Mohan Singh v. State Of Punjab & ANR
!" #$%$& $'$$ $ $& $
&()&**+ , ,
- ,
./*0.
,,,"(*(* 12 /(()"234(. ,,,5(
, -66
"*(57/*0.
,,,"(*(* 12 /(()"234(. ,,,5( $+ 8%9 ,# / $"
/ %$
!
:::
$"
/ %$;#, $9 "
#
$
% & '
$
' ( ) "*+,-).,"/012 3
.
#
( $ -*.( ( "+/4 0
5( ( 63 7 89 : ;+ ."
.,"; -.,<-=/<-=*<".,)> 9( $ ? @ 0% )43 !$ $9%$< &
$
!
(',"
".
"++-
( $ ' % 1,/ .,,/ ;-.
$
( % 9
% 9 .* ,= .,,/ % #
A
A #
'
! $ (7 $"-/ ! : . $ ! -
# : .< ) & ! 0 ) 3 ) B $ C $& ! ., ,"
.,,- D '
:)./"/
' 4,,,,,<) 9(9(9 > ' #$
( $ & ' & !
C% ( !
?
"/ ", .,"-
/
= ;
@
"+/ ( (
$
# %
$
$
& '
8 4, .,,=
$'
& !0% )+3 # %
( & !
& $ % $& !
7
=
$ $
%
$# % $0#3 $
$ $ % $ $ $
$ @
-.,-=/-=*".,)>
9( $ /
$ $
$& ! $ 7 $
$ ?
/=4,,,<) '
"-4" "/ ", .,.- @ & ! $
$ .,,4).,,- #
& ! $ $?
$$9'//$&%/ 1$ * &
"/ ", .,.-%
?
/=4,,,< # $ : . $ & !
$ ?
& $ %'
$ %
E
$
( % +
8 !
$ '
$ $ .- ,/ .,,/
.;
,/ .,,/ $ >
"-/ ! & ! $ : .
$ 4, .,,=0% )+3 : .
-
$ $
& ! ",
$
$ $"+/( (
! " #
$ %
& ! '
( ( ""
&6 (
> 9 > !
! !"
#$$% & ' 9 > ! )* +, ! ! +,-
" .
$
* / $
0
$ 1
* +, $
*
# " . +, ! ! +,-2 ".
89 0 $ $
& ! : $ $ $ 8 $ $$ %
-., 9(
03 > &6 ( '( )** +, * ! -,./$0! ' $
) 3
( 4563 !
*
(* **((1*( *
*(2 (* **( (2 0 3
$ > &6 ( ,3** 4 *
" ! 5# $$% 5 ' ?
' )563 78 907 566658!8! 5+6:5666-(!!;+- ! : <,/ ( 4=
< << < ' *
3 / ! /"
( > /38+=;( ! =,=
. * ** 6(6** (* 3
( > /38+=4( !,54
$
<0 3 "4
$ &6 ( Kunti and Another vs. State of U.P. Criminal Appeal No. 1380 of 2023 decided on 03.05.2023, speaking through Justice Sanjay Karol, observed as follows:
)+0 * ( ?@ ( ? )/
" 2 6/?
!/8!3 A ! *
9
3
37?@ ( >5655,(!!54 @
:
)54* ! (( ( & B ( (
( & 56665(!!;-;:5666(!!!=-
$ 5= * ! * !3 D!B3 D!7 AE !3 9 566;;(!!,-;:566;-(!!! FFC . 1 * ! :3 D!!B3 D! 7AE !3 9 566;;(!!,-;:566;-(!!! FFC(!!,4+- )-G/
2 12.
Having regard to the above well - established principles and also noting that the present dispute is entirely with respect to property and more particularly buying and selling thereof, i t cannot be doubted that a criminal hue has been unjustifiably lent to a vicil natured issue." "-
9
(
$ # $ & ! 0% )+3
$
03
";
9
89 : ;+ ."
.,"; -.,-=/-=*".,)> 9 ( $ ? @ 0% )43 7
7 7 03 "=
03 $
"/
$
$"
/ %$ , ,
- # &
/? E '< F<: E
F<: