R.G.Verma (Ph) v. Food Corporation Of India & ORS










 

  















!"
#$%$!&'
(())

((
*





+
  
+
 
 ,




'
- .

(
,
*
,(


(
////
 

 





 

 

!


"

 
 

#



for the respondents.
$$$$
*
,(


0
(
 .

)1



 %
" 


 ,
&


 




 

'()*)++,
 -%
%
"

"
 
#
  
#
# # 
"" 

  %
"

% .
-
%
 
-%


# %

-
 


"
# 
"
/
" 
0  


! 1

0  
1

"

 
"
" 
% 


 #
 
"
%
"
0  
1


2 

&#
 

-"
"








 

3
&  
"


4)'5)+(6

0  
1





#- 
  
0


 

#" #%
 


 


)7'6)++7
#

#15,
"

3
&  
"

8 ""9
#
)++)




# 

%

# 
# 
 "
)++41+7

"


-#
 %

#
 

#%


 



# 







 /
"
 
" 


 
 


#


 /

:%
 
2 
8:

29

 -%
#
 # %



&  

;# %




 

# 


;# %
<"" 
 

# 
2
+

3 
++ (



,
, 
((
*

0
 (
=# 

 
" 
*())++7

))4)++7
 
!

 
0 1))

 /

# 

3&
# 




 
 
 /
<

 
"
 


# 
8&9
3 =
# 

(4+7

=
3&
& 

 




!
 
1




 
:

2
& 
"


>=
3&
& 
#
 


=?8@&9

 /

 /




-%



 
"
 

8@&9

# 
1
9

 

&


8@&9
-9

 



8@&9

9

 


# 
8@&9
0
& 

-%
 


=
8@&9


3 =
# 

 
 
" 
*7
 /
"
 

4>75)++7





 


 
 
%
-%

 

5>65+7


=  
2-
3&
& 

 

!
 
0 1


 


& 
"#%

 

%
"

 
8 A
1)>7>)9
<
%
"

 
"
 

 
 


 
!
 
0 1

"
 
 
"#


 ,4(
, #5
!(
!"

6%

"4 #$!&%
4!5 &

6 8 ,7

$6
!

9
!(
)
)> >5
)(5'

4''
*)''

*7''
45'
)
)>&>5
(7+ *5'
*4''

*55'
4(5



  
?*5)9
*
)>>:8)>>:9 )(5'

*5'
*7''

*65'
4(5
4
=>>)
)(5'

45'
*(''

4'5'
45'
7
>5
(5'

75'
*6''

4'5'
4,'
5
>*
)(5'

4''
*6''

*+''
74'
6
 /"
)7++ 4''
*4''

*6''
7''
(
 /">*
)(5'

4''
*45'

*65'
45'
,
 /">4
(5'

4*5
*4(5 *(''
7''
+

B&> >(
)(54 4''
*4''

*6''
7''



- 
%
#
A 



-
 
"
*4C

 
"
- /

#

 
"
 /
?>*
A 



 
"
7C


"
 
&
"
 
 


 
  %



 
"
 

 

%
 
D  

 
# %
%
/

"

# 
" 
-" 
"%

"



 
!
 
0 
1
9


;#
-%

 

A-
1)>7

" 
  
 
#
-%

=
3&
& 

 

!
 
0 1


3 =
# 
"

 >%

%


"A
"
 
%E

 

 


 
-9

B 

A-
=>*
=
3&
& 

 # 

 - 
"

 

 

 

# 

%
-#
%

 
 

-
 
" 

 
 /

%




9
0 


 

#
  # %


"
- /
"
 
 
 

%
-%
 


# 
8@&9
8  /
?)> >5

>)9
=
3&
& 
8  /
? /">4

>59


%
-%

 
8 A-
17>49F

" 


- 
 

&#



;# %
<"" 


 
%
# 
"

 


 
 
-
  

  





  


 


-




-
  # 


 
 


-
 

#
 %


%
#
"

"" 
 
/
-%
"" 
& 


 
-%

;# %
<""  
D
"# 
#- 

-



%

#
# %


 
- 
? *)+& 1)4,5>+7

**'5)++5
 -%
# 
"
  
" 
 

-
 
#

 

  
 "

# %


 " 
-%


-" 

# %


 

)6'))++6

# %




 # 
"



"

 
"%

%
"
  
" 
 


 
  

"
 
#
  
#
# # 
"" 

  %
"

% .
-
%

46
;#
 
0
  
 
"

 

#
1
 

  

  



    

 

     

   

       

 

     

  

  

      









    

     

 



             

 



    


 





   

  

 

  !

   

    

"







 

#

  

 



       



 "

 

 

#  

  #

  

#

          $%&      

 

     '

()$ #

 

"

   *&  

+    !

  

 



"





       

  

     "



,-.+    

 

  

   

 

     





 







"

   

   

    

,/0 +(1234 





  

 

 +0 

  



$566778 66%6778   



 -(

3

  



  



 



), /0+( 1234 +  ,

 +(1234 

 , , 3 9  +(1234  



  

  0 

  



$5678 66%78"  

"

"       "

 :!;     

"

      

" 

+"   

  

 

  "



  -;  <   -(

   

 



    


      

 86778 

 

   "

               

 1=# - $4   



 

0.

"







  =#
6)8



 $>86778   "   



      

   "

    "



        <   

)              0 

 

    

     

   +   

  +  =#)6)8)6


  

  +  

 

    

   

  +,  

 

 



      



 

 

        

 "    "



      <   

             



   



       



    

 



 

  ?

   "



"

  

 +   , + 1.34  



-(1234   

 



   



 



    

  "   

   



   - (

 3

    

   ), : 0 
,0 +
,

0 +


  +     

 0   <   

 

  

   

      #



   

 



  

  

+       " 



   -(1234   - (

 3



 

   

  ," ,

@(1.34

"  +(,1234 

A,-0

  



%)8>78    



< 

  

 

  <   



   

       - ; 3

 

< 

 





       #



"

 " 

     +      

 "   <   

   "

   



        " "

    ;

 "



   3



 

   "   

      





   "



A 

  





  



    







=



 

  

   -( 1234 



   "

 



  



    


 



  " 

 

  "

 

    " 



 2

 

 

 









   "

          "        -(

  <   

 "



 



 

      <   "



 

    

        



!

 "   

     

 "   <   

     "

  

   



 

 "    

      





  



 "

    

 +    

  

 

 

    

   

        

  

 

       

   

+       



-@1+34  

< 

 



   " 

      







  <  "



       

  

   

 

  

 "      

 

 B %  

 5 '

"    ; !  C

 (

 1'4   +   +   #    "

 

 

 

 !




5$ A31,4!



6756



 



 



      

 

 

"    

"

 

 B  %  

@ 

 



 

   

D 2 

&#
"# 





  
 



#
 
-%

# %

A 
"


#
#
?(7
879
"

3
&  
"

8 ""9
#
)+(7
%

 

 

%


 #

 

0

#- 

- 
 

 

'()*)++,

# %
 

%

"

 


"
# 
"
/
" 
0  

! 1

0  
1

"

 
"
" 
% 


 #
"

 
"
%
"
0  
1

"
**'5)++5
0
  
 
"

 

#
    

     



    

 

    

  

 +   

  

    ,
(  "  =    





   

"

  





  



    +

  

 



   ,
(  !

"  

              







  

 $(1'4





 "    

  ,!./  

 



  

+. +."

  







         ,, -"  # #    "



 



!



58184 ",
!



164  !



58  A31,4!



6756



  

  

% 

"     

" 

  

  B     %  

  



  

+. +.   

>      + ."  

$$>677>

,!.6/ +.  

 

 

 

 





  



 <   ) D 2 

&#
"






 
#"" 
" 
-
%
0 


"
 

 
%
-


#
 


"
 

D




 


 -

-%

# %



%

%
 %
 
#




-
 
 





/
 

-

-%

# %
"
 
#  #
  

   


;# %
 




 

-%

#
# %

" 


- 




 
 
# 

-




-

-



2 

&#
"# 


 
#



"
3
&  
"

8 ""9
#
)+(7


  -
%
 
"
"

 


 
  

D
&# 
"
 
 
  


#



"
 

  !
"# $ %  
#  ## &' $   
   ()* 





 


-
-



 
+'
%

-
  


-
 
"

# %

 
  
"
 


%



-
-%
  -
 
0
 
#



 %


-%

D.-
 
 
D
&# 




- 
#
"

13&



(7
"

3
&  
"

8 ""9
#
)+(7
  

# %

# /
# 
 >  

-%
/



E 

 G




 

" 
# 

 

# 
 %
 
D
#- 


%


  

  -
#

(7
8)9
#-
&#
89




 

 %
 


-
 

-
 #%
"
/

 


 
%
D


# 

+
 
 #%

#%
A






#- 

%



#
 
D 

  # 
  -
#


#
"
)+(7

-
"#%
 


 

-



"
  
"
# 
# 
0
# %
 


- >#- 

-%

 
D
"# 
#- 


%


# %
" 




 

 

# 
-#

 


 
  -

 


#  


-
A 
D 

 


#  
"
 
%



 
#


# 
  

2 
#
"

13&
" 


= 
: 
# 
"
 
D
&# 



"
!
"# $ % 

  (' &,-.   '

, /.0


# /""

0 &'+ $ ++
 

'+'++' 0
 
A  
"

 

 # 
 "
-
1
>  =      

$$E6$EE6

 # 

$

8   

"



 +   

          



   



       

      

 "   



  

   =    ,     

     A3 "       ! %>$586> 

 

$7E$$EE6

 

  !6>EEE)
"  

  



 

"

   6> 

  

"

  

  



        

  =#  -  /  

 3 /     A3@   "

     



   3

 

F)+ $EE6



  

  "



    "      

 




#    "



 

   !



58184  A3 , !



 6756  #     "

  " 

 

   !6>EEE)


    

"





 





  

 



   D 

 
#- 

 

# %
"


##
 %

-


# 

-
 
D
"# 
#- 

 


%

 
"


#  


%

%

/
"

 
-%


# %
?

 # 

-


%

# 


 
 

 
#
"

  
 

 

 #

 # 

  
 -


"


-
 


"


" 
 
 
 


# 
#
 

 

 #
"

;# %
 




 
"


# %



# %
A 

 
"

;# %
<"" 

  

 "
"

 

-
#  #


 
"
 

 %
#
"
 
%
-%

& 
#
-%

=  
 
D 
 
 


-#





 

 

-
 
 
 "  

# %

 

 
 
  


%
#


 
 

 
3#  
#


 
-%

# %

 


 #
"

 


 
-
  


  
-%

;# %
<"" 


 
0
# %

 


%




 -  %

# 
-%

& 
 - 
  

#
 

%E
"

-

#
 %
#
%


 
"

 
0
  

"

  
 



 

- 
 "

 
"

- /
 
#

-

 #
D 

"# 
"


 1 /
  
 
 
-%

# %


-
 "

%
"
  



-
 

# -

 


# 

0
# %
"
 


" 


#  




- 
 
 -%

%
"

"
 
  
#
# # 
"" 

 
#


-

  %
"

% .
-
%

46
;#
 


#


"

(7
"
3
&  
"

""9
#
)+(7
 

#-



"
 




# %
  

 

# 


 

# 


-
 
>


#
 


-
 




-
 "

 


# 

;# 

-

 
  
0

#
 
 
-%

# %

A  

# 
1
G@=!=+,  

"

 

  , ! . /   + .

 3  <  !

 





>H A31,4!



6756  ,!

 (

 A3 !

    <  

  (



'

/ $613@-
6%H>878)$> 

6878 $ +'- G@=!=+,  

          

      ! . /   + .  " "

 

 



    3  


 " 

   

 ,!(B,

 >. $6 13@-
6%H>478



$$>677> % +

"  ,!./ =#+  

       C

 (

 1'

4          



 

  

$677> 8 +'- G@=!=+, C

 (

 1'

4    + )



)



 

 



       

 %  

 "      

"

 

 B  %  





'

/ >18%4)7>)'$) )(F! 

6)$$6677 > +'- G@=!=+,   

   

  







 "!

"

+ 

 !



58184 A31,4!



   "  ,!./ "



"     

 





"

C

(

1'

4



 " 





   3  +'- G@=!=+,

  "    

  



     !



 58 164 1 4 I 1 4 

!



581%4 "!



5$1$4

  

 

 



  !./  5 'G@=!=A!=,!./ 





     

  



 

   

  

 @   



      



" 6> J



      "

 

"

 

 





         

  

 



"   

 D 0
# %
 # 

  
"

  


-
"

  
-#
 


-

-%

#
# %




# %G
-#


  
%





#

#  

 

-%





# %

  



 # 


"
 
-%
 



 
  
  



-
 "


 
-%

# %
#
-


-
-



" 


"

"# 
%
"
 %
 
% 
"



#

 %

% 
"

 
 
-
#- 
-%

 


 #
 

-

-%


# %G

  
 
 "

 %
-
A  
- 





  

# %


/
%

"

#- >- 

-%




 




 
%


 

 
#  
 
 

  
"

# 




"
 
-%

# %
"
#"%
# 
"
# 
"
  



"
 
#
  
#
# # 
"" 


  %
"

% .
-
%

46
%
;#
 

#

-

 
##-



"


# 

-%

#
"

1 3&

 

 

%
"
-



"
 





 
# %
#

3
&  
"

8 ""9

#
)+(7
  


#


#

 

"


 # 
"
 

&#
"




 



 

;# 

-
/


-
 



 


 

-
/
"

 
%
"
 %
 
% 

 " 

 


#-

 

 # 
-#

-
 

-
/
"

"

 

-
A


# 
"
 




"
-%

 
 
D
&# 



-
  



A
"

"
 



 


-



A
"

 
"

#  
0
 
#  


 


-
 /
-%

1 # %

*4',)++6

"

 
"
 %
 

"

 

)6'))++6

-%


# %
0
 
"
A

"

"
 
  

-


-

  

-
 
-%

= 
: 
"
 
D
&# 



"
!
% ' (' &,-.   '

, /.0 "'

0
-
 

 


 


-
 " 

  
-%

 
D
&# 


-






A
"
 
"



# 
"


#
 
"

"

 





-



A
"



 

"
 


 #



 

"
#  
# 
"


#
 


 
"
 

"


"
 
-%


# %

-







-


"
 
%
 %


 
#


 



  -
%
 "
 
"  

 


"
 


-
 /

:



%

"


 

-%


# %
#"" 
" 
 /
"


 
'
-
 


"#
  
0
# %
 

# 

# 
"
/
-#



%




 
%
"


 
"


# %

 

"

"
 
%

#"%



 A 
"

"
 

# 


;# 

-
A 

"%


 
"
" 


"
# 
#" 


" 
" 

  
# 
 
"
-  
 -  %
D 

 

-


-




/
  
&;#%

 

  

-




 
"

# %

 
<  %

&# 
#
 
 


"

" 
# 
-%

& 
# %
  
/

 




 %
*6
% 






#

;#

 %
4'
% 





 %
# #
" 
 
 

" #"#
# 
#
-
 
-%
 




#
%
 



&;#%




 #
 

'()*)++,

-%

# %


"# 
  



;#
-"

#


#

" #
"

 
-
 #

-# 
-%



A#%

-

 " -%


 
"
"#

"
 
"
 "
%
"

  
"
 



-


 
H
6C

#
" 


"
"
"




 #
-#  





 %
*
,(



0
))(











 
*



G    

) 

KL )'

G      KL )'