High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8452/2000dismissed

Anoop Kumar Bansal v. Hy.St.

2017-02-09Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan8 pages

#$% &%'()(*+,

!+ .

/!00 / .

/!0 00 1%)%*$+ !1#2(3$4##450%*(1&3'#$%6($7 !1089%07#14#5&3'#$% 1$7%:%$($(*%1) !1*;81!($$#<5&&<&3'#$%%*%1#<5#1=#*# #2%)7 (*&#< 7%:%$($(*%1)><#*&6*%1)7#3%#::1#'7%&$7()'81$:1#=(*?

1@8#)7(*? $7%#6#1&&#$%&A

5:#))%&9=/#*&'@8()($(* <<%'$15#*'7;8<# 1)71$5.$7%<<%'$1."#))%))(*?$7%3#<8% $7% #'@8(1%&<#*&6*%&9=$7%:%$($(*%1)

1(% <=5$7% #'$) $7%'#)%#1%$7#$3(&%*$( ('#$(*&#$%& A,,-5())8%&8*&%10%'$(* $7%/#*&'@8()($(*'$5, 1 )71$5.$7%, '$."50$#$% #1=#*#)8?7$$#'@8(1% #'1%) <#*&5 )($8#$%&(*3(<<#?%#?#&71(5%7)(<#?#&71(5 ()$1('$ #48*##?#1 1 1%)(&%*$(#<5'44%1'(#<#*&(*&8)$1(#<#1%# 10%'$1)-#*&5#?#&71(

7% )#4% 6#) <<6%& 9= *$( ('#$(* &#$%& A,,5 ())8%& 8*&%1 0%'$(*A $7%, '$7%<<%'$153(&%#6#1&&#$%&A

#))%))%&$7%4#1;%$3#<8% $7%#'@8(1%&<#*& /%#1*%& '8*)%< 1 $7% :%$($(*%1) )894($$%& $7#$ 67(<% #))%))(*? $7%'4:%*)#$(* 8*&%1 $7% :13()(*) $7%, '$5 $7% <<%'$1%B%1'()%)@8#)(>28&('(#< 8*'$(*%()98*&$'*)(&%1$7% 4#$%1(#< :1&8'%& * 1%'1& 9= $7% <#*&6*%1) 1 $7% :81:)%

#))%))4%*$ '4:%*)#$(**$7%'#)%(*7#*&5($()$7%#&4($$%&:)($(* *1%'1&$7#$$7%%3(&%*'%:1&8'%&*1%'1&9=$7%<#*&6*%1)6#)*$ '*)(&%1%& #$7%15 $7% #6#1& 4%*$(*) $7#$ $7% :%$($(*%1) 7#& *$ :1&8'%&#*=4#$%1(#<567('76#) #'$8#<<=(*'11%'$7%1%6%1%*849%1

)#<%>&%%&) $7%<#*&)($8#$%&(*$7%#1%#567('76%1%:1&8'%&9=$7% :%$($(*%1) 1#))%))4%*$ '4:%*)#$(**)8::1$ 7()#1?84%*$)5 1%<(#*'%6#):<#'%&8:*28&?4%*$ *.9<%$7%08:1%4%81$(*C%&#1 #$7 #&#330$#$% %)$ %*?#<#*&$7%1)5

A "(3(<"

#*& $7()81$(* #4!81$(0#1(*#*&$7%1)30$#$% #1=#*##*& $7%1)5

D> "/

*$7%<#)$ &#$% 7%#1(*?5())8%#1)%#) $ 67%$7%1$7% :%$($(*%1)7#& (<%&92%'$(*)8*&%10%'$(* $7%, '$1*$ /%#1*%&'8*)%< 1$7%:%$($(*%1))894($$%&$7#$92%'$(*)6%1% (<%&9= $7%:%$($(*%1)7)%6%1%1% %11%&$$7%81$9=$7%<<%'$1#*& &&($(*#< ()$1('$ 8&?%5 #?#&71(5 3(&% 1&%1 &#$%& -

5 67(<% *$('(*?$7%:%*&%*'= $7%:1%)%*$:%$($(*(*$7()'81$5#&281*%&$7% )#4%$'4%8:# $%1$7%&%'()(* $7%61($:%$($(*57%*'%5$7)% #1%:%*&(*?7%)894())(*()$7#$ (<(*? 92%'$(*)6(<<*$7#3%#*= %

%'$*$7%1(?7$ $7%:%$($(*%1)$'7#<<%*?%$7%#6#1& $7%<<%'$15

D *'%($()(*3(<#$(* $7%)%$$<%&:1(*'(:<%) <#6 *$7%$7%17#*&5<%#1*%&'8*)%< 1$7%0$#$%)894($$%&$7#$ *&89$5$7%<<%'$1567(<%#))%))(*?$7%'4:%*)#$(*5%B%1'()%)@8#)(> 28&('(#< 8*'$(*576%3%15#)7%7#&#))%))%&$7%'4:%*)#$(*#*&(*'#)% $7%1% () #*=%111 (* $7% :1'%))5$7%<#*&6*%1) 7#3%1%4%&=$ (<% 92%'$(*) #*& ?%$ $7% #48*$ 1%>&%$%14(*%& 9= $7% '81$ 9= <%#&(*? %3(&%*'%567('74#=*$9%1%)$1('$%&$%3%*$7%4#$%1(#<:1&8'%&9% 1% $7%<<%'$1*$7%:1%)%*$'#)%5#&4($$%&<=5$7%:%$($(*%1)7#3% (<%& 92%'$(*)#*&$7)%7#3%9%%*1% %11%&$$7%'81$7%:%$($(*%1)7#3(*?

#<1%#&=#3#(<%& $7%(1%

%'$(3%#<$%1*#$(3%1%4%&=)78<&9%1%<%?#$%&$ :81)8%$7%)#4%% 81$7%1)894($$%&$7#$(* #'$53#<8#$(* $7%<#*& #'@8(1%& 3(&% )#4% *$( ('#$(* 7#) #$$#(*%& (*#<($= 8:$ *.9<% $7% 08:1%4%81$(*(3(<::%#<)A >A D

DE*:C84#1 #*& $7%1) %$' $' 3 !F) 0$#$% #1=#*# #*& $7%1) &%'(&%& * A-

D %#1&<%#1*%&'8*)%< 1$7%:#1$(%)#*&:%18)%&$7%:#:%1 9; ) #1#)$7%<%?#<:)($(*$$7%%

%'$$7#$ :6%19%(*?

%B%1'()%&9=$7%<<%'$167(<%#))%))(*?'4:%*)#$(* 1$7%#'@8(1%& <#*&()@8#)(>28&('(#<(**#$81%58<< %*'7 $7()81$(*#4!81$(0#1(* #*&$7%1).'#)%)8:1#":(*%&#)8*&%1+ G *'% 0%'$(* A *$( ('#$(* () :89<()7%&5 ($ () $7% <<%'$1567()$'*&8'$#*(*@8(1=)$&%$%14(*%$7% #48*$ '4:%*)#$(* #*& #**8*'% 6#1& (* $%14)

0%'$(* $7%'$$78?7$7%#6#1&($)%< ()1%@8(1%&$9% #::13%&9=0$#$%3%1*4%*$(*$%14) :13()$0%'$(*

$7%'$08'7(*@8(1='*&8'$%&9=$7%/#*&'@8()($(* <<%'$1()@8#)(28&('(#<:1'%%&(*?567('7&%$%14(*%)$7% 1(?7$ $7% :%1)* (*$%1%)$%& (* 1%):%'$ $7% #48*$

'4:%*)#$(* #*& ?(3% $7%4 #* ::1$8*($= $ )%%; %*7#*'%4%*$ '4:%*)#$(*5 ( #*= <#*& 6*%1 () *$ )#$() (%&6($7$7%#48*$ '4:%*)#$(*)#6#1&%& $%1 $7%#**8*'%4%*$ $7%6#1&5($()$7%<<%'$167$#;%) :))%))(* $7%<#*&567('7$7%1%8:*3%)$)#9)<8$%6($7$7% 0$#$% 1%% 14#<<%*'8491#*'%)H *C%&#1#$7 #&#3.)'#)%)8:1#"5*.9<%$7%08:1%4%81$ :(*%&$7#$67(<%&%$%14(*(*?$7%'4:%*)#$(* 1$7%#@8(1%&<#*&5$7% <<%'$1 () 1%@8(1%& $ ?(3% #(1 ::1$8*($= $ #<< <#*&6*%1)

%$%14(*#$(* 4#1;%$3#<8% <#*&9='<899(*?#*849%1 '#)%) $?%$7%1#*&:#))(*?#'4:)($%#6#1&()*#6#1&(*$7%%=%) <#6 &89$5( #*#6#1&:#))%&9=$7%<<%'$1()$9%%B#4(*%& (*&%:%*&%*$<=5$7%)#4%7#)$9%*$7%9#)() )%$$<%&:1(*'(:<%) <#6 3%1=@8#)(>28&('(#<#8$71($=()1%@8(1%&$&()'7#1?%($) 8*'$(*)(*$%14) $7%)%$$<%&:1(*'(:<%) *.9<%$7%08:1%4%81$(* *&(#*#$(*#< *?1%))"3*)$($8$% 0'(#<%< #1%#*&$7%1)5

" 0A

%B:<#(*%&$7%4%#*(*? $7%$%14.@8#)(28&('(#<.* C1#*$())'(#$%) 1(3#$%/(4($%&#*&#*$7%13!#)&74%&C7#*#*&$7%1)5

", 0 ,A5*.9<%$7%08:1%4%81$56($71% %1%*'%$%B%1'()% @8#)(> 28&('(#< 8*'$(*)9=$7%#8$71($=<#(&&6*'%1$#(*:1(*'(:<%)567('7#1%#) 8*&%1+ G#" * *&(# $7% 28&('(#< $1%*& 7#) #<6#=) 9%%* $ 1%'1& 1%#)*)5%3%*(*#&4(*()$1#$(3%&%'()(*)5( )8'7&%'()(*)

%'$#*=*%:1%28&('(#<<= 9"@8#)(>28&('(#<#8$71($=48)$1%'1&1%#)*)(*)8::1$

($)'*'<8)(*) '"*)()$%*'%*1%'1&(*? 1%#)*)()4%#*$$)%13%$7% 6(&%1:1(*'(:<% 28)$('%$7#$28)$('%48)$*$*<=9%&*%($ 48)$#<)#::%#1$9%&*%#)6%<< &"%'1&(*? 1%#)*)#<):%1#$%)#)#3#<(&1%)$1#(*$* #*=:))(9<%#19($1#1=%B%1'()% 28&('(#<#*&@8#)(>28&('(#<1 %3%*#&4(*()$1#$(3%:6%1 %"%#)*)1%#))81%$7#$&()'1%$(*7#)9%%*%B%1'()%&9=$7% &%'()(*>4#;%1 * 1%<%3#*$ ?18*&) #*& 9= &()1%?#1&(*? %B$1#*%8)'*)(&%1#$(*)

" %#)*) 7#3% 3(1$8#<<= 9%'4% #) (*&():%*)#9<% # '4:*%*$ &%'()(*>4#;(*?:1'%))#)9)%13(*?:1(*'(:<%) *#$81#< 28)$('% 9= 28&('(#<5 @8#()>28&('(#< #*& %3%* 9= #&4(*()$1#$(3%9&(%) ?"%#)*) #'(<($#$%$7%:1'%)) 28&('(#<1%3(%69=)8:%1(1 '81$) 7"7%*?(*?28&('(#<$1%*&(*#<<'8*$1(%)'44($$%&$ 18<% <#6 #*& '*)$($8$(*#< ?3%1*#*'% () (* #381

1%#)*%&&%'()(*)9#)%&*1%<%3#*$ #'$)7()()3(1$8#<<=$7% <( %9<& 28&('(#<&%'()(*>4#;(*?28)$( =(*?$7%:1(*'(:<% $7#$1%#)*()$7%)8< 28)$('% ("8&('(#<1%3%*@8#)(>28&((#<:(*(*)$7%)%&#=)'#*9%#) &(

%1%*$#)$7%28&?%)#*&#8$71($(%)67&%<(3%1$7%4<< $7%)% &%'()(*) )%13% *% '44* :81:)% 67('7 () $

A &%4*)$1#$% 9= 1%#)* $7#$ $7% 1%<%3#*$ #'$1) 7#3% 9%%* 92%'$(3%<='*)(&%1%&7()()(4:1$#*$ 1)8)$#(*(*?$7% <($(?#*$). #($7(*$7%28)$('%&%<(3%1=)=)$%4 2" *)()$%*'% * 1%#)* () # 1%@8(1%4%*$ 1 9$7 28&('(#< #''8*$#9(<($=#*&$1#*):#1%*'= ;" #28&?%1#@8#)(>28&('(#<#8$71($=()*$'#*&(&%*8?7 #98$7()F7%1&%'()(*>4#;(*?:1'%))$7%*($()(4:))(9<%$ ;*667%$7%1$7%:%1)*&%'(&(*?() #($7 8<$$7%&'$1(*%

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

D5#$ :#1# ,#*& *=#3 *(3%1)($= B 1&5

(3 "5 67%1%(* $7% 81$ 1% %11%& $ 1$('<% A $7% 81:%#* *3%*$(* 84#*(?7$)67('71%@8(1%)5 G#&%@8#$% #*& (*$%<<(?%*$ 1%#)*) 48)$ 9% ?(3%* 1

- 28&('(#<&%'()(*)H "*#<<'44*<#6281()&('$(*)28&?4%*$):<#=#3($#<1<% (* )%$$(*? 8: :1%'%&%*$) 1 $7% 8$81% 7%1% 1%5 $7% &%3%<:4%*$ <#651%@8(1%4%*$ ?(3(*?1%#)*) 1$7% &%'()(* () $7% %))%*'% #*& () 3(1$8#<<= # :#1$ G&8% :1'%))H 6%3%15(*$7%'#)%(*7#*&56%*%%&$'*)(&%1$$#<($=

'(1'84)$#*'%) #*& &%3%<:4%*$)567('77#3%$#;%*:<#'%&81(*?$7% :%*&%*'= $7%:1%)%*$:%$($(*$( ('#$(*8*&%10%'$(* $7%, '$6#)())8%&* A,,-#*&$7%#6#1&6#)#**8*'%&9=$7%<<%'$1 *A

7%$$#<#1%##'@8(1%&6#)4%#)81(*? #'1%)?#(*)$$7% #6#1& $7%<<%'$15$7%<#*&6*%1)7#3%#1%4%&= (<(*?92%'$(*) 8*&%10%'$(* $7%, '$67('75(*$81*5#1%1% %11%&$$7%'81$ 1 1%>&%$%14(*#$(* $7%'4:%*)#$(**$7%'#)%(*7#*&5#&4($$%&<=$7% :%$($(*%1)7#&#<) (<%&92%'$(*)67('76%1%1% %11%&$$7%'81$#$ #?#&71(#*&6%1%#&281*%&3(&%1&%1&#$%&-

5$'4%8:

# $%1$7%&%'()(* $7%:1%)%*$61($:%$($(*81$7%15#*$7%1 #'$918?7$ $$7%*$('% $7%'81$9=<%#1*%&'8*)%< 1$7%0$#$%()$7#$3#<8#$(*

$7%<#*&#'@8(1%& 3(&%)#4%*$( ('#$(*6#)'*)(&%1%&9=*.9<%$7% 08:1%4%81$(**:C84#1 #&#3.)'#)%)8:1#"#*&#))%))4%*$

'4:%*)#$(* J 5 F>:%1)@8#1%=#1&5#)&%$%14(*%&9=$7()'81$5 6#)8:7%<& C%%:(*?(*3(%6$7%# 1%)#(&&%3%<:4%*$)567('77#3%$#;%* :<#'%&81(*?$7%:%*&%*'= $7%:1%)%*$:%$($(*5(*81:(*(*5($6(<<9% #*%B%1'()%(* 8$(<($=*6$1% %1$7%4#$$%19#';$$7%<<%'$1 1

#))%))4%*$ '4:%*)#$(*5%3%*( 6%'4%$#*:(*(*$7#$$7%#6#1& )8

%1) 14(<<%?#<($=!#21($= $7%<#*&6*%1)7#3%#<1%#&='*$%)$%& $7%(1'#)%)#*&?$$7%#48*$ '4:%*)#$(*&%$%14(*%&9=$7%81$ 1$7%1%#)*)4%*$(*%&#93%56%&*$ (*&#*=1%#)*$ (*$%1 %1%(*$7%:1%)%*$:%$($(*#$$7())$#?%7%)#4%()5#''1&(*?<=5 &()4())%&576%3%15$7()6(<<*$&%9#1$7%:%$($(*%1) 14:81)8(*?$7%(1 4#$$%1):%*&(*?9% 1%$7%'81$9%<6#$#?#&71(567%1%$7%92%'$(*)

(<%&9=$7%4#?#(*)$$7%#6#1& $7%<<%'$17#3%9%%*1% %11%& 11%> &%$%14(*#$(* '4:%*)#$(*7%4#$$%1)7#<<9%&%'(&%&9=$7%'81$ 9%<6(*#''1&#*'%6($7<#6 #2%)7 (*&#<"

8&?% #1(*&%10(*?70(&78"

8&?% ,

- 4;

7%$7%1):%#;(*?F1%#)*%&+

%)F 7%$7%11%:1$#9<%+

%)F