Shashi Sareen v. State Of Punjab And ORS

   

       

"#$ %$&'(')*

+ ,(-."(.'-",$$) $#'#')$, (!

/$,(0( -#"#$ 0)1"2")%#.$,( $(3)%$)# (!

 *  45   - 6 5-  ,$($)#*7 ,/'8"(".9:-$)',%;&"#$:<'#.:

("93,$$#-'%.0:%;&"#$: ,#.$3$#'#')$, ,'8.'9 .3,":%%'#')"9%;&"#$ $)$,"9:0)1"2 ,-"%<"9:%;&"#$: ,,$(3)%$)#(")%   .$#.$,#.$$3,#$,( 9&"9)$<(3"3$,=">2$"99<$%# ($$#.$10%?=$)#@
 2$,$ $,,$%##.$$3,#$,,)#  .$#.$,#.$10%?=$)#(.09%2$,$3,#$%')#.$%'?$(#@ 77 77 5- 

5!

.$3$#'#')$,:<.<"(<,8')?"("5$&#0,$,')')%'') 5  ',9( 99$?$:".)"%:"<")(."., ,$(3)%$)#.$,$')!:

<.'&.'(" ;$,)=$)#'%$%,';"#$9> ")"?$% 99$?$:,$#',$% ,= ($,;'&$)A 
-.$."%')'#'"99> '9$%#.'(<,'#3$#'#') ,,$9$"($

#.$2"9")&$ ?,"#0'#>"=0)# (
9"&("9)?<'#.#.$,2$)$ '#(# &=$(0##."#%0,')?#.$.$",')? #.$3,$($)#&"($:#.$';'(')$)&.

#.'( 0,#:;'%$,%$,%"#$%
B
A:%',$&#$%,$(3)%$)#(#,$9$"($#.$ ?,"#0'#>"9)?<'#.')#$,$(#"##.$,"#$ C.$,$"

#$,:'#&=$(0# ,= #.$')#$,'=,%$,%"#$%A
#."#"(3$,#.$<,'##$)(#"#$=$)#")%#.$ 9$##$,%"#$%


 ))$D0,$77!:39"&$%),$&,%:#.$$)#',$"%='##$% &9"'= #.$3$#'#')$,."(2$$)($##9$%.$,$ ,$:#.$<,'#3$#'#')<"( %'(3($% <'#.9'2$,#>##"8$")>#.$,"9#$,)"#';$,$=$%>')&90%')? '9')?

 ';'9,'#$#'#')  .$="##$,<"(#.$)#"8$)##.$3$D 0,# <.$,$')#.$"=0)# ?,"#0'#><"(%'(30#$%.$3$D 0,#,$=")%$%

7
7 #.$&"($##.'( 0,#2>="8')? 99<')?2($,;"#')(:;'%$,%$,%"#$%
+
A:3"(($%') ';'933$"9ABA 
+*7 $",$')&9')$%##.')8("(#.$9$",)$%&0)($9 ,#.$ "33$99")#."(%,"<)0,"##$)#')##.$9$##$,%"#$%
 
 <.$,$ ,= )#9$?'29$!'#'($;')&'29$#."##.$"=0)##<",%( ?,"#0'#>&=$(#(:A:7 )"3$,0("9 #.$&0)#$, "

'%";'# '9$%)2$."9  ,$(3)%$)#(#A:'#"33$",( #."##.$>.";$3"'%(:A:+7 03$$(#.,$$9"& '

#>$'?.# #.0(")%($;$).0)%,$%")%$'?.#>#.,$$)9>!#'()#&9$", <.$#.$,'#'(')&90(';$ ')#$,$(#,)# );'$< #.$"

,$("'%:<$%',$&##.$,$(3)%$)#( #A#%$3('#(
::7 03$$(#<9"&)9>!

2$ ,$#.$'?. 0,#<'#.')$'?.#<$$8(.$)&$")%#.$,$"

#$, #.$'?. 0,#(."993,&$$%#%$#$,=')$<.$#.$,#.$"=0)# ."(2$$)3"'%##.$"33$99")#")%#.$=%$ 3">=$)#.$ ')F0',>2>#.$'?. 0,#(."992$9'='#$%##.$("'%$D#$)# $,$F0$(##.$'?. 0,##%'(3($ #.$="##$,<'#.')"

3$,'% 0,=)#.( ,=#.$%"#$ %$3('# #.$"=0)#2> ,$(3)%$)#(#A $(09#")#9>:#.$"33$"9'("99<$%')3",#")%#.$ ,%$,3"(($%2>#.$'?. 0,#'(($#"('%$.$,$(."992$) ,%$,"(#&(#(G #&=$(0##."#')30,(0")&$##.$"2;$)#$%,%$, #.$ 3$D 0,#:,$(3)%$)#(%$3('#$%"(0= (
::7')#.$$?'(#,>  #.'( 0,# .";$.$",%#.$9$",)$%($)',&0)($9 ,#.$3$#'#')$,:#.$ 9$",)$%-#"#$&0)($9:#.$9$",)$%&0)($9 ,,$(3)%$)#(")% ")% .";$"9(&",$ 099>?)$#.,0?.#.$ '9$ .$(.,#F0$(#')",'(')? ,&)('%$,"#')"

#$,#.$,$=")%'( "(#<.$#.$,#.$3$#'#')$,'($)#'#9$%#?,"#0'#> (:A:7"( &9"'=$%,(
::
7:"(&"9&09"#$%2>,$(3)%$)#(@

77 $(3)%$)#(.";$&"9&09"#$%#.$ ?,"#0'#>)#.$2"('&3"> %';'%$%  2>  A:  #"8')?  #.$  ($,;'&$    #.$  3$#'#')$,  #  2$    >$",( $(3)%$)#( .";$2"('&"99>39"&$%,$9'")&$03)","7A ."3#$,7:

/90=$7 0,0")"8$; )';$,('#>&"9$)%",##"8$#.$;'$<#."##.$ ?,"#0'#>'(#2$&"9&09"#$%)#.$2"('&3">:2"('&$=90=$)#(&)('(#')?

2"('&3">390(#.$(3$&'"93">")%%$",)$(( 3"> "(")%<.$)%$",)$(( "99<")&$'(#,$"#$%"(%$",)$((3">!#'(&9"'=$%#."##.$3$#'#')$,<"( )#?$##')?")>3$,()"93">")%#."##.$%$",)$(("99<")&$<"(,%$,$% #2$="%$"3",# #.$3$,()"93"><'#. $

$&# ,= 
 :;'%$ )#'

'&"#')%"#$%BA
 ))$D0,$77
!:'((0$%2>#.$ ;$,)=$)#

0)1"2

)#.$#.$,.")%:#.$9$",)$%($)',&0)($9 ,#.$3$#'#')$, ."("9(,$9'$%03) 0,0")"8$; )';$,('#>&"9$)%",:<.$,$')&9"0($7

'''! #.$("'%","7A ))$D0,$77!:'#'(3,;'%$%#."##.$,"#$

?,"#0'#>:"(=">2$=%'

'$%2>#.$-#"#$ ;$,)=$)# ,=#'=$##'=$:

<09%2$"339'&"29$##.$ )';$,('#>$=39>$$( ,=#.$("=$%"#$")%) #.$("=$#$,=(")%&)%'#')(.$,$9$;")#$D#,"&#( ,=#.$("=$",$ ,$3,%0&$%"(0)%$,*7 '''!   3$,()  <.:  "

#$,  .";')?  ($,;$%  ')  #.$,

)';$,('#'$("

'9'"#$%&99$?$(')#.$0)1"2-#"#$')&90%')? 0)1"2 )';$,('#> .")%'?",.1')$%#.'( )';$,('#>(."992$ "99<$%  #.$  2$)$ '#    3,$;'0(  ($,;'&$  <.'9$  &"9&09"#')?

?,"#0'#>  "#  #.'(  )';$,('#>  "#  #.$  #'=$    ,$#',$=$)#:

(03$,"))0"#'),3,$7="#0,$,$#',$=$)#:"(#.$&"($=">2$ .$  ,"#$    ?,"#0'#>  "(  =">  2$  =%'

'$%  2>  #.$  -#"#$

;$,)=$)# ,=#'=$# #'=$<09%2$"339'&"29$##.$

)';$,('#>$=39>$$( ,=#.$("=$%"#$")%)#.$("=$ #$,=(")%&)%'#')(G

.$,$ ,$:'#<09%=$")#."#","7A #.$ 0,0")"8$;

)';$,('#>  &"9$)%",:  ,$9'$%  03)  2>  ,$(3)%$)#(:  &"))#  2$  ,$"%  ')# '(9"#')#."(#2$,$"%<'#.#.$(0&&$$%')?(023","("9(.$,$ ,$:'# ."(#2$&)&90%$%#."##.$?,"#0'#>'(#2$3"'%"##.$,"#$ 'D$%2>#.$ -#"#$ ;$,)=$)# ,=#'=$##'=$ .$9$",)$%($)',&0)($9 ,#.$3$#'#')$,."(3,%0&$%#.$ &3> #.$)#'

'&"#')%"#$%+BB #.$-#"#$ ;$,)=$)#') 0,# #%">:<.'&.'(#"8$)),$&,%:;'%$<.'&.')&9"0($
:'#<"(9"'%%<) #."##.$#$,=4$=90=$)#(4<09%')&90%$#.$%$",)$(("99<")&$"9(")%"( 3$,&9"0($A:#.$="D'=0=,"#$ ?,"#0'#><"(,"'($% ,=3,$($)#,"#$

(
:A:7#(:A:7 );'$< #.$ )';$,('#>&"9$)%",:,$3,%0&$%"2;$:#.$-#"#$

;$,)=$)#')(#,0&#')(",$"339'&"29$##.$ )';$,('#>$=39>$$("9( .$,$ ,$:"(3$,#.$-#"#$ ;$,)=$)#)#'

'&"#')%"#$%+BB:#.$ ,"#$    ?,"#0'#>  '(  $).")&$%  ,=  ( 
:A:7  #  (  :A:7 .$,$ ,$:'#<09% 99<#."##.$3$#'#')$,'($)#'#9$%##.$?,"#0'#>"##.$ ,"#$ (:A:7 )($F0$)#9>:(
::7:"9,$"%>%$3('#$%2> ,$(3)%$)#(")% 2$ ,$#.$$?'(#,", #.'( 0,#:",$,%$,$%#2$ 3"'%##.$3$#'#')$,"9)?<'#.')#$,$(#:' ")>:#."#."("&&,0$%)#.$("'% "=0)#  "

#$,&"9&09"#'):(=$"=0)#'( 0)%') $D&$((:#.$("=$ (."992$,$ 0)%$%#,$(3)%$)#(")%  .$ 9'='#$%3')#:)<.'&.#.'(&"($<"(,$=")%$%2>#.$ 3$D 0,#:(#")%(%$&'%$%"&&,%')?9>  

5- !

 


+ (18( .$#.$,(3$"8')?,$"()$% * $( .$#.$,$3,#"29$ * $(