Balkar Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR
!"# #$%&%'(
!)*!+,%'-.!'/".#+& #"%"%'#+& 0& ,"!"# 1'2!3!'/!'".#+ #&4'/#'"& (
!"!
"
# "
!
$ %
&&&&
" !
() $ *+* , *% %+** !
-%---,-.*.%/ -.
)0
-+/ )0 1 2
%3 %/
4
6 7*2 ' ! !
4 44 6 7.2
! () 4
!
9"
! "
!
"!
,++ 4 4
! ! !
5:
!
4
7 :
"
4 4 4 !
4
5:
!
!
; "
!
! :
4 :
4
:
:
; !
4 "
"
4
< $ 33=%/=%+** 4 :"
"
$ * : >7"
$ % - 4
)"
-.* -%- --, .%/ -.
)0
%3 %/
4
!
? 4 4"
-+/ )0
4 4 % . %+*% "
$ * 4 @ *+ / %+*/
0=
! !
4 6 ! "
44 / ** %+*/
! 0=
!
4"
!
/ ** %+*/
9 ! ) 0 $ 9 ! ) 0 $ !
4
44 ! "
"
6
.B% 0 0 !
4 4 44 4 4 ' !
AC
6
!4 !/.1 5%6!7# 8& ,"!"# !.!+!&."+!9 ,14+#6#1+" 9 .!2!'5!)8& ,"!"# !+7!'!!'/".#+&9
,14+#6#1+":
!'/,"!"# ;!+'!"!*!8&51'%&<!67!'/".#+&9
,14+#6#1+"
9 44 "
,"!"#".+1-.,4#$%!)#))9#< #).%8&!82",!'/.1= &.!'1+1!'/".#+&9 >?>+)? :>,? ! 44
!4 !
47
! " ## $ !
# %
" # # # !
"
! #
#!
#
"
#
# !
"
# # %
# " !&
'
#
" "
#!
( %
!
)* " + (,
(!
)* " + -. "
" + !
# ,# "/ 0
1 # " "!
# #
"
!
#
#
#
:
! "
#
# '
! " "" # "
'
'
##
# !2
#!"
""
# "
#!
# "+ !
" "!3 ( 5 ;1)<%'/#+,%'-.!'/ ".#+&8&,"!"# 1'2!3!'/!'".#+9> ?>+)?
.B% 0 0
4 44
4 A 6 "
!"
4 "
.B% 0 0
.B% 0 0 6 D67
!"# $!
%&&'() * !( +,-
.B% 0 0 AC
6 4 ! )
6 "
"
"
4 4 4 6 6
AC
6 ! "
6
! !
4!5 " " "
#% # " #"%
!
!5 " "
# "
# &6 7
#
# 489041 2
48801 !
-!5 " &6 "
" ""
# "%
!
)!5 &6 7
#:7 " # 2 "
48801 !
8!5 " &6"
#"
!
9!5
# 0 " 1 ;
#!
!5 " " # "; "
#
"%
"
!3 6
.B% 0 0 4 !
! "
4!"
4"
!
44 4 44 "
4"
!
"
4 !
44 %!' ,%'-. 8& ,"!"# 1'2!3 !'/ !'".#+ > ?>+)? AC
4 "
4 !
47
E3/ 4! 4 44 !
4 !
() 4 6
4 ! 4 4!
-%+ 0 "
4
6 ! ! FG 12
12
"
4 !
4 ( ) 4"
6 4
4 !"
A 6 4
! !"
4 A 4 "
: 4 " !"
!
4 4H 4"
4 "
4" "
44 4 : 0
44 :!
"
G "
!
4 ! !
5 4
!
4!"
74!"
!
! "
!
4 44 4
: !
44"
!
" 4"
!
"
!"
4"
4 ! 44 4 "
4 :
4 ! 64
4 !
4 4 4 44 4 4 "
4 !
4 !
4 4 44 4 !
4 '12 4
4 ! I AC
4
%!',%'-.@&$!&#>&14+!?
%64#712+!)8&'%'
#++%"+7 ".+1-. /6%'%&"+!"+9 9 .!'/%-!+. !'/ ".#+&9 >:?
!
-+/ )0 AC
6 "!
%!',%'-.@&$!&#>&14+!? 4 !
7 4
4 ! 4
!
!
AC
6
4 !
4 !
4 %!',%'-.@&$!&#>&14+!?
AC
6 4 ! ! 4
!
"
64 "
! "
!
4 !
4"
4"
4
-+/ )0 4 () !
' !
!
4 !
-+/ )0 4
AC
4 !+%'/#+,%'-.!'/".#+& 8& ,"!"# 1'2!3!'/!'".#+9 >?>+)?
AC
6 4 4!
-+/ )0 "
! "
74 ! ! ' 4 4 6
.B% 0 0 (!
-*
!47
E-* 4 "
!
! !!
' 4 4 6!
.B% 0 !
4 !
! !
4 4 !
1)2
.B% 0 ! 4 4
-%+ 0 $
.B% 0
4 !
4
4 4 A 6 !"
1))2 J
4 !
4 ! !!
12
12 "
0 6!
4 1)))2
6
4 "
: 4 "
4 "
4" !
44 : 0
44
:!
"
4"
44 4 1)@2 ; 4
!
4!"
74"
"
!
44 !
44 4"
4!
4 1@2 J 6!
64 "
4 :
4 ! 64
4 !
4 1@)2 ;
-+/ )0 !"
!"
4 ! "
! A 4"
4
-+/ )0 () !
:
4 )
64
-+/ )0 :
!
!
-+/ )0 ( ! "
"
=! "
4 !"
!!
; 4 " 64 !
"
4 :
4 4
4 ! 4 4!
4 4
! " 4 !!
4"
4 4"
4 1@))2 J !
6
.B% 0 4! 4 "
4 44"
! 44 4 ! 4"
!
4 4 !=! ) ! ! !
<: ! 4 " "
! 6!
" 4 4 4=4 4 ;
4 4 4 ! !4 4"
4 6!
.B% 0 "
4 4
-+/ )0 44
4" "
4 ! 0 4 44 ! 4 !
'
"
A !
-+/ )0 "
4 ' !
!"
4 I
,"!"# !/.7! +!/#&.
8&
##4!* !'/ ".#+&9 > ?>+)? AC
6
!
-+/ )0 !
! "
! !+%'/#+,%'-.@&$!&#>&14+!?
!
%!',%'-.@&$!&#>&14+!? 6 !+%'/#+,%'-.@&
$!&#>&14+!?
:!
4
4 J 6!
64 "
:
! ! "
;
-+/ )0 !"
!"
!
="
4 4 4"
-+/ )0 4 () ! )
-+/ )0
: ()
" 4 :
"
4 "
" 4 4 !
4 ! 64 !
"
:
4 !
4 !
-+/
)0 !
"
!
7
12 J 4 !
="
"
12 :
"
6 6 "
12 !! ! 4 4"
!
-+/ )0
12 4 "
44
0
!
!
! 4
!
"
! !! 4 6 "
4
!
!
!
!
7
!
-+/ )0 4!
44
) 4
"
4 !
"
-+/ )0
.B% 0 0 6 ! 4 !+%'/#+ ,%'-.@& $!&#>&14+!? 0'"
" () $ *+* , *% %+** !
-%---,-.*.%/ -.
)0
-+/ )0 1 2
%3 %/
4
6 7*
' ! !
4
"
9"
*3 %+*B >,?
J :!= =$ J =$