Punsup & ORS v. Laju Ram & ORS.

1-    

 

 





  !

 


!"#$ %& '$()*)%+ ,,

 -+."/

#"#$ )0)1

-221)$* %32%3"#)%+4 5"+')6"35 "+'

"+%#5$3

,,,

22$11"+#* 7$3*-* 8".-

"9 "+'

%#5$3*

,,, $*2%+'$+#* 



  -+."/

#"#$ )0)1

-221)$* %32%3"#)%+4 5"+')6"35 "+'

"+%#5$3

,,,

22$11"+#* 7$3*-*

-:5'$0

".

"+'

%#5$3*

,,, $*2%+'$+#* 
;

 -+."/

#"#$ )0)1

-221)$* %32%3"#)%+4 5"+')6"35 "+'

"+%#5$3

,,,

22$11"+#* 7$3*-*

.)#

".

"+'

%#5$3*

,,, $*2%+'$+#* 


 -+."/

#"#$ )0)1

-221)$* %32%3"#)%+4 5"+')6"35 "+'

"+%#5$3

,,,

22$11"+#* 7$3*-* -#"

"9 "+'

%#5$3*

,,, $*2%+'$+#* 


 -+."/

#"#$ )0)1

-221)$* %32%3"#)%+4 5"+')6"35 "+'

"+%#5$3

,,,

22$11"+#* 7$3*-*

<"3+

)+65 "+'

%#5$3*

,,, $*2%+'$+#*

2- 

 =8 



7


 

        

    

>>>>

7




        !"   



  "

      

  !   " # $ 

  "

              

    !    %  #  

  "

          

    !         #   

  #

             

 !  & " #  

 

  "

           

  

    !   '        #  $  % &'    

)  *     !" * %   +,-++.

/

0     !  1' ""  ' "    !$ !  1' !

.

       23' %     *"  
     ! %     1*'% $

 %    .  -   %$   % ""   4  ! 

3-  '"    &'%  "  %   % !'  '             %%'     ! ' 1 '     !$ %  %     1*'% $   

++,   3'  %

6   %   !$   "  '   "'        $ &'      &' $"     !$   "  % 7  !   "    '  %  !$ 3'"%  ++/  1'   ' 0 % '''       3 !$ 3'"%  ,. ++. '"   '     

1'     "'     1'  %     $ '   "'    '  !  !$    '   0 " '9" %    

 '!%   3'"%  ' !$    1'  ! '

-

4   '     :%     ! 

;

< %"     0 ='" >''    '  3'"%   1'  (    !   ) *  ""  &

      +,        (  - ' % '   !  1'  ) *"" & !  

4- 



 $./,0     3'"%  ! $ '  0 ?    ' "9.

It will thus be seen from a perusal of the aforementioned judgments that in none of them it has been laid down that besides passing a resolution deciding to file an appeal, the Municipal Committee must necessarily pass a separate resolution vesting authority in the Executive Officer to file the same. The ratio of all these judgments is that before filing an appeal a corporate body like the Municipal Committee must pass a resolution deciding to file the same. We have no quarrel with this proposition of law. 10.

For the reasons discussed above, we are unable to subscribe to the view taken by the Single Bench in Garib Chand's case (supra) and resultantly overrule the same. We hold that once the Municipal Committee decides to file an appeal by passing a resolution, its Executive Officer is empowered to file the same by virtue of Section 4 of the Act."

+

  3'      !  !$  )  1'  ! '  3'"%  !$    0 ='"  ! '   !$  

     !   %   %  %    0 ='" >''       "   2 0 ='" >'' %$ 3'  % %  "   $  1'  % 3'

"$      

"     $   

,.

(,(.



7

 8 Kamal

! < *"@ A@  < ! A@