Devinder Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

 




    


     !"

#$%&'%()*)+,

 

%-)+'%  )+./#+'$/% *

%$)$)+% * -% *0*

$#$%&0+1#2#+'#+$/%

%*3+'%+$*
 #4, 5 6  
      %*%+$, 

#*$%1 )+./8 '-(#$%& $/%3%$)$)+% * 

)$$%+%/ #8 ''9

80+1#2 



#++08 '-(#$%& %*3+'%+$


 

 
 /)*  3%$)$)+  0+'% %($)+  :

  &  $/% 
'%  & 
)4)+#9  (%'0 %/#*2%%+&)9%'& ;0#*/)+.& <<'#$%'   <

%.)*$% %'0+'% %($)+*: 8#+'  &$/%+')#+%+#9
'% &

*/ $5$/%
5"8#$9)(% $#$)+ #');8 )*$ )($# )'=$ ++%>0 %"

#+'  #99  (+*%;0%+$)#9  3 (%%')+.*  # )*)+.  $/% %& 48  +  $/%  2#*)*  & (43 4)*%'%%' ++%>0 %"#

)-%'#$2%$?%%+$/%3# $)%* @)'% '% '#$%'  <   8$/%3# $)%*?% %') %($%'$#33%#

2%& %$/%9%# +%'$ )#9
0 $A99#;##.)*$ #$%8& .%$$)+.$/%) *$#$%4%+$*

%( '%'B#*$$/%.%+0)+%+%**&$/%(43 4)*% +(439)#+(%$/% %&8

%3 $&0')()#9#.)*$ #$%*$
9#**8# )'=$8 '#$%'   8 /#* 2%%+ %(%)-%'8?/% %)+8)$/#*2%%++$)(%'$/#$$/%3# $)%*/#-%*%$$9%'$/% ')*30$%#4)(#29C?)$/0$#+C0+'0%)+&90%+(%8(% ()+ 3 %**0 %#+'

++%&$/%#((0*%'/#-%2%%+'%(9# %'#*3 (9#)4%'&&%+'%

/%09$)4#$%#)4821%($)-%#+'.#9&#9%.#9*C*$%4)*$

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

$/%%>$ %4%30+)*/4%+$*8)+(90')+.'%#$/3%+#9$C& ( )4)+#9#($* ?%-% 84 %&$%+$/%++$$/%()-)9')*30$%* )+$% *% (+&9)($*  &  $?  3# $)%*  $ #+*& 4*  $/%4*%9-%*  )+$  ( )4)+#9  #*3%($ /% %& %8$/%9%.#9*C*$%439#C*%43) %$ %*9-%$/%(+&9)($2%$?%%+$? 3# $)%*B?)$/$/%#''%'$#*=&%+*0 )+.$/#$$/%#'-% *%)43#($&')*30$%

;0#*()%$C#$9# .%)*4)+)4)E%'

0$*$)99$/%( %)'%#)*$ %*9-%$/% (+&9)($2%$?%%+$?*)'%*2C30$$)+.)$$ %*$ /% %& %8%-%+$/%( )4)+#9 9#?)* %;0) %'$.)-%'0% %.# '$$/%?)*/%*&$/%3# $)%*$')*30$% %(.+)E)+.$/)*3 )+()39%+9C8$/%+')#+9%.#9 C*$%4#9*3 -)'%*&

%(.+)E)+.  $/% (43 4)*%  2%$?%%+  $?  *)'%*  &  #  ( )4)+#9  ')*30$%

%($)+D 


)*#+%>3 %**3 -)*)+)+$/)* %.# '

/)**%($)++$ +9C3 -)'%*& (430+')+.'0 )+.$/%$ )#9820$3% 4)$*(430+')+.

%-%+#$#33%99#$% %-)*)+#9*$#.% ?%-% 2C)$*-% C+#$0 %#+'*(3%8

%($)+D 


(#++$2%$/%*9% %3*)$ CB?/% %)+$/% %(.+)$)+ $#(43 4)*%2%$?%%+$/%3# $)%*/#-%B+%(%**# )9CB$2%(+&)+%'

/)* *%($)+ %9#$%*+9C$$/%&&%+(%*3 %*( )2%'0+'% $/%+')#+%+#9
'% /% %# %#9$4 %&&%+(%*3 %*( )2%'0$*)'%
-%+$$/%&&%+(%* %>)*$)+.)+$/%
+%?')4%+*)+*# %#''%'& 4$)4%$$)4%84#=)+.$/% %>)*$)+.&&%+(%*$2%9)./$%  *$ )+.%+$#+'%-%++%?4'#9)$)%*&3 & &&&%+(%*# %2%)+. %(.+)*%')+-)%?&$%(/+9.)(#9#'-#+(%4%+$ /)*+%(%**)$#$%*#+' %;0) %*$/%+%%'& 9=)+.2%C+' %($)+D


$ %(.+)*%$/%(43 4)*%2%$?%%+$/%3# $)%*$')*30$% 0$$ 4#)+$#)+$/%*#+($)$C&$/%3 (%'0 %3 %*( )2%'& ( )4)+#9$ )#9B$/% )#9
0 $(#++$2%3% 4)$$%'$$ #-%92%C+'$/%*(3%3 %*( )2%'0+'% $/#$ (%'0 % %+(%$/%+%%'& )+-=)+. %($)+:




2C$/%)./
0 $

:

0$8  #*  2*% -%'  #2-%8  $/% ?)*/%*  & +9C 3# $)%*  $ $/% ( )4)+#9')*30$%?09'+$#9?#C*2%*0&&)()%+$$$% 4)+#$%#( )4)+#9$ )#9 )+-)%?&$/%3#$%+$89#$%+$ *02$9%%&&%($B$/%) (+'0($?09'/#-%9%&$ ;0#$/%*()%$C#$9# .% /% %& %$/%&$%+(%* (44)$$%'2C3% *+* )+-9-%')+.-% +#+(% #'4)+)*$ #$)+& #(;0) )+.&&)()#93?% 

?/)9%%>% ()*)+.&&)(%3?% (#++$2%3% 4)$$%'$2%(43 4)*%'

6)=%?)*%8  %-%+  $/%  &$%+(%*  )+-9-)+.  +9C  $?  3 )-#$%  3% *+*8  20$

%&9%($)+.'%3 #-)$C&(/# #($%  )+-9-)+.(#0*)+.)+$%+$)+#99**&9)&% (#0*)+.)+$%+$)+#99**&3 3% $C2C%>$%+')+.)44)+%+$$/ %#$&9** &  9)&%B  (#++$  2%  3% 4)$$%'  $  2%  (43 4)*%'

 >(%3$  $/%  #2-% 4%+$)+%'.

#-%&&%+(%*8$/% %)*%-% C %#*+$/#$#99$/% &&%+(%* */09'2%3% 4)$$%'$2%(43 4)*%'2C$/%
0 $ )+(%$/%3 && &&%+(%*2%& %$/%
0 $8#.#)+?09')+-9-%$/%(+'0($&$/%3# $)%*$ ')*30$%8$/% %& %)&$/%
0 $'%*+$3% 4)$$/%*#4%$2%(43 4)*%'

$/%+$/%3# $)%*?09'$%+'$39#C$ )(=*03+$/%
0 $$%+*0 %$/% #(;0)$$#9&#((0*%'2C*02-% $)+.$/%#'4)+)*$ #$)+&( )4)+#910*$)(%

+')$)*+%-% )+$/%)+$% %*$&#'4)+)*$ #$)+&( )4)+#910*$)(%$& (% $/%()$)E%+$9%# +#+'#'3$$/%$ )(=*'%*).+%'$2%39#C%'03+
0 $* $*02-% $$/%10*$)(%*C*$%4 )$?09'#9?#C*2%)+$/%)+$% %*$&10*$)(% )$*%9&B$/#$$/%(43 4)*%2%$?%%+$/%3# $)%*)* %(.+)E%'#+'$/%()$)E%+

%4#)+  4 %'  #+'  (44)$$%'  $  $/%  %**%+$)#9*  &  $/%  *C*$%4  &

< #'4)+)*$ #$)+&10*$)(%8#$9%#*$8;0#$/*%&&%+(%*8?/)(/$/%)+$% %*$& *()%$C'%*+$3% 4)$$2%(43 4)*%'

+529%  $/%  %4% 
0 $  /#*  #439C  (9# )&)%'  $/%  9%.#9 3*)$)++ %(.+)E)+.(43 4)*)+.)+$/%(#*%&


 

 

  !"#+'/#*2*% -%'#* 0+'% ,


      



  

       

           !   "

 

 #

 





                    $

%&'  

  

  

 



  (





 "

  

  

     )*+ ,

  #

 +

,       

(

                 !("

          

   

     

      

 

     (    - "

  -  

 

   

(      

 

   

(  

.- -

(- 



 (     

  

/ 

(  

 

 $

 

      

  

 ($

 (-(  

   



  

     

 

. 0

 



1     

( 

 



 .

    

( *

      (  

            



        2         

  (  

 ( 

  

   

   

  - 

  (

  

    -   -

-  

-    

.  

  



   ( 

  (-   

( 

   





(     

    



  



  

   (     -    

  (      

     

  -           

    

- 



(   



 .



           

 # "



#

               (  

          

  

     

     



  

 

  -  

 



 

     ( 



#

 



       



            

    

 



   

   

       #

-

        

 

       

+ ,

  

-      

 

   

 

 

#

 

        3 /%3 %*%+$(#*%'%*+$&#99)+#+C+%&$/%%>(%3$)+* %+-)*#.%'#2-% %+(%8)+-)%?&$/% %3 $&0')()#9#.)*$ #$%*$
9#**8# )'=$8'#$%'   4#'%)+30 *0#+(%&$/% '% '#$%'

<   3#**%'2C$/)*
0 $8$/%
0 $&%%9*$/#$+0*%&0930 3*% ?09'2%*% -%'2C=%%3)+.$/%3 (%%')+.*#9)-% $?)992%)+$/%)+$% %*$ &10*$)(%8)&$/%*%$$9%4%+$ %#(/%'2%$?%%+$/%3# $)%*)*#((%3$%'

(( ')+.9C8$/%3 %*%+$3%$)$)+)*#99?%'

 <<'#$%'

 < %.)*$% %'0+'% %($)+*: 8#+'  &$/%
8#$9)(%

$#$)+  #');8  )*$ )($  # )'=$  ++%>0 %  "  #+'  #99  (+*%;0%+$)#9 (%%')+.*  # )*)+.  $/% %& 4   # %  /% %2C  ;0#*/%'  ;0#  $/%  3 %*%+$ 3%$)$)+% * 


     



7/%$/% *3%#=)+.A %#*+%'%*A  7/%$/% %3 $#29%F%*A