Vijay Kumar And ORS. v. Panjab University Chd.
DHARAM VIR 2019.12.19 09:43 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
! " #$% $!&$$ $ $' $!
(
') '* (( (+
+,,
- ((-
(
-
!"
,, ,
!#
, (,(
(, +
"
(,-+ $!"
+ ( ,, " "
%
!$.*/ 0%1 .!# 2 $! . $ & ' (#)$ %
) ' !*!!$ %
+
'*
$ %
+
, ' '
$ %
- '" $ %
+
$! . $3#4 !$15 .
+ !! +
! + !+%
+!
+ % +)
,
%
+
!/ %
% )
.0
+ % 1 (
% )
!/ ! +%!
+% 2 % + !!
)
.3. 0.4)
&, 5% +)
+!
,
!6
! !% % !+
%
% )
!!+ )!
+
$
%
!
% !+
! +
,
+!
++
!
)
+
+ +
!
$
080 0.9: 3 $++
80 0.9
+!
) )
! %
!! %
/ )& ;
< = 408> + 003 -
? 2 2)6 ') 768)9) !) . <?
"
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 ) ! + %
+6
)?
080. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%! .344.,.809.? B
(
.40> 0.3 1
)?
$ "
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0 !% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 3 '?
$!
'
080. 0.8 C!+!
+1A80
1.. 0.0 !% %%!=
.40> 0.3 8
" ?
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0 !%
%%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 A % ?
$
%!
.10 0.1 <
D
$ = .3? 004 5 +,, #: 2);) <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) .
)?
"
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 ' ?
#! =
%!
. 0 0.1 <
D
$ = .3? 004 1 ' 7 (?
.>0. 0.8 )
+ + 3 )?
" $
(
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0..
%%!=
.40> 0.3 8 '#! (?
#
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 A (?
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 > <?
)
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 4
?
* !
.10 0.1 <
$ .3? 004 9 " ! " ?
$
%!
.10 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004
.0
'!
<?
" ! "
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 5 ( ,, <>): A6;) <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)) !) . " "
%?
$
"
%
0>01 0.. C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!= 34>0,80 0?B
.301 0.. " ?
7
7!
' >01 00A <
D 1 !(
?
. 0> 0.. C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!= 34>0,80 0?B
.301 0.. 3 "#! ?
$ 7!
. 0> 0.. C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!= 34>0,80 0?B
.301 0.. 8 * ! (?
= '
!
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 A $ $
.8.. 00> )
B#$E
B$#ED
.8.. 00>
D > F" ?
* 7! ?
7
</
.10 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 4 #! (?
7
#
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 9 = ?
(!
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .0
# ?
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .. (?
* ( 080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 . "
"(?
7
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .1 " ! " ?
' '
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3
.3
" ?
*
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .8 7!?
7
#)
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .A
(?
!
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .> " !
(?
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 @5 (,-+ $8A6;)<=)>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)) !) . $!" ?
##
%!
.30 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 7)
?
* !
080. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 1 *
?
%!
.10 0.1 <
$ .3?.004 3
=?
(
080. 0.8 C!+!
+
7!
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 8 ! ?
F =
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!= .344., .809.?B
(
.40> 0.3 A "! ?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!= .344., .809.?B
(
.40> 0.3 @5 (, +
2) A6;) <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) . "
?
$
40. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 " ?
#
40. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3
1 "
?
"
.40 0.1 <!
$ = .3? 004 3 #!
?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!= .344., .809.?B
(
.40> 0.3 8
" ?
%% *,2 100A 004 <
D @5 (,(
<) 2 <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) .
?
F (
=
7 + "!) " ?
7
'
=
.30 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 1 )" ?
' 7!
.10 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 @5 ,, ,
;8) %)) <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) . !# (?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 ) ! + % 1.0> 0.4
6 , " ! (?
7!
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 1 #
"(?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 3
" (?
2) (
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3
8 (
) (?
)'
'
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 A F" ?
) "
.30 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 > (?
2
#
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 4 $ " ?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 @5 (
-
268A6;)<=)>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) . !" ?
"
.30 0.1 <
$ = .3? 004
B5 ((-
26))<=)>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) .
?
"!
B6 ' " ?
(!
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0 !% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 1
" ?
*(
90. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 3 ?
*
(
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0 !% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 8 '
! ?
(!
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 A
?
.40 0.1 <
D
$ = .3? 004 > " ! ?
(
.40 0.1 <
D
$ = .3? 004 4 '" )?
)
!! 8 $!
) ++ % +
+ %
0801 0.. !
+
,
! %
) %
.0 + % + 1.0. 0. % +!
)
+
%
+ .0
+ %
%
!
A F ++ /,,/
+ %
2
)
%%
+ +
! %
+.0 + % 1.0. 0. )
)
+%
%
.0 1.0. 0. %+% !
%
+!
)
+
%
%
!
+%
!
!! +!
! !
!
!
% ) B %!! % !
+!+!!!
)% % !!
+
! % %
+!
+
> 2 +
! ?
+ %
! !
%
+
! %
) ! !
!
4 <
+)
%
%
)
) ! !
+% %
9
)
%% !! !
+ +
! + % +%
!
) ! !
.0
%!
%
!!
) +
%
+
! ( +
$
!% +!
% 4$! . $5 @;? 3 (+ # '
( <
? &G ?= <
!
&G ?=
! " #$% $!&$$ $ $' $!
(
') '* (( (+
+,,
- ((-
(
-
!"
,, ,
!#
, (,(
(, +
"
(,-+ $!"
+ ( ,, " "
%
!$.*/ 0%1 .!# 2 $! . $ & ' (#)$ %
) ' !*!!$ %
+
'*
$ %
+
, ' '
$ %
- '" $ %
+
$! . $3#4 !$15 .
+ !! +
! + !+%
+!
+ % +)
,
%
+
!/ %
% )
.0
+ % 1 (
% )
!/ ! +%!
+% 2 % + !!
)
.3. 0.4)
&, 5% +)
+!
,
!6
! !% % !+
%
% )
!!+ )!
+
$
%
!
% !+
! +
,
+!
++
!
)
+
+ +
!
$
080 0.9: 3 $++
80 0.9
+!
) )
! %
!! %
/ )& ;
< = 408> + 003 -
? 2 2)6 ') 768)9) !) . <?
"
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 ) ! + %
+6
)?
080. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%! .344.,.809.? B
(
.40> 0.3 1
)?
$ "
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0 !% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 3 '?
$!
'
080. 0.8 C!+!
+1A80
1.. 0.0 !% %%!=
.40> 0.3 8
" ?
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0 !%
%%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 A % ?
$
%!
.10 0.1 <
D
$ = .3? 004 5 +,, #: 2);) <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) .
)?
"
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 ' ?
#! =
%!
. 0 0.1 <
D
$ = .3? 004 1 ' 7 (?
.>0. 0.8 )
+ + 3 )?
" $
(
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0..
%%!=
.40> 0.3 8 '#! (?
#
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 A (?
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 > <?
)
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 4
?
* !
.10 0.1 <
$ .3? 004 9 " ! " ?
$
%!
.10 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004
.0
'!
<?
" ! "
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 5 ( ,, <>): A6;) <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)) !) . " "
%?
$
"
%
0>01 0.. C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!= 34>0,80 0?B
.301 0.. " ?
7
7!
' >01 00A <
D 1 !(
?
. 0> 0.. C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!= 34>0,80 0?B
.301 0.. 3 "#! ?
$ 7!
. 0> 0.. C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!= 34>0,80 0?B
.301 0.. 8 * ! (?
= '
!
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 A $ $
.8.. 00> )
B#$E
B$#ED
.8.. 00>
D > F" ?
* 7! ?
7
</
.10 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 4 #! (?
7
#
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 9 = ?
(!
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .0
# ?
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .. (?
* ( 080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 . "
"(?
7
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .1 " ! " ?
' '
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3
.3
" ?
*
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .8 7!?
7
#)
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .A
(?
!
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 .> " !
(?
080. 0.8 C!+!
+ 1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 @5 (,-+ $8A6;)<=)>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)) !) . $!" ?
##
%!
.30 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 7)
?
* !
080. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 1 *
?
%!
.10 0.1 <
$ .3?.004 3
=?
(
080. 0.8 C!+!
+
7!
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 8 ! ?
F =
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!= .344., .809.?B
(
.40> 0.3 A "! ?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!= .344., .809.?B
(
.40> 0.3 @5 (, +
2) A6;) <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) . "
?
$
40. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 " ?
#
40. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3
1 "
?
"
.40 0.1 <!
$ = .3? 004 3 #!
?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!= .344., .809.?B
(
.40> 0.3 8
" ?
%% *,2 100A 004 <
D @5 (,(
<) 2 <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) .
?
F (
=
7 + "!) " ?
7
'
=
.30 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 1 )" ?
' 7!
.10 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 @5 ,, ,
;8) %)) <= )>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) . !# (?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 ) ! + % 1.0> 0.4
6 , " ! (?
7!
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 1 #
"(?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 3
" (?
2) (
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3
8 (
) (?
)'
'
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 A F" ?
) "
.30 0.1 <
D
$ .3? 004 > (?
2
#
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 4 $ " ?
+1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!%%%! 34>0,80 0?B
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 @5 (
-
268A6;)<=)>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) . !" ?
"
.30 0.1 <
$ = .3? 004
B5 ((-
26))<=)>)? @: 2 2)6 ') !768)9) !) .
?
"!
B6 ' " ?
(!
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0 !% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 1
" ?
*(
90. 0.8 C!+!
+
+1A80
1.. 0.0
!%%%!=
.40> 0.3 3 ?
*
(
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0 !% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 8 '
! ?
(!
1A80
%!
1.. 0.0
!% %%!= 34>0, 80 0?B
(
.31 0.. %%!=
.40> 0.3 A
?
.40 0.1 <
D
$ = .3? 004 > " ! ?
(
.40 0.1 <
D
$ = .3? 004 4 '" )?
)
!! 8 $!
) ++ % +
+ %
0801 0.. !
+
,
! %
) %
.0 + % + 1.0. 0. % +!
)
+
%
+ .0
+ %
%
!
A F ++ /,,/
+ %
2
)
%%
+ +
! %
+.0 + % 1.0. 0. )
)
+%
%
.0 1.0. 0. %+% !
%
+!
)
+
%
%
!
+%
!
!! +!
! !
!
!
% ) B %!! % !
+!+!!!
)% % !!
+
! % %
+!
+
> 2 +
! ?
+ %
! !
%
+
! %
) ! !
!
4 <
+)
%
%
)
) ! !
+% %
9
)
%% !! !
+ +
! + % +%
!
) ! !
.0
%!
%
!!
) +
%
+
! ( +
$
!% +!
% 4$! . $5 @;? 3 (+ # '
( <
? &G ?= <
!
&G ?=