High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/178/2021dismissed

Jawdeen v. State Of Haryana

2024-04-0415 pages

! "

# $

! # %&'() *

+ ,-) (- .-(( # %&'() *

+ ,-)

, '#,,- " # $ %! # &$& '(!) * + & # , -( ( . /////

, '#,,-

* 0* )%* -! & +%! 1% 2!1' + * )%*% !! 3453353 ! ! + * !!

5356353

!7. !!!%% $

!1( *,$*%

! *% + &%!

+ '$8 ++* *(3539+

& :

*;<( '%$

7 %1 4=4 +35>( %! ?$

-!@)%!-&%*&0* )%*- *!

! "

"" ! "

-/0/!

! $*% A +&

%' % '+ % ! +-).

! .+% +₹35(5550!+ +.' + +% & +( + & %1

%' % '+ % ! + . 3

%*%'- 1 !* ' % + ₹4 ,& .7!

%*%' ' % ! & *&' +! 7% &!+ & +* ' % ! &7%%% +)%*%'! $*% 6BC +

! +

%'% *!

(=C6 . & - !%!& % 6 %++*

*% * &* '%%:;

' & +1% *&%!9'-%&&!! 7

! :;& %+ < +%!- %* '% $ ( %*$% # & &-

%! +D ! (!% 335435>- !- ,- 1 %1 %& & %.!(' - - ,%1 1-%&* -! !1& :#;9'-%&&!! 7

! :#;& %+ <1!

7 C.

%1%&& -&* '%- +!*7 54"B'(-& & !& '( & %*!&

'%-&%*&& '% !1& :#;- %1- 7 !+ '% %! $&& ! & %, +& !1& &% ( &*!# %.!!

, *,!&!

-! !&!

+ '% %!$& %*!& +& !1& :#;- ' )!! &- * .%17% .$& + & %*!& +-!- $&%E% !+ '&

!1& !%&'%'-! -.+ '& %E% .(&

'% !1& :#; 8%!& ' % -&%*& & - 8.

!7.-!:#;(&)%*%' )!& !&% !&% +%1 + '-& & % 9)1%<!, *&%1&

!& 8 !& + '-& & % 9% < '% :; !&-! ,!!)1 +& 7 *! 8.

8 %!0 %! & '% !1& :#; D%& & 1% ( 1% ! 4

&% * '%(+ ' 5=!!365435>-

1% !! $*% 643(B5A +!% !(>A59+ & : ;< ! ! $*% 4 +

*( 353 ) %1% -

* ''*! #!%* 8'%% + )%*%' :#; - * !*! ) ' %( '$' +)%*%'! $*% A4

- !. !! 365435>7+ !# ( ' & + ( C5A35>&+& +** !-! !*!&%'

7+ & %*!&-

!7.F0$#% %*$% D '(# !** !%1.(&%

'' - ! %1 %

1% ( >5A35>( ** ! ++ ! !% *

' !

!' *!&* + **

*&** !- '!%*.8'%! + * '% +%) %1% (*&- !%&

+ E#1% 1 B ** !- %!* ' +* % +*& )%!! ! $*% 35C +

F ! !!%% $

!1( 1 ( + & %1 & 1' ( + '! *& 1 & 35>35>1% ** !! $*% 4 +

*!B5A + ( -&%*&- ! ) !8%! &%'% %'11 -&%*&& !! 1%.!*%'! % )%*%':#;-

&3.

+ 1 & %' + * ''%

% + 1! ++*( ! %

'!!&*& 1 &)%! ! !!5B35>!** !%1.( *& 1! $*% A +

*9% %)! $*% 6CA93< 9< + <!B5A + + '!1% ** !-!( -&%*&& !! 1%.!*%'! % A ! )&+* +&* (

*% 8'%!

)%*%':#; D(:;' & +)%*%':#; D3(:

;+& +)%*%'

:#; D6($& '( + ' D4(F0 )%

DB( 7G!$%1& DA(F0 7 2 DC( $'!&( #!%* ++%* ( ) ' %( ' D>( ' &( ,(# !% D=( 1! (#!%* ++%* ( ) ' %($* 5( ' D5(F0$# D (F0$$ 2 D3( %.! D6(#'(8#'7

( 1' D4( * 2 DB!F0 7 G)% DA C $' +** !- !!! $*% 66

5653353 & + ( ' . ' + ** ! !

$*% 66

- !! !!3653353D&%!.%1 %* %'%%1 )%!* &%'( & !! % ** ! + %'%*% > F + ** !* !!+*)%!*-%& 8'%%1.-%

= + & %1 1' !)*!7. !7%*

! %1&** !7 %! * %! %1)%!* !(** !-!- * )%*!! *!! $*% A +

*9% %)! $*% 6CA93<9< + <!*E%! + &*& 1% &7! $*% B5A + ()%!2!1' +* )%*% !!3453353! ! + *!!5356353

!7. !

!!%% $

!1( *,$*%

*( 353( ' !%!& % 5 %111 %)! +&% 2!1' +* )%*% ! ! +

*( & 7+%!7.&* )%* F + 0* )%* % !& 1'& 2!1' +* )%*% ! ! + *

!7. !!!%% $

!1( *, $*%

*( 353(

%77%17 !

'% 1% )!

1% 0* )%* + %' . +

*% -%

%7 ! &. &) 1%) %' )! )

% F ! * +

0* )%*

! & %' . +'% )%*%':#;D-&

&*1 %*. !& &!. &&!1 & *& !

B & + ( &.!+ '%'!- %& ' & & &!(:;' & +)%*%' D3*%'!&)%*%'&! 1 & *& &!.+ &

! *

8'%% ++ %!

-& %*' !&& +* '%% %!% &%*,. ! ! % +* '%% %!%1 &+%

% '7%!%1& + (% *&%, %% & - *&* + * ''%%1 *&%, ++*F ! %

(%- 7'%!(&!

- 1. %! & %' . +'% *&%!7.%1 %1 & ' % )%!*% %! & *& **

* ,*! - + . %'%*! ** + ' . !% 7- & * '%!+& + F + 0* )%*+ & %! & )

% + - !7.

*% % !7.'!%* !

! & ' + $'!&(#!%* ++%* ( ) ' %( '8'%! D>-& &! )! !#!%* 8'%% +)%*%':#; 8=! + %*$*%* F7 .9$F< 8H #!%*8'%% 8=( & - % 8 %2 . &

+)%*%'F !

* + 0* )%* %! & +$F 8H( '* ! 7!*! 8&%7%9 <!8&%7%3 1% -7<(& + (& % )%!* +* ''%

% + 7%1 * ''%! )%*%'&'

(%*7* + %'

% 7'%!&% . 17 .-& & '%!

%* !.+ 1!

% % 7 !-% ++'%.!-

) %) )!% *&%, ++*)%!*!7.

*% ! )&1% +0* )%*7. !& &! - + 7! 7 & + (2!1' +* )%*% !!3453353! ! + *

A !!5356353

!7. !!!%% $

!1( *, $*%

*( 353( ' 7 %! !

0* )%*-!7*E%! +&*& 1+ '!1% &%'7.

**%1 3

& & &!( %1&$ 1!

*% * % !. )! !+ '& %' . +)%*%'

8'%! D )

% % +. ! 7. & ' & :;

8'%! D3 %.!-& - - ,%1 # %&& -

8'%! D6-& + & !'%!&&&! -! %1 -.+ '& '%-&%*&&- - ,%1& +)%*%':

8'%! D6-& * +% '!& **

*!&+*&& - & %*.%+ '!7 & **

*-&%*& ,*-%&&%

!1& '% *&!& %*%''!%.! &7 %

+- %* '% +* '%:;( !1!!%) %1% - ! #!%* ! +)%*%':#; % )! 7. $'!&( #!%* ++%* ( ) ' %( ' 8'%! D>( #!%*8'%% +)%*%'% 8=$%'% .(

+ 0* )%*( & - '!%*. 8'%! 7. 1! ( #!%* ++%* ( ) ' %($* 5( '!* . +&%

#!%* F1 9#F <% 83 +$F% 8H% 1!

& 8

% )! ! + ' & %' . + )%*%'

8'%! D( !7. *% %#F 83F%,)%!*%

)! !7.8'%%1F0 )%DB!F0 G)% 8'%! DA%%.(%) %1% - *

%! 7.F0$$ 8'%! D3!& + (%) %1% *'% &&!

+ F0$#8'%! D-

! C5A35>)%!

'' 8A - 2 %! %%) %1% !- '!%*.

C 8'%!&!!' *!&* + **

*0* )%*!%!

,. *%+%* !-&&% '- !!! $*% 66

& % &%1 ! & -&& - ' .!% 7- * '% -%& 0* )%* &% +& + %!

!+* % !7.0* )%*% -%& .7 % !+ & 1& & ( + ' & )%!* ! 7.

*% ( % % !.

7% &!&0* )%* 8.

!'% )%*%'-& & - %&& &+* !)%!* !(- %1&.

* %! !! *%!7. ! %

!0* )%*-

%1&.&!1%.!* )%*!! $*% A +

*(353 - 7'%!&

!7.0* )%*! ) !% '%

6 D & ! 1' !)*! 7. ! * +

0* )%*! %1&$!&)1 & 1&& !* +.-%&&% 7

% *&* %&!( 1% ! - %%*% !!365435>83+%!7. * '%:;-& % ' & +'% )%*%':#;$&*1 %*. !

& &!. + **

*%335435>('% )%*%'- %1%

'-& &- + +!%1&*7 54"B'(-& &

!& '( & -& '- 7 !+ '% %!$&& ! & %,

+& !1& &% ( &*!# %.!! !, *,%1 &!

%'.(!

!7.-!! & -& + & !1& - ' )!! &- * .%1$&+ & %*!& +-! - !&+!-.+ '& %E% .( )%*%'!% * !&' &- 8.8 %!7.-!D%& & 1% ( 5=!!365435>- 1% !!

$*% 643(B5A + !! $*% 4 +

*(353(-&%*&%

8B -! &!

! ! ! -

! % &% *

> C5A35>)%!

'' 8A) %1% - * '!!& - *&!%+ %! %%.(*& 1 &- + '!!

$*% 4 +

*!B5A + F (*& 1 &-

'!!! $*% A +

*9% %)! $*% 6CA93< 9< + <!$*% B5A + 4 ! )&*& 1 &( %' . +'% )%*%'%

' %%* +)%!* **

* ,* 335435>7 54"B'!* '% *&!& %*! &7 % +&

- %* '%83( 1% ! 365435> 5C"55'

&%!)%*%'- 7 1&+ '!%*8'%% 7 5C"B'!

- '!%*.8'%!7 5>"B' 365435>( #!%* 8'%% 8=$' +)%*%'- !!! $*% A4

7. !!%*%#1%

& '!.(-&%*& % 8 %*%' % !&& &!+&& '-&% &-

%1 %& '-& !!* !&!

' -&%*& &1 $& !&&9

*-& - ! %1- , +-%! - %&% & '< !& !

' )!%! !&% -% ! &) *&!

& ) % * % !7. !# &*&%! %! - !

& )1%!*& &% % %*%'-&% %%1 & )1% !

&&% % & ( -&%*& &+%!* %!7& * 9< !%! ' & % & '%' *' !

, *,! !. &!

-&%*&& !&!

! -. &* %&!( **

* ,*-%&*&%!)%*%':#;-& & - %&& &

*% & 8'%!' &( ,(#

!% D=-& !*!! +7% & ! +*&%!(** !%1 -&%*&& ! +7% &% C5355 . + ) .% 8

= & + (&%' + %! **

*()%*%'- )!&+.

!*&%!& %' . +'% )%*%'% ' %! )$*% > +&!%)%!**(>C3 ! " ?* 12 / !0!"$ I

&7* ' %+.

* %!

&&. )!+ '

!%1&E % &'( + '1%)%1 % -

& E % (7.! .

(8 ' !1( !% (-&& +7 !. '%!( . & * +&

',%!

%*% %* ' %+.(

)!7.&% *.+ '!

!%1&E % &%'!1%)%1 % -

&'@ % - !-&

* . & %' . + *&%!-%

!%*+ '7 % +* )%*% %+& %' .% &+ !* !%7

% + %' . +*&%!-%

% '! .

7 + !*(%% ! % 7 &*

% + ' &

%7)%!**! !& + ( %' . +*&%!-%

* 77

&! %! . &1 ! +*, +*

% & !%)%!**(>C3! * %7. %* 1 ! '%

7* '-%

*&%! +! 1* %+.%+&*&%!& %***%. !

!&E % !

1%) % -

& + %+ **7'! && %.

*%! %

4 * %! ? !

! "

7080 !

0*@(-& )%!% .) + *&%!-%

8%!G%1%)%-& ! %% +-( %' . +*&%!)%*%':#;8'%! D% * %! !&)

+ - !7.*&%!)%*%'%& ' !!! $*% A4

8- +.*

!7.)%*%'-& &- 8'%!

5 D+ !%1 ' +*&%!)%*%'(' .E % - & ! &- + ! 7* '-%

7. ! %

$'- !!%E % - + '!*&%!)%*%'

1%8%!&' %-&%*& &- 8.8 %!7.** ! $&!.%!%+%!** !+*%1 %%&% * $&* +% '!&&

' & , *,!&!

+ ' %!!&&!

!7.

** !-& -.+ '& 7. &%1& ' & %! %1 *

8'%% & )

% '%! * % ! & )%)%!.

''7 !& **

*!' %-&%*& &- 8.

7.0* )%*-& ' &%!%+%! F + 0* )%*

! !% * *.

&*&%!)%*%' !& &&!1 *& !+ %1( & .!+ '%'!&- (-& (* '% D3

!&*&%!&! 1 *& + %!!% * *. %! 7. + 0* )%*% ' % &+* + * **

*&!,*%&& +* '%7 54"B'-& 0* )%* 1-%& %.!- - ,%1 +

+ ' +)%*%':#; D! +&

' & :; D3 & - & &% )

% '%! * % % 8'%% %*&%+ - &% *

8'%% $%! %.!

!% -%

7 8 D6!! !&** !-!-

- ,%1%!2* '-& &- %1'*&%!!%! & . ! %' . +D6*

% +* '% &:

;'*&%9+ *%1- !<- % & )%' & !

-%1& ! +)%*%'+ & * +% '!&' & + )%*%'*' &%'!%E% !7 &)%*%'-& - %1% '

! & -! -. + ' & ' &% -%

&+. !& **

* ,*%&% *-&%

%1 & -.+ '& & +)%*%'8'%! D6

*% )

% !* +% '!&&- %+ '!7 & **

*& %*. B %'% +* ''%

% + ++*- 1%)%''!%.7.

+&)%*%'% 7 !&%' + !1%1 % '% !

4' 365435>% &* +* '%&&.- '! -%& %* % !

%1&%1&!*% - , .%& '

%1&% 1(%% ) %' . +D3F0$$ (-& * . !& 365435> &- ! %*$% $* 6C( '$& *%)!& %*'

1+ ' %*$% D '# '7 6' -&%*& & *&! %!

%* % -%&%B35'% &% +* !

* !* )

+* '%& '*% - ,7.* '%)%1

* + '7% &' !* * *% A

& & &!(0* )%*- '!%*.8'%!

7. 1! (#!%* ++%* D5 + ) ' %($* 5( ' %* E 86!&% #F % 83** !%1 -&%*&

& + (-! +%!.+ *% 1' !)*!7.

+ 0* )%* C &%) %1% *

%! 7.F0$$ 2D3!F0$ #D% !. )! !0* )%*

! ! C5A35> ! & -

! % &% * F ! * +

0* )%* % ! 1'&& - 8

(& '

%- * + %'

%) 8

% !+%!! $*% 6 +

3 *(353(-&%*& ! " ?

"@ 11 )! %) 8

% !+%!%$*% B + + %!* )* +$*% B9'< ! " ?

""""# % %! * ''% 11 )! %) 8

% &'+ * ''%

% + ++* +11 )! %)

% )%!!%$*% A

*(353@ & + (* %! %1&+ %! )% (%% * & 0* )%*-! 8.8 %!*&%!)%*%':#;-& &-

%1 % & ' & )%*%' & 1%) + ** + & **

*!&' %-&%*& &- 8.8 %! 1' !)*!7. + 0* )%*&%- %'* +

%)%- +&'!%*)%!* !! & !.

6 ! : $'!&(#!%* ++%* ( ) ' %( '

D>'!%*.8'%!*&%!)%*%' 365435>5>"B'#!%* 8'%% + )%*%':#; % 8= + $F% 8H( ** !%1 -&%*& '* ! 7!*! 8&%7%9 <!

8&%7%39 1% -7< %1'!%*8'%% ( 8 %2 .

- %) .'- %*7 !

& ! * 1)& %% &

%7%%. + 8% *

* 7 !

&'!%* ! +&)%*%'! &&* + Keeping in view the definition of penetrative sexual assault and aggravated penetrative sexual assault, it is duly proved as per the evidence on record that the appellant/convict is rightly held guilty and sentenced under Section 6 of POCSO Act, 2012. The argument that there was no penetration, which would have been evident only if there was some injury on the person of the child/victim, is devoid of any merit in the given factual matrix. > F + 0* )%*-! % !&%

&& +* '%% %!%7 . &+'%. + +-

%!%1 +%

+ !*&%!

- & & + (%-

%7+ 0* )%* * ''%&% ++*D&)* %! !

& !,7. + 0* )%*& * '%

' +*&%!)%*%'& &- %1%& ' +&

&!1 + - ,(-& & ' & &! 1 ** !

-! !& '-& &- !7 !&!

+ '

% %!D& &- 7%1 8.

!(& ' & *&!& !

!, *,%1&!

&% (** ! !&!

!'1!

*&% +*% * +% '!7.)%*%':#; %+.%1 D!&

' & :; D3 %.!D6 * +% '!&-!&! -.+ '& %1 +:

'*&%;% * +% '!7.D6

4 & - ** % + &) -.+ '& %* *& **

*&!,*& % -& ) !% 7%)& %' . ++ %!-%

& + ( !,7.

+ 0* )%*% + + '* )%*%1 = F + 0* )%*+ & % !!+*& 0* )%*-!- + .%'%*!%&% * & -

!% 1 !%1' . '% D3!

%1& *

8'%% !'%!&.' + % - , +!

%.1%)7.&'

& * !& - 7*.'&.1% 2 %! * '- !- ,& * '%)%!*&- ,- %1 %1 -&& %! **

* ,*&1 !

+ % !7.

+ 0* )%*(%- 1!&* '% -!

'' . +& +0* )%* *%+%* !% ,7.

0* )%* -& &% ' - !! ! $*% 66

!%& % & .)%!* ! ) *& * & + (!+* % !7. + 0* )%*% 7

! . %!7..)%!* 35 & + (* %! %1&)%!*!7.

*% ( !

!!%% $

!1( *,$*%

*( 353( ' %1&.*' * * % &1% +0* )%*+

&* ''%

% + ++*% &7! $*% A +

*(353 - !. )! ! 0* )%* 8. 8 %! '%

)%*%':#;-& - )!&+.

+1 &%!)%*%'- %'.

*!7.& ' & %! %1&1 )%. + ++*(E' +

*%' ! 0* )%*7. ! %

E% .% + * 3

.( - ! +%! . % + % &

B 2!1' + * )%*% !! 3453353 ! ! + * !!

5356353

!7. !!!%% $

!1( *,$*%

*(353( '$'% ** !%1.(&! 33

!7.0* )%*-!% ** !%1.( !% '%

! 36 !%1 %*% 9 < %+ .( !

!% ! + ** !%1.

, '#,,-

(- .-((

+.)

D&& ,%10 !"

0 D&& 7"