Gurdial Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab
!"#
$ $
!"!%"& !"# '$ $
% ()*("+,- (..%)" )"!.,
.).
!/%"0)1
2# 3 42$2
! "
# $ " %%%%% 2 5$
# '(
$
)*)+**, -
.*)+**,
"/
0 #
" 1 23 ... *++... 4
# '(
5 67 1 8. )*8...
,*2( 7
# !
!
)6 !/!" (&.
// "& 7
".
"&
# '(
,*2( 7 7
9 / + ,*2( 7 7
/
+ +
)*8...
: " $
7 $
!
;<! !
"
/ "$ ! # ' (
( = ! < !
"
!/ /
> "
# ' (
"
!/
: # !
-
< = "
****&= ?
@
! !
"! ****& #
" !< "$
> !
"
!
:! ?
@ ! " /
-
/!
/ = )*8...?
@ ! # !
;! - " ! / <
/
< !
" < "/ ! #
"/ " *3** ! / !
/ ! "/ "$ / / !
<
! /7 "
"$
, !
"/ "
#
! "
!/
/ !
/
" <
A
67!
,*2( 7 , ;
-
!
"/
"$
!
(
!
!
!
B
!
,*2( 7 6
8,!
"
" 7 -
2 =
!
+*8
,*2( 7!
C / ""/
0
#
0 #
+... 3 D
0 #
# '(
,*2( 7! !
C
! / / B
C : " $ A: A+# A , 7
" A2 ; : ; = : # A3:0 AB0; $
2 ;
A8 7 $ A)9 "
)*8+**, 8
"
!
,, "/ ! /
:!
C /!
)*)+**, )
"/ "
/ # ' (
! /
,*2( 7 $
)*)+**,
.*)+**, "
"/
0# 6 $
# '(
. D
$
"/
!
!
/ "
9
"
: " $ A # " A, 9 7
/ / $ /
!
"! "
! "/
!/ ! /"
7 ! !/!
" / !
!
< 7
3 ! / !
"
!/
D
: " $ A # A,
C
: " $ A
9
"
!
****& 9
! "
/<
D
/ " ! /
1+ !
: " $ A
C
!
" 8*/ 9
" .+ /
C
: " $ A
"
" < "/ "
/ ! A
"
" ! /
"/ 7
"
$
)*)+**, -
.*)+**,
"/
0# /< /" "/
B * =
,*2( 7E
: " $ A # " A,
( !
/
"$ !
"
/
!/
!
/"/-
"$ !
"
" !
" 6 / )*8...
/!
"$ ;! ! /
<
< ! !
<"/
"
F
"/;:; = A3!
ECA3& EC D " / A3&;
!
!
" <
ECA3&E
!
! !
/
"/7 $ A)D <
9
! /
"/
9 "/
8 7
" "/
$ " /
67 "
: " $
!
EC =
< )*8... : " $
< ! "
"$ "/ !
<
" *3**9
!
"/7 $ ?
7@A) " *B,*
EC& "
67!
! EC&+9
67 (
# '(
"
!
"
,*2( 7 7 C : " $ A # " A,9
" !
9 !
/
"$ ! # '(
" / !
" 3B
? "$ @ : " $ A
) !/ /E !
"
!
9!
****&9 ! !
) ****&
-
"
E !
" "/
!
! !
: ! ?# A,@
-
"
"$ 9/C
" /
/
: !
/ " !<! ! # !
;! < ! " !
< ! "
"$ "/ A /
"/ "$ !
/
/ 9
! < "
/ 7
" : " $ A # A, D
/
/
" !
9
9
+ D
C /
!
9
/ 7 $ A)
< -/
!
7 /
" !
/ 7
"
C /
.
9 "$
"/
/ 9
!
/
"$
" / ; " ! !
3B
;
/
!
"/
!/
E
"/
****&
9
"/
: " $ A
/
-
/ 7
< )*8...9 -
/
" !
"$
/
/
=
" $
%8
!% . !/ " ()
49) ,6( 9)% )" )"!.,
:
% .).
!/%"0)15!
,*2( 7 !
!
! 4B 6 "
!
"
@9
,*2(7
"
" " !
"$
/
*
!
!/ "@9 !
"/ /" "/ $/
! !
@
! /
@9
"$
/
"/ "
/ "
@ /
"
!
!/ @7 "
" /
" @9C
?
" @ !
$ <
" !
! !
"
@ 7 !" G
/ C "
C /
"
!/ !
,( E
@9 C
H " H! / /
" " !
/
-
9
" C
C
<" !
/ "
!/
7 ! "
"/ <
$@:! C
H " H "
! ! ! ! /
"
<@
,*2( C
$
7 D !
+*
!
9
/ " $
"
!
,*2( @
! "
" "
"/
,*2( !
@9
"
/
!
"$
!
!/ !
! =
!
!" !/ "/
! "
! "
5 ,
"$
/ ;:; = C A3:
"/ "$ .*8... :
/
!
C $/ < "/
!
/
EC D " / ECA3&; ECA3&E
!
=
" "$
! /
!/
,( 97 E
)8+
/!
+ 4 $
%68.(!") .! !;
< ).,A -
!
!/ !
!
" !
"
"$
"/ /
! /
!/
!/
6
4!/ 5
,*2( 7 ?23 )B*@5 =
" $
%8
!% . !/ " ()
4% ("
("+, :
% .).
!/ ) <)")5
! 1, "13. Section 113B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 states that when the question is whether a person has committed the dowry death of a woman, and it is shown that soon before her death such woman has been subjected by such person to cruelty or harassment for, or in connection with, any demand for dowry, the court shall presume that such person had caused the dowry death.
Section 304B of the IPC states that where the death of a woman is caused by any burns or bodily injury or occurs otherwise than under normal circumstances within seven years of her marriage and it is shown that soon before her death she was subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or any relative of her husband for, or in connection with, any demand for dowry, such death shall be called 'dowry death', and such husband or relative shall be deemed to have caused her death. Thus, the words 'soon before' appear in Section 113B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and also in Section 304B of the IPC. For the presumptions contemplated under these Sections to spring into action, it is necessary to show that the cruelty or harassment was caused soon before the death. The interpretation of the words 'soon before' is, therefore, important.
The question is how 'soon before'?
, depend on facts and circumstances of each case. The cruelty or harassment differs from case to case. It relates to the mindset of people which varies from person to person. Cruelty can be mental or it can be physical. Mental cruelty is also of different shades. It can be verbal or emotional like insulting or ridiculing or humiliating a woman. It can be giving threats of injury to her or her near and dear ones. It can be depriving her of economic resources or essential amenities of life. It can be putting restraints on her movements. It can be not allowing her to talk to the outside world. The list is illustrative and not exhaustive. Physical cruelty could be actual beating or causing pain and harm to the person of a woman. Every such instance of cruelty and related harassment has a different impact on the mind of a woman.
Some instances may be so grave as to have a lasting impact on a woman. Some instances which degrade her dignity may remain etched in her memory for a long time. Therefore, 'soon before' is a relative term. In matters of emotions we cannot have fixed formulae. The time-lag may differ from case to case. This must be kept in mind while examining each case of dowry death."
2
"$
!
/
/ I /
! / "
"
,*2( 7 !
,( 7 E
)8+ 1! !
"
"/
/
: " $ A # A, !
!/
2
/
" !
# '(
<
,, ! !
< < "/
<
< 7
)*8... "$ !
<E !
"" "$
" "/
<9
"/
# '(
! /"
3 9
! "/
!
" "/ : A+
" # : #
C
< !
! "/! "/ /
;: ; A3 ? <@!
!
: A+
!
<
ECA3& : A+ 7 $
= ! !
<
/
EC(7
C
7 $ A)
! -
" "/
C
/ "/
7
? <@7
7
= /
? <@
9!
7
/ !
!
!
; <
3
!
? <@ "<
B ;
! "$ " !
"/
!
# '(
" "
" /
!
9 /
# '(
/
"
,*2( 7 !
/
A "
$
)*)+**, -
.*)+**,
"/
0 # - )88 **)".7&!" (&. % ()* ("+, - (..% !
"!.
=%(
)"< (".
/
"& )" )88 )*8
/
1<,(6( 5)&&!
("+*<5 ( 6(
$ 8
1+&
!
$
)*)+**, -
.*)+**, !
/ 9
1+&
: " $ A
C
" < "/ 7 "
"
1 + "/ !
" "
9 )88 )*!"1 ,)*/!/)88 **)".!$ 6) 9)% ( 5)&&!
("+*<5 )**!;
$
)*)+**, -
B
.*)+**,
"/
0 #
- "/ " "
-
) A "
"/
# '(
/
# ' (
!
"/
(
" 0
# !
/ ! 0
# !
!
$
1
/
"
.
?
@ /
?
@
/ >2 ?
'$ $
A < & J &1 A " J &1