Gora Lal Goyal And ANR. v. Ravinder Kumar And ANR.








































































       



   




































!"

# $%&%!'


((

   ))  ) * 

((  %%!' +& , +&-&

,

. 

* 

((( &/!'# '&    0)

( 1

1 1   




 


 
 

 
 






 
!
"



 
#$% 

& 1 1  2 ( 3 )4 
(

 


#

)*&
++ 

,# "

 
$#"-

&./*&/0
12#
3)4
 %(
 


!#"
5 

%(
 

 "
 


/0/)&/0
12#
3.4

%(
 
!

6+ 5 
#--"
 


#

.7
++
 %
 

86
9

*/:&/)
12#
34
#


)&/;.)
6+



+
+(
5  & 
%


-"
-
 
"

 



<
(
1
;-4
"
"
 -
86

 
"
 
#

<

 





-#"
.//
,
(
-"



):9:
-
1/304


)7/;0:)7;&
#












































































9

"




5 


 
&0/:&//&

<

 




#- 1
4




&)/7&//)



 
 (


-



#-%
'





#-

 
-


 
-





(
 

-




&//* 
#-

#
 
-
 
 

(
 
-



#-%
 
 

 




/*/&&/.
-
 
6+6+6
5
5% =

5 
"
 

<

# 


 (

#-

..&/0;3

#

 


%(
 -

 (

,#
'


 


%
 
%(
 #
#"

 . 
#"
"



<


# 


 
%(
 




+ +(
5 




 
 (


(
  

%#


--

#


#- 1
4
) #"
 
#

 

 
#
-
 
#

.7
++

#--

#- 1
4



#
'




  
%(
 
+#

!

6+
5 




/0/)&/0 
(

 



2

2#
3.

 

9 ""

 
-
$#"-


#-
1
4




%
 
+#








































































 


!#"
5 

 
#--"

 

%(
 
+#



!#"
5 
 $#"-

&./*&/0
12#
3)4
' 
(

 
 $#"-

 


!#"
5 

2
 2#
3)

 

6

 




#
 "

 
  0 

#

 
;- 
 

#-
1
4


,#
(
 
#


 

 

 
 
(
# 
%(
- -

<

# 




-
(
#-% 6






-#

9*///;3

 
 #


<

 

 


2#
%(
-
 #

 


&//*

 

 
 (


-

#-%

#-
1

4

,#(
%
"

 
 
#

 
%
"

(
#--
%(
 
'
+#

"(  "
%(
 
< 

+#
>
  
 

#(
#
 
#


+#
"
 
3
#-



 
(
 
 -#"

%(
 


!#"
5 

%( 
#-
1
4

 "
%



%
#--






#
"

 #
(
"









































































 : ?
 
 

 

#


3 
#-

 
 
 "

-
 ,#(
""
%(
 
#


<

# 

 
 
 



&)/7&//)
2#


# 
 
-

 
 
(


-
 #-%
6



(

 

(
#
(



# 


 
 


-
# 

 

 
 

%

%(

<

 
(


 -#

#"
 
 
%




%-
 

 
#"

-#




 (

 



 



#-
 9*)//;3

 

#


<


-#

 %
  
%(

<
'





<




# 




 

(
 

%#

- 6

 


 
 
$#"-

 "
 &./*&/0
12#
3)4

%(
 


!#" 5 

"

(
%
 * 
#


&3 

  

#"



%
#--





 #

 

#




%

- 
#%(
"

 
#
"

7 6


 

#

 


" 
/
5
"
# 

 
-

#
%
 


 



.7
++


.7
++


# 3









































































  

 



    



     

    



  

   

      

              

      





  "

 



 

          

    !

 

 #



 

 "



 

        

  



 

 

  $ 

  

   "

    





      

  "

 

   

     

 !

 

 %

 "



     

 

& 

& 







   

     

& '  ( 

! 













      "

)  *   

           

    + 

@%
#-
+#

 





   

 !

"

#$
 
# 3
, -./ ,./   

  



!)



"

" 

    1 

 

  "

"

  










































































                  )  !

1 $3

%  "

"        

  

           "

    ) * 

 

  





  



 "

"        3  

     

       

               

  

 !



    

  

  



             4

    

  

&



 

    

          

     



+ A- 
#B 
@%
#-
+#

 


%  

    



34

(( ( 3+%5%'

 



# 3
 .5

06

"  7      

    

!

        

    8 6     0   "

"

 

!

 

  

   

    !

    8 6 



  

.

   

 

*  )  "

 !     )  

 

    

       )   

 



  








































































 

    

"

3   8 6  

 

 

   

 !



  .







   

  

        

   

 



 

 $ 

"

 

   "

   



 !) 







  

3

"

        8 6  

 "

" !

 2  && 

"





   

 & 2       

"

  

  



  "



   

  

   #  3        !

     

     



 !)



"

"



 

     



 



  4.9    & 

3  

  

 "  7 5

06



   

:
;$ )*







 



     



       <

 "

" 

   



 

   



 



$ &= 7  "

/)!0

   9( >#?%  9"9 "

  %@:#?A 9 $ 2= 9$= ;A:#?% 0""#B   








































































 

( !

   



   


+   
  +   

       



 

   

  

  

     

    

  

   





 

 222222 ?;  

 

   "

"    

 

  

.

 

          

       

 .

 

   C



=     

              

 

 D 





      

        

 

  

   

  !

 

?A3  

 

         



   

 !    & 2    



    





    3

  

    



   

      

 

   

 



       !   .            

  

   

 

 

  "

" .0 "

" 



!
 

   










































































      

 +       
  

 



    +3      

 
   

 

!

+3





 



 

"

"        





  .  

  

       

   

5

0E  

 

: 



"

"

 



    

   



  

  

 



 

  

     E  

  

 

 

     3 E E

   



   

"

 

. 

 

F 

 .D  

       

           



  

    "

  !)

 

"

"-

        2  &&       &

2              )    

 5 !

  

 

!

  "



  "

" 

  

  

      

       

 3  

       

    

   



              








































































   



    

   D 



   

     

"





 .

 

  !

 

3

      





 

        + A- 
#B 
@%
#-
+#

 


& "       '



 !

"



 # 3
3



"

   

" 



 

  

     :

G  

 



    



    &



   

 



   

  

  

   





   



 



 

 

 

 !

 

 #



 

 



 

        

  



 

 

  $



 

  

      

  

 

   



   

 !

 

 %





 



&  &








































































 









 

    

& '

 ( 

! 

  









  

)*      

   $ 

!   

  

   



   

   





     

  

3 )    0 

G 

   GG 

GG   

    G  .

   



     

 !

  



  



 

 

"

   

"     

3

    

    

  

 



      



3"

 



   

  

 0 "

   

"  

 !

       



 

  

 



3

       

           

.





  

 

 

     



 

 3

G 

G

 

 . 

!

     

 

 !



    

 




















































































1- 
#4








































































 
@%
#-
+#

 


( )  * +!  +,              %         - 

 !

"

.-


# 3 %



 " 

  "

   

  

 

 



   



  

 

    

  

        3

  

       

    

 (!

       

 < 

  

  

  

 "

  !

          

  2   )     

     

 )



3   G G0 



   !

"

<

0&  %   



!    

   

  

 



   "

)* 

     

   3    !

 0& %      

*  



  !

 

  )                   

0

H)9 !-0$ #??A#

9"9"

  I?I:#??A# $ 2"

 I
1- 
#4 & +-"
%

 


 



-(
% 


#
 

<

2#




# 

#-
1
4

&)/7&//)

 

  
(


-

#-%

#-








































































 1
4

 
(

 

-;



&//*

#
(



# 
 
- 


 



&//*

-

 

 


&)/7&//)
'



 
 


 
 





/)
(
#


 

 # 

 
#
6


 



(
  "

 
#-%

 
(

#"





 -#


%"

(




8# 




%-
 

 

 


#"


 (



2#
 



#

 ;-



#-

9*)//;3

 
 #


<

 
6+6+6
5


-#



  
%(

<
'





 


(


<



# 




--
 

 ,#


 
 "


. 6
 
"



 
-
#


 



#-
%(
 
@%
#-
+#



 
  
#

.7
++


(
 


23 (


 
-


%
2
"(

(

  


 
#-

 



?(


"


"
-

%
"


-
 

 %
 
+#
 
#
 
 #
%
2




# 

-
'



  




%
- ,#
"

 
-
%%(


-(
6
 

 

 "



#%
 
 












































































(

#(


(



(

 -
#





#--"



# #

.7
++




 
 
#
) 6


 
%
6


-

 

 
 
 
-

- 31 1  4

 
((

 1

78 8 + &/ 9%':;+ &!' #

&;!

78 8 + + /!+ <6 

&;!