Secretary,Punjab State Committee Communist Party Of India (Marxist) Punjab v. Union Of India & ORS




   


    

       !"#!$%&%"'() ) *    +!$,! ,-. /'01 +  ! "22% !!. "22/'%&  , - "#
'3%  ,4%& . /'01        

! % %"'!,        5!,&/&  

'%"'"#
'3%'3" 6!,&   !&8"'3!' &   (  9:

 +
5
 +   



  



 !



 $% $% &'

 !



() &'

 !

+ 

 ,( -

. 
,.

/01
' &'



5
 +    :


'..& 2 +  .!!#

..

3  44

!! , 3  / 



 !.(&





6 !! , ..&

.

"..&

*,' +# %& 7,'& ( 3 



  9, :

!.(&

! "..



;

  ! ,.

++& "'.*

!   !# ,)"



((
((, # <  8 =<1:

'&  >

?**!  " @( &'

'( '2

! 



' &'

" 

.!!

! !  2 .

 44

&,..# +#& ..

.!!# ".. ,

 ( ( 2

' 2



(+,&

"..



 !.(& +#(

4 66/ 2'!'

!.,



6  2 



. " , " 

*,'

! ((,! 

' &

2 . 

A9!, A&

A.!!# 6
,!  B 

! 

' &'

 &&

. 9+.& ' 

 2'!'

 +#".

!.*#& ..

".. !

&

!! , ,("

. # !.

!'7, 3 C31



4





2 ,)"

3 .

%

! 

' &'

 6/ 2 . !'

. &

" 

++.! 

' 2

*,

!!+

!'7, . & ++.!  ..# ", * ! & **

" 

.

++.!  2 !!+

", !'7, 2

,



. " , ( 2'!'



! (+,

  ,++.

2 ! (+..

++ !'

'
, *.&
 3 

4 2'!'

!( ,+

'&

    " 

2 +  2

+ 



!&  3  !  

!

++.!  ,"(

! ((,!

! 

'

* +& " 



. 2

,"(

&  3 

. &

!'7, < 2 '* ! #

 ( 3 



 



6

* ,

,

,& &.

!'!%& '  

! !.# "..

".. +& +

 44

..

,! *'

".. < 2 ! #

!,.

(,.+.#& *!  2'!'

2

/

*! 2 ++.

/

" 

*! 

/

2 % !# 

(

(,.+.#& *! 

2   ,.# ( 1%& 

!   

!,.

&# ! ,(+ 

(  &

44  

2 !.!,.

! !

(,.+.#& *! 

(



! ((,!  2..

"..

 2 ,")! ( !'..&

2 + 

 ( "'.*

*.

2' ' 

, 
 

          



    

       

 

      

 

    ! 

"#$%"#$$    

 

     & 

 "#$%"#$$ '"()   



 

     

  

            

 * 

  



  

+ "   

!  

 ,'#  * 

   

 #    

 

"#$%"#$$  ,'"() # + '"$%

# - 

  

   

  



   

     .    /



!   &   

   

  01 



 

    2/34

  5 .    2 /       

    &         

     

  

   

  

 "

#  "#     

   

 



 

  -  

   &   

 



 

  

  

   

 

 

   "#           

  

 

    /  

! "$$%

   

 

   

 

 6 

  

     

  

 * !

 4 5     "")  7 82 .   9 2 : 

     ;

 

    <   !        '"!$!%# 



)$($    

  

    '"!()!

        

         &     

        

    4 5   

   "")     7 8 2  .    9 

2 : < ")  * <     2



 

  & 

 

  

   = > < + ?
      

  
         

   +     



  !

  <># 7>

   &  

 



     

 

      

 

        ")     *  <      

 



+ ?1

   

          



  !

  < 7!

     &   

   8    9 # 

    

  & #

 ?

     



 !!" #

 # 

+ ?1

   

            

 

  ! 

   <! 7

     &  ! 

   8    9 # 

  



  & #



? - 





   



     &    



    

        



 

 

     

!  &   -  

       @                      

6

       

    

      @

   &  !  !           

       

               

    &             





 

&

   

    ! 

   &         

   

 

     

   

  !  !   

   

  A < ', 

(

! !.# 

'   !.(&

! ' 2

2 & ++.!  (,.+.#& *! 



/

(,.+.#& *! 

/

+.! /)   " 

2 (

' *.

;

  ! ,.

++& "'.*

' .

,+  !  6 86:

A.!!#

!

 2 ++.!". '

! 

+

! # ! ,.

'

! *

.# +

9 ( ' + 

*! '&

 !

  

(



,   !'& ( ..

  ".. > *,' !   ' 

** 

# ++ ,# '& "*  &

(

 * 

+

B 

!'

'
,

!& ! #  

++ ,# '&

9 < &,



  ! !.

# * (  / 

  +.#

# *,

,+ 

A.!!# B+(

+ & ..

, 2 

,+  +  > *,' ,"( #

! 2' , +& , # *,'

2..&

+# * 

(

' ,&'

(+,&

! ((,! 

. #

+ 

! (+.! 



 6

+

'
,

" . ),

 & &,( !

.

  ! ,.

! ,.

++& "'.*

01
' &'

' ! 

!  6 86:

A.!!#

!

  ++.!". ( ++.!". .#

2' '

+,

**! +! ( <

!

+,

   + (

.# .

!.!.

(% 2 &.# ! (+,& &# ! ,(+  !'&

"

+  1' "&

+,  .!!#

! ,(+  /  #

*! ( ! 

 

"& +,.# !.!.

, ,+

!! , ++.#&

2 & (,.+.#& *! 

'!

!  6 86:

A.!!#

!

2 ,.

  " ++.!".

, 2 ,.

' "

.

,  !   A.!!#

!

2 ,.

', ' &' !   

+

.(  " ! (+,

**!

 2' ,!'

*!

 !

! !

,' 



>

' 2

  +  

+, *!



(

++ ,# '&

&

+  > .' ,&'

!   ' ,!'

+ ! , +,.

++.!". &,. 

' 2

*.#

,"( +!+. ,.

),! 2 ,.

 '. "

!

! ,!'

  "&

(

' , & & # *,' " 

!  #

 !& ' . # **

(% &



(

2'

+

2% #

<

(  ++ +

+ 

+ 

!  

+ &  "..

!.(

& '( ,

(+,&

"..

2' +

2% #

"   '.

.". # ' ,!'& (# "

(

',+ 

2 ,!'& "& .. 2

.#

7,". .*

 !&

+, ' (

+

!  ". +

. #

44

+

.#

# ' .+

' 2 ,.

' !'( (# '

 *

 A.!!# B+(

,&

&,( +

"* 2' * '   .

!., ?1/2 ,!'& !'(  

/

. #

+ 

! (+.!  +

'
,

 +&

!  ( ,!'& 2 ,.

.# && *'

4

. .* .&  2'!'

' (

+ .# '

! 

+ ,/( , 2 ,.

.# " . 1',

.&  7,

" & 7,,  + .& 

+ .!#

2 +  !!  &.#

+ 

*

! ++.! 

* #

'..

. 

+ 

!!  &.#

 !$!21!,).* (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ)

8     6! 6!,&8!;%'<=,!&"'!3 (!&=" 6! 6!,,!8", 1>!  (!&="