Baldev Kaur v. State Of Punjab & ORS




   
   

"#$ %$&'(')* +

, "-%$./"01  $#'#')$1 2$1(0( 3#"#$ 0)4"5")%#6$1(  $(7)%$)#( *  89  3
/ 9
3


1$($)#* 133'%60:%.&"#$: 1:

13")%';"-:%.&"#$: 1#6$7$#'#')$1 19 ";"1:3$)'1 0)4"5 1 3$-:3$)'1%.&"#$:;'#6:

131"1:%.&"#$: 11$(7)%$)#(#  <6$#6$1#6$ $71#$1( -&"-)$;(7"7$1=">5$"--;$%# ($$#6$40%?=$)#@

 5$1$ $11$%##6$ $71#$11)# A <6$#6$1#6$40%?=$)#(60-%5$1$71#$%')#6$%'?$(#@   / 9
3
 "-%$./"017$#'#')$1!6"( '-$%#6'(7$#'#')0)%$13$&#')   %$ 1'=')"- 1&$%01$:+,A: 1#1")( $11')?#6$').$(#'?"#') ')  %"#$%

:1$?'(#$1$%0)%$13$&#')(,:A ,::+ ")%0)%$13$&#')( ")% , #6$1=(&#:++:"# -'&$3#"#') "?6" 01")":'(#1'&#?":#$)#1"-01$"0 
).$(#'?"#')
!:

1'=$1")&61#")>#6$1"?$)&> 1 1$$")% "'1').$(#'?"#') 01#6$1 71">$1'(="%$ 171#$&#') -'

$")%-'5$1#> #6$7$#'#')$1")%6$1

"='->=$=5$1("##6$6")%( 71'."#$1$(7)%$)#( 6$7$#'#')$1&-"'=(#6"#6$160(5")%:)"=$->: 73')?6:'( ";1B$1 )?1$((7"1#> 73')?6:60(5")% #6$7$#'#')$1:

  "-)?;'#6A#6$1)?1$((;1B$1(;$1$'=7-'&"#$%') +%"#$% 

:1$?'(#$1$%0)%$13$&#')(A A:A:")%+
"# -'&$ 3#"#')"?6" 01")": '(#1'&#?":"--$?')?#6"##6$>6"%"##"&B$%#6$ B"-';1B$1()#6$%"> 9B3"56"-$&#')()A 

6$("'% 

$)&$("1$5"'-"5-$.$)#6$):)$'-5"?63')?6;"("11$(#$%")%;"( B$7#')'--$?"-%$#$)#') 1 A%">(9"#$1):B"-';1B$1("##"&B$%#6$ 60($ #6$7$#'#')$1;'#6%$"%->;$"7)(")%#6$-' $ 60(5")% #6$ 7$#'#')$1;"((".$%"# 
 $?"1%')?#6$71$($)#')&'%$)#:'#'((#"#$%#6"# )

:"#"50# *A ='%)'?6#!:71'."#$1$(7)%$)#(#: )"=$->:30B6%$.3')?6:"?('13')?6:3;"1")3')?6")%
)%$14'#3')?6 $)#$1$%#6$60($ #6$7$#'#')$1")%"##"&B$%6$160(5")% 73')?6 "?('13')?6 '1$%"(6#)#6$-$? 60(5")% #6$7$#'#')$130B6%$.

3')?6 '1$%"(6# 6'(1'

-$;6'&66'##6$&6$(# 60(5")% #6$7$#'#')$1 6$>;$1$"&&=7")'$%5>#;0)'%$)#'

'$%7$1()(:;6;$1$-"#$1) '%$)#'

'$%#5$3;"1")3')?6")%
)%$14'#3')?671'."#$1$(7)%$)#(, ")%!&&1%')?->:71$($)#  :%"#$%

;"(1$?'(#$1$% 0)%$13$&#')(,:A ,:")%+
")%0)%$13$&#')( ")% ,

#6$1=(&#:++:"# -'&$3#"#')"?6" 01")":'(#1'&#?"
#'(

01#6$1(#"#$%#6"#1$(7)%$)#:)"=$->:30B6%$.3')?6'(")C 3"17")&6  .'--"?$")% 5$-)?( # 10-')? 7"1#>B"-' "-!  1'."#$ 1$(7)%$)#(")%,:)"=$->:"?('13')?6")%3;"1")3')?6"1$#6$ )$76$;(    )$  3   =$=5$1  ")%  #6$  -&"-  7-'&$  '(  6$-7')?  #6$=: "77"1$)#-> 1#6$1$"()#6"#"##6"##'=$:B"-'"-.$1)=$)#;"(') 7;$1')#6$3#"#$ 0)4"56$7$#'#')$1;"(#61$"#$)$%#6"##6$>;'-- 5$#"0?6#"-$(()6$7$#'#')$1"771"&6$%#6$6'?6$1"0#61'#>:50#) "&#')6"(5$$)#"B$)( "1
#'( 01#6$1"--$?$%#6"#1$(7)%$)#:

A )"=$->:"(.'13')?63
: -'&$3#"#')"?6" 01")":'(#1'&# ?":

1"'%$%#6$60($ #6$7$#'#')$1")%"50($%#6$-"%'$(")%#61$"#$)$%#6"# 6$;'--70#"--#6$ "='->=$=5$1(5$6')%#6$5"1(0$##$111&1$"#$% 5>1$(7)%$)#(:#6$ 7$#'#')$1")%6$1 "='->=$=5$1(&"))#$)#$1#6$'1 60($")%#6$>"1$7"((')?#6$'1%">(5>6'%')?6$1$")%#6$1$    6$ 7$#'#')$1&-"'=(#6"#(6$'(" >$"1( "?$")%'(=.')? 1=7'--"1# 7(##?$##6$40(#'&$0$#') -0$)&$ 71'."#$1$(7)%$)#(;'#610-')?

B"-'"-:)5%>'(-'(#$)')?##6$=$)&$:71$($)#7$#'#')
)#6$;1'##$)1$7->5>;"> "

'%".'# "-;')%$13')?6:

3:3 :"?6" 01")":'(#1'&#?":%"#$%

:'#;"((#"#$%#6"# #6$').$(#'?"#')  #6'( &"($;"( 5$')? &"11'$% 0#5>"#')%$13')?6:
)(7$&#1 3  -'&$  3#"#')  "?6"  01")"   ;$.$1:  #6$   $70#>
)(7$&#1$)$1"- -'&$
!: $1D$701 ")?$: $1D$701:&)(#'#0#$% "37$&'"-
).$(#'?"#')?$"=3
!0)%$1#6$(07$1.'(') 3 !:?" 6$#6$1=$=5$1( #6$#$"="1$3 "?6" 01")":
)&6"1?$
3#"

:

?"")%3  -'&$3#"#')"?6" 01")" 6$37$&'"-
).$(#'?"#')?

$"=  (#"1#$%  #6$  ').$(#'?"#')  )  +

  
#  ;"(  0)%  %01')?

').$(#'?"#') #6"#30B6%$. 3')?6:C3"17")&6  .'--"?$:"?('13')?6:

3;"1")3')?6")% 
)%$14'#3')?6 1$(7)%$)#(#1$(7$&#'.$->! 6".$  5$$)   "-($->  '=7-'&"#$%:  ;6$1$"(  7  3')?6:  60(5")%    #6$ 7$#'#')$1:  ?')%$1  3')?6  ()   7  3')?6:  '-5"?6  3')?6  ()  

6')%$13')?6:"171$$#3')?6() 6"4")3')?6")% "1;')%$13')?6 () 4=$13')?6"1$#6$1$"-&0-71'#(')#6'(&"($&&1%')?->:#6$'1 60($(;$1$1"'%$%:50##6$>&0-%)#5$"771$6$)%$% 
#;"( 01#6$1

0)% %01')? ').$(#'?"#') #6"#%0$# 7$1()"-$)='#>:'-5"?6 3')?6: ?')%$13')?6: "1;')%$13')?6")%"171$$#3')?6&)(7'1$%;'#6$"&6

 #6$1")%#6$>=")"?$%# "-($->').-.$30B6%$.3')?6$#&5>&"0(')?

'1$"1=(')401'$(# 73')?6")%&)&&#$%" "-($(#1>")%-%?$%"

"-($   ')  1%$1  #  ($##-$  #6$  (&1$(:  1$?"1%')?     +:  %"#$% 

: 0)%$13$&#')(A:A A:A :")%+
:1$?'(#$1$% "?"')(##6$="# -'&$3#"#')"?6" 01")":'(#1'&#?"

$(7)%$)#(#:')#6$ 1$7->%"#$%+

:"-( "

'1=$%#6"#
 $1D$701 ")?$: $1D$701:6"%&)(#'#0#$%"3
) +

:;6'&6'(=0&671'1##6$ '-')? 71$($)#7$#'#')
#;"((#"#$% #6"#71$($)#(#1>;"(&)&&#$%#71$((01'D$71'."#$1$(7)%$)#(')("'%

+:%"#$%A 

:1$ $11$%"5.$ "-($ '1$"1=(:')401'$(6".$ 5$$) "51'&"#$%)#6$-$ #-$?")%-$ #(60-%$1 73')?6;'#6#6$'1 ;);'#6,51$7'(#- 6'( "&#'(51)$0#  1= $=7#>&"($( 1$&.$1$% 1= #6$(7#5>3
)(7$&#1"#')%$13')?6()" #$1#6$ &&011$)&$)

6$;$"7)0($%')#6$&&011$)&$'$,51$ 7'(#-%$()#5$-)?#")> #6$"&&0($%)"=$%')#6$ A51$ 1'

-$5$"1')?+  :1$?'(#$1$%')#6$)"=$ 30B6%$.3')?6 1$(7)%$)#!'(->')? %$7('#$%;'#6#6$3'%600)0($(')&$ +A

:"(7$1$)#1> 
#;"( 01#6$1"(($1#$%#6"# 1=#6$&"-- %$#"'-( =5'-$76)$( 73')?6:?')%$13')?6:'-5"?63')?6")%

"1;')%$1 "1=')%$1!3')?6"-'"( 6')%":'#6"(&=$#-'?6##6"##6$($ 7$1()(;$1$')#0&6;'#6$"&6#6$1)=5'-$76)$(?')%$13')?6 6"%&")&$--$%6'(=5'-$&))$&#')")%#B")$;&))$&#')")%(#"1#$% 0(')?3
&"1% "??"3')?6:1$('%$)# 3")?"#701"")%="%$&"--( 1= '#  3'='-"1->:'-5"?63')?6:;66"%=5'-$+,

:)#6$ ='%)'?6# 

6"%

A=')0#$(#"-B;'#6"?%$$73')?6"-'"( "11> 1"11")?')?;$"7)#(0

$1')401># 73')?66'( "&#;"(

 1$.$"-$%5>"?%$$73')?6"-'"("11>5$ 1$#6$3
   6$1$ 1$:#6$ ')401'$(  ;$1$  ($-  ') -'&#$%  ")%  71'."#$  1$(7)%$)#(  "1$  5$')?  "-($-> '=7-'&"#$%
)"(61#"

'%".'#%"#$%

: '-$%5>"-;')%$13')?6:

3:$70#>307$1')#$)%$)# -'&$:"?6" 01")":'(#1'&#?":#6'( 01# ;"(') 1=$%#6"# 1$71# 3
6"(5$$)"771.$%5>#6$
:

$1D$701 ")?$: $1D$701 $#")#6$1(61# 1$7->5>;"> "

'%".'#%"#$%+

:

'-$%5>"(7"-3')?6:

3:$70#>307$1')#$)%$)# -'&$:"?6" 01")":

'(#1'&#  ?":  #6$  &7'$(    (#"#$=$)#(    ')401$%:  $>$  ;'#)$(($(:

"=")%$$7/"01;'

$ ?')%$13')?6"-'"(1"")%/"=-$(6/"01;' $  "1($= 3')?6%"0?6#$1(')-"; 7$#'#')$1!:1$&1%$%)

 0)%$13$&#')1 :;$1$7-"&$%) '-$
6".$6$"1%#6$-$"1)$%&0)($- 1#6$7$#'#')$1:#6$-$"1)$% 3#"#$&0)($-:#6$-$"1)$%($)'1&0)($- 171'."#$1$(7)%$)#(# ")%6".$"-(&"1$ 0-->?)$#610?6#6$ '-$ %='##$%->:')#6'(&"($:  ;"(1$?'(#$1$%)

 )")%)+

:#6$
: $1D$701 ")?$: $1D$701: 1=$%"3
:

6$"%$%5>307$1')#$)%$)# -'&$!:?"")%#6$3
&"11'$%0##6$ ').$(#'?"#')6$.$1(') #6$&=7-"')")#')#6$ '(#6"#;6$)(6$ "-)?;'#66$160(5")% 73')?6:%"0?6#$1(')-"; "=")%$$7/"01;'

$  ?')%$13')?6")%/"=-$(6;'

$ "1($=3')?6;"(71$($)#')#6$'1 60($: "&&0($%&"=$')#6$&01#>"1% 30B6%$.3')?6:C3"17")&6

.'--"?$:  ;"(  "1=$%  ;'#6  1'

-$  ")%  "?('1 3')?6  ;"(  "1=$%  ;'#6  7'(#- &&0($%  3;"1")  3')?6  ")% 
)%$14'#  3')?6  ;$1$  "-(  (#")%')?  ')  #6$ &01#>"1%
#'()#"--$?$%#6"#("'%3;"1")3')?6")%
)%$14'#3')?6;$1$

 &"11>')?")>;$"7)6$):'#'("--$?$%#6"#"?('13')?6?".$"(6# 6'( 7'(#-)#6$-$ #-$? 60(5")% #6$7$#'#')$1")%30B6%$.3')?6?".$"

(6# 6'(1'

-$)#6$&6$(# 6$160(5")%;$.$1:#6$(#"#$=$)#

7  3')?6:  1$&1%$%  0)%$1  3$&#')    1   )  

 ))$C01$  !(6;(#6"#"&&1%')?#6'=:3;"1")3')?6;"("1=$% ;'#61$.-.$1:
)%$14'#3')?6;"("1=$%;'#6"1$.-.$1:"?('13')?6;"( "1=$%;'#67'(#-")%30B6%$.3')?6;"("1=$%;'#6"1' -$30B6%$.

3')?61"'($%-"-B"1"$C61#"#')!  3;"1") 3')?6 '1$%"(6# 6'( 1$.-.$1:;6'&66'#)-$ #(60-%$1 73')?6")%#6$)
)%$14'#3')?6

'1$%"(6#  6'(?0) ;6'&66'#)6'(-$ #-$?  6'('(')&=7-$#$ &)#1"(###6$(#"#$=$)#="%$5>71$($)#7$#'#')$1"##6$#'=$ -%?')?

#6$ :;6$1$')1'

-$(6#')401>;"("##1'50#$%#30B6%$.3')?6")%7'(#- (6#')401>;"("##1'50#$%#"?('13')?6:;6$1$"(3;"1")3')?6")%
)%$14'# 3')?6;$1$)#1$&1%$%# 5$&"11>')?")>;$"7)  3'='-"1->:')6$1 (#"#$=$)#  0)%$1  3$&#')    1 :  "=")%$$7  /"01  6"(  (#"#$%  #6"# 3;"1")3')?6 '1$%"(6# 6'(7'(#-;6'&66'##6$-$ #(60-%$1 7 3')?6")%
)%$14'#3')?6 '1$%"(6# 6'(7'(#-;6'&66'##6$-$? 7 3')?6/"=-$(6/"01;'

$ "1($=3')?6"-(="%$"('='-"1(#"#$=$)#
)#6'(;">:)#6$ '1(#%">'#($- :')401$%")%#6$1$>$;'#)$(($(&6")?$% #6$'1(#")%")%#6$7$1()(;6 '1$%(6#;$1$1$7-"&$%")%(;$1$#6$ ;$"7)( ;:  #6$ =$%'&"-  $.'%$)&$ 7-"&$%  )  '-$ ')   #6$  1= 

%'(&6"1?$")% --;07&"1%:'((0$%5> 
:6")%'?"16:;6'&6"-(&"11> #6$%'"?1"=( ($"# ')401'$((6;(#6"#)$(6#6'##6$1'?6#7(#$1'1 ('%$'$5"&B #6$60(5")% #6$7$#'#')$1")%$C'# 1=#6$ 1)#('%$ )$"1#6$(60-%$16$$)#1>;0)%'()#6$5"&B")%$C'#;0)%'()#6$

,

1)#6'('("-(&)#1"1>##6$"(($1#') <(#6"##6$(6#;"( '1$%

1= #6$ 1)#")%6'##6$&6$(# 6$$)#1>")%$C'#;0)%(6;(#6"# 715"5->#6$7$1():;6 '1$%(6#:;"("#-;$1-$.$-#6")#6$-$.$- #6$ $)#1>;0)%#6"#'(;6>#6$$C'#;0)%'("#5'#6'?6$17-"&$#6")#6$&6$(# 6$%'"?1"="-((6;(#6"#)#6$-$ #-$?:#6$1$'(")$)#1>;0)% 1= #6$ 1)#")%$C'#;0)% 1=-$ #-$?:1$(0-#')?') 1"&#01$ #6$-$?6$ $)#1>")%$C'#;0)%'("##6$("=$-$.$-(6;')?#6"#'#;"( '1$% 1=#6$ ("=$-$.$-'$-;$171#') -$?3"=$;$"7)'$,51$7'(#-'( (#"#$%#6".$5$$)0($%')#6$&1'=$ 
#'(#5$ 01#6$1)#$%#6"#);

)?1$((.$1)=$)#'(')7;$1')  0)4"53#"#$:;6'&6'(#6$7"1#>

73')?6')401$%! ;:#6$E0$(#')5$ 1$#6'(01#'(#6"#"(#;6$#6$1#6$3
 &)%0&#$% "'1').$(#'?"#')1'#'("#"')#$%').$(#'?"#')@ 6$3
6"(&=$##6$&)&-0(') #6"#  #6$')401'$(;$1$

"51'&"#$%  &&1%')?->:#6$&=7-"')")#7"1#>6"();5$$)&6"--)$% 0)%$13$&#')( :: ")%


")%0)%$13$&#')( ")% ,  #6$1=(&#:++##6'((#"?$:'#'()#"77171'"#$#&==$)#) #6$   $.'%$)#'"1>  ."-0$     #6$  &)#1"1>  (#"#$=$)#(:    #6$  ="))$1  

&=='((') &1'=$: #6$;$"7)(0($%#6$1$'): #6$(6' #')? "&&0($% 1$?"1%')? "##1'50#')  ')401'$(")%"--$?$%0($% 1'

-$5> 30B6%$.

3')?6:C3"17")&6 .'--"?$:;6'&6'( 0)%#5$)#0($%')#6$&1'=$

'&$#(">#6"# 1=#6$%&0=$)#(7-"&$%) '-$:#6'(01#6"(&=$# #6$&)&-0(') #6"# "'1').$(#'?"#');"(&)%0&#$%5>#6$7-'&$" #$1 #"B')?')#&)('%$1"#')  ="#$1'"-&--$&#$% 1=#6$(7#:(#"#$=$)#(

;'#)$(($(")%#6$ =$%'&"-7')')  6$1$ 1$:#6$3
6"( &=$#"

7"1#'&0-"1&)&-0('):;6'&6?$("?"')(##6$7$#'#')$16$1$ 1$:#6'(

 01#"##6'((#"?$&"))#(">#6"##6$').$(#'?"#')'(#"')#$%6$1$ 1$:) &"($'(="%$0## ?$#")#6$1').$(#'?"#')&)%0&#$% 1= ")>#6$1 "?$)&>
#5$')?(:7$#'#')'( 0)%#5$;'#60#")>=$1'#")%'( 6$1$5>%'(='(($%;$.$1:#6$7$#'#')$1(6"--"-;">(5$"#-'5$1#>#"."'- #6$  1$=$%>  "."'-"5-$  #  6$1  0)%$1  #6$  %$    1'=')"-  1&$%01$ ;$.$1:'#'(%'1$&#$%#6"#&==$)#(="%$"5.$(6"--)#5$#"B$)')# &)('%$1"#'):;6'-$%$&'%')?#6$&"($5$#;$$)#6$7"1#'$()=$1'#( / 9
3
!

 

+

, (4B( <6$#6$1(7$"B')? 1$"()$% * $( <6$#6$1 $71#"5-$ * $(