← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/562/2003allowed

Harminder Pal Singh v. State Of Punjab

2019-01-25Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice Raj Mohan Singh10 pages

 

        

 !""

 

   

#$"

%&'"

()*%++, ++&& , '  %, -.  + 

  ! 

#-"

()*'), " ++&& , '  %, -.  + 

 

""

/0"

% " "  , #-"

()*'), "  ) +   #$%& '()*+#,-./0+ $1/234$#%$  '()*+#,-./0+$#/'5+#3/'643/54, %

 '

- )1! 1 )++&&   

1  ',)"')$  $2")  1! 1  )++&&     4"5')$4)") 1! 1 )+ " "   6 6  ' % ' 7"

1" " &! 8 &1%, -.

$1/234$#%$7  !!$$ 9, " &0 ! "

&"

 ) !."

( 

1  

 6 61 )$."

("+.:!$$

-,($

 7)+ ++& !"$"

&"" "

 " , ("

 )-,($  

1 .:" " &'"  /,(1; 7!5, 1<,)"

1"

'"    6

1 "0)"!)!!,#-"

()*'), " #$"

%&'"

&"%++,10)0!)(0" )  " ) !+, ").& , '! "  =6>% '! " ? )$! 10! "! 

 !, '! "  =6>% , ("$+" $ &"

 +:"

  1=!) "

,& +:$ "

1  , ), ("(,"$+" $  0: ++&& #-"

()*'), " 0&! "!   ! , ("(, "$+" $  0:, '! " ? )$! $","

( )"&"! & & +:"

1= "

,&  +:$ "

1 , ), ("(,"$+" $ +" "@$ )  7)! )+!, "  , )&&" )  

 %A/0"

()( !)"  $   )!  ) )" . ))"

()* ) ,1   -'"

() /(-"

()1" "&&((0&<+/( 10+  )), )"

()" , "

)&&1 #(."

( "

()* , "  '"

()')+  10'.B" "1 <,)"

1!$  )$  & ) ))( $& ! " 0" ) #-"

()*'), " #.)- '"

()1%++, 8,&.

()1  )+  5+1  '.B"   "  7)  +   ),$"&"   )"$  $)" ,.

#9, /0"

()!$+&"

1)" . ))"

 -'"

() !!$+ :)"$ '.B"

 " (  )"+,  & 7):0  '.B" ""

 )!

 "

() > 0., 3 %    )  "$ 7): ++" 

)+   10)"!).& ( "

()* , " #-"

()*'), " %++, 8,&.'"

()& (0" ) =+ 10) 0, " ""1!$ !   )$ /0"

()( 0

$ )! 0  #-"

() /0"

() "  & )$  %++, 8,&.'"

 )+  "

( ) "  )  )!$+&"

+ :),&  .+  ):

),&. ,() & )&+"

("

() >  )$ "$1 #-"

()*'), " 5&$)"+!5 #") 0)"

() )"

()&&0   )(,  &$0" 7)!!,&0:$ )+ )" " $ "$ > 0&  "

 )!$+&"

 )  &" !!" "

()* , " #-"

()*'), ") "+,  7).:0 + $ $@$"

!" 0!  >  "( " 0!$+&   !)&& 0+, ,+  !$+& " && )!&$&" "  7)+!, " @$"

 ,$.0"

"

,++  )! 7)  $  )!!,0&!, '! "

 %  7): " )! )+!, " 7)!!,@$"



0"

"

 ! 7)!!,0! "!   !1

 "!. '+ ++&). "&.: )++&& ("

 )-,($  )&  "&, % " " /0"

+& ()1. )!)"

()"& )"!"$"

& ""  ) !$  ! ( !$+  "   ) $"&:$$. )!

6 <   !, &  ++"

(    .)&    )  ++&&  )$ &:(, )  )+!, " )"& +" ! <  !, &++"

( )'  )$ &:(, )  )+!, " ) +" !.:  .&,.  ,++  )-,($   )& , .&010)& !, & )+ " "  ,.$"  )  !$:5"

&:.  ) !  !$+  " . 0  )$"&:$$. )!  A))& !, & )+ " (  ),() )-,($ !:!,&&:

?

%A? )50 '"

()  "" ) 

 .,     %  1  ) & ( 0" )     "&  4$      8( + ! ,!  )+ $ $@$"

  ).:)"

&" ) , 7):  "! )&&0"

("

-,"  <! 0, 6$$"

"$ 0" )"

  $("

 ,, "

(5"

0.,"+ 

)  &  !&"!&  (" CC  $  $"  &"

1 !+ "

()&0  )!& ) <! 0, 6$$"

"$ 0" )"

  $("

0" ).,5"

  ).!5 !5 & " CC$$"&"

   <! 0, 6$$"

"$ 0" )"

  $("

0" ).,"5"

., CC. $"& "

-,:   <!  0, 6$$"

"$ 0" )"

  $("

+  $"&!

 ),"() :  <! 0,  $$"

"$   ).!5 !)    &  "  "

  !+,&  ("  0" ) !+ "

()&  )!& )  ",0&&"

( )& +" &("

D: ).:0 5 1)0"

( )

.,&&      "

 )  5,&&1     "

 &  $   "+)($  "

& ,+!&"!,&("

7)!, )0, )$)( )!5 ,& "

-," " &( 10)"!)0,"!"  !, )"

"

:!,  , && )"

-,"0 $ $"

 , # ++ $ $+ 1E@ % 7)+..& "$ ) &+. 0

)"

-,"  )0"$$"  . 0  ) ) +  $ $@$"

0., 3), #!&"" ) "

-,"!,&. , "$  %A/0"

()" ):0"

 #& (0" )  -'"

()0" "

("

 )),)". ))"

()&"

) ,"

0#(."

(10) "

()&" , :   '"

()1!$ ) # & ) ))$"+, 0" )#-" ()&"'), "  #$"

%&'"

()&"%++, 7):) $)" ,.

#5 )$ !!$+ :)"$ '.B" "1 <,)"

1  & )"+, . 0  )$ 7) 1)!!$+ " )". ))"

()&" ) ,  -'"

()"

 )! & (0" )"

()&" , : 7):!)0'.B" "1 <,)"

1 ., 3  %  7)&"() 0   )'.B" "

&!&" : 7):+5 )"!"

 ')+  7)++&& & ( 0" ) = )+ 0+   )+ #5 )!!,   & )$  #01#$"

%&'"

()&"%++, )", " ""!$+ "@)  )  ):),&. ,()  &  ):.  + !!,#-"

()")  )" . )  )"

+&  '"

()  #  &&  0  !!,  ! ,  ""

( &(  )  )!$+&"

),&. ,() & )"

!&&+ 7):! ,""

(&$ 7)!!, 0:$ ) + #0   )+&"! &( )+ #-"

()*'), 0"

( "

)"+ ! #$"!&,  $  ) )) 5+ ! !& && (0" )"$+ " ) ."

 ) 8-&$")&:"

("

)"), 7)"!&,  $ "E@ % &0!""B,$$1E@ %E 7)$&"! !0 & 5 +" > )"!@$"

1)$"  ) )" . )%$-" '"

()&!)  )+ #"),0 " !  F5"&$ $ )),)"

()! #, )"

()0 " ! 5"&$ $ )+&! !!, ! )"

()!0&""

(+ &: )& ., 3= :"

!  7)!1"

0)"!) ): &&10  5 +"  %A   -'"

())!.  )  $  %A /0"

+&  '"

()    )  $

  "

 0)"!)  )"

+&  '"

()  0 $, #+ ) )0" "

("

 )),)"

+& () "

()&" , "!$ )  &%A/0"

+& )"

()!.,  )"+,  7):0   '.B" " !!,#-"

()&"'), " !!,#$"

%&'"

()&"%++,& (0" ) = )+ 0&:+

) 7):0!  .: )++&&  !!,#$"

%& ()&"%++," "

 "(  7) 1#-"

&"'), "")  )"

+& )"

()!&&+  ) + #+ ) 0)  ):0 &&"

("

 )!1"

& )$ )  )0"+, . 0 )"$  )!!,+ :

("

($ :$  "+, 0&"(  &.:)" +&

? () ,  ) &$,   61=1!!,#-"

&"'), ")+" 1=  )"+, 0("

($"

( $,  1= > )"!@$"

1)$"  ) ))  & )+&"! ) 0)"& &&"

("

 )!"

()) & )$ .,  )$ :"+, . 0 )"$  )!!, )+&"!)  5)"$ #)&   & )+&"! ) ,  )"$,  61=1  1=)&:. +" "

 ) "+, 0("

( )$"

($,  1= "

)&   & )  )&&("+, ) 5 +&!  )+", :"

 )$ (   %A > +!  (B'"

()&( )+  ." )   $ $.:/0"

() #! )  $ 1E@ % 7) 1  ;>1  E@ %=1  0  ("   #  ++  " 9,  + 1 E@ % #)  ).:+ $ $@$"

# . ) )!!, 6

 #"

( !!,#-"

() # $"!&,  $ 1E@ %1 ( !& . 7)&0 5 +" & (0" )"$+ :! "( 7)0 5 +" !!,#-"

()&+,! )"&"! !&1E@ %?  

7)! )+!, " +!"&:" )  )0$ $ :"+, . 0 "

!!,#-"

()* '), "  7)  $   0  (   &  .: )" +&  '"

()  ! /0"

())+",$ 1=1,  &$,  61= 7)"+, 0("

(+:$ .& !$, "

()0   )),)"

()10)%A/0"

+& %A  -'"

()0+ %A/0"

()1%A

3  -'"

()1"

)"

()0  ')+ 

)"

+&  '"

()  0  5"&&  .:  #-"

  '"

()  0" )  )"  &"!  &  !!"

(    )  ! 1  )  !,     )  0  ,   )$)( )!5,& "

-," " &( 10)"!)0 ,"!"  !, )"

"

:!,  , 7)"

-,"0 $ $"

 , 7)+..& "$ ) &+. 0  )"

-,"   )0"$$"   ) "$. 0  ) ) + $ $ @$"

0., 3),   7)&++&& #$"

%&'"

()&"%++,0 ) )( @) 1 ) #-" ()&"'), "" )  )"

() !"0! $#$"

%& ()&"%++,  6 !!"

(    )  !     )  ;>1  )  ++&&   ) $ ) ,.

"

() > "  $ "

 );> ) )0"+, ("

($ :10)"!)0( &&".:

)"

()! %A  -'"

())&$" "

)" !@$"

 ) ))   & )+&"! )   )0: '.B"

 "1 "

 '"

()  ) &  )$ .,  )  $ : "+,   %A /0"

())&$"  )  )),)"

0 " ! 5"&$ $ )+&!!!, !  #0 &""

(+ &:"

! "

())  &( :!$+&"

("

  )++&& 0" ) )+&"!0) )" ,.

0$ %A

 -  '"

()  "

 )"  !@$"

 )  $"   )  +"    ) !!, !1 )"+, . 0 "

 )!!,+ :0 ( &.:!)"

() 7)0  $" :. 0

)"

+&  '"

()    #$"

  %&  '"

()  *  %++,  7)  "  

" !("

 )"$.,  ) " " ) ))"  7) "+, 1" :10. 0 "

#-"

()*'), 

>  0      +$"    !  7)  !$+&"

 + : ) !) )+ 7)0 "+, . 0 )"

 ) !!,+ : #01 )!  )$ " ) #-" ()* '), "" )"

()10)"!),& "

)" ) '"

!)) , )&"! & " )"

()1)) )"

5"&&)"

()1 ),()))  $" :0" ))"

+& () 7)!, )0, )$)( )!5,&  -," " &(  7)"

-,"!,&., "$+ )   $  )! 10)! ,!  )+ $ $@$"



>  )"!1 )+!, " )&  @$"

"

()0)1!!"

(  )+!, " 1)"+, 0" )#-"

()  *  '), "  7)  +!, "  )  &    +&!    !  :

!,$ 0" )( "

!"&  ! " . 0 "

 #-"

()*'), ?

> "0 )""!," !1 

 



  1"&&0 !!,#$"

%&'"

()*%++,"!9,"  )!)($ ("

 )"$ #" ."& #"."&. "!)(  3   G



    1"+ &:&&0 7)! "! "  !++&&

G#-"

()*'), ", '! "  >%"!   '! "

6% >>% 7)'  ""!  +,!)"$" ,  



.) 9, ,$ !, '! " 6% >>%

 

7)+: )+ " " "

"$"

&""  6 

6  







 

 1 0" ) (  ) !$  !  ," !!"

(&:1 )$  "$"   -"')$ /,(

 

 #"

()'"),   /,( A) )+5"

(=  H=  A) )+ .& H=