Gurcharan Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab

Gurpreet Kaur 2016.11.21 09:46 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document


 

































  

 
 


  








 




















































 
!"
 


  







































!
# 
 


  








 
















































$ % 
 
 


  







































 

 
 














  










  !"#$%%

  & '
(
)"
"*

)( % 
'



!+*
)( 

  

 



'
!
 *
)( 

  



 '
%
+*
)( 

  

&

'



()*

 '
,
 -*
)+
)*




 & .....


' / " 

"


++
 

 (
0 
  

 
1  

'



'

'

()*




 
+%
 (+(

++
 



"
2%(*


-

 ( *



3
"

+,+-.+/0/+/+) 

   
(
 +

 
  

4  



5 6




" 



+* " 


578 



%++



7 5

* % *

 3 



 
)

 

+

"


 

  


 &


 
+


   
# + *




 *

"



   *
 

  
%
 ++
 

 
9 


( 
 
/
%
( 


+
++

:

 
)

 



( 
+ *
;
" 
"


 

 
)

 

%


 

)

  





) "+
2


" 
% 
%
( 


+
++

:

) "+
2


<
( 
=+

>>?

+ *
;
/
" 
%


"


 


 * ' 
<> 
%

 ?*
 +

' 
<#+
# ?
 "

 

)

 
 
 
   

 ;;*
++ 

 +

:

) "+
2


=+

>
( 
+ * ; @*
:/


 
)

 



( 
+ * ;@
 
:


) "+
2


<
( 
=+

>>?
+ * ;
%
+


+
++

:

) "+
2

 <=+

>?
( 
+ *
;;
<& &
++


A;;
+ B?
)


 
+

;;*

 
9 
%


"

 

)

 
 

( 
3  

 
 
"


 

)

 
  7 
 
9 


 
 
 

( 
3  


 
)++
  " 7" 

%


"



  &"& " 
/
 
9 
%



( 

+


;6 & C 7&
  ;5
% 

+ 


 D
 
/

+ %
( 
% 

"
 ;






+




&6

*

8

&6C

7&
<
 
 ( ?
 

85

& C5

7&
<

 ( ?
)++

  
%
 
 "


( 

+


 
"



 (

"
)


 
    *



 
9  *
)

 
 



 
%
"

 

 

%
 (
 



+ 
/*


+
%

(
  &
   

 ;;
/

 
+
% " 
( 
   

; C;;
)

" 
+ *

  
+
%
( 




 

+ 

+



   
%
+ 
( 
 

%
+ 
 

"
/  


 (

+
%
-
  
( 
+
 8 ;;;
  

 

 + 7+    
/
 & 


 


5 6

( 
% 


+   
%
 (
 
"+"  


E
 =""

""  



)

 

*

+"


 

+
%


"




%-


" 
   


"+ 
#
+ 


 

*


  3 


 
(
"

  
%



   *

%

 + 

 
   *
( ++ 

"


5 6

<)

3
&?* " 


578 



 3 

 7( <)

3
&5?
 


7 5

<)

3
&?


 3 


 
" +





 
 3 
  7(




( 
   , 


+


   " 


 
 

( + (


  + +
 



 
  

 3




= ( +
( 
< ( 
 ?

+ *
;;
 


 
%
+ 
 

"
/

 (




% 
 ( 

 

 
 % 


  
F( 
 *
% (*


"  



( 
, 


+
+ 
" 



+



" 

+

F3 (


/
+ * ;;
"


% 

"
C ;;


++
" 

% 

"




  &"&" 
/
   *


"+ 

7
 ( *
%
 

+

%

 
  +


4 + *

   
%
" 

%-
   
%


 
  
)


+( 

  *
"

C D


)

+
=    +
 *
 
  

( 
*
%







/
)

+
=    +


%

 ( 


  

+ 
 

 ++

"+


( 

%

 


 (
%


 , 


+


  

+ 



"

2 @ +

)3
=

%/(/0 (1(&/2(),&(/02
2()*%)+  34%


'%/(/0 (.5()(,&%2(6&20.()7 (2(*8.

4%

 99'%8:2*0,%+)72,&)+) )*+(()*/20.&

34%



'.(;28(5(-<2()*0-=(-,&
2(+.6()'%
()* /20.&

4%


';2+1+/2&2(&/+*(.,&)+) )*+(()* /20.&

4%

  '8-&+(&()*/20.&,&,/ ()* /20.&

4%



'*(5.(/(>%+)72,&%/(/0 +2(. %


'2+/(&2<86(.()*/20.&,&6.(:(&2%2(.6(()*/20.&

4%


'%(/200*0,+,&.(&())(

3 4%




%++


"


=

.(60&2=(.
2()*0.()*/20.&,& 20%/(/0 8)1(; ()* /20.& 3


'
 


 

4'%/(/0 8)1(;()*/20.&,&6(.1+/<(8.28--(.

#(=0.(-*

'(-()*2(.6>.,060)/.8&/'(-()*2(./2.872+/&
2(+.6(),&(?22>(-%+)72*0?0(&0*/2.8722+&#&(.)(+-%+)72 ()*  /20.& 

4  
  3
+,+-4 

'  %8;2(&2 
2()*0.  ,&  %/(/0  

(.5()(()*/20.&

4%


'$#
2>.(,&)+) )*+(

3%8>>4#  './20.))*+()-(&&)*8&/.+0&#+6+/0*,&%/(/0 (.5()(()*/20.&

4
3
+,+-4 
 
.+/(6%+)72()*

/20.&,&%/(/0 8)1(;()*/20.&

4%
 



   

 , 


+


 &






"

"

+ 


+


   " 

   
(
% +
"   


%

 

"  * % *

% +

 

+" 
'(*

+" 


 

+*
% *

(
++

( 

%
     
  
1*
C
 

 

+ ++
%
   



 


+  +


 
 
 
 *
  + "
%
 


" 
  
   
&
) %
!"
%
% +
 (
  

+



 
) "+
2

 *
% *
 % 

" 
  
, 


+


 & + 
" 

(
   
1
 

+ ++

4 
   

4 
 



2 
%
( %


"  
 

 

&+ ++" 


4 
   

 
+ "
%
 
 
 +



(
%



 " ++ *
   
18
%
 

 



 
% 

2 
%
+ 
( %


"  


%
+ 

+ ++ 

4 
   


  

+

"+ 




+
( 
   
6
%
 
 

+

"+ 





( 
% 

"
C ;;;
2
 
%
+ ( %


 

+ ++

4 
   



+ "
%
+  







(     
5&
=


,+

"+




( 
  6;;
 

 
%


 (

 "
"

> 

$  *
% *

%
  +


 
"
 ;;;





(
%



, 


+


 &
+ 
" 

  


  
%
( %


" 
 

 %

+ ++ 

   

    
/*


 (
%



, 


+


 &

+ 



" 

2 @ +

)3
=

%/(/0 8)1(;,&(6#8;2(5( (77( 934%



%++
 "


=

. (&>(-%+)72()*/20.&,&%/(/0 8)1(;()*/20.&

34%


()*.(60&2=(.
2()*0.()*/20.&,&20%/(/0 8)1(;()* /20.&3


*
 


 

4
2

"

+ 


+


  
( + 
 

" 

%++


"
( + +



 + E
+ 

 " 


  

 
  
9  
*
" 


 
 *

  
>

+ 

" 



" 
( 
+ *

"+ *


) "+
2


=+

>
( 
+ *
; *


) "+
2


<
( 
=+

>>?
+

;
 


 
)

 


( 
+
;
%
+



) "+
2


<=+

&>?
( 
+
;;
>

+ 
  


  

( +
;;
G 
 
+ * 
  
%


-


 

+

"+ 
 
 

 ( 



( + + 


 

)

 


   *

%

 

"  * % *


 


 &*


%
 "  +
 

% +
+" *
% 
%


"



"



 

( 

)


 8 ;;;
<)

3
&C?




 &

++
2
 " 

  


 + H 




  3  (+( 
+" 

 

+
 ++


 
  + 7+    


4 + *

 &



 

 
 

+
"+ 

6*
;


6


( 
( 
+

5 6


G 
 

*

%
( 


+"
 
+
%

++%
 +

 
"+ 
% 
(&++
( 

%

 
 
%
  +

" 
% *
AB
(  
%
+  

"
"

C D
)

+
=    +



 


+ 

 *

+ 
%
+

AB
E
 "


 *


"-
"

:)(@
>

+ 

"   

++
+"
 
+
%


 (
% 
 "

> 


$ 



3




% 


"+ 
"+

( 
4 

+"

  
+ )

%  " 
 
"
( 

+  

+


 &*
  
1*
C
 

 

+ ++ %
   

 



 
+ "


 

+
%
 


" 
  
   
&
) %
!"
%
% +
 (
 

+




 
) "+
2


" 


 


+ ++

   

 



2 
%
+ ( %


" 
 
 

"
%
 

 
&+ ++" 

4 
   

  " ++ *
   
18
%
 
 
+


"+ 


 



+
( 

 
% 


 ;;
 
 6;;
2
+ "
%
 
  

 
+

"+ 




+
( 

  

+ ++

4 
   



 

 

+
 6


+
( *

%
 


+ ++

4     

8 8;;;
/
 
%
 +
++%

 "
%  
"
 

% 
++%
"
(  
 " ++ *    
15&
=


,+
%
 
 

6
 (   ;;;
/


5 6

*
% 
(

++ 


 
 *
%




 &" *
% * 
   

%
4 


+ ++
 

% +  +
 "+



/
+ 
 +
+ +" 
 


" 
  + 

+ 

 

%

  


" 

E 
 
" 



+
> 



 

 

" 

" " 

 


+ 
)


 + *

 7  +

  +



( " 



 

( 

  
/ +( 
 


5 6



 
& A

 






 
 


 

  








 
 


 


 

 

  





 





 








  


 

  


 

  

 
!


 



 
"



#

>

+

2 @ +

)3
=

(6#8;2(5( (77("&
 
< ?





 

 

+ 
"
 " 
 "
*

 
 "

 


>
 



 
"


  "

 

 

    
/


 


"

+ 






2 @ +
)3
=
"



" 
2 @ +

)3
=


 (  
" 

+



&
A



4  



(+  

(
+ 

  *


( %*


"++
% 

"


=

% 
 
 


 + 

 H

 
 





  +

  +
  


 
 ( *
"  



++ 


 *
%(*

 
 




3
%


  
( + 




   +*





(

+%
0
(
"

+ 



 "



 "

  *
 *
+%

+ 


 

( + + 



  
>

+ 


3

*

%+


  *

=

 -

 

 +  *

  +



+ 


 


 


 (  
/
=
%+
 "

+
"
  


+"
% 
+

 3 (B  " +
( %

3

(-?6>-500&)+),

)+) )*+(()*.&

3 4%



A
)+ 

 + *




 
(

+ 

+ " 

  

+%*

" ++ *




=

3"


%
 + 




( "
  +


+ % 

%


=
% +


 
 (+  



- 

+



+ 
4 " 


 
E + H
E * % 
%
%

 + 

 - *

   
 *

=

E + H
= 
!"
< ?
( 
G

>  *
==
;<?
C
 
C6
% +
+ 



++*


(


++%

& A
0
 +


  +
 
% 
 "

 




" +
 '  4  

"

 

% 
/ =



 

  *
 

"


  +
( %
" 

++
 
 
( 3
>

 


( " 
"



 + *
(



+


% "* 



*


 *
-


  

 -
/
  
+ " 

 %

"

 (
 

 
 
 "

 

  +

 


  ++
"+ 
% 

"



 


+

 + 
"

   >
%/(/0 $,()*-(-(+&=(-' 34%



*
  


+ 

-



' 
 

 +  




  ++ 

" 
 
+

  + 4

3 
 
%
++ 
+ 
% 

%

 =



 

(+  

+ 

+ 

 "  " *

%

(

++%

& A
86
#*
% +


 

+  + 

) +

6


 *
%
" 

"


*
( 








*

= %+

+%


% 

+ 
+ 
%



(

 

+  

"  
+

+ 4
/
=
%+*

( %



 +
   


"" 
++%
 +
" 

+ 



(

"



+ 

+ *
" 
  

+ 4
'(*

 


+  
 " 
 
+

+ 4
%+


 ++

 "

 " 
+ 
%

=
%+  

( 
 
 -
%
%

 (

 *
 +





+ +   *
  +

"+
 
0


 





 


=
  ) +
6
% +
+ 
% 
+%
+ 
  " 
 (   !

(
G

>  
0 



 

+%
+ 

 "   (   +

( %
% 

+ 


+%
 
 ( +
  

"

* +   *

0


(


+ +
+


++%
"
+


 


 +
% 
"+3
 +"

% 


" 


+ 


  

 & - "+
 

 ++


 
 + + 
+ 
% 
 " 
" *
%* ( 






 +"

4 



+
% *

+





++%


+ +
0
4
% 
(+
 ++% 
"  
 (
E -
$

$.05 ,8* > 

00.-0&&0)0.(-+)()?0()*),0&/60)/
#/* ,0&0.,0(): )*+('

%
9 *



(


 & A
/
  


=




+%+  

 


 

 + 
 -
  


  
>

%++
+ 

 + 

( 
% 

%
" -



3

 

%
>
" 
- % 

+ " 


 
"" 


> " 



 
 

" 

 +  =




% 
 " 
+ 
% 


  

3 
>


  

 

" 
(
"

 " 

+ 
 

" 

 +

+


3

  
> 
"
(
3   +
   +

+
 
=



3

  "
% 
(

 

3 B >
.06+86.()+/0&,%/(/0  % +


 
 =@
%  
% 

+ 
 *

%

(


 & A
>


"


=

"

-





 + 
+ 

3 
 




%

 +
 + 
+ 

% 



 + 
+ 
 
(+(
 3 
" 
+


  


3 ( 
+ + (
  

 
"
B >

 


  
%
 
 

+
"+ 

 
( 

4 
 

+ 


4 + *  

%
 3
 



(
%



/
(  


  
%



 
"


 *

%

 


%

+ ++ 

    
"-
 
 

(
%



>

 




( %



% 


  

% 
 ( 

 
  *
% *

  
%
  +







% 




 
 
/
%


 (    
4
 

%
 


%

%

 ( 

"
 *
% 


4 " 

  + +
  F(

%

 ( 

(
)

+
=    +
  
%

 (
 

"-
  




( "-





)

+
=    +
 
2


 ( 

)

+
=    +
 *
% 
%


)(*

 
+
(
"
   
>

+

(  "

2 @ +

)3 =

%++



=

 

 

 
%

 


  
 
% %+

 
 *

% 



 (    
 
4
 

%
 

 %

%

 (


 
% 
%
 
+ 
/


4 " 

+%

  "

:  + +
 @


( 
 
) +
6


=

  

>  
)+*
  &


+
%

"+

+ 


-


 *
% 

+ 
 "+


  

  + 

 (
 
  

%
"

&  

 

   

 +" 
 ) + *
>
"








"  

(
+
(





 ( 
 

   
(



5 6

%

 ) + *

 (
 
  


 

% 
   











   


 

 ( 
"

 

 
>

+ 
 


(


 ++



- 









































 

 

























































0
- 7  I 0
 + I