High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5575/2023disposed of

M/S Medi Gas Corporation v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2024-03-13Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj24 pages

!"!

#$ % % M/S MEDI GAS CORPORATION

STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS

& '(&%) *

)%+ ,,,,,

" #

Mr. Aditya Sharda, DAG, Punjab.

$$$$$ *

)%+-%./01 1.

# "

'()* + !, ' %,

-)))).

)/ ) )// + "% /001 #

/2 // ) & '%

" , #

# # "

, ' 3" #

-2- 4

' # #

', "

# # + !, + " !5 ' %6 3'+ + " ! + "% # /001

/- ) ))/ # 7

# '

# , #"

4 !

: 5;

6 8 = > " 4

&"+ ?

&" # ;@ ," "+ %A &

# # # '

! '% # 3'

8 '

' ' "

! "

,,"

' & # / / ))) 8 # "

&%#

# ", % !

& "

# 3' "

, # -)))). " ' % !

+ "/.'.4>;. 0.B)/< )/ ) )// 8

# ', !

# # '

! "

' %

&! , &

' !

"% ",

' " # % )))1C ))1)BC ))B)2 ))2)0

() )( )// , '%

>, ( ; # "

# ,

, D, &

# , ;

&!# # , , &"

# # ,

& !

) )1 )/ &

-3-

& # 7" &

% E3

#, ,

# 4 8 & #

## " #

# , &

8 , '

'% #, % ,,' #

, D, F

", ' % #

>, 8

# ,

) // )/

# 3 , '%

, #

8 F

# ,

,' E""

& +? "

# #"

', # " ' %& #

&! % ' %&

")/ )0 )"

% ' %&

& !

/2 // ) 8 " , #

# # "

, #" ' % & "

!% ! '

' "

# "

# , '"

# , &

8 ! # ,

7"' &

! "# "

$%%$&'()*

-4-

$%--.

-/+' 0$

12 10+3.41.536+ %7%%3633

8 2)$ 9010( : ) 2 ) # )) 6%643633!& )) ) 010( : ) 2 3

& # ( ( ,( )) %-+%%+36%4 ( (

( ! ! " )) )

( ) # ( ,( ) ) +36%4 - )) 6%643633 ! # # ) 01 0 ( : )

2 ) 5 #

( ;

! # &

' #

! # % &

#" "7"'

+ , " ' %

-5- # -)))). & "

)/ ) )// '3" "

" ' "

# '%

! , # 3' + "% #/0B2 /02B/020/00/001 ))(!

# "

/( // )/0 8

# "

" & >, & ' ' ' "

" ' %

" ! "

% # &

' # #"

" ' % + "

# ,

, '

8 ,

# # " ' %

! , ; " "

/2 // ) &""

' ' ' )

# &

6 "

" ! & "

)/ ) )//

'", #

## , # , "

" ' %"

# , "

' "

& ' % % "

" %

', # ' % '' %

6 + # "

# ', # " ' %

-6-

/( // )/0&

%)2%# " ' % % ' "

; "

% , #

# # " ' %&'3", #"

! "" #$

% &$ !&' ( +& '%

& ' # , %

' #

# , & ' # ,& &

' # ""

# ' # "

; "

" #

!,' )/0 "

, , #

" ' %&

%' "

#7,

! % # "

% ,

# 4 "

# "

'3"

# #

" / #

# '%

G # 3'

)/0 "

H "

# , % '"

#, % ,,' ! '

" "

' "

, #

# , '"

, #

5! # ' #

6 8 #

! / (56

-7-

, "

/ (56 #

#)/0 & &

"# ,

# ,

, & ' ,

# ,

# , # , E

# " ' %.

!, ;# ', ,

' E '%

!% '

% # ' % + ! "

' # # " ! !

& &

/) +

" ' %

& "

)/ ) )// " ' %

! 8 "

#' %7" < &))(()#)

)*1= ) !# < &)) !)) # )#( #(!

&> 1( // & ,, % #

& () )( )// 8 "

F ' ## &,% ' " ## !%"

# "

! , & " ' % &"

# ,

-8- / +& %& ,

% &"

# #, % ,,'

)- )1 )/ +

&& E

"/B )/ /000 8

)B /) ))) '& # !

C:% C;' 4 C,3 D , =

;

#, '", "

# "

)- )1 )/' " ,& '

! # + &

% # " # &

/( // )/0

# ' 3" " , #

8 &

, , #

%)2%

" "

# " ' % /( F ", E# '%

' % ,

' " %))0

& "

() )( )// ; " , #

F '

& " ' %& "

, "

# "

# ,"

, "

# # " ' % "

# + "

# &, "

& , % # ,# , % !

" ' ! '%

# ,

# '

& '

" ! ' %

-9- /- "

" '

# #' %&"

, # #$

% &$ !&' '

!"" &

3 , ) ) )// 3 , %

% I

, ' ,'%

" # "

%# # " ' % '%

# , #

# "

"% + " ! ' % "

, "

, '" 8 ! 7" #3 ,

" #<E 56 7" 33 &)

( )#

)) # (# 1 !

) ) ) +!)) # & # )) )!

3- @* ) ( &>

! ) 743664 > (# () (# (() (() ) ( ) ! " A) (* 01 0 )) ( A ;(< ))

( & & ! B& ! ) & !& ! ( > (() &)( !

-10- &C # ( &)! ) () ! # ( D & D (

( () )>)#

( & C # ! & &# C #)B 35 )# ( & ! &)

( +

!# &)) ; 010 ))( A ;(<< (35 8+ B?

( ! *( )) # # ( #

) # *( # ) # () )# # ) & )

D * ( (( & ) )&# & >

)) & ! > (> & &) # ( ( ) ) ( ! &) ) # ( (&)

) ! ( &

( (

) C# )344

) # () ! # ) )& &! )&! )&@!# )&

))# () )# # !

* (

( )

-11- # ) )& !

(! !) ) )& E C))# )

) & ( () !

) )& ) # (# (() ! # )

# B # BF G# ) ! ) B ) &) ) & D BBF & & * ! # &

( ! ) ) E ) ))# & ( ))# ! ) *! * + ( # ) )& & )

& ) & # !

)

(() ) # ) (# (() ( (# (#

* !

! & * !

( ! > ( > & &) # ( (&)) ( )# ( ' ! > ( ( ) ( ) ( &# ! ) ()) > ()> # (! !))&

C ) # ) ( ) & )!) # H** **** **** **** **** **** **** ***

-123/

)

)) # ! & ( !

( # ) ( ( +

!)( ! ()

! ) #

()#

(( # ) ( +

&)) !& )# )& %%.

%7/3 & ! & ( # ) ))# (

( )! ( ) ( !))))& # ( & ) ( ( ! # !+)) ( +

) )))# )

( () C) #

C (() ) # (# (() & # " A) ( ?

)+ *),

-.$ . &)

B& ) * ! #) ! ) ()# & D ! ?

) ( ( # (! ) #* ( # # )&8 * !> (! D ) # & * (& ! )&+ &)) ( &)) (

! D B 34 $ )# ! ! ) 010 ))( A

-13- ;(<;) ) ( < ( (# (() ?& ( 2 A ;(< " A) (* !;(36< ))&8+

3% #& )) # C !# ( !

( ( )

! & & &)) )#

) # ! &) & ! >( (() ! ) #)#

* > # (()) +( !> !

( ))&)))# ) ) # (() &)) > & ! &))> (() ! >( ! # & ! ( # ! ) #& ( # ! ) (

& &

B -60 # (# (() )(() )

) #1

) (()( () )&#& ( ) # ( #

( ( ) ( &)) (( &)) (! # ( ) ( G #( #& &)) ))# )! *

-14-

) (() ( ) ( #

(!)##

) ( # (() )(

)# ( & ( )! ) -% ! )) ( ) & C ( ;<

& ( () (# (()(() )

;< &

(& ) ))# ) )) # ) # !) # )#

( +

) ) 1)! );

*% 3< ) +!)) # F H** **** **** **** **** **** **** **** **** -4

(

(! ! ! (

> ! ) )!

( #( ! () # C)# ! (# (() )

) )))# (

() )# ( +

# + (() ( !)# # ! #> #

#( ( @! &

!) # ( ( ) # )#

# # !) # ) & > ! ) > ) ) # ) )

( )

-15- #1 ! ( #

)) )! ) 56 $& ! * )

) ( ! ! 1) ) )

)) ;

*%< )! )

( +

) 1 ! # )

)# ! () &)) , ! ()

) ) ;

*%< ! D

)! ) ;

* 3< () )

!1* ! 1)

)))# ) ))# ) )) # ( (# ! ) )# !)) ( +

& # (! C (( # ! ( +

> &# # * ! 1) & !

# )& #))

()# )#

! ;

< (& ) ))

(( !)# !

>&# # )# ( # # &# C

( ( )

! 1) &)) #&#!

(

)) )! ) #

-165% 0! (

(

>( )) #

& &()# ( )& ( # # ) ( ()# ( ) ) ) ( +

) ! &

( ) ) ( & )# # ( )

) ) )! )

()# # & ) ( # & 53

# # C ! 1) #

# ( #

( ( & ( & !

# )& )) ))) #

) ) )! ) & ( ! ( +

# ) !1 ;( +

< )!

# # ( +

* () )() ( !(

) # )# () ) & ( +

& ! # ( +

# ))# ( ) # ) &)

(# (()

-1755

)

) #1

)))# # ) )) ( )) ) ( +

( () (# (() & ()# (() ) ( ) ( #

)B B! #()) ( )&)& B I (() ) ( !# () & () * J / ? "

# " #

# ,E

) # &

' "

# "%

%',

) # & , 8 F ", # "

# , !%' #

% !

' !%"

; " #

# ,

7 /1 ! & & !% , '

. '

# ,

" /0( # "

" " .

" !%, #

' # #

' # '%

% % #

# , !

, "

& ' , ! ' !

6 !

, '%

& "

-18- /2 // )'

+ .'.4

.0.-) /B &

/( // )/0# #' %& '

'%3 ,

.<E

56! '

! #"

' '3" # " '

, ! " #

$%%$%!""

02!

/# /"3!4!/5 )! (

(

)) ( 1 # ) )1

( ) #1 ! !( 1

)

( ! #

( 1 # (!

( %4-3

( & )!

( %4-3

( 1 #&) )

( ) #1 ! $) # (!

( %4-3&) > &) )1

( ) #1 ! #

#! 1 #( ) ()

( 1

@ #1

) ?

) )1) ( )#1 ! ! ))& #( 1 ! ) &) )

) ?

) )1)

( )#1 ! !8+

-19- ;%<) # 1 ))

& 1 &

( %4-3 ;3< ()# ) ()

( %4-3(

))& &! (( 8 ;<# )) (

))

(

)! ;<# (( #! & > )& ) (

# (

( ! & ( ! > # ))) # )) ) )

( )& )! > ;-< ) ( (( 1! () 53

( %4-3 & & (

(8 ;< * # *(#

E ;< # ! > # ()

E ; <# (

;<# (

)! ;5< ) # $

( G)) () 5-

( %4-38

-20- ;<G (

( &)) # )!# #(

! &

)) (

;< )! )

;.<)

(# 55

( %4-3

("("( , +& & ! /01 )) (

A) A ) !# *

(&A A

( ) ; )(

&) ( )

#1 ! ! @ #1

(

1 ; ) ( )& )! () #1 & #&

<( ))# &

)

)1) () 1 (( )1)

#1 ! !( 1 "

( ) # )

#1 ! ! J777 77777 77777 7777 7777

-21- -2 /& !1 1 1

(

)#&)) )# C

(* ( )#

) )))#

( ?(

1* 1 )) )# * (

)(( (& )))# #

( & ! ( ) #1 ! !

) ?

) )1)

( ) #1 ! ! 3425 ! 61& &&+!7 6 G @ #1

) ?

( &(

( * )(

(1 # ! & &

( * )

(!!8

( *

@ #1

) ?

) )1)

( ) #1 ! ! ; ))# ! )

( ;)< ( &(

* )(

) ?

)

)1)

( ) #1 ! ! +#

" '

, ,

! "%. "

, # , . ' # "

" ' %.

" !

-22- %.+

,% ' "

" ' %.

" ! A /2 # # "

& ,&

#" ' % , ,

# 3 ,

<E 56 /0

, "

# , '

# ! #"

, )

' & "

,% 3 " #

" "

## F , 8 7"

# & ,

% "

' " ! ! "

' "

% &

'# #' % + F 'E

% '% &% #

# "

/( // )/0 "

' " !%! & ' %#

)// /

' , E "

" # "

% ! "E

& #

" #

# # " ' % 8 #

, #!

, "

! #

3 # "

# " '#

8 !

%)/0 ' "

% "

" ' # #

-23- # ,

# '# 7"

# #

& "

" / ( 56 # 9

# , # , ' # !%

! '

! #

! ,

" % "

" & % ' !

'% ,

# 7

" #

&% ,"

, #

7" # , # ,

'", #

# " ' %

%)//&

" !& "

# "

F '## '% " + "

# % & "

# ,

% "%

% #

! "

! '%

, % ' '%

# "

& ' ' ''%

( ""

% &

# 8

" "

" ' %

)/ ) )//&

#& ,

# " #" # "

% #

K1*

,# , # "

-24-

" + " '

! ,

#& ,

K 2*

, 8

' &

#,(8 ' & #9&:

$ %+ 11

( - + ,' # "

" "

& + '

# "

'%"

# "

'3"

# E

' # ""

, "

+ ! '%

&% , '% "

! "" #$

% &$ !&' ( 4 "

% #

' " '#

# "% 3' %"

, '% '%

'%!

&% ,"

& & '!

& , '% % , "

,, "

, #

)%+1 &$ - =) L E

I. L ' I.