← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17998/2018allowed

Ranju Dhingra v. M/S Vardhman Yarns And Threads Ltd

2026-01-27Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj17 pages



   



 !

 " 

  # 

 $%$&'$ ()

*+ + +

#,$ (- $./%/()

+ + +

01($ ()

+ + +

+



 

#

+++ $,/,/($& %

23

43 2 #  " 3 #  #3 5#+

+++$%0($, % 

 

#

+++ $,/,/($& %

23

43 2 #  " 3 #  #3 5#+

+++$%0($, % 





 

#

+++ $,/,/($& %

23

43 2 #  " 3 #  #3 5#+

+++$%0($, %   

 

#

+++ $,/,/($& %

23

43 2 #  " 3 #  #3 5#+

+++$%0($, %      )

 6!5 +

3

2 # 3+ ! #7

  

 

 



  "#$  



 

%&  '( $ 

    ) *% +  

  

 



2 # 3+ ! #7 8 +

,

 

-(

  .

(   

(

 *!  

% .

 * ! 

(

  / 0  % , (*  //

% 

%&

** 1( *   2

 



%(

 (

  0  3

0(*%

 *! 

 4

 

 3"566/ / 

 7"1( )    8  

* 9  2



: ; 



 < !

%& =(    >

 3

 $

 !(  3"/< / 

 7"1( )    8  

* 9  2



: ; *!0 5



/ < 

 78 

*9  2



:  "  )   

;



 << !

 %&  =(    >

 3

 $

 !(  3"6< / 

 7"1( )    8  

* 9  2



: ; *! < 



?< 

 78 

* 9   2



:  "  )   

;



/< !

 %&  =(    >

 3

 $

 !(  3"< 5 / 

 7"1( )    8  

* 9  2



: ; *! 5



/< 

 78 

* 9   2



:  "  )   

;



5< !

 %&  =(    >

 3

 $

 !(  *! / 



?< 

 78 

* 9   2



:  "  )   

;  2   

   &

 

  .

 % 

 

(&



* ,/,1$ % 9:;

#</=&

2%+ 4%

2&<> "&% <&$% 5/>/,$; 2 *!(

  / 0  % , (*   //   %

 

 %& 

      (

!





% )

8 4 3 3 *!&

 :*

   %

 !(   



  

 *



* 

 *!

* *    *    (  (

&  -(  0 <6 

  ?

  (* "

5 8

. @,+A:*

 

( *! . 

(

    &

%

%



!( 

%& * ? 4 !

    

   -(  .  (

B (   (

C

 * * 

 < 2   (*

*  

<. 

&

 .

 !&* . *

.

(!

 *! %

 

 < 2

(**  

  < .  

 

(

 5 (



   !





      

  

*! 

"1()  )

 (



& %   8 4 3 3 *!&

 :*

2 

 %

*! 

 (

   *!. "  )   )

 .  *! 

   (

 0  2

 

*  *

 *! 



  -( -(

  %



(

   %& 1(  &

?

D 8  3  *!&

 :*

  .

 .    *    1(  &     %

 *! 

   

(

    

 $ 

     %

  1(  &   %

*! 

   ! &  * !

 (

    /    0  %  , (*    //   %

  )

  (!&, (!!

   (*   !

  1( *  (!

* 3 (    *

  

           

 !

! ""

 / ,  ( 

 (

 

   

&  -(   -(

    (     

%

 

  * *   (!

    3 *!& $ 



  





 (  

%



 

 6 (



  

   &

   (

  -(    %

 

(

   %     1(  & 8 4 3 3 *!&

 :*

  1(  &     %

 *! 

   

(

  

*! (

(

  / 0  % , (*   //$  .

 

  (

 *!  1(  &

 (  %&

  %

*!



* 

    1(  &  , 

  

    

(

 !!

 

 



! 

   

   

( 

(*   !!

   . 

!

 

<

 +

 ( 

 *

.

( % !!

 

E  * * ! 

 *! %

 (

%&

 *!2 *  E 

 (

          

  

     

         !" # 



  $  %  &  

'

 

 (  ) 

* " ' + $! + % , - + $+ % & 

   )  ( '  # 

   ./0# 1 

! + ) **22.2 (

C  >( 



*    

*    

   *! .

( 

%



  1(  

!

  2

*



(  ,   

 3        )  ( '  '

    

  

 )          .   

 

   4 5 26,27*  ,/**,2*8       .9/222:0    ;<=" #  "

 *20; >  '    )       )3)(    

 3(     )?

5

 +

  



( A %& 

  

   



(  5 5 =@ ;" "@5

 @ !;5  @5@ 5 =;#==

=" !;+@ A ;>;=5"

@ @"@5

@ = =5@?

  ,   1 

!& 

 %& 

 *! 

 

* *

! 0 



(  *   3'

 4     3)

      +  )  ' +    )  ( '  #  +  '

   4  4

    )3)(  

 ( !:

  )  ( '    

 3)  )3)        4

    .9/222    ;B #  '  

 ?

?   /   0  % , (*  //



(  *.C +    4    (     

D (  4   3(        3(    3

  (   (    (          

    )     (  3    )3)( 

  3(  3     3 

     (                 4    B

    3

    3(  

 

  3 

/

  )) 3

  '

     

))   -  (   '    ; 3

       / E    ( 3

B      (  FG   

 ( B    

    4    3H '       

 ))  )( )

$%   4 

 

    3

 

  B           

 

   ')(  '

 

) I $3%  (

  )    

   4  

( 3  

     (   

    ( 3( '   I     

   4  8 E  ( ( G        3(    3       4

 I  $%  

    4 )  

(   

    (   (

  

( 3    )    

   4   

 (      

  @B )D1   

 

  3    )3)(?    ) ))(  3) 3   )3)( BBB BBB BBB */*  

3(  

D$*% = 

     

 *.C    ( '

(      

     

 3)    (      3 

  ( 

))   ( )) 3

  3

)(      )) 3 )3)  3 

      )(H '       

30

 ))

6

  (  )3)       '

 

 

  

 )      



 ))  )    '

  

     '          +     ( 3( '   ) (  

 )(     ) >'

   " >'

    )       ))  3(   ) >'

    " >'

   

( 3  

))  3 )3)  

       5   (    30

 $*%

(      ; 

   3(   (    '

     

 

  

  '    33)  (  )      (    

 (        (     

 (     )) )  3

  3 )(    

 )) 3 )3)  3 

     )( @B )D1   

 

 D $%  (?   ( 3(    )

    

  ') I  $3%  ?   )          ?

<  ,



*%



  (

    !



 .   

   

(      %

  1(  & %  !

     %&   (  

 (  -( (  %

  

2  

 *!  (





  (*  5 2  (!

*  3 (     *

        &   * 

&

-(

* (

      0  %  , (*    //   *!     )

  *!& 2 *! . ( 

   3 *!&    (

  

(

D



  *% 2 (!

* 3 (   &   *%&  (

 (  -( * &  

.

*!& E

 

& .    



          % , (*  //



*!

(  / >( 

   

  !

   . 





 %&  (!

* 3 (  *

#$ %&'

    ' (   ) !!* !+,++ 2



 !  ! 

E 

 (

 82 ;          '

)  

   )   

   4

  3 )    ( 3(  

( 

  

   

 

(     0 )    ( 

3    "

 */*  5= ; )

 (   

    4

    

    ) 

)  3 

   1  ' )3)(  )( 3 B       



   

 (     (  ) )3)   

      "

 *.C BBB BBB BBB 88 JJJJ )( ( 3(   

 ) 3



) )3)

  "

 */*   5= ; 

'

 

 )  '

    3

    (      

     ) 



B )  3(  3         ; 

0K

#      ;

  ' > '

) 

 '       

 !!""

3

'

 *9 '    '

( 

 (

  

     "

 */*$*%  */*$,%   ;  3 

    (   )     

    

'

(   '  

  3     BBB BBB BBB 8C ; )(      

        

    3( 

 (   B 

      

' )3)(     

 

)) 

 (?    

 

 3 ) )(   3)( )      (  3



    )( 

       

) 3 ' )( )3)    

3-    '

   

       3 3)'       (  -         

3)( =          )    '(     3



 

        +  

  87 = '

  

 )( 

'

 



3)

)    



   "

 */*   ;     (   

   '





 

    )( 3 3   0        ' )3)( 





  )    '  

)

(   3    )     

 E$*792% .

" /7* H *79* " $% 79G    

0K

#        '

B 

  "  ; ) E$*7C/% / " .8, H *7C/ " $% 6,2G 

  )( )(    )  )( 

3( '

)     ;)  E$,222% * " * H ,22* " $% *9/G  '

)  

4)  

    8*    ! + )) ( E$*7C9% . " 6C/ H *7C9 " $% 6.,G 

 3     3

       



B )  3(  3'

?

$@ 

 ) % "

;

     87   

    

)( B      ) ) ) 3'

3     ) B     

3)     ) 

L  )   

3)     )(  



 )      (   

3) 

  ) )        ) )  3

   =       3

  

( ) ) )(   )  ")3  ) '  

 

    ) 

)  3(   )

  '

     

B   3

B    

 )  

 

BBB BBB BBB - = ;

  $  %      '

 ) )3)(        4 )( ))   

  (    B    

)(        "

 */*   5= ; 

   )

B )     

 



))   (?    '    3

'

   

     3(   ( 

 B 

     )(   

 3)     (  



       

  "

 */*  3

' )(  )3)        "

 *.C   5= ; ) ' 3

' 

   3 ) 8. =   3 3    "

 */*   ;      

3(   ( = 

  ' )( )3)  

           ( ;



   3(

)   ' )3)(     

    )    "

 */*   ;



    3     

)3)( 

)         

'  ) 3  

    ( 

 BBB BBB BBB 8C ; )(      

        

    3( 

 (   B 

      

' )3)(     

 

)) 

 (?    

 

 3 ) )(   3)( )      (  3



    )( 

       

) 3 ' )( )3)    

3-    '

   

      3 3)'     

 (   -        

3)( =          )

 

   '(     3



          +    ?

$@ 

 ) % "

1))   )  ;

  $  %    ;) >  ' " = '   $,2*/% *2 " .9.  )   )       "

 *.C  )(

     

     

 (   

4   "

 */*   5= ;

   )   

   (

 3)      4  



 3(  )    

   (         (   (   

   "

 *.C    "

 */*   ;  

    )) ! +  )  )  3   ) ' 3

'     3 ) *. = 

 

    3(    -   *.0C0,229 E 

   ' " = $%  ) !  

5 ,.C2  ,22/     *.0C0,229 $+ )%G  )  

 )   

  ,  (  3)  4  



 3( 

)    

  ,  ( 3( 

 ( 3    (   

  "

 *.C    "

 */*   ;   '

       -       3( 

   ;)  E;)  ' = ;()  $,222% * " * H ,22* " $% *9/G 

 '

)  3(  

0K #      ;



?

 E;

  ' > '

)   $%  $,2*,% 8 " 66* H $,2*,% . " $'% .82 H $,2*,% . " $% ,/*G

'

     3 

 

       -  E 

 5   ' " = $%  ) !  

5 ,.C2  ,22/     *.0C0,229 $+ )%G 3(     )   



   ))  3  '

  3

   (

 )(

      

   -    *.0C0,229 E 

   ' " = $%  ) !  

5 ,.C2  ,22/     *.0C0,229 $+ )%G 

 3( 

       )

  ))  4

  

     ) 

5 67C  ,22* 4  ))?

$@ 

 ) % "

 L    ;

 "

 ' "  ; 

 $,2,.% C " /9.   )    ) )    3 ( ' )3)(    ) '  3 

'

  )  "

 */*   5= ;  

B    )  =     ' )3)(

) )( 3     

  

  3

) ' )( )3)

  ?  

 3)   (?      3 

   (   

      "

 *.C   =  

   

  ' )( )3)  



))   ( ))

  3 )(       "

 *.C  5= ; ) ' 3

'  3(   

   3 ) ,* "

 */*   B    ) ) 

<

 3 ( ' )3)(   

 

) '  ' )3)(        30

 $*%  "

 */* 

  

 '

 '

(      

    

 3)    (     3 

   ( 

))   ( ))

  3 )(       "

 *.C  5= ;?

$@ 

 ) % " = ))

  

   

       

  (    3    )  3

 )      "

 *.C   5= ; 3 

) 3)(  3

B     

   

  +    0   

 3)  

 (      3 

 =  3

  

)3)(   

  ( 

) ))( 3  4   )    ' )( )3)  

      "

 *.C   5= ; 6 2  !

   . (

*



   

 

      )

   (  . ( *!   

*!& 

 (  *

 

 .     /0  !

 1

+-  

2 3 

) .

  *

7 

#  '%

 4/0!1

)" 

-3 

-      

  !

   

 .     %



( 

(

%& (



 *!, *   !   !

 !

  

   %   .

   

5

   



    %  *%

.

  1(  & *!& 

& *!  8

   %  *%     !



 $   *!   .

   

(**  

(&

 

 2

    .

 . (

1(  



! 

. % %

& A

(

 !!



8

*

&

.  2

!

 

 .

 

* !!   & 

 



&   !

!&

% !

 

   ;&?

8

+

2 # 3+ ! #7  &:

&(&

# 5 607

 89 5 / 89