High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AS/39/2022dismissed

M/S V2b Infra Thr Proprietor v. M/S Dsc Ltd Kmp Expressway Project And ANR

2022-03-24Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj17 pages

!"#!" M/S V2B INFRA THE PROPRIETOR ... Appellant $% '())*+'

))-

!!! . ' /*'

! )$ )! -

$ )! -!!0 %12

"# "

$ %& '

()* ), ) -

,.$

0 '

1 12 # # / 1 '

# ! 1 3 401 !

' 12 3

1 401 !

' ! ! 12

! '

5 $ ,6, 7( )( )

-2- %

7--))*' 1 /8&/ & 2 $1 8

' 1 ! 91 1 51

2 1 1 2: ! ! 1; , ) ) )6 ), ) 1 '

1 ! 1 '

1 $ + ## (6,1 1 !

1 7+$

/ 1 ! 1 '0 '

' 1 1 34!56 %

189& 4!5 &% ::#!"!"6 4!5# *71 ";!"#!"6 4!5 <

1% . 4!5= 4!-6( .>?%@%%A /'

0 !

8<'

1 4!-6( .>%

9& %> 4!-6( *%" !" !"6;

-3- 4!-6( *%B!"#!"6;

! 8 % 1 ! 4!56 .>89&!#;#6 B - = 1 # 1

0 !

012 # 5'

,. $

/ > # ! ! #

/ 1 1 12 '

1 12 ,) ).

)

% - ,) 2 12 !1 2 %

6))))*' 12 !

5 $ ,6, 7. % - 67)) 2

)( )

1 0 !5$ ,6, 7( )( )

7--))*' !1 2 5 12 1 0 12 512 ? ! @1 ),

) )

-4- .

/ 5 1 5 12

)( )

1 ! '

2 !

( ! #1 !'

! % -

6 21 ' 12 ,) ).

)

10 1 12 A 121 ' ) 9!1 2 5 %

7--))*' 1 91 ' 0 ! 12 ? ! @ 1

2 1 5

' '

1251 %!

5 %

7--))*'1 ' 11 ! /1 1 '

2 5 ' !

! 91 ' 5 / 51 B 1 ! !

! ! 1 12 1 0 1 ,. $

/ 9 1

-5- ! )!1 2* 12 ,) ).

)

1 ! ' 5 5 0 '0

! !

/1 '

012C1

)

# 1 0

1 ' :

! "

" # $% ##

"" & '!( )

## #"

* # # + ,("

& * #"-

& + & . / /0 /

+&(# +!

1 2%/%///' & . + *& #. #

%3/%///' 4" & . "

* & # #"-

# 5 3 60 /$ /

1 2% 3%6//'% & + & (# %

# + 7 -

-*% # 5 3 6$ /$ /

%62%2//'8

5 5

9& + + *& #. :& %#"-

# 5 1 2% 3%6//'%! ""- (# *& #. : # "

* 5 # 5 5 & ""!*

##!* +""

* # !

. 6 4 " ## #"

*% #"-

###"

&-- #"- & . - (# & . (# #. !

. + --; <//

-6- : # & . /$ /

& (# 1 2/%//%///'% & #-

- & . - 7 # & . &

##& - !- . # "

* 1

3%26%///' & ! = & . 7

1 3%26%///'& #-1 2% 3%6//' - *

#!*

- # 5 1

%62%2//' - # 5 5 % & "

* & "" : #% ##

# 5 3 <6 /< / /

% 1

%62%2//' 7 5& / /

!*) 4* > % 4

+ .% . ) 4

< %"

!* ###"

* # 5 # 5 5 ## ## #"

* "

!* ) 4* > % 4

+ .% . ) 4%

# &

& ## ###"

*%& 5 5 & &-- & & "

. , % ###"

!5 # 5

%62%2//' & / /

% & & !5 -* !

! %&

# 5 5 % #"-

# "

* # 5 5 !*

# 5 3 <6 /< / /

%62%2//' , % # 5 5 # 5 3 <6%& & ( #-* %& &

#"-

# - #"-

- "

+? 6 ,( ) 4%& !--

!* #"-

(# & . & & .

!* ## @ " - !--

-7- / / / % !--1 <%03%6' , # #"-

##" -

(# & . -* 1 <%03%6'%& ##

* 1 3%26%///' @

!-- -

# &

#"-

(# *& .(#" !-- / / %&

1 <%03%6'

3 , % #"-

* + # -

#"- & . %& 5 #"

* & . *

& . #

-+# # #- % # 5 # !

( + - !-* % "

- !-* !

#. #"-

% # 5 5 !

/$ /

%& !5 # 5 /< / /

/ /

% # ! * #"-

: #% #

###"

!5 # 5 - # 5 5 ""

0 @ & -% # 5 5 &

* & . / /0 /

% ! (# !* #"-

#"-

- (# & .

- & . / /0 /

& "- #!* && . /$ /

& "

# 5 & !5 -* % # 5 5 & * -+ --*

# !-- !-*! # (# & . % & #"-

(# & . % "

-+ --*

# !- - !-* #

<$ : A!- "

# #" -+ --*

# !-- !-* B 7 ("-

"" # 0("-

-8- + ("

C! - !-*D " " # 0 7 ("

-+ --*

# !- ! - !-* # 0 # 5

#% # 5

! #

+ * ! - !-* 7 ("-

# # 0% -! -+ --*

# !- ! - !-* ! +

- # 5 & %

# 5 #

+ ( + "

=# - !-* 5 !

+ +

# # 0 # 5 #"

+ * "

-+# - # #- !# # #-- &% - + & "

& "- # ""-% # &% # 5 #

( +! - !-* "

* !*# 5

* #

- # 5% &

( +- !-*

! '

12 1

! '

2 5

. 1 ,( $

/ ..

! ! '

! 0 ! 1511 12 1 121! ' 012

-9- 12 '

** )

*)C *

1 !9 # 1 5 9D #

! "

# $ %&' "8 29# 68 9"

# ! "& ""-- " + "" -"

! #- 8 9 8!9 - & "" - #5 - "" - # # "#-* 7 !

"& #

!* #- 8 9 & - & "" #5 - & "& #

!*#- 8!9 -& "" # # % % !

:+ A "& - + &

"" -

5 --*&& "" - 5 #5 - # # 7

"# 5 7 "# 5 #

& :+ " - +& "" -

#5 - - + & # "" -% :+ E

--* !

# #

##" #

" + !*

#5 -"

!* - %

##" - !

!- !&-- -& *!"

:+ & - & # 4 ""-- :+ +

--* -& ! + +

# !* - %"

-*& + !

- #!# -

+ & # + &

+ # 7 % + "& :+ - +& "" #5

-10- &

- +& "" # # % ' - + & #- "" -% ""

+ #

-& +

# # % & ' "& "

;% & - ## % #* " ""

- +& "" - #5 - "

% "

& "

-+ -"

& # #"# # ""

:+ * ! - + & "" - #5 -% !-* - & # #- " # # !* "

# "# +-

# # ## "

! #-

!* * #- &

" 7 % +," 8 9 ?

," 4 1 $6< <

- # % & % "

; + " # " + # ""

- +& "" - #5 -%& !

# #

#!* #5

%F + - &

+ + &

+ # # !

-* 8 9 8 $69 1 2 4 $0 89 4 1 $6< < % *! #"-- + FB

7 8 9 -

-* 4= = ! 89%& !

# :+

"" #5 - &- ! = -*

F *! #"-- + A9 # %

#5 ! -* F+

# -*#+ F F + F ""

# +

# ! %! !

! &

- *& +

-(!- -& - +

# :+ "" -

#5 - 7 * & % - !

' #

-# #- 8 9 # 68 9 4--

-11- '"

:+ - + & "" #5 - + ! # !# 1--! # &

"% "

# #

## F # -*& . !*

! #5 - F7 % ++!* ("

#"-- + F - ! # -

! +-* ""- *# 7

# # # % #% 1 =

89 :

7 = ! 869E % #

! + =+

#5 -% :+ #

-* #

+ # " 7 % 5 &

. - "

"" -& -"

#!* "

# % :+ & = + # #-

8 98 $<9 1 $% / 898 $<9 16 0898 $2 9 1 / 8698 $29 "" 1 /6 "

# # ""--

! "

!* '

!-!%

* & . !* - & %

& + 5 % & &-% !% # - !

# ""

# + # !* ""-- # #- :+ 4 #- 2 & &-

-* ! -#

& +

# # !* :+ "

-*& +

- #

, "9D # ( )## "* , "- # + "" - % - &

"" #5 #" ! # 30

# !* :+ ""

#5 - 5 !# - # !

- 8/ /9$ 0$%

#"- ! --&

-12-

"" #5 - # 30 "

$%! -

- & +-

& =+ #5 -"

!* -# 7 ""-- # -

-* =+ #5 - & &&

"!-% + &

""-- # * ! "

!- ) - - + & =+ #5 -% ""-- #

# # # %

+ & & -# & " &

!- 7 ""-- # -# &

+ +

#% -#

- . #

!- #

. #

+ # #

*- & -

-*% +"- # + ! "

* -! !=#'

# *!* ""-- # 8 - .1 G 8 $3<9 $%

8 $$/96 3%

" G 8//9 32 %?

8//69 /2$$% G 8//29$ 3 % G 1 8//39

/% 1 1 1*8//09<<<%4 - 8//$9 //2% - .

1* 4 8//$9 2$0 1 : 8/ /966<9

" +," 4 1 $63% * #-! B8 4" 6/69H :+ - &-- -& * + "

" &+ #

# 8 9 & >+ # !-* & E 89 "

# #

##% "

" # -* & . !*

! #5 -E89 + ## ! * !E 869 -&

-13-

""-- # ! + +

>+&

+ + &

6 7

#"- - &

# -* !

--& !* 8 7-

4 1

$<6 % -! = !4 1 $<3 2% I 4+

4 1 $2 //%

8 $3/96</% !

- 8 $$09<6 %

+& 8//960< I = *7

8//393<<9

8//396 <%

-+ - " B 8 " 6% "

69 8 9 4 ""-- #

-- "& &% ""

# # # " & #5 - 89 7

- # % $3 " - % # # ( # # "& ""-- # # ! * & # #- % ! 5

- 89

% # % C! #"-- + D%C+

# + D%C * + # # #D% C # #- D% C+-

+ .D%#

# -( "& ""-- # "" #5 - # "

C - - + +D "

-# # ""-- #

& #5 -

# - "& # & # #& # #-

8694 ""-- # % & %!

#5 -% !-"

## J -*% "

# #

- !- - "

#"-

-14-

- = "

* "

-- ! "

# - "

+-*!* #" # - & # -*% ##

+ # #5 -% "

# #

+ !* -# 8<9 &

!-# #-

"!- !

# # % ""-- # - ! + #5 # !* #

2 I * - G 8//09 /6</%

&% ! +

""-- # - +& # & #

#5 ##% - !

- # D #5 - !- "

# 7 ""-- # + &+ #

# -#

# + & # + & % & ! " - # !-* &

3 1 =

8//$9$20% (

- =+ - &

B8" 36%"

/9/ H

#5 - - !-+ -*

& # !-

# " + + &

0 G

8//$9 6 3 % + # --

# # # & &-!=

+& =+

#5 -!* :+ 7 # # # #-B 8" 02%"

09897 :+ D# !

--*

& - & !* + + --+ -" 897 :+ D# #-

* #

-15-

# # E 897 ""

:+ - +& # & "

-* --+ - - + +

+ =#E 897 :+ D=+ -* =

!- !

- &

# # E 89 7 -& * + "

" &+ #

+ :+ E 897 &-!( -* -#

+ & # & ! :+

# #5 - 4 -

- 8//$9 /6/

$ 7 % - & # !

(#"

- # &

#"-- + # # #% =+

"" - ! " % ""-- # #

& #5 - 7 ""-- # -!

# #

- # D #5 !- "

# #

& &"!- - ! % -

# 8"

""-9 -) +

# # !* # # ! - !"

! -& # "

# %& "/ 7 +

# # !* # # ! - !" +

!*+ + (#- + - - !* . + #

!- - 7 + * -! !" &+ # % +

+-* -+#

-* 8 1 =

-16-

- 4 8 $069 6 2<% ,(#

7 ( @

# '#'4 + 4 * I" ?

K $$""89 %7 1!! K - # , $$6 "" 89 22<% I * :

8// 9 </ % 4 - 8//$9 / /2 I - &

1 4 8//$9 /229 8"

""-9 -' ! %

--& + # # -" -# $$$9 /%

# + -*

- !- #

!- " &- # " % &- ! " # # & ##" !- & #- ! - " % # #- &- ! " +&- !

-' # = *

% 8/ $9<62%

## # #"# 30

#!* :+ "" #5 - 7 #

# +

%! - "

4 # - 5 # ! # ! G!

> !

8 $309 0 # ! % :+

& #5 -"

!* -

# # # :& % :+ % & - + #5 -% # + !* -

-# & -

#5 + ##

+ =+ :+ % ! - "

/ B 8 " 9 / @ # "" - & + -* #5 -% :+ -

# # " -* #& # #- @

-*% :+ &-+" # "

-17- >+ &

# # 7 - &-- !

""-# !- "

# & >+

!--* & + " * #- + "# "#-

# # # #

6 I"

-1* 4 8 $3$9 <<%

& -# --& - !!&

# -!% =## & * # - . & #& !!

-*"!-% !* :+

=#%-

=# ! !

+ #- 8"

""-9

1 '

12 !

! ! 1 ! 012

1 ! # /

551 !

!! '

! # / ! #

! ! 0$ )! -2 ' D"

Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No <%

E*$