High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1463/2024disposed of

Kuldeep Jain And Another v. Shashi

2025-08-08Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja11 pages

!"# !$ %&'

(( !$ %&'

& )*& + ,+&

" #

$ !

& '

()

* !

" +++++ ,+& $ -./'

, !

& "

' $

& !

- !

! "

! $

& . "

/0 '

0 " ! & $

112 $0 0 .

'$0

)

" & " $

" 0 "

(

& $

(

3 / "0

0 & " " (456712 8

. '

0 '

$0 $

$ " & 9 411 : '

!0 ; '

! $0 ! )$

( '" 114114 31<11 & 315114 = 11117) ! & &

" " 111 3116 $ ; "

! 0 " 0 #(

$ 5 0 /! %

$ $ $0 (

(

3 :

' ' ' "

$ " " (

>! " & 315114 $

& " " 11117) $0

0 ? 0

" ( '

" " ( & @1511<

" @1117) ' ! '

& $

! 51117) .

! 0 "

3 . '

(

! "

3 . '

@1117) 0 : '

" '

; $0

0 "

!! " 0 $

3 :

' "

$ " " (

>! " & 315114 = 11117) '

0 " '

@1117) ' ! & $

! 51117) $ 0 "

3 .

! ! 0 '

" !

$ @1117) &

()

" '

$ '

; "

! 0 " "

0 33

' ' $ " "

' "

! "

? !

1<11 & )

0 & " $

" '

!! " $

& " $0 (

( : 0 $ ! & ? !

0 ""! " ; '

11117) '

& "

& $0 @ && " !

1<11 $0 ? ' ' "A ))1 "

! "

& & " $

& $ ))1 "

! "

& "

& ! $0

? $ ! " !

; ! & & " $

" 0

! !

/ ' !

$0 0

. !

112 ))1 "

! "

' ))1

' $0

& " $

" "

& $

" (

(

& ! $0 0 "'

& ' !

$ "

! " ) # % ?)263)12

& " !

112

))1 #$% ?)44)12

& " !

112

))1 < :&

& & $0 0

! $

& !

$ "

$ ! $

& " '

B ! & $

& '

" '

" ! 9 "

& "

! " $ '

0 .

" ! C

& ! #D> )E% ' ! '

! " $

& " '

< B !

& "

$0 (

$0 ? '

!! $0

0 .

" $ !

& '

: $

& " " )

0 #9)% ' "

& '

! < & & "

! 0 ! "

0 $

& " ! 3#3% # % " C 0

#? F D % ! 4<3 !" #" $%&'( '

! B ! $ ! 3#3% " 4<3 ! ; $

" '

!!0

0 $

! !

0 ! $

& '

" ! ! " 424

! 0

& ' ! ! 0 !

$ "

@#::% " '

#! !

$ !

#! % &&

'' ' & (( ) !

*" %

'' #

"# &

+, <3 B ! " $ !

! $ ! !

& '

' '

0 '

9) .

B !

' !

""!

0 '

& '

! '

!)>

' '

" C B

$ $ !. " B ! & $

! &

!! " $

0 ;

;

$ ! "

" ! '

; $ ; !

G $ "

$ ! " $ & & 112 $0 0 $ 5

! " $ $

& " '

0 "

$ ! C $

315114 ' ! '

! D> ) '

( '

' ' "

$ " "

! 0

!0 "

()'

& $0 "

; '

( ' & $

- " ( & #D>))%

& '

5 B ! $

$ !0 ! C $ " ! " @#::% "

' !) >

" 9)) 0 ;

! 3 #3% # % " 4<3 ! $ 0 ! 0

0 '

0 !!

0 $ "

& $

$0 0 C $ )

! " "

0 '

$ . !

! $

0 ! " " 9) !

#9)@%

" ! '

" '

& 112 $0 0 4 : ! "

& & $. 1 ! & " $

& " $0 (

" ? $ " !

' " !

& $0

' ' "

" 1<131< "

! ' " (

> ! ) ! .+ $ " & # )/ ' 1 + ! .+

2 & + 4 " ## ##

5!#

! .+ % + 4 ! .+ "

! ##!

' !

# & 6 ' !

! .++ ! .+ " %& & ! .+ " # '+, 1 ! "

! " $

0 " 6 ', $0 (

! " ( $

& '

" 0

! $

& " $0 (

( '

! 0 $

0 :

' " !

$ "

! $0 0

" $

& " $0 (

(

& " $

! 0 $

0 ; A $ $ " " ""!

& " ! 3#3% " 4<3 ! ' !

0 :

! " !

& " $0

@#::% " A @#::% "

!)>

$ ! '

0 $ "

& " $

$0 0

" @#::% "

(

" ' "

$0 ( ! ) )*!++("' , ' 3 !

& #

" &!

+ % + 7 #! ' !

#!8

. 9 2

& !

' !

'# !+ 7 :+ '

+ % #

& #$#!+ !!

+ 9 ! ' & #' &

'# !

" "#

$ & & :+ '

< '

#! !

$ !

#! % &&

'' ' & (( ) !

*" %

'' #

"# &

+, )*!++("' -' , + & % ' % !

&&'!+ " ;

! & # + 1

% *" = 1 # ) & /

##!

# $ $ !

'' ' &

+, :

' !

@#::% "

' . "

!)>

& " ' ! ' >

& $

' $

& $0

0 " .

' 0

& ! :

' " "

0 $ "

&) " $

$0 0

!! "

0 ! D; 0

' )'

0 !

$ > ! " '

$ !. " ' ! "

! 0 0 ' ! !

$ !. " $

& '

& &'

0 " & - ! " $

0 &&

0 '

9) ""! '

7!!

0 ! $

& '

" ! ! " 424 !

" . !

0 " "

"0 $ ! ; "

! 3 #3% 4<3 ! '

0 3 & '

" !!

" B

C $0 "

0 "

$ .

0 '

!)>

0 '

) ' / 0

C "

" "

0 "

; ' ! 0 " " " " $)

) ' " ' .

"" ! !

" 0 >

!)>

0 ' '

& 0 " "

; ; " $

" 0

(

' '

0 &&

9) ""! (

$ 0

0 .

" $

0 ( '

!)>

" "

& " " )

0 '

0 ' ! " & !

" $

" 2

$ !

' ""!

! "

" 0

& & ! 3 #3% # % " 4<3 ! '

$0 .

& &

& (

& '

$0 $"

$ $

& "0 " ! !

! '

& !

! ' !!0

0 ! $

& '

" ! ! " !

! ! ! ! '

" '

;

& " ' $ !

$ ? "

'$0 "

& ! $0 0 3 $

" 15151@ $ ,+& '

9 .

&7 E7( 9 $ E7 (