Neraj Chaudhary & ANR. v. Ut Of Chandigarh & ANR.
!" !# !$!! ! !#! # % #
& '(') '
'
*' (
!& +", '
- !! - !"! #!!$
%& $- '# & $- (
% !
# %&$-
'
) * + , -", * *,
! %
**''..''/, !
0
- 0,
**''...'/, ! 0
- 0 **''..1'/,! 0
- 0, "2 " !$-!- !! 3 **''..''/, # 2 % " !//4'// '''//5 , +" 1 +" 6 - 7
!",89. ,07",89.0 % '''//5 ' "2 % % 3 **''...'/, # 2 % " !/4'// '''//5 , +" 1 +" 6 7", 89.
% '''//5 ' "2
%% 3 **''..1'/, # 2 % " ! 814'// :/'// 5 , +" 1 +" 6 7", 89.
(
% :/'//5 ' "2
%% !! -# # *4
% , ;<=! > ,0*4 % 0
#% 4 $ *4 % 3# , "%-% **''..''/ " /:/8'//,# .(/ *,#
' $ " # + + ! +% , 7
3 ", % = # !%$ #
'#% !" $ # # /?% #! *!?
#!"!$ "
$" ! 7
3 " ! #! !?
!
5 ! $
$ #!" !
, #, % # /8/8'// !! "
! "# 7",89.$" ! @5, !$ #
! " !" 16A!?
! , % "# 8/A
!!%," ! +"1 6 7",89.$ ! % '''//@ # " !, B
"! *%, % ?
.
"%C" -
%
'''//5 ' 3# , "%-% **''...'/ " /:/8'//,# '.9 *,#
'$ " # + D <,7 3 ",
% =
# !%$ # '#% !" $ # # # 9?%
$ "
$ " ! !
#!"! ' !$? # 7 3 " $ #!"!
!
5 !$ $ #!"!
, #, %
# /8/8'// !! "
! "#
7",89.$" ! @5, ! $ #
! " !" .8'A!
! % "# '9/A !!%, " ! +" 1 6 7",89.$ ! % '''//@ # " !, B
"! *%, % ?
"%C" -
%
'''//5 ' 3# , "%-% **''..1'/ " /:/8'//,# '(/ *,#
9
' $ " # + + ! +% , 7
3 ", % = # !%$ #
'#% !" $ # !% %,%,!!% "!!?
,<, , , %-
" !4"$ "
$ "!
! ,"
" !!%% - "- - 7", 89. , , " ! +" 1- 63 7",89. $
!.8 7
!,899$ !
%
% :/'//,
$ +"6 7", 89. !! -# ! "
!!%% !% " ! % % - 7",89. -!
# ! !",$" ?$ 7 + + ",'//6 ,07++", '//60 " #% " - " 5 (4(4; # $ # - " 7++",'//6 -#
!"#!3! % 7++",'//6" $ '8/1'// 3! - "$" /:/8'// % -# - 7",
6
89.$ "
! , , #! !$ !#!#2 ",
! !
$ - !$ #
! " !
-#% !
! - 7",89.+" 81 7++", '//6 $ # % " '8/1'//
" @ +" +"
! 7++", '//6 ! $ /9/:'/-$ "7 9/'94.4'/ 7E /./:'/ "
, %
-#% !
% - 7",89.$ "
$ "
- 7++", '//6 $
!"#!
" !!% " 3 - ! " ! " > " ! - !
" !;- - "5 (4 (4;$ # - " 7++",'//6 -#
!"#!+"81 7++",'//6$ % !
-% #
!"#! - "
'8/1'// " $ " /:/8'// @" +" 81 7++", '//6 #
!"#! - " '8/1'//, !" ! $
" " 7++",'//6,!! !
1
"% % "! 7 +
+ 3 # C ! $"" # "! % ! " , %, # ,! , -!#!
$ !
" ""
$ " ! +" 7", 89. ! , % "- #! !$ ",!
!, % - !
" ! " !
# - 7++",'//6" " $ " - "5 (4(4;, 5 !,+"(6.1 7++",'//6, " 5 (47, " " $ (/1'//8,+"8','('8,((9,.::/,:8,8.8: //, "5 (4;" " $ '8/1'// + " " @ " +" +"
! !! ! "
!;-
# ! + "
" !% " @ #
/./:'/ " @ ! $ /9/:'/+ " 7 + +
!,'/ #
#! ;C 3 - ;+ (6'
F 9 * ,'/ " "/9/:'/
:
% -#% !
- 7",89. ! % 7",89. -#- # +"81 7++", '//6 3 -" -!" ! " ! 3-$ % -" # ! " !
, !!$% " # )
!"
# $
% & ' ()
&
*
+ D 3 !$ ,$ !
#
" !- - 7++", '//6 "+"(,:8,81 8: ) , -....
, -....
,/-0 '
1
& & 21$
&
&
&
8
3
# &
# &
# & & &#
!"#
4, - '
1
&
2
5 5
6
67 ,-
& &
8
,- &
& *
&
2
8
,-&
&
&
2
8
,-&
&
&
&
&
& & &
&
&
6 , -0
&
# &5
9 1
'
/
:,
:-
&
5 #
,/-;#
2
& 2
#
.
&
&
,"-;# & &
# % $
2
.
&
&
$
% #
;#
2
5 5 &
*
2
5
#
& &%
2
%
&
&& &&%
< " /./:'/ ) =0 .
#
& 4 , - : 5 &5 9,/"
9- '
1
&
5 5 5 &5 9 )%)%
# !
<
7++",'//6"! !$!% #! 7 + + 3 ! % $""# "! % ! " ,%, # ,!
, -!#! $ !
" "" $ " ! !%! "-#" $ !$ $!! "
"%-! - 7",89. 3 7++", '//6 $
!"#!$ ':/9'//: - 7++", '//6,
! -# -# "#
" -#? "+"( 7++",'//6?"! !!" " "
!;- ,# " @ "!;C,
, #
- " # ",!
- $!! " " $ " " ,% # 7++",'//6" " " ",
'
$!! " $ 7 3 " " " %
7",89. ! % " +"81 7++",'//6
! " !% - !!
% #? " !!
- # 5"+"81 7++",'//6
+" 6 ;! ! ",:81 !
" ! # $", "
%- - " "!!
! -%"! $" !
+"81 7++",'//6-! $!!" "$ "
!;-
# ! " '8/1'//5 (4;$
% #% " +" 81 7++", '//6
" /./:'/ # - $ "
" @ +" +"
! 7++",'//6 ! 3 !! /9/:'/, "
/./:'/,7",89.
! " , +" 8: 7++", '//6 -" %! +"8: 7++",'//6" "! $ "
) G$ % ! " @ " +" +"
!, , 2
- " ! % !
(
@ ! +"
! !!" # " !!
$ " " ! % ! F
! 3 ", !?$7 + +
!,'/ -#
#! /9/9'/ +" 81 7++" '//6, " /./:'/ !%" @ +" +"
! 7++",'//6, # 7++",'//6" " $ /9/:'/ 2 "#
"#? - ",
!, % ! @ ! +" +"
! !!"
!! - "!! ! "# 7++",'//63 "! # - "
+"( 7++",'//6, - 7", 89.
!, 899, , $ !
%?!!/./:'/ - 7", 89. " # - 7++",'//63
", " $ " /:/8'//, ,
% - # % !
- 7",89.
!,899 3-$ #-,3
'(') .
/0 - 12
-?
1