High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/625/2003disposed of

Dalbir Singh v. State Of Haryana

2017-10-11Mr. Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul,Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa11 pages

Sumit Gulati 2017.11.02 11:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

!" #

$" #

&'()**)+,-./*0+112)()++0(10.('3034

!"#'+.

$"#5460.7&180()+94(13'::066'+13 ';0704+/.43:)30.)5704+/';434+/)-1)51803'*04*:-/+0.,-./*0+1)5 ()+94(14)+.'10. !

#'+.);.0;)530+10+(0.'10.# !

#:'330.

7&18060';+0...414)+'60334)+3-./0<.8)(=43';5);()**4114+/ 180*-;.0;)584;'> '+.84;'+.('-34+/4+,-;4031) *';?'38

80'::066'+1320;0:;)30(-10.)+1807'343)518031'10*0+1 <@ A=*'.07&';?'38> *';?'38)+ 284(8;0'.3'3 -+.0; C

! " # $

% &

# $ '

() $

$ * & +

, $

. /

+ &

1 2 3 # + $

$ 4

) '

()

$ '

% &

# $ ) 1 ,

1 # +

% &

1 #

% & 5 6

& +

% & 7

# $

+ $ $

# '

+ 8' 1 9 ,

# 1 &

2 " :

$ '

() $$

$ $ '

; '

$ $ $

86 '

6 '

)

* 2

< !1 $

# $

4 )1 $

$ +

$ '

# + +$ '

)

1 )

$ 2

2 , # $ - #

6 3 2

#$ $

# $ $+'

$ 1 $ '

+ ,$ 2 ,

$ # $$ ' $

)

$ $

$ '

)

$ +

$ &$ $ $

+1807'343)5'7)9031'10*0+1)5 *';?'384+414'66& ) $ .'10. -+.0; 0(14)+ #BA$"$A##A$BA$E 2'3 ;0/4310;0. '1 )64(0 1'14)+ ';2'6' '+. '((-30. 20;0 ';;0310. + 4+10;;)/'14)+'((-30. '8'74;*'.0'.43(6)3-;031'10*0+118'1808'.?0:1 ()+(0'60. ' 6'184 4+ 843 8)-30 7084+. 180 ;)+ 7)@ '+. '510; .4//4+/ -+.0;+0'1880/)1;0()90;0.1803'*0284(82'31'?0+4+1):)330334)+94.0 @ %A ((-30.,414+/8>414+/8'63)*'.0'.43(6)3-;031'10*0+1 18'1'6'1848'.700+?0:1()+(0'60.7&84*4+843;034.0+14'68)-30280;0 ()11)+314(?320;06&4+/18080':)55-06'+./)1;0()90;0.1803'*0284(8 2'3 1'?0+4+1):)330334)+94.0@ ((-30.'674;4+/8*'.0'

.43(6)3-;031'10*0+118'1'6'1848'.700+?0:1()+(0'60.7&84*4+843 ;034.0+14'68)-304+7'(?34.0)54;)+7)@'+./)1;0()90;0.1803'*0284(8 2'31'?0+4+1):)330334)+94.0@ FA

-;4+/4+90314/'14)+84;'> '+.84;4+/83-((-*70.1)843 4+,-;403'+.(8';/0-+.0;0(14)+0(14)+# 2'3'..0.

80;0'510;180:)64(04+90314/'10.180*'110;'+.3-7*4110.' ;0:);1 -+.0; 0(14)+ # ;

'/'4+31 180 ()+94(1'::066'+13 -+.0;

" 0(14)+3#A$"A$BA##A$";0'.24180(14)+$E

80 :;)30(-14)+ 0@'*4+0. 241+03303 '+. :;)94.0. .)(-*0+1';&094.0+(01)3-::);1413('30

661804+(;4*4+'14+/094.0+(02'3:6'(0.705);0180'((-30. '::066'+11)284(8180&:60'.0.4++)(0+(04+1804;31'10*0+1-+.0;0(14)+ ## ;

80'((-30.'::066'+1360'.094.0+(0)5% '*6'4+1804; .050+(0

% '*6'.0:)30.18'1412'3180()*:6'4+'+1:';1&28) -+.0;1804+56-0+(0)564G-);1;40.1))-1;'/080;*).031& 80.0:)30.18'1 412'3180()*:6'4+'+1:';1&28)8'.1)70/;4660.7-1180:)64(0';;0310. 180'::066'+132;)+/6&

801;4'6 )-;1'510;1'?4+/4+1)()+34.0;'14)+'66180*'10;4'63 )+;0();.()+94(10.'+.30+10+(0.180'((-30.'::066'+13

0+(0180:;030+1'::0'6

0';+0.()-+3065);180'::066'+13()+10+.0.18'1180;02'3+) *)1490 5); 180 '::066'+13 1) '11'(? .0(0'30. 84;' > '+.84; 4+/8

'180;180.0(0'30.4+10;90+0.'+.412'3'13:-;)5180*)*0+1'+. 180;05);0 +) )550+(0 -+.0; 0(14)+ # 43 *'.0 )-1 '/'4+31 180 '::066'+13 0';+0. ()-+306 5-;180;()+10+.0. 18'1 180 )((-;;0+(01))? :6'(0 )+ 280;0'3 180 .0(0'30. 2'3 1'?0+ 1) 8)3:41'6 )+ '1"

28).40.)+"

'1E $":

'.14*06& *0.4('6'33431'+(0700+:;)94.0.1)180.0(0'30.80()-6.8'90700+3'90.

80;05);05);+)5'-61)5180*4++)1.06490;4+/*0.4('6'33431'+(01)180 .0(0'30.180&('+70806./-461&5);180)550+(0-+.0;0(14)+#

! 2'36'316&()+10+.0.18'1180:;)30(-14)+8'35'460.1):;)90180(8';/03 '/'4+31180*

0';.60';+0.()-+3065);180'::066'+13'32066'3180()-+306 5);1801'10'+.:0;-30.180;0();.(';05-66&

%$ *';?'384318031';241+0334+1843('30 0704+/180 4+,-;0.0&0241+033301180:;)30(-14)+('304+*)14)+'+.('10/);4('66& .0:)30. 18'1 '7)-1 H *)+183 :;4); 1) 180 .'10 )5 )((-;;0+(0 4

80:-;(8'30.'8)-304+%';.) B';2'6'5;)*1807;)180;)5 )+0 ';'3 '* '+. '((-30. '674; 4+/8 28) 2'3 '63) 4+10;0310. 1) :-;(8'301803'*02'3+-;34+/'/;-./0'/'4+3184* + '1'7)-1 :

280+80'6)+/2418.0(0'30.84;'> '+.84;4+/8 '* -*';

'+. ','2'334114+/4+180()-;1&';.)58438)-30'((-30.'674;'6)+/2418 5490)180;:0;3)+3+'*06&,41 4+/8 ', -*';'1:'6-;038 '+.

'8'74;';*0.24186'18403('*0180;0 ((-30.'674;;'430.'6'6?';'18'1 0+0*403';0:;030+1180&70.0'61'(();.4+/6&'+.'((-30.'674;/'9012) 6'18476)23)+18080'.)584;'> '+.84;4+/8'+.)+'(()-+1)5284(8 84;'> '+.84;4+/85066.)2+)+180/;)-+.

((-30. ', -*';/'90 6'18476)2)+18080'.)5';?'38> *';?'385;)*5;)+134.0 ((-30.

-;0384+564(10.'6'18476)25;)*1807'(?34.0)+18080'.)5';?'38>

*';?'38 ((-30.,414+564(10.6'18476)2)+180184/8)5;4/8160/

((-30. '8'74;/'906'18476)2)+18031)*'(8)584;'> '+.84;

4+/8 ((-30.'1:'64+564(10.'?4(?76)2)+18080'.)584;'>

'+.84;4+/828460802'36&4+/)+180/;)-+.'+.'?4(?4+1807'(?)5

*';?'38<()*:6'4+'+1= +843;'434+/'6';*%"'44+/8'+.)+0

8';'14+/8('*01)1804;;03(-0280;0'3 '* -*';'+. ',364::0.

'2'&

%" '4 4+/8 ();;)7);'14+/ 18090;34)+ .0:)30. 7& %$ .0:)30.18'1)+ 280+802'3:;)(00.4+/1)1808)-30)5 ';?'388080';.+)430)5'674;'-,4;'434+/6'6?';''+.'11'(?0. ';?'38'+. '+.84;4+/8 %"8'3/490+'/;':84('(()-+1)518028)60 )((-;;0+(0'3.0:)30.7&180%$ *';?'38

-78'388';*' 0+0;'6-;/0)+'+1')3:41'6 ';2'6'*0.4()60/'66&0@'*4+0.';?'38> *';?'38)+ '1 '7)-1 #:

'+.5)-+.1805)66)24+/4+,-;403)+843:0;3)+ C/

5 =/ $ = /

)

;

$ $

80)(1);):4+0.18'11804+,-;40320;0('-30.24184+'.-;'14)+)5!8)-;3 241876-+120':)+3

-78'388';*' 0+0;'6-;/0)+'+1')3:41'6 ';2'6' '63) *0.4()60/'66& 0@'*4+0. 84;' > '+.84; 4+/8 )+ '1 '7)-1 "

" :

'+. 5)-+. 180 5)66)24+/ 4+,-;403 )+ 843

B :0;3)+ C/

" $

$ #

$ $

$ $ +

$ B =@

4 $

; $ $

B =@ $ > = ?

80)(1);):4+0.4+,-;403) '+.1)70.'+/0;)-34++'1-;0 +704+/ 38)2+18020':)+)5)550+(01843)(1);):4+0.18'14+,-;403()-6.70 4+564(10.7&3-(81&:0)56'18403

%!;

-*'+ 0+)+ 0.4('6 554(0; 0+0;'6)3:41'6 43';()+.-(10.:)31*);10*0@'*4+'14)+)+180.0'.7).&)584;'>

'+.84;4+/8)+"

'1$ :

'+.5)-+.1805)66)24+/4+,-;403 C

4 $ $

4 $ $ 5 5

$ $

4 $

) & / $

E 4 $

+ 4 $

80)(1);):4+0.18'1180('-30)5.0'184+1843('302'338)(?.-01)80'. 4+,-;&284(82'3'+10*);10*4++'1-;0'+.3-554(40+11)('-30.0'184+ );.4+';&()-;30)56450

18'3()*0)+;0();.18;)-/8180.0:)3414)+)5% ', -*';18'1)+;0(0494+/;-G'@ ;0/';.4+/'.*4334)+)5 *';?'38)+ 80;-380. 1) '+1')3:41'6 1) ;0();. 18031'10*0+1 )5 ';?'3894.0'::64('14)+@ 7-1180)(1);.0(6';0. *';?'38-+541 1)*'?0'31'10*0+194.08430+.);30*0+1@ A + % '/'4+ ;0(0490. ' ;-G' @ ;0/';.4+/ '.*4334)+ )5 4+,-;0. 84;' >

'+.84;4+/8 %'/'4+5);2';.0.'+'::64('14)+@ 705);0180 )(1);7-1180)(1);.0(6';0.84;'> '+.84;4+/8-+5411)*'?0'

31'10*0+194.0@ A280;0'394.00+.);30*0+1@ A180)(1);

.0(6';0. *';?'385411)*'?031'10*0+1)+ '+.80;0();.0.843 31'10*0+1280;0'34+,-;0.84;'> '+.84;4+/82'3.0(6';0.-+5415;)* 1)# 7&180)(1);94.0@ A1)A# 614*'106& 84;'> '+.84;4+/83-((-*70.1)8434+,-;403)+"

'1E $"'

%';;0310.'66180'((-30.

80 094.0+(0 )5 %$ '+. %" '+. 180 *0.4('6 094.0+(0 031'7643818'1180'((-30.4+5-;180;'+(0)51804;()**)+4+10+14)+28) )180;2430+-;30./;-./0'/'4+31%';?'38> *';?'38'11'(?0.180*

'+.4+18'1:;)(033('-30.180.0'18)584;'> '+.84;4+/8'+.('-30.

4+,-;4031)%

35';'3*)1490:';143()+(0;+0.418'3()*04+094.0+(018'1 180'((-30.'::066'+1'674;+-;30.'/;-./0'/'4+31 *';?'38'+.80 '6)+/2418)180;'((-30.'::066'+138'.090;&;0'3)+1)'11'(?84* -1180 :;)30(-14)+8'35'460.1)031'7643818'1180;02'3'+&:;094)-30+*41&); *'64(0);'+&:;0*0.41'14)+1)/4904+,-;4031)84;'> '+.84;4+/8'+.

('-30843.0'18 04180;412'3180('30)5180:;)30(-14)++);'+&)5180 241+033038'3.0:)30.18'1180'((-30.'::066'+138'.+-;30.'/'4+3184;' > '+.84;4+/8 ;-0414318'1'((-30.'674;:;0*0.41'10.180'11'(?)+

*';?'38'+.8'./)+02066:;0:';0.'+.'11'(?0.180()*:6'4+'+1:';1& 24186'184'6)+/2418)180;'((-30.

-1)+180)180;8'+.418'3'63)1)70 1'?0+4+1)()+34.0;'14)+18'1'::066'+1'674;+-;30.180/;-./0'/'4+31 ';?'38)+6& 12'34+'541)5;'/018'1'((-30.'674;4+);.0;1)'11'(?

*';?'38('*0.)2+80'946&(;'384+/'+.(;-384+/090;&184+/18'1 ('*04+8432'&,-311)1'?0;090+/05;)* *';?'38'+.-+5);1-+'106& 84;'> '+.84;4+/85'(0.1807;-+1'+.70('*084394(14*

80;05);04+)-;):4+4)+'((-30.'674;8'.()**4110.180 )550+(0-+.0;0(14)+#$';1 '+.+)1-+.0;0(14)+#

4+(0 '3:0;180094.0+(0)5%$'+.%"'((-30.'674;('-30.6'18476)23)+ 18080'.)584;'> '+.84;4+/8'+.'3:0;*0.4('6094.0+(0180.0'18 )((-;;0..-01)18080'.4+,-;&180;05);041('+703'506&806.18'1)180; '((-30.+'*06& '8'94;4+/80014+/8>,414+/8 ', -*';'+.

-;0388'.+);)601):6'&4+180*-;.0;)584;'> '+.84;4+/8'+.('+

)+6&70(8';/0.2418180)550+(0-+.0;0(14)+$"A$BA##;0'.2418 0(14)+$E

80;05);0 180 '::0'6 4+

!" )5 # 31'+.3 .43:)30.)552418*).454('14)+18'1'::066'+1'674;43()+94(10.5);180 )550+(0-+.0;0(14)+#$';1 4+310'.)50(14)+# '+.43 30+10+(0.1)-+.0;/) 5);&0';3'+.1):'&'54+0)5"A'+.4+ .05'-61)5:'&*0+1)554+01)-+.0;/)5-;180;;4/);)-34*:;43)+*0+15); &0';

80 ()+94(14)+ '+. 30+10+(0 4*:)30. 5); 180 )180; )550+(03 43 *'4+1'4+0.

80()+94(14)+ )5'::066'+13 4+

$")5 # 31'+.3 *'4+1'4+0. 280;0'3 180& ';0 30+10+(0. 1) 180 :0;4). '6;0'.& -+.0;/)+07&180* 8030+10+(0)554+0'6)+/2418180.05'-61(6'-3043 *'4+1'4+0.

# " #

(1)70; -6'14 %80180; 0:);1'760 03 %80180;:0'?4+/A 0'3)+0.