← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2236/2022allowed

Shamsher Singh v. M/S Shri Balaji Grain Traders And ANR.

2023-12-13Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal3 pages

 



      

 !"#$"%&'&#()** +, -',".+&(/, 0"!&!&#(". 1".'2'

3'+,.& 4 5& . &( . 6".' (6 (#!,".  0*"'7#(6"(!'

#. -)   



   ."'"(!)

.*5 8 27! 961#% !"$#.!,"7"!&!&#(".*

.*+ -&. !, 2.961#% !"$#.!,"."'7#(6"(!'* :::



  

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

&#( 44#%C6#<(*2"!#4#%C6#<(9,"%#246 (#!%#-"!#D &!, 4 (6"(@2&." ;#2!!,"'! 2'#$,&' 77" 4*(!," $&.' <""C #$ 2("9 9 ," ."%"&1"6 (#!&%" $#. 77" . (%" &( !," "B"%2!&#(7"!&!&#( (6!,"(1&'&!"6!," #2.! #-74"B9D &!, 4*2.&(/ ,&'1&'&!!#!," #2.!9,";"% -" < ."#$!,"$ %!!, !+,.&+2.5""!

   ,&- (961#% !"92($#.!2( !"48"B7&."6-#(!,' /#* ,"." $!".9 !,"7"!&!&#("."(/ /"6+,.& -"', 27! 961#% !"9<,# 77" ."6#( ,&';", 4$&(!,""B"%2!&#(7"!&!&#(* " 4'#"(/ /"6+,.&**+, .- 9 61#% !"9$#.$&4&(/!," 77" 4* ,"."'7#(6"(!'#77#'"6!," 774&% !&#( ;8 %#(!"(6&(/ !, ! 62" !# ("/4&/"(%" #$ !," 7"!&!&#(".9 !,"." < ' (# '2$$&%&"(!% 2'"!#%#(6#("!,"6"4 8*  E" .("6$&.'!77"44 !" #2.!, '6&'-&''"6!," 774&% !&#(* ?

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

 ,&' %#2('"4 &--"6& !"48*  ,&' #2.!, '%#('&6"."6!,"'2;-&''&#('* F ,"&-7 %!#$ #1&6=%#246;"'""($.#-!,";"/&((&(/#$ * ,"." $!"9&!'7." 64&C" <&46$&."*('2%,%&.%2-'! (%"'9!," "B74 ( !&#($2.(&',"6;8!,"7"!&!&#(".&'74 2'&;4"*(!,&'% '"9!

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

  (6!,"&-72/("6#.6".7 ''"6#(**&''"! '&6"* ,"$&.'! 77" 4&'."'!#."6!#&!'#.&/&( 4(2-;".*   ," 7 .!&"' !,.#2/, !,"&. %#2('"4 ." 6&."%!"6 !# 77" . ;"$#."!,"$&.'!77"44 !" #2.!#(>**?*



  

!" **