← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7405/1999dismissed

Naresh Chaudhary v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-09-09Mr. Justice Darshan Singh12 pages

 

  !

    

"#$ %$&'(')*+

,  

          *-. /

0   

  

   

 

    !" # 

"

  

0    1 2"3  



     



!  " #$ % %' ' "'

$(! %

   





  

)*++ "& 

, 

  

-  

 ."*/$*) "



0  1+++ ++ & 

2++*+++,

."*$ ** -       

- &



  ."1 $*/, 

  &

&  "

&, ,

"&   "   

  

 " ."1 $*/-  -  

"

# 3# , ! **+1+ "

  ,   

     

+



-   

  $

 "

   

"    



# ' .% " 

4& 5-   6 5 7  & '



8"7 $1++  '912$,   ,     &  

  8"   '

  ' " 

'& $*/* - & "#: ;'

 < "' "

'& $*/ - %

<   4         ."  1 $  */       4& 5    ,

- %     '

   *$  *2+       

  - %    ."1 $*/ 4& 5



 

,

4& 5- 

9

'

 4&& '



8"$1++*1'92

=  

  

$ 9  

  "     ,  "   

    !  ,    - %    ."1 $*/

 - 9 ."1 $*/, , 0 

8"  */*  '

%

  */

= 0   , 

 

 

 "



& '

$,

      

   

 

- &$ ", &     $     

5 ,

 '  & &  &   $

4     

 

, 

&  =

  ,    $ , !.5 

    

"

5 < $0  8$ "    5 <   ,  "  

"





"

4& 5

9 

 , , " '  9 >;'& '



8"$ *2*'9

*

      

  = ,    -     "'

'

' $.

,  "  ***1

- 

,&

 

   "



 "

  

&

,  &   

   

  &""  

    ,

  ,   

,    !   " " =   

   ,

4& 5" 

 ,  

     

* =  " 

 4& 5 

 , , " '  9  '



- & ? !$ ($*2 '9 +1'9 '



- & @4$ *'9907' 1    "

 **7 *1 A B**

=  $"

 &$ 8"'

    */* 8"  

 '   

& 



 9 

&

 " '



*/*8" A

 

 

  

   

' -

& 

 $ '

%  "  A           C

 $   

" 

  &  

 "A  &    '

  %  "



 "   

     

  





&



    " !

 

   " 

'   )* 

  */*  8"    

,      '

  %  "    

 !

"



*/*8"

 =  

 ,  "' ) *

*/*8" $ 8" %    */ 8":

 === 

  

"$ ,  '&:  :*+ 



"$  , " 

"  A B*+            E' * 

"

 "     





 1  

 , " 

   "                  

 

%

" :  **    

 G&G   :  *1    

G& ,4" ,G :*

G'&: G  

"

*/ 8":$ 

$ & 

"

 ",     





:  5$

  

  , " 

"

     

  %   "    

 



$ 

"

"  " */ 8":  



*/*8"  */ 8": ,  "4& 5

9

 



    = 4&G

9  

 

      

  !  "#$  ,    = , 4&G

       1

/ */  ,      , */*8" ,  */ 8"   0    , 

   

  "  3 

   

&     

  ,        



  

 ,   

-  & 

", &  $  

/ */  */*8"  */ 8": 8 ,&$ ,

 



$ 

&     "   ,-  4& 5  4&G 

  

,

  8 G   '    9       

%&'

 ()  *+ %  # , - ./ 0 1  . 

 .  ** 

' + *  

  %.!  

+ " %/#+

%2

+ !.

 

'3   

 

4

+ #

%/"55

%2 

+ %%# +67 

,

 

 %/8" 32 

$  " %%

+   

9    5$  

9  9 . 

    .     ** 8  '  "5  

, 

    

$   %/  +

32

$  ' 85: 

 

 %/+#+ 32



!$5"%&

  

* " %/88 32

*  ! +$   

     

/ */  

,  

    

 

*+, " %

 8"    &       

 

 

   "    ,  

 

=  

       1

/ */  

   

      <   4  ,      ,           

     

 , ,  A 9<%?:HGG  '

'       34 "< 34

 ' 5

9<%?:HG5G % =A #   ,   5   . % ==A .

   #  , 5  3= 3# .

 

% ===A   ' $    %$  !$4,# 9

  9   8 $    #  I$  & '

 ='

6,   "   

% =6A C 

 ,   !5

$5 '   

=   $           



$   8 # 38  34  = 



'

$,  

9 "GG &         $ 

 , $  "

 ,

"A 9<%?:HGG : **+ *+*+1+, 

#    # '      $     

 

  "%

   

 : **+)*+*+1+   : 1+*+ ++   )

 *    &"

9<?%:HG5G ,A : 2+)+3*++* + #A : *1+*/

5

A : * +*+11+

*1

  8"  %    */ 

 , A B'  

  % &  

 8"    " ,

 */



#    

 -   .

  , & 5  $5 < $ -

 ,  A

   & &,     & 

    " &    



  ,

  , "  " 

  



    ,  

    



&

 ,

# G

     ,       

  %

 8"  

   &   

*+  

 , 



 "   &   

          

 ,A B=  

 



 - % &

I4 @

+2 I=:**3/  1  ."$*/  -  

   &$  ,       &

"

&  

  &              " ":& 

$    

  

    

 >& && "

  



  



< 4 $ 

 &   $  ,        "$   "  GG     "  G5G 

  ,   $ 

    $  " ,       

           !     "

 " #        $    %      $        

      "

  

                        $   &@  "$ "

&   " 

    "  4      !     &,          

     " 

$     



' "$   

       

  ' 



 "(     

 



     

  &      ,       



 )  *   &+&&,&          $      -   .&&/&              - .&&/  '

 

   "   $    0 

    - 0-  "                 - .&&/&

  -  .&&/&  /          $  



         

     $     &+&&,&    

& &1&/&#

"' 

        -   & &  &+&  &,&             

  -   

        -                  

 $    &+&&,& 1&/&2#

"'3  

&

           

  

   &    

  1  ."$*/

  &    

%         $          

       







" 

   &

 

&  4 

 "

 ,& 

'

%

 !   &"   &

  

 "  

 &   

? 



= 

 &       "    

%   ,   

       " '

%

 

  $ % & 

8" 

      ,        "  

    

 4  ("#  

  5&6768 )9 ::06;08877 4<. :=6; " $   0   

 " % #        

     

             "  

 

    



0$ 

      $   

            

  &  /   0   

  ,    "  

     

          

   

          0$ 

     $  

         &D           

*+$  

$  "           1

/ */  ,  

      

           

*+ &   3   < 4 ,  



"

  & 

 ,  "    

     

 

 3 

    

   

"

  "   ,,

  "   4& 5 : ' & '



8"7  $9>@

11+

1++$ I "1*$1++2 



9  

      9"

   ,     " '

'

 ' $ .

+ !

 4& 5 9 

 

     & "

  , J



  $ 9 

   ,     

 

-     -   

 "$ &

  ,& 

  "$   " 

    ,   ,,   "

 

0           +

, $%