M/S Godrej And Boyce Manufacturing Company Limited v. Union Of India And Others

 



   
 
     !"##$%&%'()  



   





 



  





!


 ()  *+  ,
,,
  *+  ,
++
 
 
"  #$%&    '()*+,+$ )-+./$)*+.0$))**,(-*/0 '()+1$,1/$.+)+$/*+/1$/-+1)$/,-)/(-*/+

2

#$%& 
! 3 2#$%&     '(/*4,$//04$/-)+$/-++$/1+.(-*/+ '(+.4$)-.1$1+0,$.**0$0,*.$,.0+$,40-$1)+,(-*/+ '(1)+4$14*)$4*.*$/*-1-$++/0$/,.-+(-*/+

2  #$2  %&  3 
% $%&   

'5
-+1).-*/0

'5
/4.4.$/4*-$.+00$.++1$4.1-$44+0$0/--$0/,-$ 0/04$-1-0)-41---*/+
 
2

  $%&  


2 $%&

   '(,0,-$1+44$1+0)$./-,(-*/+

%#6#$%&    '(/+4.(-*/+

2  7 8&$%&    '5
0)1/-*/+

%  2 $%&


! $%&     '5
/+1/.$-40+/$/1-.+$-0,*0$-0,.+$-44,*$-4+/4$ -400,$-4+*)$-4001$-4+/+$-0*01$-4+.*$-0/.1$-4,1*$ -4,-.$,.,0$+/4)$-/41/$-/+*- /-).1-*/+

&

2 $%& 
% #$%&    9:

9'5
,114-*/+:


  
! &2  $%& ;  
56 #2  $%&    9:

'5
114,$.-*/$0+..$/++.1$.),/$.1+*-*/+

%7 $%&  
! $%&

   '(/*+04$+.-4$/*4)1(-*/+

"
2
 $%&

   '(/1-0.$/1140$/1..1(-*/+

 #; 2 $%&

   '(-+1).(-*/0$/4*-(-*/+

  "; 2 $%&  
5  6$%&    '(01+,(-*/+

!67 $%&

   '(/.-*.(-*/+

!6  23$%&    '5
-,0*+ -1)*)-*/+

<= $%&    '5
,114-*/+

2  62 6  $%& ;  
% 

!$%&


% 2  $%&     '5
-0-*)-*/+

 $%&  
 #  !$%&    9: '5
)+4/, ,*/,-*/+

%6 #7  $%&     '5
++0/-*/+

%  2
< ##$%& 
! 6 #$%&  '5
-0,*0-*/0 
2#>#; $< %&   #$ ? 

6 $%#%&   #$ 3

2 3  #$2  2 #; 
2

&7  #$%&

  5
/)'()-+./$))**,(-*/0$ '(14*)$/1..1$.-*/$.),/$4*.*$.1+*$.+)+$/-+1)(-*/+$ '(.**0$,,/0$/.-*.$,1,,$1)+4$1)+,$,40-$,.0+(-*/+ '(/*-1-$)-.1$01+,$/*+/1$0,*.$)--)/$+)--(-*/+ '(/,.-+$/1-0.$/1140$/4.-/$/4.++$/++.1$-/*)0$ -41//$-1-0)$1,0,$-*./1(-*/+-

   
/)'5
/4.4.-*/+   
/,'5
-/41/ -/+*--*/+$   
/)'5
-/++-$-,,0)-,,1/ -*/+-   
/)'5
-+01--*/+

2  # $2  2 # 3 
5"$%& 

'(+44$ 1+0)$)+4/$,*/,$,.,0$,0,-$114,$0)1/$./-,$.+00$.++1$ 4.1-$44+0$0/--$0/,-$0/04$+/4)$0+..$/*4)1$/*+/1$ /*+04$/-).1$/-+1)$+.-4$++/0$/1-.+$/.*/4$/+1/.$ -4001$-0*01$-0,.+$-4+*)$-4+/+$,114$-/41/$-/+*-$ -,0*+$-4,-.$-4,1*$-4+/4$-4+.*$-400,$-0/.1$-44,*$ -40+/$-1)*) -0-*)-*/+



#$%&  
%#$%&

  5
-)'()*+.0 )*+,+(-*/0

>

 " $%&  '5
)+1$,1/$,,/0$114,$.-*/$.),/ .1+*-*/+
@@@ ,,
. A  #   $

   &    /



 0# 1#2"#$3'45%#& 6"+"1 
 '%'
'1%! 2&

,,
    ++
    6#78#2 . 


 

 ! "

#! $ %& #!