High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/18887/2016allowed

Jyoti Singhal & ANR. v. State Of Haryana & ANR.

2026-02-10Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary8 pages

! "#$$%%%& '()*+$, -./012304565178'9' 9 ' ( :;1/5<57=>.?.73.71/>0@ 9999A0/5/5170@6 B0@6C6 </./012D.@;.7..73.71/>0@ 999#06E17307/6 F G HIJ KKKKK A@0607/8 $@9 L.@.MN00@<57=>O.7;.7.PQ3N14./021@ />0E0/5/5170@69 $@9QM@5RS.@T.?P-QUPD.@;.7.9 $@9#<$.M?5PQ3N14./021@@06E17307/S19 9 KKKKK

VI 9 W>0 E@0607/ E0/5/517 25?03 C730@ <04/517 X% "@9A9"9 56 21@ YC.6>57= Z[# S19 !P 3./03 '(9'!9 '(P @0=56/0@03 C730@ <04/5176 X ' .73 X'( [A"P ./ A1?540</./517"5N5?\5706PUC@=.17.?17=T5/>.??41760YC07/5.?E@1400357=69 9 \0.@703 41C760? 6C]M5/6 />./ />0 E@0607/ 4.60 56 45N5? 356EC/0P T>54> >.6 ]007 =5N07 4@5M57.? 41?1C@P 57.6MC4> .6 />0 41ME?.57/ 56 T5/> @0=.@3 /1 .7 .=@00M07/ /1 60?? T.6 71/ ]057= >171C@03P T>54> 4.771/ 07/.5? .7; 4@5M57.? ?5.]5?5/;9 $1@01N0@P 71 45N5? 6C5/ >.6 ]007 25?03 ]; />0 41ME?.57.7/9 W>0 E@0607/ E@1400357=6 .@0 575/5./03 M0@0?; /1 .@M/T56/ />0 E0/5/5170@6P />C6 3060@N0 /1 ]0 60/ .65309 ^9 \0.@703 41C760? 21@ />0 </./0 .6 .?61 @06E17307/ S19 P 17 />0 1/>0@ >.73P 417/073 />./ />0 E0/5/5170@6 >.3 57/07/517.??; 71/ .3>0@03 /1 />0 /0@M6 12 />0 .=@00M07//160??P/>0@0];4>0./57=/>041ME?.57.7/9

"# $ % &'(# ( )*+ , (("

% $% "- ./ + % #, ''#""# (+ 3 ( 5,- '!#( 3#(" 4'67 # 4#(3%+ " ( 857 4#(3% (

$ 4%8' *'+ *9 1:;<+ 2

( )

+ =#&> =#%+ ?%# 4#+ ; #" '# % ?#("% @ (

4%2 4#(3%+ !'(( "#(

=#3 *#% @ + /%"# ( ?#" * %> ( (

' "##(3 @ 0' =#%+ 0%"+ )#" )

+ * 7

+ 8!'(+ ( A53 #, "+ 3 ( %& ( #( ( 3'( " ;BCB; #( *"<B+BB+BBB9

#% 4(57 4#(3% ( # 4#(3%

#% 3 ) @ BB+ ,>?+ 0' D ( %

4# (+ 4, ;+ 0+ 3 (

%#,% #"

E 9 " EF % ($" , 0#& H#'#+ ( )

+ E2) * + 3 ( /% !!#,( % ,#& *":I+BB+BBB9 " (" (7 #( ,"% ( % '#(#(3 '

(

% (",# ( %" !# % #'

3#"7 : 4#+ 4'67 # 4#(3% ( 4(57 4#(3% #" ( , '#(3 $ 3#"7 #( % J$$#,

*3#" #("!#

,#(3 3#( ( 3#( G%# % !!#,( %" , %#" !"(, #( %

$$#,

( ;:B<B; ( BB<B; $ 3#"# ( %7 %& ( , ' H#> %#" %7 %"" ' ( , ''# $ 37 ( (

% % ,, " "

%(#(3 ' ># ( ( %7 3#&#(3 '7 (7 ' #" K " % % "#, 3 ,# ( '7 >#(7 >( 3#(" # 4#(3% ( 857 4#(3% /%(>#(3

? BCBCB; 0, 3 (+ 8!!#,( ?#("% @ (

4%2 4#(3%+ "#(

=#3 *#%@ +/%"#(?#"* %>L I ( "#'# $," ( ,#, '"(,"+

%#( "

% 3'( "

" ( F, ( ( )* ,'

3 3#(" % !!(+ (M % !'

K "% % ,#'#( ! ,#(3" #( NOPOQRST UOVP WXY NTOTZ [\ ]V^ROQ_ `B:a411:IB+ 7 "&#(3% "- .< J( % '# !,

( , 7 % !#"+ # #" &#( % ( 3'( "

" F, 7 % !!( #( $&

*"!

(( + ('7+ 4 5# b $ "

#(3 ; `>(a /% 3'( " "!,#$#,7 '(# (" % $, % % !!(9% &( 3" (# % ! !7

( % "#"

% 3'( "

#$ &'(&)*+ , # -

- # - &(0&)*1 / - &1*&&)*1+ , - . 2# 32# 4 -/ --

3 # 32# 5 6-2 &

! # 2.-

- #

.3 -##

- 3!+ **+ 4## - -

- -#

# 32# - #$.

6-2 &+ 7

32# &*&)*'+ ,

32# -

# ! 6-2 & *(0&)*'

-- 896 :- - .-+ ;

- 5 -

6-2 & - 3#! 2 2--

22## /# # .

3 # - . - 3!

$ / - - . 2# 6-2 & - !

/##. . - # .-+ , -

6-2 &

.3 -##

! # 2.- . - #

.3 -##+ 9

5 # -

- #

-/ -&1*&&)*1+ *&+ , - . -..-

! - -- 6-2 &

22## . - # .- <- 2!

# -

- # 33 #!

+ = # 2.- /

#- 6-2 & 2 #!

#. 32# - / 2# /

/ / #

! # 2.- 5 :-

/##.--

- #- -2 3 !+ *+ >

- . - 3 # 2-

. #--

# -- - -/ .

- + "#!

##.

# $2 2 23- /## . 3 # 2.-+ 83

# # 5 - 6-2 & 32 - - -

- 32# -

# / /

##.

22## - #!

- 22! #- / - - -: 32# - 3

22## - 3+ ;

- 32# 5 #! :- -

3 6-2 &+ ?

- 32# 5 - 32# -

# / 32

- $.

##.

22##

- /## / - # 32# + , -3-

# -2

# $

( "

)

* "+ ,

& - ./0 - "

- ! #

# !

!1 ! "

$ 2-"

- & &

$3 4$ 56&

7 8 9:: ;<=> ?@: AB=BC ) DEFEG HE 788 HIH) - , "

) '

! '

J KHI$ - - "

L IE8M8

8 / N 8$ '$ OPM8 / Q $ R/ N 8$ '$ OPM8 / Q $) DEFFSG S 788 4TS J DEFFSG T 788 D8G HII J EFFS /O78 UEV !

- &

!-" &

) -

J D788 $ 44W) HEHG KHE$

L IE

8 8 M

% !

-XY ' Z-L 7 '$ 7& L 8 L 2" RY ' Z-L 7 '$ 7& L 8 L 2" ) DHWIIG H 788 SWE J HWII 788 D8G ETV )

5# '$ [ L Q R7

! 5# '$ [ L Q) HWWE 7 DHG 788 TTU J HWWE 788 D8G ESV ) 0 \ [LL '$ ]- M 7" ^ R0 \ [LL '$ ]- M 7" ^) DHWWUG S 788 HW J HWWU 788 D8G HFUWV ) 8[/ '$ \ 2" /

Q $ R8[/ '$ \ 2" /

Q $) DHWWSG U 788 UWH J HWWS 788 D8G HFUV )

[ '$ 0L 2"- R7

[ '$ 0L 2"-) DHWWSG I 788 HS J HWWS 788 D8G SEIV ) 0L

[LL '$

DO8% \ G R0L

[LL '$

DO8% \ G) DHWWWG T 788 EUW J HWWW 788 D8G FHV ) Y _ M DMG Q $ '$

! "! #$ % &!'# (&)

+ (,---) /"" ,01 2 ,--- /"" ("') 034 + 5' 6 7898 &'$ : '# * ; !'

5' 6 7898 &'$ : '# * ; !'+ (,---) < /"" 30= 2 ,--- /"" ("') >=04 + ?'$!88 * :96 /8!

?'$!88 * :96 /8!+ (,--3) = /"" 0< 2 ,--, /"" ("') 314 8 @8 A &!'# A B'C$

* !

/!';A 5DA

@8 A &!'# A B'C$

* !

/!';A 5DA + (,--) 3 /"" 3,, 2 ,-- /"" ("') ,=.4E! F'8F $+' *8 A'FA'F$ ' 2 () G #F8 8 H DA$!

I! '

! 8$ # 8

! #F8 + * 8 ;

! 6 '

C 8

! ' ; *A 8 F

! ' '

8 F'# ; 8$ 86 ;; 8 ' #C A

! $ 8$ ! A$ J'

!$ FA'F$ +

! #F8 !$

H K#8 $ I! + HA I !A K#88

! # ' ;

! 8$ L ! '

8DA'6 8' # AA$ 86$$ ;

! # ' 8' 8 $$ $$# 8 ;

! ' H 6 ' 8A8 8 $$ ;

! 8$ 8

! #F8 + $ I''8

I! K#88 F'6 ';'DA$!8;#F8 () G #F8 #6 $ H DA$!

I! ' $ ' HA$ ;

! F' $$ ;

! A'

+ $ I! 8

! '#8 F' 8 $ ;A8

!* H 8 8

I # ; $M# ;' I' C8 * 8 8 '

A$ !'#+ ' I! '

! 8$ ' H$A'

8 8! ' 8 6#F'HH () E! FI '

DA$! $! 8 + !I * '+ H A$

$ ; ' $A

# F'$ A 8 E! FI ' $!A H A$ $F'868 I !HA8 8 A 8 (*) E! #F8 $ 8 ' DA'

* 'H # ' F' A

! 8'

8 ;

! ;; 8 N;

! 8 $$'6 ; A ;A8 8 $ 8

! #F8 + # ' 6 8

! 'A8

! ; I 8'

8 !* 8 H 8 $

! F' 8$ $!A 8 H DA$!

OA$!8 ;

! #F8 $ I''8

86 I! '

! #F8 $ $ H ' ;

; * 8

! H$ ; I!! ' H$A 6 8 $$'6 ;' #C8A ! ;; 8

#$ %#&'!

' (& )

& * %#&'!

& '

)

' (&

& '

& ' &

& # ' ,%#-

#&.

& " & ,! ' (-

' '

& '

+ . #&

, %

' %& ,

& ,

& ' %& ,- . &

& ' &

& *&

& -

& (..

' & ,!

& .

',- *! '

& #, /# . . & ' %& ,+ 0. (..& .

'' .

& '

& + 12+ 3.'

. #- &! "

& ( ,! *# &'

& %#&'! ' ,%# & '

+ 0.

* #'!

%& ' %& .

' ( & ,

, ,

,/# '! %& . &

',&4&, &+ 5#.

,! & '

'! ,%#

' - ' , &&& *' *& ", (

&& 4

'+ 0.&

%& .

#', .

( * ',

& ' %& # - .&

'"'.

' + !

& ' ' ,%#

, - (.. , '

! & '

- *!

%%'! %&#& .& #. & ' %& # .

#', * ,%& ,

, , #& ,+ 6 7+ & 5#& + 5

8+9+ :7+ & 5#& + 5

8+9+- ;<<< ; 5== 2 ;<<< 5== =& >12 ;<<< 1<< = % = 12 ;<<< 6?5= 2@A . = #&

*&,$ 5==%+@2-% & B CB+ D 6 *

&- (.. ''!

' #&- .

& '

+ =& ' %& ,

& #

.& & ,

*' (+ E

& # %&

& '

#& .

& , '

# + & .

& #

&+ 0. = #& .

, & %&%'

. *

(.. . H. = #& F& I#&, #,& 5 @B;

. = ,+ J#&, #,& . .

* F&, %&

. %&

! " # $%" & '

'( ) ( *

' + ,* )

- ( ) * '+'

) ' ' ),'

, . + ( '' ) ' , (

) '

* ' '

' ) ' + ) +'.

)

* ) ' , (

' " / ,

, + - + +

)

, 1 234565 ) 7'.

' ) * , ),' "8 )"9 $:" ; 5 '

< ' 5," =< ' 5," *" >?65 < @". A244BC B 155 DB E A244BC D 155 A5 C $FF E 244B <>15 %32G

( (

(

' * ,' * '

) ' " ; 5 + *

+* ' ,*'

* ' ' ) ) ) ( 7' ,

' H " ; 5 '

, '

) + ('

) ' , .

))

') " ; 5. ' ( ' ' +

I" 1( 1 *" 1 J"6" =I" 1( 1 *" 1 J"6". A2444C 2 155 BDB E 2444 155 A5 C 3$D E A2444C $44 5), 5 B$D E 2444 <>15 D%G '

' * '

, ' )

*'* ) ' . + ,,' ( ,

( ) ' ,

' + ,

(" ; 5 '

+ * (

'( ) ( *

' + ,* )

- ( ) * '+'

) ' ' ),'

, . + ( '' ) ' , (

) '

* ' '

' ) ' + ) +'.

)

* ) ', ( .

' " 9 F" K , ' L<M *'

,' * '

" > ( +

) , 7

( +( ( . (" ; * '

#$ %! "$ #! # "

! &"

'! ! !'

( !! # & '$ '! (# "!!) *) +! $$ #! #

! $$ &) , #'

-./ )123 45)43)1425 ! 6"

714 745 .89 $" 6

9$ : ! ;'

$$ # "

( <'!)

==>?=@A?=B C@ADE F F G)H I!#%

K L!J0 I# $ K L!J0