High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/763/1995allowed

Saroj Jain And ORS v. Sunil Kumar And ANR

2019-03-07Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu10 pages

!""#$%$&'(()( * * +

,,* -.* * ,/

+ * * )

* - +

,, -.* * ,/

+ * * 1 2' &345" 16%!$#"*7 5$

!"#$ %&!"#$

$&4!8!8" 99" 5% ( ")*'!"#$

'"+,

$&4!8!8" 99" 5% ----- *7,:

, ./ " #0

"0 $ %! & " 1""" '"0 " $$ "2 %3 0* !4*"

5 "6 3 0* 7! % $ %' $$* " 1 "

* "0: *#9 !'$ # .+/ : $ $ "

'' ;

;+!$ 9 <- ! *0" *

8*%! 1 8*% 9 0 " : *# 9 1 #

0 * 2 2=-;-

% *%4*"

3 $10 " #0 *

8*%!1 $ 1

1 )' " %< $ $ "#

4 #

> !*$&1"

" " " 1

% 0 " $*# "

*$&

1 ! " # * $%

8*% " ''

$ '"" *' % " &' " #

" 1 : *#9 !* $ 1 8*% 9 *$$*%0" '! 1

: *#9 * " " %' ' % <- $ 9 ! *0" *

9 1 1" # * 2"

" 1 '" $ " $"'"1 # 1$ $%

0*$$* # '"" *' $! %$%1

8*%! ?<-" $* 1 "$* " %

1 " % "" * "' $0* " ' $ " $" '" $ " $ *" " # !* 1 $ ! 1 ": *#9 $ #" * .

/ @ $-A% ! *

9 " "

& $ *

" 1 $

$ ' #& $ *

" "'

1 "# %' $! "

"' $"

" $" '" $! 0$% 1

/ 3 3 0* & $$* *

8*%&"$ '"*' $ "$

!1 $ 1& '

$ "" $ 1# $* $$ " # #"" " " "&'

$$$* $! 3 0* 1 $

"0$ *" "$ $ %! * $$ ""** %# $ $* "1"$%' " , 1 "* "

" # # $ ./ '* % <- $ 9 # "'

8*%

1 " ''

$!'""*' $"&'" # $!* 1 $

" 0 1 8*% 9 1

: *# 9 "

* *

8*%"

" 1 '" $ $ ' 1* "$

0** '"

*'! $ $% 1

$$*' $ # 0

" %B* "

$4 &1 ! *

8*%

# "$" "

"' # $ "'

0 $* "0 1

" "" * " ' $! " $" '" $"$ *"" # ! * 1 $ 1 " : *#9 $ #"* "*1 $ 1 "

" '!1

* " . / @ $-A% ! "% " "

1" "# 1 8*% 9 " ''" $ " $" '" $

% *$* " #0#" ./ 4"$* ''

$"" $ $1$ $ 1$$*

$ " # * 2% *

8*% # '""*' # $ "'

%B* %"

$ # $ $%1

* 1 $ ! 1 $$*' $

* "* 1*"!* 1 $ 1 "

" '!1

:*#9 $ #" %'

.C/ 4" $* '

$ *' "$ 2- "

:$ 2* 6

D! ! > # :$ =D0 )* = 2* 6

"$ =D0 *'%2* 6

? #A$ "$

% "$ '"*$"*"- 6

! "# $%& #$ '( ' "

#$ #%)

#$ %(( %* #$# #$ ( " #$ + # %(#

'% ,%-') . / # - #%(! ,$ '% # % #$% #%#% $ ( ' # #$#

# " &'%& ( $ (%%& " #$ (%) #$ $%' '( # - #

( *%#$ #$ '# #$# %# *%#$% #$ & " 0"% ( #$% % $ * #$ " #$ $%' '#( % #$ (#$ " 1 # 2%&$! #$ '% # #$% #) #$ #%' #$

#%#% % %#%-' ( #$ ,%-') $ #$ 3%(%#% # ##% ( # #$ #%#% ! ( ' "

#$ '% # ( " # 2$%3% 4 #%' ! 5#$' 6## + ) ! ! ! 2!

! 7!

6% " (% ! 2$%' 4%) !

! ''! *''

#( 3(& # " 1% $' ($ 1%&$

#) .!!8!9 +!5!! " (%(( !! 1!!,!

( 8! ! 8 :$) .!!8! " 1! # #( #$# #$ ,%-' $ * &' $'( #$# #$

#%#% * # %#%-'! ,$ 3(& # %#( - #$ '( ' "

#$ #%#% #%' $'

#$ '% # % #$ #$# #$ " #$

# $%' '#( % #$ (#$ " #$ ((! ,$% ## - (# %( ' %" #$ #% ''

*( # '( %(!;

! 2%##( #$) %# % ' #$# % #$ # ) #$ (#$ " #$ '% #< $-( * ( # " #$ $%' % =#% * #$) %(#') *$%$ #

' - " $ ( &'%&# >(%%& #$ - %# (% % $ *%#$ # %& " #$ "# " #$

&) #$ (% $ # (

# #$ $ # # # $% (#%#% ( (%( # "

* #$ " # ( %# =#

( - #$ & %'(%& '% #< $-(! ,$ (#$ " '% #< $-( #$) %" * %##) # -# - &(( #$ (#$ ( - %(# %%& #

" #$ " #$ %( $%'!;

! ,$ &$ %# $ - &%##() -$'"

" #$

(# ?

! ) #$# ( !"" # $

) '%-%'%# "

# "

#% - %

( #%' #$ %(# % # " " #$

# $%' ( #$# % #$ # $() #$ (#$ * # ( - " " #$ $%' ( '%

#% '( $ - ##%() *$# ( # -

%#( # % #$# ( !"" #

) #$ =#% "

#% * '() ( -#(') % ' *$ #$ (#$ %3 % ( '# " %(# %%& # " $ ( &'%&# " #$ $%' -#) # #$ #% ) %# ' ( # - - % %( #$# #$ " #$ $%' ( # %' #$# #$ $%' $ # - %

#% ! . "

#$%) #$ " #$ $%' - %"( *$ %# % ##% ! 2% %'') *$ # " &% %##% ) % =%( # -

#: % (%%& $%' % #%' ( $ % # #:) $ (%%& *%''

# # $ ( &'%&# (%%& " #$ $%'! ,$ *) #$"

) # #$ =#% *$#$ #$ (#$ %3) % &% ) $ - ( '# " #$ " $%' # *%'' '' ( ( #$ "# " #$ &% ! #$ # $() % #$ " #$ '(%& () #$ - "

#$ '% #$# #$ '% #< $-(< (#$ * %(#'

%%& # " $ ( &'%&# (%%& " #$ %( $%' - %# (% # -'% '!;

! "# & %& #$ &$ #$ 3(& # " #$ 1%&$

#) * " #$ %* #$# #$ 1%&$

# * # %&$# "# #$# #$ * &'%& #$ # " #$ * #$ (%

" #$ - %'' *$ #$

''# $ %"%''

'(( - # #$ &'%& *$%$ * #( - #$ ,%-' % #$ '%&$# " #$ '(%& ( " #$ %(

(( -"

%#! ,$ @ '

% #

' %%( #$ - % ( %##( "# ( #$ '

'% # * # #$!

,$ 1%&$

#) @ # -%& #$# #$ *

&'%&) $ # # #$ "%(%& " #$ ,%-' #$# #$ #

$ (%& #$ % ( " %(# *

''#( =%%& #$ # " #$ (# ( (% " #$ -! ,$ # - ( -# #$# #$ %(# # #$ " #$

# $%' 3#%"%& #$ '%

" #$

''#! A #%"%( *%#$ #$ # " #$ ,%-' % =#%"%& #$

#% %

!)) *%#$ %## # #$ # " B!; 3 *!

' "0#! $ " 1 " * "0: *#9 1 $$* "

* * 2 0 *

8*% 1

# $"

& '

$ % B* "

$ " ''

# $ '""*' # $ 0"

$ $%

0 @ $ $*%$! " 1 8*% 9 " * " 0 : *# 9 $ 0* 0 "" $*"0$$ " * * * $ ./ "% "

! 1 8*% 9 1 0* % " "

" @3? C-;!

$ $% ?!;;;,- " ! @3? ' ";;

;;

;+ 1

$%?+!+C;,- .;/ 4" $* '"-@*$ 2%' 0 1" $"" $% A * ' " ;;

;;

;+1

"0 9 !1

1 " !

$ " $%?+!+C;,- $% ?!;;;,- ;-

"0 1 %

" $ $%A* -+ "0

$ %*$ $% 1 1

" '# * ! 1 '' % 1

" 1 # 1 $%' ./ @ % " *% " $* " % $$'$ # 1 % <- * 8*%! E>2! @$% 3A

$!<"-@! *1 0 $"" *

-+' " ' ";;

;;

;+" % " * " 0

F" 0 "'% G ?+!+C;,- "0

"0 % 9 ! 1 8*% 9 @ $-A% ! " " $$ *

$% 1 "0

" " 0

# "$1 #1 "0 '"-@*$2%'

*'' '

$% A *

" 0 "$" 1 8*% 9 1

" @ 0$ *$ # "$ # 00* $"!0 " $%A*

"0 "$" 1 # 0$$'"0 "'%! $% " 0 $% A "'%

$%1 $ 0& $$* '*' 1& * $%' 1 "

" # 0 "

#"'"

!1% "* !% "% =1" + % " .+/ 4"$* ' $% "$"10 1 A0

% ! ! $%A1'0 . / @ $ $*%$! $%' '0 $ % 1* "1&**"-

1!$#65 1% %%"%%"; 4< !8"

1$46& 5 $&

"= %%"%%"; 4< !8" $>8 61! $& &#2" %%"%%"; @4 +!+C;,-5*

7 ;;'

6!61" 1%9"#!% @4

;H +!+C;,-I;!+,- ";6#!$&% @4 , C+,-I C,- ! 5&#2" @4 +C!

65!$95$"1 @4 6 D "9"&;"&#< @4 +C!

,-A I !C!

;

,- ,%%#&%1!$62 @4

;!;;;,- 1 "1

6&"1 5?9"&%"% @4 !;;;,- ,%%%! !" @4 !;;;,-

! 5#29"&% !$& @4 :)@:(0.= $$"

! ''

" "1" $%' ?!+C!

;

,- 1 GH '*%1

$ % " $ %' !

" '% . / "! $%' '0 *" : *# 9 !

" $* $"" "*0 : *# 9 %

$ "1; "!0** * "0 %!

%% 0 " % " *" % ' " % " # 1 " %"

$ % % %! ! $%' ?!;;!;;;,-"1 "B*"% %*% ?!;;!;;;,- 1 G +H ' *% * # 0 1""0& $$*# * "*$ ' *

!' " '

F ! A' $*" %"

$ %! ** %"

$ A'! '"*$ #

$$* %%! % ''$! %

$ 0 " " $ "'$ "

./ $"1 % " * ! "$* '"-

$" $ %= * " 0 "? !;!;;;,-1 * 3 % $$'"0 " $* ''

$$"

! # 1 % " $* ' !

1"" ''

" " *%'*%'% ? !;!;;;,-1 * ! 0' "1 ' " 1% %" $ ' $

"$' "!

1 $ 1

0'0 G H'*% 1

% " $ % ' !

" '% $$"

" 55A";! 1" "" '"0 "$$ "2 %3 0* !4*"

%"! %$;" " ''

" " $%' ' "

#0# *7,

1#8(:)( C3$D < '& ," J, < '0 J,