Narayan Alias Nitin And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another
!" #$%$ &'()(
(((((((((
$ $ & *% STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER (((( %+ &" & % ' ,- ( ./ .( 0
! " #$%&' (&
) " ) " #$%&' (&"* &
%+," -" #$$!
.
/
)"
0.&!#$%&' (&*&$& "&-2" $&,&('
23 44444 / .( 0(( * )2 **!
' & !!&5$ * /$(& $6-78 $ 7 +&'&$
" * & " % **& '"$ "
,&- + 2 9- "
2&(:
& ;$ $< <= <2 $-$' &8># 8=# # 8 $ <? &( , &!
' & @ !! A"2 " $ # ': $ A $ $ !!-A9-*&'$ 2 2"(& &
77 " A &( '& *& $ $ ;
< < 16- 73 (('$ A5"* B $'&-!(&"* &'&$" (& $ :
5 -!&(& 7-$ $ 2 2&-&( & ! $ *- &5%#5 "" % &&("*' A!(& A&"" $# " " A !$ $ ' A!/ &!%$ (-" -A $ " " '& *& &2 " * 5 (('$ & ''&-&((5 !! $5 "&- /*- $'&'
& -- & " &$ $ $ <> < <# *& " A ' %$(& ", % !C-$21C- & % &37'- 7C-$ '
! :
,! # : $ A $ % $ & & 8 $ $ 8 < < " !% 6 '&("*& $"-7
! " # $%# " &'
% %
%
(
)*
(("(+$ % )
"( $ % )
(
)
( )
',
%
*
( - ) -% '' .)) "-
( /01 ("( " 2*
*) 34(45(3431 (
77 % - ) -% ' .)) "-
( /01
( "" 2* %
(
%
"
(
"
( !$% ( 1% 3 - ) -% ' .)) "-
( /01
("( " 2* % *
. '
'' ) ( 1%
3 ) -% ' .))("-
(/01
("( " 2* ' ' " # $% # " ( 2-+56170(48(3437
("("
*' 2*
'' (2-+
(/69343: ("("
*' 2*2-+
(:6893437 "("
*'
''
( 2-+
(7593478 ("(" ; '
' ' ( 2-+
(/69343: ("("
*' 2* 2-+
(:6893437 ("("
*' 2-+
(7:59343:
("("
*' 2* 2-+
(30193435 ("( "
*' 2* 2-+
( 31593433 ("( "
*' 2* 2-+
( 74:9343: ("( "
*' 2*2-+
(37393435 ("( 2*
' '
! ( 2-+
(:6838(77(3437 " 781 535 146 5: -
787
'' &'
( 1%
3
(
%
"
(
"
( ! $%
* < '
'
*) = >* =' ( 63 ) %
*'%* %
) *
! ( " # $%# " &'
-% ''
))% %
) (
%
( *- !&(" (& $*&"&5" '& *& " A(('$%&!- !/A5"* $ 2- $5 "&- '&'
&& /-$-*- &&%#" 5&&"% ' !/ )& ! $ B DD % #"&-2"& $ * " * * &# )& ! ( !$ * :
& ? $ $ ;
<= <-$ ' & E <? &( " $ ! ,&$# ;?< 2 $ &!
' &@ !! A"2 " $ # ': $ A $ * & &" " (& $:
5 9- "$A/"
,&- % $&$$ $8 < <* $ , 7<?=7<&"A &('& *& (('$A5"* " &;
< < ,&-! ** 2 & A" !( &( " * & "
77 ' 2& ' !!/ $ " 5 " *' & '& *& 9- B DD % #"" $&( !$ /:
2 $ 2" '
$ $" 5 2 $A/"** & $ -'"" !,&-" $$ A/ & 2" *& ?
B $ '&-!$&&$ *-" ( '- &(" '& *& &2"* $$&&" % / &-&AD' & &"&!- &&("$ *- &2"* >
)"
0 .&!# $%&' # ** & A" !( &( *&$& $ "! $"
'&'-'& ":
$ !!"&"'&9- !*&'$ 2A 29- "$ ;
":-!!@'"&("
,&- " &(
*&$
!
""
#
$ % " A&A%$ -$ >30 ) * % * ) '
*
* * ?
" :03 ) ( ( (
* *
" ) (( % * )
) ) ( 38-& '
(
'
& '
) '* = >* - &(
)
)
' @ ) ) %
7?7
)
' * % ))
) ( 54
%
)%
( - * *
% ' ?
) *) ? )
)
% ' A
)
% ) ( 57
*'
* )" 5348 ) ( ( (
" :03 ) ( ( ( 53
< )
*% (-
) )
" :03 ) ( ( (
) ) ) ( $
% '
,
) * * *? '
" :03 ) ( ( ( % )
*
( % * ' * ? )
* )
) % ) ' ) ' ( 55 %* )
* %
7>7
* ( ( ( ))
)
" :03(2 *
< '
% ,
* )) ' * " 534 ) ( ( ( % * ) ) ( 5:
" :03 ) ( ( ( *? B?,$*& %*
)
) ( * ? % ) , * =' % A ?
( -
)
) (
" :03 ) ( ( ( (= % ='
?
'
( ? )
*
( % ?, ))%
(
)
%'
%, ' '
(+
)
* )
* ' '
)
)
% '%)
))
* )
)
%'( =
"!2 !* '
*! !
$$&5(&9- "
2&(":
5 !& **&%$A/"&FA!-* ,&- " &(+,
7;7
-
* $
$
! !+' !! (-"#"A& $* '
*!(&6'
2"*&5-$' &8; 5 - 0$ A/ " &FA! -* ,&- " &( + .
/ 0# #
, $
23$+' <
% $" % 5&(" ' A!&!- &&("
- &2 " * # & -(-! *-*& 5&-!$ A %$ A/ '& - &&("*&'$ 2 "(-" '&("*&'$ 2 !
+!/&A 5 &(D-$ '
! $" ** &A&'" '&( '&% ' & @ $# !/ A' - " &" :
2 " * &# "&-!$& ' A 2 ' A!&!- &&(" $ *-
" &FA! -* ,&- " "!$ " &( 4"# 5 . .
-
& *
$
)
6!3+*" " 5"
'"' A' 2& 0$ *& ! - & " 5"
'" " - &( D- $& & 6"
!$* % /&'& &&( &(('&(-'" &- - " 9- "
2 &( 5"
'" 5&-!$ &% $ *-A!
' # " ,&- ' 9- "":
% 5&("! %$ &2"*
"&A% &&("&FA!-* ,&- 6 '$ -$7 78( C ,
" 534 ( ( ( < ' *
*
) )) >
* >
) A ?,
7=7
=' " :03 ( ( ( % 7:3 ) * % A * * ) " 534 ( ( (
)
' * ? )
? ) < ' '
*' @ )) ) )) )
D "
) ) D
)
* % D F % )
) )
)) 9
% (
"(&!!&5 2!% ( '& 2(& *- !&(" ' 5!! "-A9-$%!&* -**! 2 ' (&
%&' & &( " *&5 -$ ' & ; &( " @" / 2 + - +" "
#< 7
3
" * ' # " :
5 -! &( & 7 -$ $ 2 2&-&( & !$ *-
3
" * & & # # # ? " 5 $ '& -$ ' ' &&("* & !
+!/&' - %*'- &&"* & $ '" 2&(" &'
!&A!
2 & 5!! " 5&+*! ' iii)
"&((' 9- &' &A $&A" &-& &(('" 5&-!$A"&'+ 2&"'&'
'&("
7<7 &'
/&*-A!
' ! 2 ' !&&A $ & "&'+ 2&"'&'
'&(",&-G iv) ,& - &&("*&'$ 2 $(&'
2"* & -$2& 2&-&('
!*&'$ 2 &!
+!/&-A7 % /! 2*-A!
' G v)
" *&'$ 2 !
+!/ & $ (- !
/ (& 5 &( * &-**&"' &("*&'- &G % 3 &! 2*-A!
'*-*&5&-!$A%$A/'& - & &("*&'$ 2G vii)
" '& *!
& !
+!/ & -**& " ' &( " *&'- & ,& - &&("*&'$ 2 !
+!/&A 5 &(D-$ '
! "&AD'&(! 5 5!!%$ 5"" * &!% " $ ((' $ '"&& & * '(-!!/'&76 $!
% " &/
% 5&("*&&("C-$ '
! #,! # : $ A $ $"* '
*!!
$$&5A/"*6,&- ,
-'
$
$
! !* 5!! "# 5 . .
-
&
$
)
6!3 $ !&A/":-!!@'"&("
,&-
-'
*
!
""
#
$ % * " * & !!&5$ " (& $ :
& ; $ $ < <= <2 $-$' &8>#8=##8 $<?&( , &!
' & @ !! A"2 " $ # ' : $ A $ $ !! &"
77 '&9- !*&'$ 2 2"(& "A/9- "$9- " * & % 5 &( '& *& $ $ ;
< < 16- 73 &5%#" 5&-!$A-AD'&* / &('&&("'$%* 78 & A $*& $ A/ " * & 5 " "
9
" 5 :* .;; <'
!126$$ 3 %* =:
8 0=< $ 2 !*
0( =* <
;
;*
; $ * * 5 "
* &$ &( 5& &" (& ' * &( ' ( $'&*/&("
&$ & !!&5$ / .( 0 . 3 E " H""* + 2I &$ ' I& H"" *& A! I&