High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11055/2026allowed

Chandan Kumar Alias Chandu v. State Of Punjab

2026-03-11Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

11;

!"#

C7&%"%"'& 8& # # * $%%&'( ) C7&#-' &% %&'(&+"# %&'(&+"# %&'(&+"# %&'(&+"# %&'(-!' %&'(-!' %&'(-!' %&'(-!' , , , , &#&%, &#&%, &#&%, &#&%, #"', #"', #"', #"', + + + +011;

011;

011; "., "., "., "., + + + +011;

011;

</7$

$ / / / / 7&*.!0 8'+%&(' 7 "#"0 8'+%&(' %& -&%"%"'& 7 7 &%.. =!0 )*7 >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> / / / /073/5 073/5 073/5 073/5 $ $ $ $ &#&%#&+' -&%"%"'#*&& ("!& & $&+%"' 92'(%& & $$0112 3$&+%"' 2?'(%& 7775#&& &6".. %'( &.

! *"!%'%& & -&%"%"'& 0 " +#& *& ". '7;@

2727110 &."#%& & (' %& & '((&+&# - "#*!& & $&+%"' 1135 '( %& +'%"+ .#

#4+'% '-"+ *#%+&#+%0?93(' #' % %A $+%<53$&+%"'113+5'( ( %& $ +%

!%& '50 % '!"+& $%%"' "%4 "

6'%0 "#% "+% "

6'%7 17

&. 8&'(%& "B &#%"'"#%%%&-&%"%"'& "# ++ #& '(* &"."8'!8& " -& %"". %' $+%"8'!8".!!&.&

&+'8& 4'(9 9#% "-#3&++'%"".%*!& &%#50%'%!9%*!&%#'(%":'! '- '

'!'! '+!' "

& *!&%#%"': 3=&".".@71.5( '%& & -&%"%"'&

"#+'++ #& 0&!40&& &8"7

1 27 /& & +'

#&!(' %&-&%"%"'& #"%& %& %%%&-&%"%"'& "# " + #%'

4 #"+& 2727117 /& & +'

#&! (' %& -&%"%"'& # ( %& *"%%& %% %' 4- '8"#"'#'(%& $+%8&'%#+ - !'

#!4 *&& +'-!"& ="%0 % #0 %& - '#&+ %"' +#& # ((& # ( ' "& &%

&(&+%#7/& & +'

#&!(' %&-&%"%"'& #"%& %& %%%&% "!"# &!4& %&!"*"!"%4%& &'(+'%*&(#%&& -'%&-&%"%"'& 7/& & +'

#&! #( %& "%& %& %%%&-&%"%"'& ## ((& & "+ +& %"'(' ' &% ?'%#7 #0 &.

! *"!"#- 4& (' 7 7 /& & $%%&+'

#&!#'--'#& %&- &#&%-&%"%"'*4 .

". %%%&!!&.%"'# "#& ."#%%&-&%"%"'& &#& "'

#"% & 0% #0 '&#'% &#& 8&%&+'+&##"''(%& &.

! *"!7/& & $%%&+'

#&! #( %& # *"%%& %%%&"#%%*"!-!&"#* & *4%& ".' #'($&+%"' 2@'(%& $+%0 % #0%&#&'

.%%'*& "#"##& 7/& & $%%& +'

#&!#&&6#%'-!+&' &+'

+ #%'

4+& %"("+%& 72711;0"%& '

%%'

40="+"#%6&' &+'

7 7

8&& +'

#&!(' %& "8!- %"&# 8&.'&% '

. %&8"!*!& &+'

#'(%&+#&7 ;7

& -&%"%"'& =# &#%& ' 272711 =& &"(%& "8&#%".%"'=#+ "& '

% +!!=#- &#&%& ' 7@7117 '%! 1- '#&+ %"'="%&##&#8&*&&+"%& 0* %'&#*&&&D"& "- % %"!! %&7 & "8!+'%&%"'# "#& % ."8& "#&%' &*%*!&"## &#0="+ #!!*& %"'+"%& -'

".%&+'

#&'(% "!7 "#'

'&#'% && "%-- '- "%&%' &!8& &&-"%'%&#& "8!+'%&%"'#0%%"##%.&0!&#%"%4 - &)

"+&%&% "!7 '%".%."*!&#*&&* '

.%(' = %'" "+%&%& !"6&!"''

'(%&-&%"%"'& *#+' ".( '%&- '+&##'() #%"+&' "%& (& ". ="%%&- '#&+ %"'&8"

&+&7

2 ;77

& % "! "# " && - '+ #%"%". ('!!4 %& &'( +'% *& #

!& -'%&-&%"%"'& 7#-& + #%'

4+& %"("+%& 72711;("!& *4%&!& & $%%&+'

#&!0%&-&%"%"'& #! & 4# ((& & "+ +& %"' (' -& "'

'(?'%# ? 4#7 ;717 %& 0#-& %&#"

+ #%'

4+& %"("+%&%&-&%"%"'& "##%%& %' *& "8'!8& " '%& 3#57 '=&8& 0 %"# (+% +'% *& . '

(("+"&%*4"%#&!(0%' &+!"&%&+'+&##"''( &.

! *"!%'%&-&%"%"'& " %& "B &#%"'=&+#&"# &'

%(' . %'( &.

! *"!B %& "B &#%"'*4 %"'+"%". -'%&(+%#E+" + #%+&#'(%&#"

7 &!"+& " %"# &. + *& -!+& -' %& )

.&% '( %& '<*!& - &&'

%" !' 7" # "87$%%&'( !' 7" # "87$%%&'( !' 7" # "87$%%&'( !' 7" # "87$%%&'(77 '%& 0 77 '%& 0 77 '%& 0 77 '%& 0 11 35 3 ""!5 9;

11 35 3 ""!5 9;

11 35 3 ""!5 9;F "8"#"' &+ )

.&% '( %& '<*!& !+ %% ".'

%"+#&'($ "

#87$%%&0??93153 ""!5 $ "

#87$%%&0??93153 ""!5 @@ @@ @@ @@G)

.&%#'(%"#'

%" '729911111%"%!& #6"!&# 6"!&# 6"!&# 6"!&# $". 87 $%%& '( $". 87 $%%& '( $". 87 $%%& '( $". 87 $%%& '( 4 4 4 40 &+"

' 1?77110 ! ) 87 $%%& '( ! ) 87 $%%& '( ! ) 87 $%%& '( ! ) 87 $%%& '(

40??93253 ""!5?7

%"#8"&='(%&%%& 0%& ".' "-'#& & $&+%"'2@'( %& $+%#% # "!

%& "!".%'(%& %"+!&1'(%&'#%"% %"''(

"7 ;727

"# '

% " )

.&% %"%!& #

!=" & 8& # # $%%& '(

!=" & 8& # # $%%& '( )* )* )* )* -##& " ; @ ; @ ; @ ; @ 11 11 11 11 311,

,1;?5F (%& &!4".

-' %& %"' &+"

& "'( %& )

.&%# '( %& '<*!& $ - && '

% "

##" %''8#7 '&$&+470$%%&'(" 3?95$9F*

! &% !48#7$7 463??15$11F8& ! *"$"6 8#7 $%%& '( #% '%& 0 11 325 3 ""!5 ? F ' #!" H

##" 8#7 $%%& 3 '( &!"5 &-' %& # 112

$ 2F

""!--&! '71 E11 @71711%"%!& #I"%%"#=#!"# *# 8#7 & $%%& '( J&#% &.!KF I "%"# "6 4 H - 8#7 $%%& '( J&#% &.!K0 $-&+"! /&8& %' --&! 3 !75 '72111 11797111 %"%!& # I' $! "( $"6 8#7 & $%%& '( ) %KF ""!--&! '7;?'(111 797111%"%!& #'-!

"# % H '-!

# 8#7 "' '( "0 6

4 8#7 $%%&'( 4 &#011 3 53 ""!5@1F#&!

0% #, I@797

& ".% %' #-&& 4 &D-& "%"'

# % "! "# '% '!4 8"%!#(&.

%'- &8&%

& '-- &##"8&"+ +& %"'F%'"%".%& D"&%4 +'+& ++'-4".%&++ #%"'#=&!!#%'+ %"!4 "-" &%"%&*"!"%4'(++ #& %' &(& "#&!(0* %%& &"# '8& +".#'+"&%!"%& &#%-8".=4(' #-&& 4% "!7 "# ".%# *&& &-&%& !4+% "%& &+&%-#% %& %"' &+"

& "'(%& *'8& &(& & %'$ - &&'

%<#)

.&%#8&!"

'=#& "&#'(

&+"#"'#'-&". -&=8"#%#'(( &%! ".%#7 &+'+&-%'( #-&& 4% "!"#!.%& "%'%& %"+!&1#&##&%"!- %'(%& ( &%! ".%%'!"(& !"*& %40.

%&& - &#& 8& & '

'#%"% %"'7 & ".% %' #-&& 4 % "! *&."# ="% %& +% ! &#% "% "-'#& % %& %"& '( %& &#% '( %& ++ #& +'#&B &% "+ +& %"' ="+ +'%" &# % !! #%.&#0 &!40 %& #%.& '( "8&#%".%"'0 "B " 40 % "!0 --&! &8"#"' #' %% 4 -'##"*!& - &)

"+&%%4 &# !%

&%'"-& "##"*!& 8'"

*!& &!4#"+& %& %"& '( %& +'"##"' '( %& '((&+& %"!! %& + ""! - '+&& ".# +'# %& "%' ("!"%40 +'

*& 8& %& 7 & #-&& 4 % "!0 & !4 & ". B "+6 "#-'#! &#"&B ''(+ ""!) "#-

&+&7 '8& + '= '

% '+6&%#0%&&848'!

&'(=' 6 %& &# !%% - &## &'%&- '#&+ %"' %&'!"+&0"

*"%*!46&&-#%&&%" & + ""!) "#-

&%"!&+"# & #% &## #% "7 '=&8& 0%"# +'%*&&D+ #&(' 6&&-".%&#='

'('+!&#.".'%& ++ #& (' " &(""%&-& "'

'(%"&7 '&#'%#& 8&4+ & "%%'%& + ""! ) #%"+& #4#%&0 %& "% 6&# (' # #%%& '( ((" #7 .

%&& '( #-&& 4 % "! "# "%& %' 8'"

'-- &##"' - &8&%

&!4 *4 "-'#". ' %& '

% %& - '#&+ %"' '*!".%"' %' - '+&& ="%%&% "!="% &#'*!& "#-%+7 &.

%&&#& 8&# % &&('!

- -'#&7" #%!40"%- '%&+%#%&++ #& ."#%'-- &##"8&- & % "! "- "#'&%F #&+' !40 "% &!"&8&# %& ++ #& '( %& D"&%4 - *!"+# #-"+"'

&%' &#'!8& + ""!+ .&# !#%!40"%- '%&+%# ."#% %& "#6 %% &8"

&+& ="!! *& !'#% ' &' "&# "& *4 %& -##.& '( %"&0 % #0 "-" ". %& *"!"%4 '( %& ++ #& %' &(& "#&!(7 %.'&#="%'

%#4".%%%&+'#&B &+&#'(- &% "! &%&%"' & . 8&7 ++ #& 0 - &# "'+&%0 %"!! - '8& '%& ="#&0 & *)&+%& %' -#4+'!'."+! -4#"+! &- "8%"'# '( )"!!"(&0 !!4

& '& '

#+' "%"'#7B !!4"-' %%0%&*

&'( &%&%"''( +++ #& ( &B &%!4(!!#&8"!4'%&"'+&%&*& #'("# ("!47

& & "# 4&% '%& #-&+% '( %& %%& ="+ &#& 8&# +'#"

& %"' % %"# #%.&7 & !!&.%"'# " %& - &#&% +#& &!%& %' ++ #& *&". "8'!8& " &!%". %' +'& +"! B %"%4 '(

+'% * & %& $+%0?97J"!&+'#"

& ".*"!-&%"%"' "+#&"8'!8".+'& +"!B %"%40%&'

%#%'6&&-"" %& ".'

#& & %& & $&+%"'2@'( $+%0?9="+ %&# %% '

%# + . % *"! %' ++ #& '!4 (%& & ". %& - *!"+ - '#&+ %' (%& 8".#%"#("& "%#&!('(%="+' "%"'#="+ & &#'*!& . '

# (' *&!"&8". %% %& ++ #& "# '% .

"!%4 '( %& '((&+&+ .& E!!&.& %%0&"#'%!"6&!4%'+'"%4'((&+& ="!&'*"!7 &#% ".&% ".'

#'($&+%"'2@'(%& $+%0?9

#% *& &%"+ !'

#!4 #+ %"":& ."#% %& *+6 '- '( ++ #& <# ( &%! ".%%'#-&& 4% "!7 & ".%%'!"(& -& #'!!"*& %4 +'%*& & & & .%' 4*4 = %& &!4#"%&)

"+"!- '+&##0 - %"+ ! !4=& &# + &!43#5"#&"%& %% "* %*!&%'%&++ #& ' ) #%"("& %%&& '(%&- '#&+ %"'*4 +'.&% &#'#7" "8"

! +'% *& 6&-% *&" * # (' "'

"%& -& "'

'( %"& *4 %6". &( .&" ".'

#!"

'="$&+%"'2@'(%& $+%0?97 !&."#!% &""%#="# '0"'

& %'&# &#-&& 4 %"&!4 "#-'#!'( %&+#&# & %&+%0#- '8"

(' %&+'#%"% %"''(#-&+"!'

& $&+%"'2;'(%&+%7 '=&8& 0%"#'

%+'%% &!#'<# &4&%'%&- '% +%& &!4# #4#%&%"+"&(("+"&+4%%( #% %&%"# !&."#!%"8&- -'#&7'

%'(!="#

%4*'

%'&# &%%"% '&# '%*&+'&+'-!"+"%"8"'!%"''(" "8"

!<#( &%! ".%#0 '%="%#% ".4%".+'%"& "#%% %&7J"!& &!".="%*"! -&%"%"'"+#&.'8& & *4%& ".'

#'($&+%"'2@'(%& $+%0 ?90 %& '

#% #% "6& )

"+"'

# *!+& *&%=&& %& !&."#!%"8& "%&%%'+ *%&&+&'(

.# %&#+ '#+% ".%'(%&++ #& %'(" &D-& "%"'

#% "!7 '!'.& "+ +& %"'0="%'

%) #%"("*!& + #&0 "#6# % #(' ". - &% "! &%&%"' "%' - "%"8& "- "#'&%0 '

%+'&%"%&%"+!%'%&- "+"-!&'() #%"+& &B "%47 .'0%& &B "8'+!"(& &+&"#%%=& &%&% "!# ("!& %' +'+!

& ="%" &#'*!& %"&0 &# !%". " - '!'.& "+ +& %"'0 "% "!"%%&# ."#% %& - &+"' # ( &%! ".%# '( !"(& !"*& %4 . %& & %& != 0 # # +0 +' "%"'! !"*& %4 '8& "

".%&#%% %' 4&* .'+ &%& & $&+%"'2@'(%& $ +%0?9'

.%%'*&+'#"

& & #-& (+%#'(."8&+#&7 '%& ='

#0. %'(*"!"+#&-& %"".%'+'& +"!B %"%40'%& . '

& &!4"% "!0+'%*&#"

%'*&(&%%& & *4$&+%"'2@ '(%& $+%0?97K ;7 7

*"%*!40 %& - &#&% -&%"%"' "# %& #&+' %%&-% *4 %& -&%"%"'& %'#&+ & &.

! *"!7 &!#%*"!-!&=# "#"##& #="% = '?717117 '=&8& 06&&-"."8"&=%&&%" &%4'(%&(+% !% "D'( %&+#&" F&#-&+"!!40(+% '(%&-&%"%"'& 8".# ((& & &D%& "+ +& %"'G-+&'(% "!F%"#'

%"#"+!"& %'((" %"8&!4+'#"

& %& "#%%-!&(' *"!7- '("%*!& &(& &+&0"%"# &. 0+*& &%' )

.&% '( %"# '

% -##& " $1221 1221112 112 112 112 %"%!& # ("B ("B ("B ("B 8& # #$%%&'( 4 '%& 8& # #$%%&'( 4 '%& 8& # #$%%&'( 4 '%& 8& # #$%%&'( 4 '%& F &!&8%=& &'( & ## & ,

; I7 # &-"!'.

& %' %& *'8& "#+ ##"'0 %& ('!!'=". - "+"-!&#&& .&,

$&+' E# ++&##"8& &.

! *"! -&%"%"'3#5 ("!& "# "%"*!&"!=G&+&# +-&%"%"''

.%'%%'*& &)&+%& #'!&!4'%&. '

'("%"*"!"%4%& &'(7

7 + #&+' E# ++&##"8& &.

! *"! -&%"%"'3#5 "# "%"*!& =&%& & !"& -&%"%"' =#

"#"##& # ="% =E "#"##& #'%- &##& "#"##& (' '- '#&+ %"' ' & !"& -&%"%"'=# "#"##& '& "%#7

' %& #&+' E# ++&##"8& &.

! *"! -&%"%"'3#5 %' ++&& 0 %& -&%"%"'& E--!"+% #!! *& &##&%"!!4E-& %"&%!4 &B " & %'#'=# *#%%"!+.&"+" + #%+&# #'=". '(& &# -& ("+"!' '#%&#"*!&+.&='

'%# (("+&7 &%-' "+ &D- &##"' '( #&&6". #&+' E# ++&##"8& *"! -!&3#5 '

.%'%*&*#% +%& "%'!"%& !"%& %"'#'(-&%"%"'3#5="%' *#%%"!0&((&+%"8& +'#&B &%"!+.&"+" + #%+&#7

L '&D #%"8&.

&!"&#+-'##"*!4*&!"

'=#%' =%='

+'#%"% %&# *#%%"!+.&"+" + #%+&##&8& 4 +#& # "%# '= "B & (+%#E+" + #%+&7 6". # + %%&-%"#'%".* % %'-"& &8'

7 .'0%"#"## &"# *&#%!&(%%'%&)

"+"!="# ' "#+ &%"''(%&'

&!". ="%# +#&+' E# ++&##"8& &.

! *"!-&%"%"'3#57 L +#&'

%+''#&#%'. %#&+' E# ++&##"8& &.

! *"!-&%"%"'3#50+'.&% !

&#'# &-& %"&%!4 &B " & %' *& &+'

(' . %". # + -!& &#-"%& # + -!& *&". #&+' E# ++&##"8&-&%"%"'3#57 '%& ='

#0%&+ #&(' '

8". ++&##( !!4 +'

%&+& E&%& %"& + #&+' E# ++&##"8& -&%"%"'3#5 '

.% %' *& & "!4 +!& !4

&+"-& *!&( '%&#"

& -##& 7K (("+&%'#40( %& &%&%"''(%&-&%"%"'& # & % "!"# '%= %& "%&(+%# +" + #%+&#'(%&+#&7 @7

8"&= '( *'8&0 %& - &#&% -&%"%"' "# !!'=& 7 &%"%"'& "# '

& & %'*& &!&#& ' &.

! *"!0"('% &B " & "4'%& +#&0'"# ( "#". *"!E# &%4 *' # %' %& #%"#(+%"' '( %& / 7 +'+& & % "! '

%E %4 ."#% %&7 '=&8& 0 "

"%"' %' +' "%"'# %% 4 *& "-'#& *4 %& +'+& & % "! '

%E %4 ."#% %&0 %& -&%"%"'& #!! &"*'

*4%&('!!'=".+' "%"'#, 3"5

&-&%"%"'& #!!'%"# #&%&!"*& %4. %& 7 3""5

&-&%"%"'& #!!'%%-& ="%4&8"

&+&0' !'

'+ &% 40

".%&% "!7 3"""5 &-&%"%"'& #!!'%*#&%"#&!('4 %&*&(' & %&% "!7 3"85 &-&%"%"'& #!!'%+'"%4'((&+&="!&'*"!7 385

& -&%"%"'& #!! &-'#"% "# -##-' %0 "( 40 ="% %& % "!'

@ 38"5

& -&%"%"'& #!! ."8& "# +&!!-'& *& %' %&

8&#%".%".(("+& E$ '(+'+& & '!"+&$%%"' #!! '% +.& "# +&!!-'& *& ="%'

% - "' -& "##"''(%&% "!'

%E !!B."#% %&7 38""5 &-&%"%"'& #!!'%"4& % 4%' &!4%&% "!7 38"""5 & -&%"%"'& #!! # *"%0 ' %& (" #% =' 6". 4 '( &8& 4'%0(("

8"%0*&(' &%&+'+& & % "!'

%0 %'%&&((&+%%%&#'%*&&"8'!8& "+'"##"''( 4 '((&+& (%& *&". &!&#& ' *"!7 +#& %& -&%"%"'& "#('

%'*&"8'!8& "4'((&+&(%& "# *&".&! .& '*"!"%&- &#&% 0'%&*#"#'( "#(("

8"%' '%& ="#&0%&$%%&"# %''8&0 (' %="%0 (' ++&!!%"' '( "# *"! ="+ -!&0 * % '( +'

#&0#!!*& %"'+"%& -'& "%#%& &'(7 97

+#& '( * &+ '( 4 '( %& (' &#" +' "%"'# %'#& ="+4*&"-'#& *4+'+& & % "!'

%E %4."#% %&# " &+%& & &"*'8&' -'#'=".4'%& # (("+"&%+ #&0%&$%%&E+'-!"% #!!*&%!"*& %4%''8&++&!!%"''(*"!'(%&-&%"%"'& 7 ?7 & & ++'

".!47 7

'%".#"

& &"*'8&#!!*&+'#% #&D- &##"''( '-""''%&& "%#'(%&+#&7 7 $"+& %& " +#& # *&& &+"

0 -& ". "#+&!!&'

# --!"+%"'0"(40#!!!#'#% # "#-'#& '((7 3$ / $ / $ / $ /5 + + + +011;

011;

011; 8" J&%& #-&6".E &#'& , &#E ' J&%& &-' %*!&, &#E '