High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5052/2023allowed

Subhash Chand And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-09-04Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary8 pages

! "

#$%&'()&*+,+'-./0"0/ 1234$,44$-)$-)$-'%4&5 000&%+%+'-&5, 6&5,2, 1%$%&'(7$58$-$$-)'%4&5, 0009&,:'-)&-%, ;< = >;? @ ;

! AAAAA 5&,&-%.

5012-+BC0D&45$$-) 509$4+B $4$E$-FG)H'*$%&, ('5%4&:&%+%+'-&5,0

50#2,48$-%1$4$5$-FGGIF7$58$-$0 AAAAA

;

! J ?

!"!

#$ #

# % & %%&

& ! '&(%

)$ *+,( -# $. /'

# +

0 #

(! 1 %% % **&+ ( # $#

%$%

( #

#$ $* *+ %%&#! ' %%&& * *

&# *+ ( & # +

2 % & + *

&& $%! 3&( #

( 4!5!5 #

& $ % #+

%%& *+

! 0 3) 6&

2+ + 2 ,% $. /' %$$# (

( + 7 # &# # + ! &&

&& 2 % & # + ( *

&& $% (## (&*& % # # * (

( !8 # (# #

(! '

# ( % ! ( !7!7 #

( ( %%&#

(! %$%

# (# %%&# # $*

%%&# # * $* *

2+ + ,%

2+ $& &0 %%

! ' * ( #&$

%$%

#( %%&# # $# ! '

$ ( $ # %%& :

% $& * & * &# :

% ( &*&

$! ' $ 0 + * %%&& + * $

# ! 1 (

* ( * %%& && !

"!! % *+ & & ;$ ! ' % # ) %%&&

%% ! ( (+

&+ # # ( *+ # $&

%%&& %%&& && #& #$& * <#% #&#$&

&* <%+! = $& && *

! "

% & ' " ()(*+

,(*%)# ((*+

)(*+

- .#

" !

/ $ 0!

1# ! 2 345622 375822 9:;22 <=7=42 >?22 @7AB7572 C2 #

$ D.

! *( "

F F

# !G H' / ! !

! G H' E I"

F! ! F $ J!

F K L

(**, ) FDM ,,(#

/ " N

/ / # !

! '!#

/ $ 0!

1 N

/O // / " #

" "

$ /! $

$$$

" " $

/ KN

&& ) ' P/ L # /!

D. $

" !

%# ! !!

" $ (,%%

((+*# ((((+ '

! Q RQ ()(# (((

!" #"" !

! $% "

" ! &

!% "

! # ! "!% !

" "

# &"

" " '' "

# " " '' # #$

( # " &"

$%) "

! )"

* % $ ! & +# !!"

& #

"! )!, -.

/ !

$ " "

% $

) )

* % $ !

& "

! &

" &

$ '

' ,'2 $)# "

!# !

,' $!' #

&# % !! "

! ! #

!$ !) "

! ! # )" "()!

" "''!

( # "'4 ' . !$ % #!

%% $

% ! # ")# ! 5 # !

" #!

6 789:;<66 =>?66 8@AB<C66 DCE66 7@=@B6 8F66 G=<H=>=66 =>?66 8@AB<C6

# ")# !

+# !! ! ## "

! ) !

!% "

! & %% $ !

()

&% !

" )!, - I

! $ "

!% "

# "

# $$ " &"

! " " '' ! !

# ")# !

+# !! " )" %

" $"

( # !

+# !! )$

# ")# !' I

# "

# ")# !

5 # # !! "

& ! ! !

()"$ " " ''2 %!!

" 3 J

1)%

$ ) 1 3 &!'

1 "

! & .%% K '2L2L ' .!

" " L'' %!!

! ) 1) M)$ J ! #!

!)% "

# ! & %%

! ")# ! !

")# !

%% " # # !!

#% J ! # $ ! J ' N

!" "

# ! & %% $ ! &

" &

!' I !

!% "

! & %% $ !

()

!' 3 &

( # " '2' . +)

' $5 %% $ ! #!

!$ O PO 2"

" L''

!"# $ %# &' ! ( ) *&+,-. /

! ") !

( #-# ! !!/! !')!(!/!0 1-# 2 ! ) ! / ! "' 3' 4/ ! 4' 5 "'! 6 5# " / 6 !) + + "7 8.

) ! !

! !

/ ! ! !

' ! ! ! ! 4' / ! 6'! / !# 2 "! 9! 5# : / 2) -..- " +8 ! &; !'! ! ! ! / '!

( ! ! ! " !( # <( / ! 4' "! 9! 0 18# 2 ! / / ( / / / / /) ! / / '!

! !

' #

! / (

/ / ! ! '! ! # : ! ' / / ! ( # 6() ! ! " ! ! / ' # 7! / ! ( !

/ / # & / ! ( / ! / ) ! "

! ( / ! ) / ! )

# 7! !

! ) / ! " / 6 (# " !! !

!) =-.8+> - "< -%?

@ "!' (# " / 6

!) =-.,%> + " %, 3 A

! (# " / 4

!) =-.,>-"<,..# $ -+# <

! 4' / B ! < 5# " / 6 !) - "7 ,- ! ! ! ' ! / ! "' 3'

!""

# $# %

%' (') * +

,- ! #.#$

! " , $/ "

" "

! " 0,# $# 1

!' + "

" !, - !

# 2' "

, !,

+ 3 - - "

+ 3 "" " , " , # $0# % ,-

#4 0# 5 6 789:8;<66 =>?66 7@8@A66 BC66 D8:E8F866 8FG66 B@<A:>6 -

* "

- '- ! , - " ,

#I#$

! " " ! ##

' , - '

" J K/# + L' - '- &" "

" " ! * !, 2, +"" +

#I#$ , "

" ' ! " !, , " # 5 *

*M NM # I# "

* M NM ' ! * !, 2, +"" +

!& "

" # 1 ! -

H O

* 'O''' !

! " " ! ##

' $ P%I

! "

#! $

% % & &

% ' !( ) " % % ( " * $$ % !! + &

% , $ %!

% - -! .+

" - $ %

! $ ( / 0 1 2 $ $

+ %% 3 $%

" !

$3 &

4! 5& !3 2 -% & $

& & $ $ & ( $!

3 $ % 6 -& $7 89:;<=>;?@77 A9B77 CDE@;F<9;77 9A77 G<H<E>E<9;I77 J;77 B@7 K7 & 3 $! 6"3 3 %3

- " #% $! $ ! + 3 % & % 3

- !

3 %! "

3 " & -

" %

! ! $

" !!3 !( !

$ -$$

! !&

! $ M% $ ! $

- " #% N !3 !%%- 3 &( $

- "$ ""7 O9HP<B77 >;Q79ER@BF7

$ $% %%!% $ %3

& !

" L %

3 " - " % S

! " ""# " " "# " $ &'(')%*+',-+'./0% 1,-23% 4564768485% 9 :

$; < =;! #" < =;!