Joginder Singh v. Chhinderpal Singh

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND

HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

  

 

 !"

##$

% &

"" #$ !"

#
 ()*+, !

-!./
, (/!' *.


 

  
 

(/!' *.0







 


!



"

#$%&'(


)

)* 
"






+
 





"*
 
 
-.

-.

/- .


!

)"

 
0"

 
1
) 
0  

)* 
* 



 

 

  
"

#%


2 
3"*






   
 !

 4 "
 

,"


*

 /  !
 
"





!
"



"*

56 
"

*
)"

  

       !"#$ %% "$  &
 
" *
 
!








"

#$/
 )

      

 

   ! "# $#



 % &'&

 *




  
)"


 



# 3
  6
 
&"

(

56 
"

*
)"
 
 

#$/

#$%&'(

) 
 
 
 
*

 
* 
 





"

#$/

) 


 
 

)"
 

56 
"

*
)"
 
 

7$

/

 








 

  


1 $2

*

*
*"
 
"





 

"* 
!
!



3

 
 

*
"




!




,"



 "



*







**
!



 





 *!

"

,"
 
" !$2



*
*"








 "

 
"






* 





"

#$'
 ))




*
 





"

#$'

* 





" 

!

* !

*

*
 




*
" !
*"
 



." $2




 
 

  *
"







" 
#$/
"
*  
!




" 
!

*




8 

"

 
  
  
*



9

 !



 

 
"

" 
"






* 




"


"

"
"





 


"
5



 !
 !

3

 




:"


*


*;







+
  


*

5
)"
"

#$%&'(


))
"

 !

 
 


!

 *
!

 )) 1& "$2

  *
 

*

#$%

"* 

*;




"


 
 




 


9


 

  *
 





#$/



 

"





*








"
*


*



1"$2

*


 

 
 



"





 ""
!




 "

* 

"
 



 
* 


/--


))

'#



!

8 

  





))


* 

 

"

*




* 



 

* 


*

"

,"
*"

"


*

*
 


#$/
 


 

*
"

/& (


)








" 

 "!






!
"




*!

 "!

"
 

"



" * 

"

'

/


)"
3  











 

,"







 


* 


5

 "!
"






!

 

!

 
 

 





#$/


))







*




"
*



8

4

3

"* 


 







  
!

*


"


 

 
**


"

 
<-

 ,"
 



!

*


 



 *!










,"

 

"

*



))

*

 !



"



3
"

 


 



"




#$/

"

#$%
!
"

*
3



 


#$/

*
 



"

 



"
"

 
* 




"
*  


   



 

 
!

5
)"

 
"
  
 
 
 




"


*  

9


 


*




* !

* !



* 
"



))


"

"
*


+
  


*

5
)" 3



*



"
 






 

 

*



#$/
"
+
!
  


*

5
)"
!


"
*






"

/--
 ))

* 
"




**
!



 
"
"




"
 
<




*
"




#$/


))


 !





#$/


))
 


 "
+
!




*
#

/ /--.


 

 

"

*"

 
*"



"




!

"
3



 
"


 

*



 





"




#$/


))



 







=
 *






 


"




#$/





" 
&'(


#$%


)) >
9

"


*
"*
  8
)"


 




 



"

#%


2
3


!

* ,"

!




* 

)
* 
  
 

* 
!

)"



'


 '


%(() (( *&

+ ' " $   ,%

 -


%((.&*( 


 
-/ -$ /-/<


%+ '

 %+ %((&/( !"01$ 

 
-$ -$ /-/< < 3



"

* 



  
* 
!
56 
"

*
)"

  6
 
&"

(





*

!






*


)"

 

0"
?"




 

 *


 


"

#$/

)


 

0"
?"
* !
"




* 4




*

"
 
"


  @ 2

  !
 


 
 


 
 
)"





*




)"
 




 * $ ? 
"



)"



*





 


)"
?"



5







 

 

0"
?"




"

"


- /-/< % 
!





* 

 +



 

 

0"
?"  .

 


  (MANISHA BATRA)


JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No