High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/18597/2017allowed

M/S Anubhuti Cold Chains Pvt Ltd & ORS v. Assistant Commissioner Of Income Tax Circle 4 Chd

2020-02-28Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill10 pages

!"#"$%

&'( ')* +#$(&,( "-., "$# 01 .0 '# 00200

'# '#(# ##"#

44"##"$ ' $!4 5"'!- 6*, $."7 ',

#8$.

% 91 0 : ::11

% #0

.,";

:('"*:'0./!

*<"

'00:0= $.

*./!

* '

'#0 #0 '/ #,"(77 *:'0:

$."$7($# -* '

#8$.

$!4 5 0

, 8'

"$ ($.

' :

"$ 6 '0 00 , &

$ "- . ' >( #,"$7 !48- "$ .

. 0?0 @$$ 5('

A($.

"$B'

.<"

$!4 5!

*B@,

CA '

## ##4

'6* #(44$"$7'.

?0?0 @$$ 5('

A $ 7'($.

."#!-# !44"##"$ $) 8($"#, &- ($.

".:

"$# 0 #8 # 8'

'0 "- ."

('$# "$!4 ' ## ##4

'6$ 006* .

!- '"$7 "$!4 #0**?+

' !- "4"$7

DE .(!

"$ #0**+"$,

'3*&(

'< ##

. '#!'( "$) $ ($.

6?@A !

< # "##( . $ 6000 , $ ($.

"$ 6?@A ' $ ($.

' :

"$6@A !

#"##( .$00B #;"$7

8'.(!

#,&;0, !!($

8'.(!

.$ 00B0 "# '

. '4 $ "$7 #,

# .

00B

!!($

; & !; #, &;

!!'."$7-)* #(44$# < 7"$7 "'

8'.(!

#, &; $ 00B* <,"!, < # '

"/ . &)

$* # '/

F"$.

' '7 < # $ 8'

'* ## ##"$7 "!

'8 58

##4 '.

'$00B0 "# ('

$ ($.

"$??@BA #"##( ('$"#,!

#,&; $ 00 < # #(&4"

. $ 00 ($.

' .( !;$<- .74 0 #8"

9# , /"$7 8'.(!

#, &; $ 00B "$ $ 00* #,<!

(# $ '8'# !( "$($.

B #"##( .$?00 '$$8'.(!

#,&;0#8 !" "!'

8-)< # "- .&)

< # $ '

#$ $ 8

8'.(!

"$ !

#,&;0:"4"- '$ #"##(

0* 7"$7 "'

$. 8

' 0?* '4 ' "'

,(7,, .'

#"7$ ."$8'"-0 # 8

$ &) '

#8$.

##"#

44"##"$ ' $!4 5* #(44$# ($.

D?E :

"$ ? !

< "##( $. < '/ ,'(7, '#$<';"$7"$ ,(# $..('"$7 ##4 8'!

."$7# ($.

' :

"$ 6?@?A !

* $ ($.

' :

"$ 6@A

. 00B < # "##(

$. < # .(-) '/

#(&4"

#,&;0, < # "5 . ' 00B $. $ ". .

( ,'"G

"/ @0 0A

. &( .".$ #(&4"

#,&; 4

'< .F('$ 00B&( $ "..

-#*$$

.0, ( ,'"G

?00B &( .". $ #(&4"

#, &;0

' # 4 $)

#* ( ,'"G

!!($

8'.(!

#, &; 00B $."

# ($.

.4 - 8('!, #* '

"7, )4

!0 4'

#0*+"$ ) "$ !

#,0 ,

< -# #;

#,< <,

' ' !/ .&) 5!

"$6@?A 7"/ $"$ (- B0 "# ('

.('"$7 8'!

."$7# "$ $"$7 00B*

. &) ( ,'"G

*, #"$ '4

#, &; , . &

< ) &) 4 <"

,( '4"##"$0 < #;

' $ 00B <"

, !

#, &;*&( $&.)

.0, ( ,'"G

8,$"!

--) #;

('$ #, &;* &( $ "-0

4 , "- "' 8,$ < ($. #<"

!, . 0 ,

'* #(44$# ($.

' :

D6E ?< "##(

000$00B 7"$7 "'

$., !!($

$. "!

?0 00$ .

)* &( 7"$7 "'

' '

(# !!

$ !!

.&)$

$*<,<';#"$ ,(# 7"$7 "'

'0 ,(#* '.

' ($.

' :

"$# 66+6?@?A !

< # 8 . $ 00B0 / # 8

## ##4

' 6* < < "'

'# 48 $)* $ -)*

F"$.

' '7 $. " $#, =, $0 ,(#* & "'

'# -"

&- ' # !44"##"$ 4"##"$0 , ,

'. -

'$ . :

$"' ($# - '

'* -

'$ .:

$"':

$."$7($# - '

$.<"

"' &- ##"#

*, 7$ ,'(7, "- 0 8'!

."$7 ('

'* "

<(-. & F(#

88'8'"

"$B #($.

'% H

'#$<"-- (--) "-# 8'.(!

*'!

& 8'.(!

.* $ ' & .

#8 !" "

. "$

$) $ '/ . $ ,"4 ($.

' #(&# "$ @A "$6*#(!, !!($ $..!(4

$ ' <"- (--) "-# !48-) ."'

"$ "##( ,"4 ($.

' #(&# @A

"$* , #, -- & 8($"#, &- <"

'"7'(# "48'"#$4 '

'4 <,"!, 4 )

$ )

$.<"

, "$ 0I , 8'/"#"$#

"-"$7 ($.

' :

B<(-.!4 "$ '!

" '#$<"-- (--) "-# 8'.(!

!!($ .!(4 #0 # 8 '

!'. $. '.

.00B* #,&;< #8'.(!

$."

!!($

."$ ./

& !; "$

#, &; < # '

"/ . &) "!

' $ 00* <,

##,<!

(# $ ($.

"$B "##( .$?000 # # 8

' 0? J " $#, =, $ "# !$!

'$ .*, .'

#"7$ #"'

'"$8'"-* $., &

$ "$/-/ . "$ .

) .

)

"'# 48 $)0 '4 "$."!

" $#,=, $, .$ &

##!"

48 $)<0 0 00600 :

"$? "#'

8'.(!

#($.

'% ! "#" @A , ## ##"$7 "!

'* 8( ) 44"##"$ @88

-#A* "$ 44"##"$ '* 44"##"$ ' @88

-#A*

'"$!"8 - ,"

44"##"$ ' ' ,"

44"##"$ ' '

'"$!"8 -44"##"$ ''44"##"$ "#8(

#-(

- '

"$ !- (# @A #(&# @A # "$ 66 #, --* ' 8('8# # ,"# !

8< '# /

."$ !('

($.

"/"- '!

.('

*@ A*<, ')"$7 #("

"$'

#8 --<"$74

'#*$ -)%K @A."#!/ ') $."$#8 "$L @A $ '!"$7

$) 8 '#$* "$!-(."$7 $) "!

' & $;"$7 !48 $)

4"$"$7,"4$

,L @A !48 --"$7 8'.(!

"$ &;# !!($

'.!(4 #L @A"##("$7!44"##"$#0 @A '"$!"8 - "'

' - ' "'

- ' '"$!"8 - "'

' ' "'

' ' "$ "'

' ' ##"#

' ' 8( ) "'

'* ( ,'"# . "!

' '

"$ #(&# @A # "$ ? & ,

"$ ($.

!- (# #@A @A

#(&# "$*, #'

#$ #(#8

$)"$!4 #&

$!$!

.*'"# -";

-) & !$!

.* &) $) 8 '#$ ' !- ##

DBE '#$#* <"

,"$ ,"# F('"#."!

"$* $* ' 8('8# # 4 ;"$7 $) $>("') ' "$/ "7

"$7

* "

#, -- & !48

' ,"4

'!"# 8< '#!$ ''

.($.

'#(&# "$@A "$!4

5 ( ,'"

# '

#(&# "$* $ ,#

$."$7

$ 8'!

."$7# ,'

#8 #(!,8 '#$'!- ## 8 '#$# $."$7 & ,"4 ' $) ' "$!4

( ,'"

)0 @A

8('8# ;"$7

"$>("') "$/ "7

"$"$'

#8 $)8 '#$'!- ## 8 '#$# "$ '

"$ :

"$ ' :

"$ * "

#, -- & !48

' $) "$!4

( ,'"

) $ & -< '

$; ##"#

44"##"$ $!4

5* # 4 ) & $ " "

. &) '. "$ ,"# & - * '!"# 8< '# !$ ''

. ($.

' #(& "$ @A $ "$!4

5 ( ,'"

# '

#(&# "$* $ ,#

$."$7

$ 8'!

."$7# , '

#8 #(!, 8 '#$ ' !- ## 8 '#$# $."$7& "

' $) '"$!4

5 ( ,'"

)0 @?A :(&F $) '(- # 4 ,"# & - * $)

( ,'"

"$#(&# "$@A'#(&# "$@A '#(&# "$@A4 )"48($. $.'

"$"$"

#!(# .) ' #(!, 8 '". # "

,"$;# "

$) &;# !!($ '

' .!(4 # 8'.(!

. & "

$) 8'!

."$7 ($.

,"#!

'/".

$ ## ##"$7 "!

' ' $ ##"#

'' 8( )"'

'#, --$ K @A "48($. $) &;# !!($ ' .!(4 # <"

,( '

!'."$7 ,"# '

#$# ' # ."$7*' @A '

"$ "$ ,"# !(# .) $) #(!, &;# ' .!(4 # ' 8 '". 5!

."$7 "

$ .

)# @ 5!-(#"/ ,-".

)#A ,( &

"$"$7

88'/ - '"$!"8 - ,"

44"##"$ ' ' ,"

44"##"$ ' ' '"$!"8 - "'

' - ' "'

' - ' '"$!"8 - 44"##"$ ' ' 44"##"$ ' ' '"$!"8 - "'

' ' "'

'* 4 )& 0I

'$ .:

$"'($# -

'"$7 '

'# !$

$.#

"$#

# $ '

!'. . $ !"8,

$) '.

' < # 8 . ' ."'

"$ 7"/ $ '

"$ #, &;0 ,(#* $!

< # $ <"-- (-

"-('

8'.(!

&;# !!($ #* "48(7$ 8'!

."$7# "$"

&- ) # - <0 "# ('

' #

# 8

. - <* <, # $ !'. . $ ."#!-# !44"##"$ $) 8'!

."$7# -"

&- & >( #, .&) ,"#$9&- ('

($.

#"$, !'"4"$ -F('"#."!

"$($.

"$6'0 00 $ #(88'

, "$#* -

'$ . :

$"' !($# - '

'#, #'

.(8$ F(.74 :(8'

#,< '"< '"M '#3#0 $.

="#,'

)* '"4"$ - 88

- 0 .

!".

. $ 00L -8"! "$ 1 .0 3#0 0 :

#"/ '* @A? : ?L

8#" .# 1 .0 ' 3#0 :8 !"

- (."!"

- 7"#

'#* @A : 6 $. :4 "

- 3#0 / '$4 = '$

*@A:6 F(.74 -," "7, ('

"$ :,'

$ (8

3#0 ##"#

44"##"$ ' $!4 5@A* $(+++0 ', $.*-

'$ .:

$"'#

$."$7!($# - '

#8$.

'7(

#$'

!'.!-

'-)8"$ ( <"-- (- "-('

'#"$ 8'.(!"$7 #, &;0 "# ('

'7(

,(7, #, &; , . &

$ 8'.(!

. $ 7"/ $ .

)* .&

$& !;&) !!($

'# ,( $) ( ,'"

) ' !$# "!"

-#+ "!

DE #8$.

0 "# ,(#* !$

"# $ $-) $$ !48-"

"$ 6@A !

* &( "# ,(7 !$ ."!

"$#"$

$.#

$&)

-0 "# ('

'7(

$.'

8'"$

#, &;7"/ $($.

"$??@BA $00< "$ !48-"

8'/"#"$# :

"$ 6@A !

0 $#(88'

, '!$

"$#*-

'$ .!($# - ' #8$.

.(8$ F(.74 :(8'

"$ 0 ) $3 '#(#:0=0

'(4 -*6 :B?6 BBLF(.74 # ,"#('

"$+# -(

43 '#(# *6 @ MA $. :('F"

$7"$

'"$7 N';# M '# '#(# * 6 @ MA F(.74 .,) #,"7,('

"$ 0077 '< - '#3 '#(#

$"$ $."

* B0 $

8#" .#1 .09#!

@#(8'

A<,"- '

-)"$7(8$ #8'

/"(#.

!"#"$#"$ 'F(.74 #'

&/ *

$9&- :(8'

<,"-

"$7 #".

'8 &) "7, ('

, -.

" "# $ #(&#

"$#"$ !48- "$ "7,('

<(-.& -- ,"$"

#'"7, >( #, 8'!

."$7#0, &# '/

"$#4 &) "7,('

;"$7!7$"G &) 7"#

* "

$$ & ".

"$# "$ !48- "$ # &#('. $."$, -)"48'& &- $ & #"# <,"!,$8'(.

4 $!

!, F(# !$!-(#"$

5"# # $ #( "!"

7'($. ' 8'!

."$7# "$#

!!(# .*<

#".

DE "# #

. - <

<, $ "$ # $ !'.* $ "# 4 ( * !$ "$("$7 <"

!'"4"$ - 8'!

."$7#*"#$ ,"$7&( &(# 8'!

## - <0 $ "$#

* <, $ !

#,&; < # 8'.(!

$00B*$'.

''."'

"$< #7"/ $ '"

($.

' :

"$ ?@?A !

0 '

'* 8'# !( "$# ($.

"$B!

$$-)& - ($!, .$<"-- (- "-('

8'.(!

&;# !!($ #0$ ,"#!

8'.(!

00B

00 .(

!;$<- .74 0 ,(#* < # $ /"-

"$ ($.

' :

? <,"!,

"-#8 )8'!

."$7#($.

0 ($.

"$6@A

$.# !48-"

.0 , 8

'# < "##( < '$"$7 $ #(44$#($.

"$? <"

"8(-

$$!48-"

<"--

"-8 )0 - (# @.A :

"$@A *<,"!,!

<0 0 0060*'

.# #($.

'% H:0@A0 $)8 '#$* @ A @!A55 55 555 @.A "-# !48-)<"

$ ($.

'#(&# "$@A :

"$ 6 ' #(&# "$ @A :

"$ 6? '

"-# !48-) <"

."'

"$ "##( . ($.

' #(& "$@A :

"$60I , "$ , $. .". .

# $ -- <"

,"$ 4&"

"$ @A@.A !

"# $ <"-- (- $$ 8'.(!

"$ !

#,&;#0 .4"

.-)* #,&;, .&

8'.(!

. $ 00B $. 00* <,

#,<

DE (# $ #"##(

'#$?000,(#*

$& ".#,<!

(# $ #,&;, .&

8'.(!

.0, "##(

#,&;8'.(!

.#(&# >( -) < # <'

, '

' $ "# &

$ "$ ##4 8'!

."$7#* &( $$ & 4 & #"# ' "$"

"$7 !'"4"$ - 8'# !( "$# 8

'#0 , F(.74 -"

. (8$ &) -

'$ . !($# - ' '

#8$.

88-"!

&- # 8'

0 ,(#*"$/"

) $.!"'!(4#

!(8- . <"

- < - ". .<$ &) $9&- :(8'

8#" .# 1 .09# !

@#(8'

A* "48(7$ !48- "$

#(44$"$7 '.

?0?0* &)>( #, .0 --< ."$ &/

'4#0

&'( ')* $%&'%&( )'

)**+ .# ,

( N,

':8

;"$7+

#$ .% #+ N,

&- % #+