← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/673/1999dismissed

Faqir Chand v. State Of Hayrana & ORS

2016-09-02Mr. Justice Darshan Singh14 pages



   

!"# $#%&'&()* *+ 

          



  ), - .

/  

   !

  "# $%&&% 

/   0 1!2 '    ( ) 

  *($  

   )       )"# $%&&%  + ,     *

$ (( $  % %  

    - .  (  /'+'001 $ )   2,3(  4'''001  (  5 



!64(    % )

1'+'0017 8'49

(  5  *

  : . 

   



    $     

 %   $     

  (  $$     *$       & $   +'''0;< (*) 28..    *$ * =. $     ) ($  :<  ) (  (            5*  $ $ %  '0:6   = 

$ $ %  



   

*  *  

2>8.  

   

)2( $  )   (*) 28. '0:'01< % (  )$  *$    ';6'01<    :'<''016 ) 1     )$   *$ % $  

 %$ )    *  ?@ 

  *$    '0;;    *

 

).    $  A

 ($$( 

+4<:'00<%    # ) 

*  

 $

      



 '6<''01;. $    % =.% & $ %" *   

+'</'00<  

 (     (  )  $$( )    

 B  7?$ 9 7" ?   2C8..D '0<:'01< +;<;'0;;

   * ;<6'01< <:<0'0;0     * :'<''016 +<<4'01< ?   $C=D +'<6'010 '/<6'011

 &.

'+<6'010 +/<''010 6 

 

% ($    -   *$ %   <:<0'0;0';<6'01<

 

).    $  '011   

 ):B107   )       ?@ 

  *$ 9( %( 

( % $



 E $ $ *



  )    *  $)*$ 

   $   )   ?@ 



 *$   *

  )  )  

$ 

<6<6'00< /   %$ $ A !'+<;: '00<  ) 

 E $  $    

+;<0'00<% (

  $   '00'  (  *  )!:</ '00< $ *   )         

   +;<0'00<  (       %     

        +1'''00'  

+<+'00+= .  

$ * )   (    5         (     * =.  

 

 

+4:'00+ % $   $ +6'00+( (    *  .    

$  

   

   <1<6'00+%   ) *

+'/'00< @  *  *)    2  C=D  (    /'''014        &.  (   0'+'014             *  *)    2  C?D  (   '+'<'00' *  .(  '+'<0'7  +0<6'006 1</06   $    )  * ) 9 4 *  $%( (   $(

  $    DF

+4<:'00<% =.B& B" *   

'/'00+%)  ) *     60  *$ (( ) $$   *)   DF

(  +<<4'01<   '<:'01'&)     

* 

3 )     % . 

 =.

'/'00+)  )  $ 60 *$  =.*)   

   =     (     ) %  8$% $ *

)      $  D



  60(      )



   $   $  $) .( $  .$  



      $$ (  = (  

)  . (  $

       *.

 . @ 

( *  5   ; = )

   (  %(   <'<;'000  (         *  =  )  ( ($

 . '+'<'00+) )     

($    * *  )"!'/41; '000

   

'0;'000       

 ) 

%  *  )

$$  



  "!'1/61 +<<< )     5 A$  )    "% 

   

:'<1+<<<

$$ *   *5 

      %  ((



* = 



00+<<<

 . '+'<'00+( 



 =. +'</'00<(  ( %  $

  *

 $   $$   *           

 

'0<;'000



(  $$

4

<0<0+<<< 1 .  (    $ * 

% $

     *

$$ )

 )*

  ) 

   %   )$    * 

 )  +;;'0;;:0'0;0  %  ) (

 ?@ 

  *$   $( $  *

 $ * $$>      !" 

   '0;<2 /</%(     $ 

 )     *$  

) .    $  

     *$  * ($ *     $

 )  *$ ($$*  .  *

 

 '011% D   

) ).    $ ($   60     *$ ((  ( %  (

   

     (  % (

 

)    $ % (   )    *

          *    )  )  60   

 *$ .  *

*  *

)

 *

        $ $ 



+4<:'00<  $A

 !+0'< '011   $   *    *$  ((   

 %(  "  % ($  )

'+'<'00+% (   (

       *$ %  * (%  *

$ *    ) .D



'+'<'00+ (     0   2   2(  F

   *    )    (

 %   %

- ) $   



. <1<6'00+ '+'<'00+( $  ($ $

)  )     *  

(($ *  $ $  $ 

 $( $    .  * * % 2 2(

  $   # )      "# $

 %  &+<<'7+9';6  (    4%; 1 # ) ( @   * $(  ,'"

( "( 

 )  &"



 " *

))   "

  $$

(  + (   

*      

 ,    "

 ) $

  ( (    



*   ,"("  ,   *  "

 , 

)     ( ! 

  

*   ,"

 ( $,"

"

" !)

"

 , ("

(  '"

(



, - !

" - "

  "

  

,  )

.'"

) 

 *$ ""     

 !* (  "

"    $  " ,





*    ( !"! $

"

 

/   "

  '"



 ""

    

)  "

 ( ! "

 "

0 !$

 "

1) 2       /"  !"3  (  4 )5 1((  ! "

$"

 ( ,"("" *

-

   (

 

 *  "

 ))  !

 "

  $  ) 



* 

(

(  "

  ,  /  

  ,"(" 

6 7  

 $

 - 

"

8 45  

 $

 - 

"



 $

!  

"

 "

$  - "  *  $  *   (

  $)    *



 9(

(  "

 "* "

$  (   !

  !   (

  (( : (

&,"

"

 "

   !

(  ) )(( 2) 

( "*

(   (

   ("( "

"

: (

    , (    "

,

: &"



"* ) $) '" 



 ( (

," $ ( 7 ;

  ,    "&  "

  *$  "  "

     

) ! "

$(

*  

"

*   '" *$

,"("

))  * ( !"

 

  (   ( 

;



- 

(

 

"

) 

 /  <45

45&,"(") (( $) , "

 "

 

$- ( !) 

,"(" 

68 7<45%( !) 

 "

 -

*8;

) ( &  1   *8  ;

) (   4+ 

 5



* "* $

* 

    (     1



&=  

/, ( ; "

 , ) 





* 

$

!(&"

> )  ;

) ( =



  (  "  $-   *      1  *8;

) ( &



* 4 

  

* 5

"

) 

  $

( 

"

 451) 

(

(  !;

) ( & *8 ;

) ( &1  *8;

) ( 

5 

*   $

  "     "  *

) *"

    "

(  =?

 &  

(

* 

"* 



" !"  "

 > )   ;

) (   =

 

( &,"

"" "

) ,     ("

 

 (  ! 

$ ("( ;



"



!"$

 &> 9 "(  $) 

)) $

   "

   -&  ,"("  "

   :   $- &"

"))  "

> ) 

;

) (   =

       $   $  

"

 >(7 % )   "

)) $

  

(   "  "

 ) 

  "  *

 $

( !



* '"

  ( ,"(" * !)(

/   "

/  & 

68 7  *

 )  ) 

81

( %( )   -"*

) *

    ,

&  )    "  "

))  ! "

 $ &* ) (  

("( &) $)   ( ! (

(

 ,"

)  ) *

%

"

(

( 

 "

) *

  )       "  *  

     "

  "



$) ,   (

$"

) 

,"

"

"

(

$"

(    "$;

( ""

)  ) *

* 2

*

  ,

     (

$ !   "



$           (

 ,"    

* $ 

 "

2) "  ,"

"

"

( "

* (

$

   "

) *

( $ *

     ,"

  )$

  ) (

!

("    

 " 

  *  (

 

  (

 "

) )    <7 (  $8(

(  '"

) 

(

*

 (" $! 

* "

 * )

"

 - 



* 

!

 "

*  &   

* "

$   )

"

( $) 

"

)  ) *

,

 ) (*  "

/   ("

! !"

 

  

'"

$ ( * 

-   $

"

 !  '"

 * !

)  "

"



") "

& , ("

( 

  ,   (

 ! (

*    "

$

,"

"

,  !

( !) 



 "

 * !

 

 "

 (""

 ) 

" *

$

((

 "

( ""

,   !) $

  (

( * (

  45 "

/  &,"("

 

6 745  





* " *  $    ((  (  ,"  "

 ) ()

(*   *8  4 45'"



$

 "

* $ &*  "

  $  ,"(" 2$ 

"

*

) "* -

 (

 

( $) !4( $) !@5: (

;

(   ,"

 "

  : (

   : & 

    "

 ) (   (  "  *  "

( !  (  

(

 !  (

*  ,"

"

) "

A ,  ("

 

"

( ' ! ("

*  "

,

(

   * $ &,""

))  "

> )  ;

) ( =

&* ) 



*  ) $2$ $ 

) 

+ (

 ( ( 7 "

 !""

) 

"

*

" *

) ! "

B:



"  "

 ) 

  !

   "

$  , 

( !*  ! ) 

 &"

  &  "

2) ,

"

"



*

     ,"

    , !  "

 ) (  

) (*   *  ,  '"

 ) 

    "



* !"

(   ,"  *

(

   *    

(

 !

!"

"

) 

"*

"

* "    

< 64<5 '

4 C 54>D5 D0A    "

& (

.'

"

$

 (    "

* 

  (



    +

 ) 

  ;

    '"

,  #  

"

&.45/ 6.45 '4 5  ) !" "

   0*

"

&  45  A/    +   "

  

  (  *  &"

) 

) 

 

$ ((  ! E '<     ) ) $ 

+;<;'0;;7& @ 8'9%(  (  $$ 

       *$  $    %  (  $$    

 $   

:<<;'0;;%)  )$   * 

$ ':17+9%  $  * -  )$   (     

$ ':17+9.  ) % $  $    5 )  = >   D0 A    &'00676944+.   

 )

$ ':17+9%   (   

$ ':1

7+9        *$     *  (   *    *5            # )   D0F( 4 )5  @ * $(  G+ ) 

 "

)  



*

/  

* $ " )

,  ("

  A33(

 ! $ 

!* 

*  :   * $ 



("( "

$  *     $- !  ) 

    "

 )    



* % ) 





*  

 :   * )(

) *

   ,

'"

( $)

 "

 (

     ("  ) *

 

  

*    " , - (

 (



(    !

"

)  ) *



(

) /   (   2( )

 $"

$   ,"("

$-   ) !    "

 A ,   ("

      (



) (

 ) 

 "

) 

  

*   H

  "  2( )

&  "

( $)

 "

 ( )  (

!



*  "

 - 

 

* 

,"

) !A ,  ("

  

,  & ") , 

*    * /"

&  *0 ( "

  , !(



68 45 (") 

( * !

 "

(

= 

* ,"("

( 

""

(  " 

"

( 

  /  .I 45"

 "

, (

   *   ("

) 

I 45"

> )  ;

) ( =

  ( "

 / !

 (

( 

  ))     ("

) 

I

* 45 (") 

"

 2(

)  (

 "

 ( (  '

 )) ""

  $- ! "



"  (

   ) ,   )

 "

 ( $)

 "

  $- ) (

) 

 $

!"

 ,"

"

) A ,  ("

    !" 

* ,"

$

" *



 ) 



(

= 

* * "

$

" *

*

 (   "

 A ,   ("

      '"

  & -

) !  ,"

 * $

"

*  ( &"

( $)

 "

 ( !

) 

 ) ) (

 "

 ( (  ;&"

  & !( "

"



* & ,"

"

!



(

= &( * )





*

 (

  /   45 '' F   ) $ %   *   D0AF( 4 )5&  *   *

  $  )  $    

(  )

 *$  ( $)*$ * *)  28..*  )* $(:<  ) *     *$          5* $

$ %'0:6    ((         *$ %

 %   *

  )$ 

 @   

$ ':17+9  *   $ *

)    $      $  D

+4<:'00<%( %  * $$(  $    *$ (5     (

    *$ *

  (*) 28..

     *$ 

 % 

 =  .  

$ $ <'</'00+ = 

$

$ %  <0<0+<<<  ) $ 

 =  .  

$ $ +'</'00<%$ $$ 

$$ *$  $(   )

 $ 

) E $  $ 

      

       

      %      (

   8   '+ F  $ $  ) $(  *%. $$ )

( * 

* 2  2(F

 

 %.

     

<0<0+<<<% * = 

$ $ % ( *   % )*

 - )  

     *$      

 %    $                       "  % $ $ $$     (

+'</'00<      =   

 $  :'<:+<<13 ': .  ( *  %    *  )

   '6 >

  )(

%   

 $*$  

*"# $%$  &&%  * $ )   

   

*  

(-*

  *$%   ( 5 )  )+'+  $*$ 

3  (($  *

 $$ ) %(  .$  ( )      $ 

     $ $> $)$     

  $   $*$ $(    @  ( $   $     )

* $ )    (   $$(   )    .    

  $      )         *    5 )    .        

      $$ $    

$).  (- $    *   5 ) 

   $.  @  *  )         $ $$$

$ )(  $  ($   >

 $(

 %(

$$  * %* @  )   $$  $

  )  $$ (  

$$(      @      )

     

 )  (-  

 $$ $ ) $   )  *    )  ()

    '/

 

 

   

/        *+ *+  - "

"

) - !J 

K  "

"

 *

K