Chatar Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others





   
   

 !"# $%&%!'()*)*
 



 !"

 #"

 (  +, ) -
)-)

. & '$ %&'

#()"&* # ' &+ ,())'( ! -+%()"&*  #".  //// )-)/) 0 # "* 1 

 2,"2!

#3
 45 """66 7 #

"2!,")"",

 8 "(,9,&"9* ##,* "*6

," 2!*:#,

::  : 9  9  4:     "", **

" 2%*" +,! "(* * ;<5  9

,""2!*:#,
  2( " &,,"4,(9 :#,* "   4"2  =! 9 :"9  4:

 ( "# + (>,6   ?!"

&"9!*,  #*#*!(9&(49 

"

":,"2!

2" ":,9: 9

:,!4"&"9! # 

? 4

"2&2 , ?, 7: # *"(4"2 "#,

?

 7( 

2"4" :#  *: #,

442*4?*:#,9

#     :?    4  9    "!          ::,:? 9:4" "

,4, ",!9?*: :2   :  ?9*:#," 2> %9 :(!2 &"49 ,!2""9

&:?      2   4"(    ,"    "

       "



::

2"":,9(  *

:"

*,# 2, ? 9 :&",*, #,:9  9 ""%  #,(>,? 9 4( 9&(4@#" #, )         :,  ;<(    :  9

& " **

"9  " *  *:#, & ":, (9 *,,")#  *,,  "*:::#*" (* 9

",")"",

 8 "(,9,(9:"

:,*  ", :#*""("

 * 9* :*:#,
9 *"" 0(##,* "*6

9 ,"2!

 *:#,

::: 99 4:  "",**

"0##,*9 "

"2!,
  &"","""#&#"  "$
 

    

               

             

   



    

      

 

    

            !"#  $   

     



  

 

  

  

    

 $ 

            

   

 



     

  

       

       %

                 

     

 $   &  ' $ () $ %    *+"&,"-  .
/&,$ -          

   

  )
"0  

 

            1                 1       

  

   

       

    



    1     )
"0  

 2  '

3  () $  ' *++4,
-

   , - "&"         

 

 

     

 

  

          

  

  

         

 



 

   

    

 

      

       5  6 % () $ %    *+++,
-  , - 502      '

7 1

                           

   3       

       

      

    

 

  

    $  
"0  

   

      

    

      4 8   

 

)
+&#9   ""
#9   :



 "/4*  

        

 

%  

   

 

        !"

 $          )

 ,:1 "-    



  

  3            

 ;3       5)4           $

  



  

 

          

 *+    

 $       

=    

 

     

              5)4  

          

  

   

 

     

 $     

                       

  

     ;,&"(*:#, ,"#  #(  *    9*  9  &     #" (  9  #    ##* *  , <&","*  ,# 2 "   *" A"  *  ,      #    *""   : 9(:,9"* " #**,,!:" ;<" #**, 22 "(2 ,*,#,* ",#**

"#!""*,,?*:#,
    9,  ##    B    **,,!  "# "

"* ,#2,!: 9?,
 ,, "

    ##,*  "  *  6 

  "  

::: 9 "",**

"   "

#: ,""9,":4 !


    

  !"& 24#&92!,
 9,"

##,* " 92 "2!  ":# """

: 92""2

::" "",**

" *,,9  

7

"(,"*  , #". 3 : 9 &:,!""":# ""

2:  #*,!,,"&,""" 

:!:!?

      :    *    #      :2,     *:#,  "  :"!    ,    &   #      :# ""(9* """"& ,!(#

"  *  1 

  * 

&&  < 

##       *( " !#      

$%%   ""

  !&"(9 9 2 &"* ",8 "



:: #  "",**

"(&"#! :"!, &  "*6C 

"# "* 1


      :2,  * 9        #**  :"!

#&"" 2!9!,##,& (#9

"* 1 

*=

*"  ," 2 "A"*  , *"":# "

" ""66 7(9** ,"2*,,"96"!

2!

9!,& #<9  ""# " * 1 

9 ,"= (9* *,,!:# 9, ,:2!*,&#*" )&,* "   "2!,"*  ,# (<" 4#&9* "** :

* * (,
  9 %

""

##,* "*6

<

9* # * "* "9  " #,

7: #"0( *,!

 *  2

2%*"* ,!

:"

 :,9: 9  2 " ;

:( "* "4"*

:"# #,

" ::,:"&!:#*2*"  : 99 #  #94"*

:"

#  9 *,,"2!#,* "

,,"9 9 #:" "

*

:"#  * ,"2," #2  : : 9(99 9 #:94"

*

:"# <


'* 

#()#@
 

2 &" 

::#  "",**

"

9* :#:**  @* ": :*2    *@&"*    2 "  9 ,"  ,"      *&*   0  , 
  @*  

2%*&   *  *:      **,

   :9(9"*& 9"* ", 7 : * ,"2 "&#:**::"* "9!"  * ,"2",9**

" (

* ##,*"2"

" <""!,,,!:!

*"(9* :  &  *,,"    *  2!   
   9,  @*  %  "* "* 1 

 0(# "

"

"  )-)

)*)*    .%0 12 2 ..

&!' #3&4 5%'6 (  &3!

1 12 2 .. 4!.

(  &3!