Monu (As Alleged Correct Name Mohit) v. The State Of Ut, Chandigaerh
!
"#$% &' ()* *
+,-&- ( .* *
$ /"
& 0012,,
3$-% ***4400
5&/& +**
-1 ***&4 6
+**
-1 ***4400
5&/& $ / ***&4 $( 7 8$* 9: ; 8$* **:9
!"# $#% & ' ( ) * **:92 * +"(# %# , ( " # #"( +"(#
-, .
%( / #
( +"(#
"("# " ( %.
"1
(".
" %
* 23 4 5
#
6" 7
3 8 7 84
"( (" ##
. .
9 1 " " "( (" ## . % #( #
* 3 4
:
%+ !" (
. # # (
# "( # ( # ,# " " #( "
( " # , %. :
, (
- # "(
3# "61#
%
,
** 7
0 5 , , , +"(# -8%
"#
!/ ; "+ :
3 4
*
% 8#84 (
:
< . ".(
7 .
6 ! "
:
%" #
# " ( . (
#.
##% .
% (
= .
( )) >
:
3=6 )? 14 . ((
#
# /,
"( #
(
%. #.
"
3
4
#
:
: .
(
#
%"(
"( %/ # - "( (
#
(
" "
34 "
, ,
?
# ,
#
"
34
, ( %" " #
"
0 # # "
" "
"
"
7 . #
"(( "4 "
34 #
#"
%.
## "
"
#
," # #(
# .
," /
" 6#.
( " .
#
# .
! " "
#
#( /
#
# (
.
," # #( "( ,.
#
," /
#.
(
/
#
#.
## (
,
?
% ( @5 (
: % # # # ?
#( .
( ( 3"4 " # +" A
, ( # "
5 " ( " 6#
, "( ? # ? A 3# #4 ?9 ) % # (.
6# #
# "1
* * # #+ # (
" #".
" ( #
(
"1 "(
( %"
) #.
,. , #.
#
-
% .
#
.
# , .
( # " (( # .
, "( ("( (
# " B" #
#.
- "
% .
# 6 #.
" ( # #
% "( " "" "
#.
% " "
/ " (
# # (
# # (
- "
% .
(
#.
% #
#
% /( "" (
"( # ( ( #
#
% ( " (
( -
/ #
/
"
## (( 6" " "
.
## .
#
'
"
6# , 7 "# . #"( +"(# %
$ " "
#.
% .
#.
#
-
" "%# #1"6
#
:
"
, ,
< , %.
% #
- " "%#
#
( )) =6 )? 1
:
%
"(
( " # /( (
" , ,.
,
" .
% (
"( %" "
-
6 "%# "#
"(( ( # .
( # # # , "
# " ( 1"
"
% " "%# ( %
# .
#+ # ( "
, B".
7 ,
* 5 # " (
# 5
% "%#
! " .
,
(
, 7
"
#.
"%# # " . # $ "
"%# " )) 3)? 14
#
, #+
=
# .
" . # " (
# ? # ("#
" 6# ?
C"#"/
( C#
.
. %"(
= %
# 9 :
- 6 # , ( %"(
# =6 9 .
# "%# # # # , " =6 =6
" ( "
(" # =6
5 6 % %+ .
, # " # ( %"
:
< . ' %" 6#
" 3)?:4 ?/ 5" C# C
.
0 ( "%# +" %
# # # #
9 : "%# # #.
"/ %
# #
9 :
/ "/
3 #4 %( %
# %"
"%# # %
5
.
# "%# +" # # "/
. "
6# ?
C"#"/
( C#
.
. (
.
%
# 9 :
6 % ( # %+ # #.
)?:
" # # " ".
%
" %
#1"6 9 :
# " ( %"
:
< . # 5
% "%# " )) . =6 )? 1 #
,
# #.
" .
# -, @5 ( ( ( (
% (
#
? "% ("# , =6 )? 1 " .
# 5 " =6 )? 1 .
#
( ( . .
, " %" # " -, .
# /,
,.
# "( .
/
# # (.
%( .
%"(
%/ (
%(( # %/ (
(
. @5 ( ( #( B"
" ##.
( @5 # 3=6 4 #
2:
" (
( .
%.
/ ,.
D
" "
( %.
.
( = # ?
"( "
" " #.
(.
6#
#.
" % / .
.
#
= #.
, ".
% # ? A 3# #4 " " " # % " # "%+ % 6" " .
% ( .
" 6# ? # " .
,
% "((
(
"
, 5
6# .
(
%.
# "( # "%
= "# / ("# # ( .
# # # ## # % (( B". % "
.
#
/ ,.
#
## 6" "
# ? # ? A 3# #4 ".
" #.
?9 ) % # (.
6# #
:
" 6# # 6# ,% # " ( %" .
, /
,
# (
( , % # , / ,
@. %.
6" " " % " " = # , @
$%.
.
"# # ,% / # " .
, # # # " "%+ (( 6" "
% ( .
7 -D%
"#
:
% " ! "#$%&''()*
!
"
!
# "
#
"
$%
"
&'(
)*+*,+-) ./0 1."
!
2
3
"
"
4
# !
(!
#
#
/"
!
!
"
!
1 '
0
/ +,#-.
$%('
'
0
"
!
4
) / 0"# "#$%&'')(
!
2
1#2# 3 %&( ' "
! " 0 #4 0!#$ 0&'5 5* +"
"
1 '
0 */
2#2 3- / %&&(6&)$
5 > ("#
B". " # ? # ? A 3# #4 ?9
) % ?
%+ !" 5( 7 " % , , # , ", .
"%# , .
7" +" # " # #"( +"(#
"( "# " (
" " 3"4 % # 6
%
& ' (
. #.
#"(
"("# " (
, " 5
% "%# " &'
(
, "1 B" /( , # % % @5 (
:
7 .
7 (".
7 % " (" ## #
%
.
#.
6 ## % % $ ##
2 0
7 "%" , ##"#
6 7
%
.
A" "
/
:1
: ##"#
7 ," # %
.
#.
6 ## " # # (# , ##
# 7 ## " (".
# " ".
" #
# "
% , , B"
%+ " #
% ".
0&>/?;&8 @&+
")-- 250/324 ).
%2
" "482. Object of punishment-"
#
"
"
#
!
2
!
"
#
"
#
#
5
) (emphasis supplied)"
-D%
"#
&
&5& + -&1 2"
% "0*%6.
" "The law enunciated by this Court in its recent judgments, as already noticed, adds and elaborates the principles that were stated in Bachan Singh and thereafter, in Machhi Singh. The aforesaid judgments, primarily dissect these principles into two different compartments-one being the "aggravating circumstances" while the other being the mitigating circumstances. The court would consider the cumulative effect of both these aspects and normally, it may not be very appropriate for the Court to decide the most significant aspect of sentencing policy with reference to one of the classes under any of the following heads while completely ignoring other classes under other heads. To balance the two is the primary duty of the Court. It will be appropriate for the Court to come to a final conclusion upon balancing the exercise that would help to administer the criminal justice system better and provide an effective and meaningful reasoning by the Court as contemplated under Section 354(3)Cr.P.C." .
,
, % ((( #(( "#
A
% ( ,( (
/ % %, , ,
+"
5 , E .F
"% ( .
5 #
"" .
6# +" %" " /( , #
.
(
C" % , , ,
% "
<
, "
$ "
"%# "
## #
" # .
. #6#"# % , #.
% # # 7
" " "%# ."( %. ( %"
. % #.
- .
#.
/
( #
.
6 - % " #
# A( . , #.
% / # ,
#.
, " " ?
"#".
6# ((( , #(( !( , % , , # + . # "
? # # , B" & '
( #
( "# % %
#
%.
# B". +"(#
"("#
" (
# ( . (.
= . . % .
6.
# '
% %/ "9:% "**:9%
.* *
#/ ?
/(1 G=
>7 ?
% G=
>7