Ajay Pal Singh v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And Others



  



  !


"

 !




!#$% &'

(%)*&  ++ ,#- #.

/01 ++++++ %$$&%2 3%2*4* 4,#5 /$#$% &6%2 &27&2#$& 8$(+ #( &$1%2*

++++++
%*7&(%$*


 9 8

+

/
:  


 









 : ;

+

< 2#.=










 
  











   

  !

"#  #$

  # %  % 
#$%
&

&

&
# '!(%
)

*
+ 



 ,- ,../
!"


0%
&12

 
&&





 #1  



 

 

34($
2



1  
&
)


*
+  




 
  

5 (,67-(4#
&
&
2  





8#

#5  9 2
!8 59%


 


 

!,%
)



&
 1
 :2




; 
 (0 .$ (366
<



2
 

 #


 #1 
 







 2

,-

(33. 
(%
=
 


2

 &

 #1 
 

  

3
2


& 
(( (33.

&
12

,
 #1 
 
 

 

($
2


& 
(/ > 
(33-
=
 




& 
 




; 

 
,6 ,..(
&




 
 ? 
 @ 


 
& 
-.

.3 ,..,




   

-% =


 
12




 # 



 

 
&
 
&

1





 
 
8 59



5 (,67-(4#
& 12
 
& 
2
?&
 
@
  2



 


"

 

 

; 


,6 8 1 ,..(   1  14

&

 #1  






  
34($
2


2

!7%
)





 # 




 
 
&



 


12
&2

A
B (6(,$
 ,../
&
&


&



 







 1
=
 



  
 
,-
8 1
,../
!"


0%

1 

2



 
  

 

(0
> 2
,..3
!"

 $%




&


!0%
=




 



  



!$%
)
2
+ 








&






  




; 

,6
8 1 ,..(
 
2
+ 

&

 # 1 
 

&
&


 


2


,- .7 (33.C !6%
=


 2




 



 

,$
> 2
(33.


5-4(%
 
12

D


 


'




  4
 
E
)
  



 


&# 



  
     

   
    
 




 

    !"#$ %%& '   '    %"#$ %%  

 
 () *+  * 
        (*#"$ %% 
  *) *,  *&  
 

  
    
   
  
  
  
 
 
 

 
  
 

&

   -

-

-

  
() *+  * .




   



- 
 
 

 
  $ &$*

.#2')#$& """""""""""""











"""""""""""""

/ 0 - 


1 
  & '( #! )# *#+#   (#'# # )

#     *# (#'# #

 #

#'(  # #*

,%- !  .

""""""""""""""

""""""""""""""

!/%
)




 1



 



 



 2


? @
 
 





 


 
 2





 
2 

 

34($
2



B $

! 
1%


 1
 

1 2 


 2
&

@
2 

,- .7

(33.
&12
 #1  

&


1


  2
&

 

3

($
2
 
&

& 
2
 
A
  2

 



24  4
12


1


1

 1 2
& 

1



 #1  
 2

1
 2 
1


 
1 
 

 
 

3

($
2


2
 
 


&
*2


 
 
  

!3%
=





(

,
 #1  

&




 ((

(33.

(/ .$ (33-
2
)
 









 

 

; 
1
(/
> 
(33-









 

 

&

,6
8 1
,..(
2
& 



2
1
 





& 
 

&

&




& 



!(.% )
2
 

,$ .6 (33.
!"

 5-4(%
&






 
1  + 


 


($
2
 
& 
*
&2


1


  2

 

3
2@
 
 

 



 
1 
&


 #1 
 
2
 
 

34($
2



 1+  

 
 







 


*
&2

 
1 
  
&
&
2



1
 
 2



!((%
)
  






1  *
&

1




  
 
)
&&


 
2 

#

+ 
   


@



 
F 2




&  




2





 


1



 





 


&
  

!(,%
;
 



& 


 
@



  

 2
 #1




 
 2


=

 




'  

 
 

E

 2
&







2 ,..,
5







<@1

 


 '

/ 0 #   1 

# #* /

2 %3 

 !(-% =
&



2



 
1
D2


&&
  
2

& 
2




<

"
 



  &
12



 
)
 12





*




 
12




 
& 
)

 

*

 
&



 2

   



 


@
2 
&
 12




   





)2

 2
 

2








 

  
*

&


,- 8 1
,../

2



  

(0 .( ,..3
!"


$%
=  





&

 D1 2
,..3



!(7% =





?@

 #1  
2

1



2
 

&





 

 


=







 



D2


 2
 

+ 



 ,- ,../
!"


0%
&12


 



2


1
  & 2


 

&

 
 


'


&

   

2
1


&
& )2



 
 


    


9 2



*
 
1

& 



 

 
2#

&


 

 

34($
2


) 

&
 
&
"

 
 
,,$


 


1 
12
  




1&
 
 
 



2
 



!(0%
;
 






 &





&


 
+ 

2
2
=
2

& 
1

2
1

2# 



 
12



!($%
)



2
&




, 
$


&



&
2

  #1 


 

34($
2


=






*
12
 





 

  



&
2

  #1 
 
2




2 
 





+ 
 2

&

&
 


 2





!(6%
D


#

&


&G 
  


(( ,..,
!"


,%





 1+ 
*


,- ,../ 
0%

12
+ 
)

 



 #1 
 
2 



& 
(( (33.
H
(/ .$ (33- 2

 

34($
2


 1
 

  

5 (,67-(4#
  

8 59



)

  


#"




 



2
)

 1


 
  

&




  
2#




& 
I
3J



=


 

1




5 (....4#
&
 

1

12



 !%4!%
&


1

 
&&


 
2


 
)
 

1

&


 









2 



!(/% K
2

!(3%
!#*$+> -

)


& 

1

12

  


12
&


 
 



&


1

  


2






<: =

!  ++











Dinesh A
*4
 L A
51

B