Chanchal And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others




   
 




  



!

"# !$%

&'

  

 !"#$%&'(# $#& !

) $

(

) * $  +',# &

) *"- - +***+ !$%* ) *.-, /!0 +',# &' *12*  $#& !

) $$
*+   &    %  #'  !'  "  451   & 67# 8! 7# *9:''99*9*1:19!' " 2;4+ 2;4 +  2;4 +  24
  7  '    "+ /  &!

+   ' ' !% 8!& '7

7 # 0%

#0& <=!



1>*

8! ? 7 7  '%60&

&' *1  '    , 7  00'   *  ?, +  ?    ,# &% +#6&

,' 0'

6 ,'  '

&!+? && # 00& * %

# 0+&

,-7 &? #  %6& 67!# & '7 ?!'% #!= '%!

#&

#!

'!

+  8! ' !% 8!& '7

7 # 0 06 % 8! ' #$!

*

  ,' '

''14*2*1:19'

'&  &&  %#        !

@
8  )7   #  '7  

0 +    ''  %#     !

+  '       !

@
8 )7 ?  '

' ' & *
&!

! 0+ ')
+' 

& ''9:*;*1:19 *A &   ='

 7 0 # &'*1 $B $+ &' *20 0'$ 0#&

+"+) 7? 0#"
"0  ''2:*4*1:19* %

# 0 + ')
+'  !'' &  &&

& , '0& ,! 6'

   !

'&  * . '"!  !%0 #& ?

, ' '

0' ##' *
, ' '! # & +& !

'  '

' &  %6 ')
+' % & !

# ! 6& , #451 **?!'

?7!

060- ! '

+ 06%

6 7,##6 ' !'  ' & ,%!

#&

#6!

  ?

 !

'

#$!

*"21:

8!6 ,#  ' +?& % & '!

#

0&!'7### !' 
' '* /&7,?!

### 7'600'

'#%& ,0%6 ' '

&!+ !# 0&  !?!'%#!= *C% "!& 0!

!0% # !'7
 





   



 

B.S.Joshi and others , State of Haryana ,-*


&./*0.*

#?'%6  ! #2.+3,*&4-, -*5&6.78,-*9

1


,' ?& & ,,'&  ' '?*  # +C%"!& 0!

Gian Singh :State of Punjab and another
  &./*0.*

#!

 ' ?

!'  ? '%6"!& 0!

# 8! 7 # State of Haryana :Bhajan Lal9 ;;&.//
&

D9#$!'70 '

!' (







 

  









 




 

 
  

  
  

 !

  


"





#







   


 


  
 
 
   




$


%&'




 

 








 (







 "



 




 


 


 )*
+ ,


 
#

-

+

,


 



 


(

 


 
 
   
  

   
 !
(

"

 









 


 
    





 

 

 



  (


  
 -
 
"





-

 








 
 

(


 
  



  


 

(



.
-
 -


(-
 


 

 (
 

 







/


(










 
$




   

 




   

( $ 

 (-
(
   


 






 









.
0








1 


 


(








 .




 

(-
 *


 
 
( 

 
  
  
   




 
2 
  

 
   (
 3  

 (


  




 



 





  -


  (




  
  -
  -


-


-
   



.
 

 





 
   ( 


(-
 




(





 





(
  



 
 




 


 





 



  (

 -
 


(
 
  
   


 -  


   


 





-




(

 







 .
 






  
 
  
 
 

 



# 

"


#


  
  

 
(


  

  
 






  



   












  -

 




 


 

  
  

  (

 


#



 





   
  

 






  

  
  
  
 

 


 





   


 





   

 


 
#

-

   

  
 






  

 


+ ,



 

-

 

 






 

#




 

  

  4  &&67    ?  '  %6  C%  "!& 0  !

   & #$!'70 ' 7!

+ && ?

&  ,   '      0& +    !  #   & '7 ?!'%0 6%!

#&

#!

'%6 ?7'&7& 6 #&

%68! 7

?!'% !

7'

#$!

+? & 0 6%$# 7 !

7!' "451  !+ #'

 ' 8! 6#

?0%'& 0

'%6$!'& ' '+

*9:''99*9*1:19!' " 2;4+2;4 +2;4 +24

7  '      "+  /  &!

+     '  '    

!% 8!& '7

7 # 0 8! '8!&

%

#0& *

'

 6&  0 %!'%6 '' #0& ' 0

 ''%# !

%?*

 '

?'* 
 $#& !

) $    $%<#

  !-6 A &-7@  '(  @ A & %(  @