Jasbir Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Revenue) Punjab And ORS
!"# &#'()($*
+ ,+
++++++ #"("($*#.
2#.)3)
#6#*3#7 3*8!- $"1#.) ++++++ #)9$*&#*") :
; +
/ /
.#)#*"
.+ /3<15##"
/(*017
&6$'!"# 9#"("($*#.+
.+ (.5!48("
(=!*!7 /#*($.
3*8!-+
+ + /
7
+
;
>> .!?#.
!994('!"($* %(4#& /#'"($* 94!'(*0 .#'$.& '#."!(* &$'35#*")
**#@3.#) >+ $.
.#!)$*) 5#*"($*#& !994('!"($*7 )!5# !44$=#& &$'35#*")
> !.# "!<#* .#'$.&7 )3-8#'"
!44 83)"
#@'#9"($*)+
994('!"($* !''$.&(*04?
&()9$)#& $%+ + #"("($*#.
%(4#&
."('4#) A , $*)"("3"($* *&(!7 (*"#.
!4(!7 ())3!*'# *!"3.# '#."($.!.( )#""(*0
#6#*3#7 3*8!-
7
)1$."
:$44#'"$.:+
+
.(#%4?7 ()# /1.( 3<1"(!.
/(*017 9.#6($3) !4!7 #1)(4 ()".('"
!.(&<$"7 9.$'##&(*0) =#.# (*("(!"#& %(44(*0 !%$.#)!(& 6!'!*'?7 =1#.#(*
!8(*&#.
=#.# '!*&(&!"#)+
+ 1# !(- #1)(4&!.
=#44 #1)(4&!.7 .#'$55#*&#& '!*&(&!"3.#
!%$.#)!(& 6!'!*'?7 /3- !0()".!"#7 .#'$55#*&#& '!*&(&!"3.#
!8(*&#.
!99$(*"5#*"
!%$.#)!(& 6!'!*'?
$44#'"$.+
+ 1# 6(&#
7 !99$(*"#&
!8(*&#.
!4!+
+ ##4(*0 !00.(#6#& !0!(*)"
!%$.#)!(& $44#'"$.:)
7
9.#%#..#& !* !99#!4 (6()($*7
)1$."
:(6()($*!4 $55())($*#.:7 =1('1 '!5# !44$=#&7 6(&# ++
7 =1#.#-?
$44#'"$.:)
)#"
!99$(*"#& !4!+
+>
#(*0 &())!"()%(#& =("1 ++
7
!8(*&#.
9.#%#..#& .#6()($*
A 7 =1('1 '!5# !44$=#&7 6(&# (5930*#&
=1#.#-?
&#'(&# !%.#)1+
+ * !%$.#5#*"($*#& '(.'35)"!*'#)7 %(4#& )##<(*0 .#4(#% )7 *$"('#& 1#.#(*!-$6#+
>+ #!.&+ + * '!)#7
!8(*&#.
!99$(*"#& !4!7 #1)(4 ()".('"
!* !99#!4 -#(*0 %(4#&
$44#'"$.:)
)#"
!99$(*"#& 9.(5!.(4?
0.$3*&
5$.# #&3'!"#& "1!*
!8(*&#.
/(*017 =1$ $*4?
"1 '4!)) 9!))
1!& 1() !)"#.:) �.##7 .#6()($*
A -#(*0 9.#%#..#&
!8(*&#.
/(*017 )#"
++
7 -!'< &#'(&# !%.#)1 !%"#.
'$*)(&#.(*0 5#.(") #.(") -$"1 '!*&(&!"#)7 .#4#6!*"
#@".!'"
"1#.#$% .#!&)
>
!"!#!##
$
% &
'
!())#!## *
+
*
,
% -.' % ,
$
&
/ )0 1 23
/ / )(!( " /
!())#!##
*
4 +
9#.3)!4 !-$6# #@".!'"#&
=$34& )1$= #@!5(*# =1#"1#.
!4!
$.
*$"
("
'4!(5#& 1# .#)(&(*0 !"
/".##"
7
1!* $4$*?7 !.(&<$"+ A+ * '$3*"#.
!%$.#)!(& .#!)$*(*0 0(6#* .#'$.& 6$"#.
'!.& 6$"#.
4()"
)1$=(*0 1() 6$"# !4!B 5?
'$*)(&#.#& 6(#=7 5#.#4?
1!6(*0 6$"# !"
$*# 94!'# '!**$"
4#!& '$*'43)(6# (*%#.#*'# 9#.)$* 5!?
94!'#+
9#.)$*) 5!?
1!6(*0 4!*& 1() 6$"#7 -3"
1# 5!?
=$.<(*0 !"
)$5# %!.
!=!?
94!'#+
"
=#44 )#""4#& !6!(4!-(4("?
9#.)$* $*# 9.(5!.?
.#C3(.#5#*"
!99$(*"5#*"
9$)"
;!5-!.&!.7 )$ '!..?
$3"
%3*'"($*) &3"(#) #*)1.(*#& 39$* )3'1 9$)"+
* '!)#
!
"# $3."
1!& $-)#.6#& .#*&#.(*0 )#.6('# '$553*("?7 9.#)#*'# #*)3.#& #6#*"
*$* !6!(4!-(4("?7 )39#.($.
C3!4(%('!"($*) '!*&(&!"# !.# *$ '$*)#C3#*'#+ ,+ $*)(&#.(*0 !-$6#7 %(*& $-8#'"($* .!()#& !0!(*)"
.#0!.&) !6!(4!-(4("?
9.(5# (59$."!*'#7 =1('1 .#C3(.#& '$*)(&#.#& '$*'43)(6#4?
&#'(&#&+
+ * 9#'34(!.
%!'") '(.'35)"!*'#) '!)#7 %(*& *$ '$59#44(*0 .#!)$*) (*"#.%#.# (5930*#&
=1#.#-?
A #@!5(*# =1#"1#.
!4!
$.
*$"+
+ 1!"
!9!."7 )(*'# !4.#!&?
&##5 ("
!99.$9.(!"# &(.#'"
!9!."
%.$5 !6!(4!-(4("?
'!*&(&!"# 6(44!0#7 $"1#.
%!'"$.) #*6()!0#& 34# 3*8!- ;!*& #6#*3# 34#)7 '$*)(&#.#&+ + #)34"!*"4?7 %!(4) )!5# !''$.&(*04?
&()5())#&+
+ #*&(*0 !994('!"($*
)7 (% !*?7 )1!44 )"!*& '4$)#&+
/
+ ,+
)8<) 1#"1#.
)9#!<(*0 .#!)$*#&
#)
$ 1#"1#.
.#9$."!-4# #)
$