Manoj Kumar And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

  


  


  

!"# $%&'(&)*+*,-

$,./01$ $,(%2& + &%*%*,& + 3& +0+

%$%&'0,.$4$,($,%2& &+5,(&,%+
 $1- 6 7  


    &+&,%-  / $ %*$9 (3)$%&' %2&5&%*%*,& +  *%%&,&2 $9 ((: 90,.$4  $0%$1*;$,9 (3)$%&'  &+5,(&,%


 

 
 2*+  5&%*%*,  0,(& &)%*,    '  %2& 
(&  ' 
*1*,$:

 )&(0 &2$+4&&,'*:&(' <0$+2*,='($%&(



&=*+%& &(0,(& &)%*,+  $,( '%2&,(*$,&,$:
(&!' +2 %6%2&
6#9$%:*)& %$%*,81&,
&::9*+% *)%$%*$:$!

,,&>0 & #$,($::),+&<0&,%*$:5 )&&(*,=+$ *+*,=%2& &'

19,%2&4$+*+'

)15 1*+&(&&(($%&(? 

!

,,&>0 & #$

*3&($%4&%;&&,%2& 5$ %*&+ @*(& (& ($%&( A

9%2&5$ %*&+;& &(* &)%&(%$55&$ 4&' &%2&:&$ ,&(% *$:
0 %B::$<$$=*+% $%&9' =&%%*,=%2&* +%$%&1&,%+

&) (&(C$+%%2&=&,0*,&,&++'%2&)15 1*+&,)15:*$,)&%2& &'9

&5 %' 0(*)*$:$=*+% $%&+%
:$++9$%*$:$9($%&( 

92$+4&&,

&)&*3&(9;2& &*,9*%2$+4&&,,%*)&(%2$%%2&5$ %*&+2$3&+&%%:&(%2& (*+50%&$1*)$4:D;*%20%$,D0,(0&*,':0&,)&9)& )*, 5 &++0 &$,( ,,&'%2&$))0+&(2$3&4&&,(&):$ &($+5 ):$*1&(''&,(& 2&0:%*1$%&$*194.&)%*3&$,(=$:'$:&=$:+D+%&1*+%

&),)*:&%2&+)*$:),':*)%+7$;*+ &<0* &(,:D%&,+0 &%2$%5&5:&( ,%2$3&%'*=2%;*%2&$)2%2& .0+%%5 %&)%%2&* *=2%%5 5& %D9 *=2% %:*'&$,(:*4& %D$,(%2& *=2%++&)0 &(%%2&14D%2&:&=$:+D+%&12& )*3*:(*+50%&+$ &%2&),':*)%+4&%;&&,%;5$ %*&+92$3*,=:&++& 3& %,&+ ' %2&+)*$: (& 9+)*$:2$ 1,D %2&+)*&%D$++0)2&,)&$4+:0%& '

&&(1*+=*3&,%%2&5$ %*&+%+&%%:&%2&* (*+50%&+4D)15 1*+&+9'

)0 +&9)1*,= ;*%2)& %$*,:&=$:),+&<0&,)&+$+;&::;&3& 9 %2& ) *1*,$:(*+50%&+(,%,&)&++$ *:D &+% *)%%2&1+&:3&+%,:D%;5$ %*&+ %%2&(*+50%&*,%& 1+'%2&* +)5&9),+&<0&,)&+$,(&''&)%2&) *1*,$:

$)%+%&,(%)$+%%2&* &''&)%$,(),+&<0&,)&+&3&,05,%2&+)*&%D$% :$ =&2& &' &9%2&:$;5 &+) *4&+50,*+21&,%9+&3& &50,*+21&,%+$,( %2&&>% &1&50,*+21&,%+9*,):0(*,=(&$%25&,$:%D' ) *1*,$:$)%+ ;&3& 91 &'%&,%2&,,%%2&)*3*:(*+50%&+ *,%& +& ),':*)%+  '  %;  5$ %*&+  % $,+' 1+  %2&1+&:3&+  *,%  ) *1*,$:  $+5&)% 2& &' &9%2&:&=$:+D+%&15:$D+&15* &% &+:3&%2&),':*)%4&%;&&,%;

5$ %*&+C;*%2%2&$((&(%$+E'&,+0 *,=%2$%%2&$(3& +&*15$)%'(*+50%& <0$+)*&%D$%:$ =&*+1*,*1*F&( 0%+%*::%2&) &*(&$*+% &+:3&%2& ),':*)%4&%;&&,%;+*(&+4D50%%*,=*%% &+%2& &' &9&3&,%2&) *1*,$:

:$;*+ &<0* &(%=*3&(0& &=$ (%%2&;*+2&+'%2&5$ %*&+%(*+50%& &)=,*F*,=%2*+5 *,)*5:&,:D9%2&,(*$,:&=$: D+%&1$:+5 3*(&+'

&)=,*F*,=  %2& )15 1*+&  4&%;&&,  %;  +*(&+  '  $  ) *1*,$:  (*+50%&

&)%*,



*+$,&>5 &++5 3*+*,*,%2*+ &=$ (2*++&)%*,,% ,:D5 3*(&+' )150,(*,=(0 *,=%2&% *$:940%5& 1*%+)150,(*,= &3&,$%$55&::$%& &3*+*,$:+%$=&;&3& 4D*%+3& D,$%0 &$,(+)5&9

&)%*,



)$,,%4&%2&+:& &5+*% DC;2& &*,%2& &)=,*%*, %$)15 1*+&4&%;&&,%2&5$ %*&+2$3&C,&)&++$ *:DC%4&),'*,&(2*+ +&)%*, &:$%&+,:D%%2&''&,)&+5 &+) *4&(0,(& %2&,(*$,&,$:
(& 2& &$ &$:%1 &''&,)&+5 &+) *4&(0%+*(&
3&,%%2&''&,)&+ &>*+%*,=*,%2&
,&;(*1&,+*,+$ &$((&('

1%*1&%%*1&91$E*,=%2& &>*+%*,=''&,)&+%4&:*=2%&  +% *,=&,%$,(&3&,,&;1($:*%*&+'5 '

'''&,)&+$ &4&*,= &)=,*+&(*,3*&;'%&)2,:=*)$:$(3$,)&1&,% 2*+,&)&++*%$%&+$,( &<0* &+%2&,&&(' :E*,=4&D,( &)%*,


% &)=,*+&%2&)15 1*+&4&%;&&,%2&5$ %*&+%(*+50%& 0%% 1$*,%$*,%2&+$,)%*%D'%2&5 )&(0 &5 &+) *4&(' ) *1*,$:% *$:C%2& *$:

0 %)$,,%4&5& 1*%%&(%% $3&:4&D,(%2&+)5&5 &+) *4&(0,(& %2$% )&(0 &&,)&%2&,&&(' *,3E*,= &)%*,  

4D%2&*=2

0 %

0%9  $+  4+& 3&(  $43&9  %2& ;*+2&+  ' ,:D 5$ %*&+  % %2& ) *1*,$:(*+50%&;0:(,%$:;$D+4&+0''*)*&,%%%& 1*,$%&$) *1*,$:% *$:

*,3*&;'%2&5$%&,%9:$%&,% +04%:&&''&)%C%2&* ),(0)%;0:(2$3&:&'% <0$%2&+)*&%D$%:$ =&2& &' &%2&'%&,)&+ )11*%%&(4D5& +,+ *,3:3&(*,=3& ,$,)& $(1*,*+% $%*,' $)<0* *,=''*)*$:5;&  ;2*:&&>& )*+*,=''*)&5;& )$,,%4&5& 1*%%&(%4&)15 1*+&( 7*E&;*+&9  &3&,  %2&  '%&,)&+  *,3:3*,=  ,:D  %;  5 *3$%&  5& +,+9  40%

&':&)%*,=(&5 $3*%D')2$ $)%&  *,3:3*,=)$0+*,=*,%&,%*,$::++':*'&  )$0+*,=*,%&,%*,$::++'5 5& %D4D&>%&,(*,=*11*,&,%%2 &$%':++ '  :*'&C  )$,,%  4&  5& 1*%%&(  %  4&  )15 1*+&(  >)&5%  %2&  $43& 1&,%*,&(= $3&''&,)&+9%2& &*+&3& D &$+,%2$%$::%2& ''&,)&+ +20:(4&5& 1*%%&(%4&)15 1*+&(4D%2&
0 % *,)&%2&5 ''

''&,)&+4&' &%2&
0 %9$=$*,;0:(*,3:3&%2&),(0)%'%2&5$ %*&+% (*+50%&9%2& &' &*'%2&
0 %(&+,%5& 1*%%2&+$1&%4&)15 1*+&( %2&,%2&5$ %*&+;0:(%&,(%5:$D% *)E+05,%2&
0 %%&,+0 &%2& $)<0*%%$:'$))0+&(4D+043& %*,=%2&$(1*,*+% $%*,') *1*,$:.0+%*)&

,(*%*+,&3& *,%2&*,%& &+%'$(1*,*+% $%*,') *1*,$:.0+%*)&%' )& %2&)*%*F&,%:&$ ,$,($(5%%2&% *)E+(&+*=,&(%4&5:$D&(05,
0 %+ %+043& %%2&.0+%*)&+D+%&1 *%;0:($:;$D+4&*,%2&*,%& &+%'.0+%*)& *%+&:'C%2$%%2&)15 1*+&4&%;&&,%2&5$ %*&+*+ &)=,*F&($,(%2&)*%*F&,

&1$*,  1 &(  $,(  )11*%%&(  %  %2&  &++&,%*$:+  '  %2&  +D+%&1  ' $(1*,*+% $%*,'.0+%*)&9$%:&$+%9<0$%2+&''&,)&+9;2*)2%2&*,%& &+%'

+)*&%D(&+,%5& 1*%%4&)15 1*+&( ,64:&  %2&  &1& 
0 %  2$+  $15:D  ):$ *'*&(  %2&  :&=$:

5+*%*,, &)=,*F*,=)15 1*+*,=*,%2&)$+&'


 

  

  !"$,(2$+4+& 3&($+ 0,(& -


      



  

       

          !  "

 

 #

 





                   $

%&'  

  

 

 



 (



 "

  

  

     )*+ ,

  #

 +

,        

(

                !("

          

    

     

       

 

      (    - "



  -  

 

  

(      

 

  

(  

.- -

(-  



 (     

   

/ 

(   

 

 $



 

      

  

  ($

 (-(  

   



 

    

 

. 0

 



1     

( 

 



 .

    

( *

       (  

           



        2         

  ( 

 ( 

  

   

   

   - 

  (

  

   -  -

-  

-    

.  

  



    (

  (-   

( 

    





(     

  

 

  



  

   (      -    

  (     

      

  -           

     

- 



(   



 .



          

 # "



#

               (  

         

  

       

     



  

 

  -  

 



 

     ( 



#

 



       



           

    

 

 

   

    

       #

-

       

 

?

       

+ ,

 

-      

 

   

 

 

#

 

       3 2&5 &+&,%)$+&(&+,%'$::*,$,D,&'%2&&>)&5%*,+ &,3*+$=&($43&&,)&9*,3*&;'%2& &5 %' 0(*)*$:$=*+% $%&+%
:$++9$%*$:$9($%&( 

1$(&*,50 +0$,)&'%2& (& ($%&(

A

5$++&(4D%2*+
0 %9%2&
0 %'&&:+%2$%,0+&'0:50 5+& ;0:(4&+& 3&(4DE&&5*,=%2&5 )&&(*,=+$:*3&%;*::4&*,%2&*,%& &+% '.0+%*)&9*'%2&+&%%:&1&,% &$)2&(4&%;&&,%2&5$ %*&+*+$))&5%&(

)) (*,=:D9%2&5 &+&,%5&%*%*,*+$::;&(($%&( 

 &=*+%& &(0,(& &)%*,+  $,( '%2&
$%:*)&

%$%*,81&,
&::9*+% *)%$%*$:$!

,,&>0 &#$,($::),+&<0&,%*$:

)&&(*,=+  $ *+*,=  %2& &'

1   $ &  2& &4D  <0$+2&(  <0$  %2&  5 &+&,% 5&%*%*,& + !


     



82&%2& +5&$E*,=B &$+,&( &+B

82&%2& &5 %$4:&G &+B