Sonu Dhanda And ANR v. State Of Haryana And Another
!"# $%&%!'()**
( +, * - - -
! " #
$%
&$%
& '
- - .*
(
#
)*'"
"
+ ,-& ./.'
') ./ './0
/'.12 ).3 4 )'. - # "
/*3.
# $ #
# 5 ## + #
% ( % %
./ .6 '.'/1' *
( ,- 5
%
1
& '
#
%
1
! " # $ % & ' ( & ) ! * + ! , - . ! ) / +" -1-
!&0 1 $ 2 2 #% 3 ) 4 5 $
6 $ 4 $ '
2'7%8
*+ $4 4 $ ) $ 9! 4 4 $ : 4 $ 4 4 4 )
4 4 44
) 4 $ 44)%$ +'; 4
+*3- %$ < +*3- 4 $ 4
$ )+';
*
*4 $ 4 ) 2 4 4 4 * '77/'7%8
* 0 ( +78='-8-
4 4 ) ! 4 ) > 4
* +78='-8-
+ 4$!+ ! 4
- 4 4 ) 2 )
* ! 4 4 ? ) 9
$ 2
' *4$49 4 ) $ 2 %3%/ $ -2-
)+*%/7777@3
* $ $ (:
' * ) $ 4 4
'* -)%$ 3%$ ) 4 ) - 2'7%8
* - 4 44%3%$
/3%7
)44 "
4 $
4)4 4
44 4 4 4 4 < $ ) 4 < ) 4 $ 2 $
* - ! 4
% /9)
% /44
4 4
4
$ 2
% / %7$44) +'' $4%73%' > $
/3; $ )
+ +%*777777@3> 4: 4 %7$ 4 ) $4 $ 4
% / )$ 4 4 $ +' 1$
! 4 4
! -3-
*73783'7%8+%*'77777@34)
% /
4 +' ! 4
)
'* - 4 >
) 4 ) 1$ 4 %7@%'
4) ) %/ 4
$ 4
* + 4 4 $ 4 $)
4
'3* 4
4) & '7%8 4 )
* 4
4
' *
/
( + 2 4
/4
1 4 $ 4 4 $ 4 $ '@-
*$ $ ) !2 4 !
14 4
4%73%/ 4 '7
% / )
1 $
% / 4 >
% / ) 4
) 4 $
4
4 &
%
) 4 4
14 4$
4 ) )
6/ 4
$ 4 4
)
4 )
-4-
4 4 ) 6 $ )4
) $
) 4
! @ ''7%'7%B 3 @3
#3
@ "
4 , $4 )
-'7-71%'730)
A+( %7' '-37%3'7%B -'7-71%'730 !
4
4 ) %*B-
) A+ 6,
C * - %#
.) /.
'.'6 (
"
.3 // '.'6
! $% 5 -
#
$ # (
# % !
"
#
# /* #
%
(
% (#
# (
5 ## %#
& '8
,-+ # 5 ## + #
( +
-
(
# #
#
.9 .'
'.'6 ("
2 5
( "11*0/:1'.'6 4
5
-5-
##5
# +
,-
% ;
*
D #
# 5#
(%
%
/96 "
"
#
(
(%
(
"
%
<
.'
.) './0 /:
.3 './0 '3 .9 './0 .* .) '.'/ /0 .9 '.'/
# =
## >
& /1 # (
% ( # ? #
, "# $ #
@?-"A '* .6 '.'68 5
# ./ /'
'.'6 #
5
& /1 % 5 <
# %
# #
@ #%
A ( # ?-"
// .9 '.''
7 # (%
%(
%#
8
( % 5 * B
# # %# !5#
% % % (%
(<
% ,- + #
+
0* # #
5(#
# 1*
1(!
# "1
2 5# % '9 .9 '.''
##5
1 -6-
-8' 6 A+ ( 7%7' '-%'7%B %'730 -71 -'7 ! & !
( 2 , 2" & 2 )
,( !2 )
@ ( '
" 4 $ 4 +4 4$ > $ , () ! &2E
4 )
@6, %8%7'7''
) @6 ,
@6, 4
: 4 4 #3 %(
A+ 'F
* @
-F
) 4
%8%'7'* 4 2
@6 ,
C )* -
%
( # ?-"
/'
./ '.'6 5
,
1
4
( &
%'7%'7'*
-7-
C =%# )*
/* ./ '.'6 "
2 ##5
1
+
) 4 ( %
A 4
( % ( 4 ( %
1''7'*
)
) ';;'7'' : ( 4 '%*'7'*C )* -
%
/:
.6 '.'65
%# ?-"
#
%
1
' 717''7'*
&
4 %/7*'7'* > %/7*'7'*
&
(
& 4 ) $ 4
))! 4
$ 4 GC * 2
"
+ % ,-# 5 ## + #
%
% %
(
5 ##
& '1 %#
-8-
* , %
# 5
# ?-" HI # #
(#
#
& /1
%
- # %
#
(
#
#%
( "
%
<
##
#5 C
(
& /1
# #58
%!
< #
% !
*
%
#
.3 // '.'6 HI +
(
%# 8
: >
1
/
!3> . H. IJ K 2 E4 L4 J HJ2ELJI 4 )
@
%% A+
& / A+4
(& H ( 'I !
:
A+
$
4 A+ #3
HI A+( '8 %77%'7%B?@ -71@-'7@/71@*-@*;B30@*8-
)L!( 4 : 7*%%'7'* L 2!2 .! -9-
HI A+ ( %7' 7/7*'7%B ?@ *7;@*1-@-71@-'7@/71 K '/@/-@/B 2 2 ) L ! ( 4 : %8%%'7'* L
HI A+ '%B %/%%'7%8 ?@ -71@-'7@%'730 ! 4 : 7%%%'7'* L ) 2., ! H)I A+ ( *; 7/7*'7%B ?@ %-8@%-B@*7;@-71@-'7@/71@*- K'/@/-@/B 22 !4 6 L ) 7%71'7'* H)I A+( '1 '17%'7%/?@ %-8@%-B@*'*@--;@/%%@/71 K'/@/-@/B 22 )L! 4 6 ) +,3,( *B77* '7%; H)I A+ ( '% 7*7''7%1 ?@ -'7@/71 )L!4 6
L 2" ., ! )
7%71'7'* H)I A+ ( %8* 7'7/'7%8 ?@ -'7@/71 )L!4 4 > 4 : 7%%%'7'*
L 2.,! ) H)I A+( / 7;7%'7%B?@ -71@-'7@/71
A 4
6 L ) %8%7'7%B H:I A+ ( *' '/7''7%B ?@ -71@-'7@%'730 H" I 4 : %1%%'7'*
H:I A+ ( %7' '-7%'7%B ?@ %'730@-71@-'7 !4
&
>) %%7;'7'' : : 71%%'7'* H:I A+( ''/ 7;%7'77;?@ %-8@%-B@*'*@-/'@/71@-'; $ 4
4 6 ) 7-%''77B H:I A+ ( //*@'7'% ?@ *8-@-'7@-71 . H 4I4 : 7B%%'7'* -10-
L L 2 . +
$
HI A+ ( %7' 7/7*'7%B ?@ *7;@*1-@-71@-'7@/71 K '/@/-@/B 2 2 ) L ! ( 4 : %8%%'7'* L
HI A+( '8 %77%'7%B?@ -71@-'7@/71@*-@*;B30@*8-
)L!( 4 : 7*%%'7'* L 2!2 .! HI A+ ( '%B %/%%'7%8 ?@ -71@-'7@%'730 ! 4 : 7%%%'7'* L ) 2., ! H)I A+ ( %7' '-7%'7%B ?@ %'730@-71@-'7 !4 : 71%%'7'*
L +) ! ., ! ) H)I A+ ( *; 7/7*'7%B ?@ %-8@%-B@*7;@-71@-'7 K'/@/-@/B 22 !4
" .! : 7*%%'7'* C
(
# ( >
# #
# (
+
%#
,- #
5
*
# # #
% #
,-& '*%
& HI#
(
+ ( "
2
.9 .'
'.'6 ( % ## ##5
1 % -
##
%# 5 ## -11-
%# / 6'
> ## # ; ''
..#!
!
%% ( ! ##
( # ./ !
../ % 5
% 1 ?
;$# %%% D
%
.9 .'
'.'6 ##
(#
%2 -
/96"
"
5(%
5( !
%
> 1
& /
#
(
2 5
.9 .'
'.'6 # ( E
(
#
#"
2%
#
5
& / (
#
#%
// .9 '.''8
% 5 <
8
# !
/*
#
(
% >
& / '* .6 '.'6 5
8
5# (
%!
1
5
1 !"###$ +) ., !
% & & '
( ! #3
*778'7%8
& +" 4 4+%*'
+''L$$
)
4 -12-
3 4 )
$
6
)*+ 4 %'70
)
4 4
$ 4
) + %*'
: +''L$ $ 4) ) 4
4
),* 4 %'70 2
) H+)I .,!'87*'7'*
) )
L
H+)I .,!'87*'7'* :::::
# %+ ! 0 ) +@ 9> , & ! '. ! "
+@ & E( '! * ( ! +" ! +@ !& ! - $ +) ! 2" +@ %'2 > +" 2 + (2 /+" 0 $ +@ !$ =
)
M 2 < = & M 2 F +>K2 H+)I -13-
.,!'87*'7'* @3+ @3. @3(! @3 $ @3+"N 0 C * - 5 ( +
%
5 (
#
C %
% %
# % 5 %# (
(
8 % (
%
5# >
5
)*' "
"
B
5 (# + ,-5# (
<
%
<
%#
(,-5# ( %#
% "
5
)*' "
" ( >
2
#
-
5 +
,-##
# < 8
##
%
%#<
%
# +
(
<
* A(#
% "
34' -%'56 '# 6 3& 7&*- !"
33 # &663!456% &- $3 38 '# '! 6 3. -
0.5# # 5 5
)*'"
"
/) (
1
%- ( ) " HI
)
)4 4 ) -14-
)
4
>
4
" ) 4 4 ) ) 4
4 4
4 4 )) : 4 -8' 6
A+ C *
: ' 7&* 6 - !"
4;
! 6 3& ,%2 , < -
/. A(#
% "
& 6* 604).(
1
*8
4) : 4 -8' 6 A+
@
)
)
) )
4 ) )
6
4
@ ) $
)
) )
6
4 ) 4
*B> 6A+ @
) 4
4 4
6 4)4 :
A 4
) )
3
@
4 4
) *71 -B82 *7-30
4
-15-
-7 .
> A+ @
4
4
) 3
4
@
: "
) 2 4 4 4
3
) @ 4
C 0*
# # #
(
%
(%
5 5 5
+
& /
+
#( #
& '
( % # 5 %
(
, !
% / 6'
## # ; ''
.. #!
!
5# %# 5
1 # % %
= ##
# ( ! 5 ./!
../ % #
(
% 1 ?
; $# 5# ( %
# (# #
( !
C
5 ##
1
%
#
#
8
#
-16-
1*
#
"
5 # %
5 > %# 5
! #
%
(
)* $
5
#
#
# "
##
%
> #
#
# % %
#
$ # ##
!
& /
#5 %(
#
#"
#
"%#
(
(6/ ./ '.') * 5
# (
% ( (
>
%
(
#
#"
%
8
(
)*'"
"
# * # ## # )** - -
- '. / .
- & / .
-17-