 

#(0!##   (!

02 




  1!#  !"#!$%&&' %()"*)"*!*%&%)

!+&,&' %()"* $ !/  "   (!

02 




  1 !# !"#!$%&&' %()"*)"*!*%&%)

!+&,&' %()"* 1 

&  4  $#

9 !#"0 ":;2  5! )  

&  # - <)- ;$ 0#  ! $ 1& !  +# 2 5- +17#-7 "!!-#  7 "!!!!11# (#9  

0# !

#0 "

,  "(!##

,#

 ( . "!

#(/ .!/

!

!+ ! 4  
=

$) 8"       (!

0  2 


- 

     1  !#  !"#!$%&&' %()"*)"*!*%&%)

!+&,&' %()"*"!#( 1

  &    4   $  #0  9 !#"0 

 "  :;  2  55  !  )   &  # - <)- ;$ 0#  ! $ 1& !  +# 2 5-+17#-7 "!!-#  7 "!!!!11# (#9 

0#!

#0 "

,  "(!##

,#

 ( . "!

#(/.!/

!

!+ ! 4  
=

$) &,1!

1/- "   (!

02 
. /

/  1 !#  !"#!$%&&' %()"*)"*!*%&%)

!+&,&' %()"* "!#(

1(/ "    #

9 !#"0

 "!

,  :;2  55!  ) !!11# (#9  

0#!

#0 "

, 7!

#

#1

 "    ## ! # "! !11 " "

!##- ",!  "!#(

,#( . "!

#!# "   (!

02 


-

 .!# !11/ 1  "

  (!##

,#. " "# 1 ,1!! -!,1/-8' &0"

.!1- "#

+

!  4  !## "!    "!    "!

# !!

(

 ";11!9!!0# !     

!/ !  +   "#!



0 "# ! , #

"!

##

,#6

# ! # "! 

!   " !

#! 

-  " !

# "!  !!

  (

  1!

  !1  

  ! " # ! , #.  

 8"#!# ! , 

#  2   ,1!! 8'

&0"

.!1 

(/1!

!0# !     !!#   >


 
 

 








 
 !
 
 !

" #
"$ #
 # %#&'
()
#
'
$
 
*'
$
+#
, *)'

* 
# #
! -
.
, *)'

* 


# 
-#

)'

,
.'$'

$!
+/, #
.
$
*
+
0$

$!
, *)'

* 
$ *'
- $ 
#1
)''?

;  !

!  2  

 " 

 !   4   + 

@ !1!0# ! # 1!##-7 "!!.""#1!  " 1

   (!

0  2 


- 

 !# !

-  1!

  !0# !  "!# ,   "!  !!

# "!  "

,#"!#(+  !

1/    ( . "!

#. "

!/ ##



 !

,## 0  ( /"!# !!

! ("!1

#  2 8' &0"

.!1 "

!/ # ,!(1/  "0

 "!  " ,!  "!#(

,#( . "!

#! " # ! , #

 "# 0!

.  

(

 " !1

   7!

#

#1

 "    ## ! # "! ."1 " !#.!#  +# 0!  :;2  55! ) ! ",! 

.!#  

,#  . "   ,1!!  8'  &0" 

.!1-  .

!00 + #-!,1/-, 3 ,!

!' 3 ,!

7! !"!!1#

0 " 1!,. " " 1

01/- " 1!

  0 +# 0!  -  # (,   "!11!  !0!#  "     #    "  (!## 

 ,1! 1 0(/, 3 ,!

!' 3 ,!

7! ! 7!

#

#1

 "    #

# ! # "!

# ""!11!.!# #   "(!##

,1! 1 0(/, ,!

!' 3 ,!

7! !-!#!

!    (!

02 
 . /

/.!# 1(/ "    #

9 !#"0

 ":;2  55 ! )  ,  # 8"#

+

! 4  !## "   (!

02 
. /

/"!   "!

# !!

(

" !1

 "! !1 !/ =



0

 " # ! , #!#

0!

# "# 1, !

+! ( . "!

#8" !1

.!#   

.!

 "

!



0# ! , #

 "!

# 

01/- "!

#. !!

(

 " !1

! "

# ! , #  .   

  8"  # ! , 

  ,1!!  1  3 ,!



(/1!

@ !1!0# ! #  1!##-7 "!!   

!#!#   
$

$!
, *)'

* 
$
*'
- $
$

 ,,
#

*
..' #
$
*#
- $
*1
.'
-

# - $ 
#1
, ', #
#
)''

$!
', !
*1
# '  
* #
#
# $ #


 #
$

3*4
"

'

 ', '
'

*)

1
#
 ,*#
#
'  #

$!
+#
$#
!'

$
,,

$!
#
+/, #
.
$ 

0$
 #


$
,,
+1
$
5 #6+ 
5 $  '?

&,1!

# ! , .!#!1# ,!(/! !00 + - !,1/- '  3 ,!

 7! ! (

1!

  @ !1 !0# !  #  1!##- "!!   

 "(!##

 "# ! , # 

(/ "!

#-1!

 @ !1  !0# !   #  1!##-  7 "!!  "! 

.!

  "

 !      "   (!

02 
. /

/ "!  ",! 

"!#  (  

,#  ( .  "  !

#  . "

 !/      !

##

!. " "

.11! # 

 "!

# A"1 "   (!

0 2 
. /

/ .!# 0-!!1!  (!

02 )4 5

5.!# 1(/ .

!1! #-!,1/-"!

!' 3!

. 

1! &! !1&0" 11- # 

#2  4-0!

2!0!

-7 "!!!&  11. 

&! !, &0" 11- # 

11+ 

# !0 #

-B!

.!1!- #   7 "!! 

 ,1!0  ",  !#  #  #  2 5  !   

01/-+

! ) 4 !##(/ "#

- "# .

!00 + #. !1#    !!

(

 " !1



0 " # +# ! , #. " 0!



,#8" !1

7 

 .!#     

.!

 

 !



0  "  # ! , # 

01/-  " !1 

"!  

  " # ! , # 

 ( "  "# #  8"# ! , 

&  3!

11,!(

1!

!0# ! -7 "!!   !#!#   
$
'  #

1
#
8/ #'
#$
('-
- *)  ##
#
$
+ !
 
 
- $
-$ *
$
,, )'1
*

, *)'

* 
#
.


)  #
#'
, #
9 ' 
+' #
 7 
#
' #
$ )##,1
.
$
)  #
#
%* 
:*'
#
%/ 
"&'
.


 
#
$
+ !
 
)  #
#
.'
$
$1
  *)'

* 
$
*'
- $
$
,,
)'1
' #
$ )##,1
.
$
+ ! 
* #
)  #
+' #
  7  



#
- $
*1
 '
$'#/ 
:'
.



   9
.

$'

$
*1
, #
'
 

+
%! -$ ,$

)# #
+.

'
$
5 #6+ 
5 $
 '
.

'
;

#
- $
$
'  #
)  #
 -

$!
 
, *)'

*  $
+/,
*'
.
$
+ !
 
 
- $


$
,, #* 1
#
(  
')
:*'
/$
$'*
<
/+ ' %#&'
()
#
/$
%'-
=,,
#
$
') '
 7 =>
' 
#
#/!
:*'
$'*
 $$
(   *$
# 
#)
( 
=,,
#
$
)) *#'1 ,$

#

7 =9>
' 

$!
$#
!'
'  #

 ,*#

$
,,
 -
# $ #


.
* #
 #

*4
* 
'

 ', '
'

*)

1
'
#1
.
$ ,,
*# #
+ !
%

'
,  *
$!
+#
  * ,+ 1
.

'!'
8$ 
*#

 !#
+1
*
- $ 
+ # #'
#1
)''
, ', #
'
#
#.

#,

$! *)'

* 
$
+/,
*'
.
$
+ ! 
 
- $


$
,,
8$
, *)'

* 

# #
#
!

#'1
#

9 $!
#
+/, #
.
$
+ ! 
 
 #


$
,, *# #
+ !

0$
+1
5 #6+ 
5 $
 '
.
#/+ #
5'1#
$# '$? &,1!

# ! , .!#!1# ,!(/! !00 + - !,1/-  "!

!'  3!

 (

  1!

  @ !1  !0# !   #  1!##- "!!  

 "(!##

 "# ! , # 

(/ "!

#-1!

 @ !1  !0# !   #  1!##-  7 "!!  "! 

.!

  "

 ! 

  "   (!

02 
. /

/ "!  "!

# "!+

,# ",!  ! "

,##0 -+  !

1/ !. "

!/  

   7!

#

#1

 "    ## ! # "!  . " ,!  "!#(

,#( . "!

#! "!00 + # "!+0  " # ! , # 

(

 " !1

!- "

- " # ,, 

 "#

9 !#" "!

,   .

:;#  5! 55! )   "(!##

,# 7!

#

#1

 "    #

# ! # "!

"

0"!11 "!00 + #"!+ !!

 "#

!/-(  "     #"!+!1# # 1 ",!  . " ",!"!+#! #  "

# +1!,#  && ( -+ ! 

 "!1! #2 )4 5

5
. / /!1# # ! # "!  "

0" "!1! #"!+ (

 (,1!!# #  #-(  "    #"!+

; 

,# "# . " "!1! #!#.11 7!

& ! 

#1# ! # "! # ""!11!"!#(

#  "!

#!:;#2  5! 55! ) -""!#

#

  # "#!## ;"!+"!

1!



#1

 "!

# ;+.

 "!( +- #

1

#.

1(# +

   . " "

0#(

 " !1

 "!

#!:;#  5! 55! )  :

.0 " 1#1! .(/ ":

11B"'

0,

 "#

0!123')"34(&' %()"*)"*!*%&%)

!+&,&'

& %()"  

.  -  
  
"353&1   6 !  !

+  (/ " 6 C(1 &

,

#3&34()"*!*%&%)

!+&,&' %()"* 



- -- "   (!

02 




! "   (!

02 


-

!

!11 . 

01/- ":;2  5! )   &  #  - <)- B;$ 0#  ! $ 1& !  +# 2 5-+1 7#-7 "!!-#  7 "!!!!11# (#9  

0#!

#0

,!

9 !#"  "(!##

,#

 ( . " !

# &,1!

1/- ":;2  55! )   &  # -  <)- B;$ 0#  ! $ 1& !  +# 2 5-+17#- "!!-  #   7 "!!  !  !11  # (#9  

0#  !

#0

,!

9 !#"  "(!##

,#

 ( . "

 !

# & !

 !#       (!

0  2 
. / 

  / #   - "#!,"!#!1 !/(#,##(/ "#

+

!  5 9 ! #  2  8' &0"

.!16 .+ - #:;2  55! ) "!#!1 !/(

 (9 !#"- " #    "!#( ,



#!##,##!## " & ",!   #"!+!1 !/(- "0 ,#11!

#!1!  
#- !/-#"!11!1# # !## #

 $"

 /

 "#

(1!  " 1

  !## 
   

  !"#$   D!0

A" " #!0< !#  D#<2

A" " 

!(1 D#<2